Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

New Chisel Dilema

Posts

New Chisel Dilema

#1

New Chisel Dilema

lee

Looking for some advice on a new set of chisels. I currently have a set of Narex chisels in 1/4", 3/8, 1/2, 3/4 and 1 inch. I have been doing a lot more hand tool work of late, and only see this desire increasing.

I have been looking at the Stanley Sweethearts, Veritas, Hirsch and possibly lie nielsen too; although they are very expensive up here in Canada and not so easy to come by.

what chisels do you use? have you used any of the above? what do you think? Any other manufactures i should consider?

all comments appreciated

thanks

Lee

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#2

Re: New Chisel Dilema

Howard Pollack

I have bought many used Japanese chisels off of Ebay have been very satisfied. Look for ones that look like they've been well treated.

-Howard

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#3

Some information to chew on.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Lee

I have included two reviews below for you to read, should you feel interested.

The first is a test I did on modern bench chisel steel. The chisels were a Koyamaichi (white steel), Veritas (PM-V11 steel), Blue Spruce (A2 steel), and vintage Stanley 750 (O1-type steel).

In this review, the Koyamaichi edged out the Veritas for edge holding, and both were very far ahead of Blue Spruce and Stanley. Keep in mind that we are comparing steel here, and there is more to a chisel than just the steel. There is comfort and control when holding a chisel. Japanese bench chisels are designed to be used with a gennou (hammer), while the other chisels here are more comfortable to push with a hand. The low-scoring Blue Spruce is, in fact, has the most comfortable handle of the lot, with the Veritas in a very close second place.

Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/FourChiselSteelsCompared.html

The second article is a review I wrote on the O1 version of the Veritas chisels. This article was as much about chisel design and the types of chisels available as about the Veritas chisels.

Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasChiselReview.html

For reference, the bench chisels I use mostly are Veritas PM-V11 and Koyamaichi white steel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#4

Re: New Chisel Dilema

Brian Holcombe

Before buying new chisels, you may want to consider how you sharpen your current set.

Narex are capable of a fairly fine edge, equally so to the other manufactured steel chisels.

I prefer Kikuhiromaru chisels, that is after using Lie Nielsen and Koyamaichi.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#5

chisels are personal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

While the steel is important the ergonomics of a chisel are most important. I suggest you buy one of what ever you are contemplating and see how it fits your use of a chisel.

I have tested the steel in the Hirsch and this steel makes a durable chisel, better than most. For a western pattern chisel I think the Lee Valley chisels have the best steel, and for me, good ergonomics. But they are costly.

If you are cheap and need several sizes then home made chisels are a possibility. If you can get someone to saw the metal blanks from bar stock, and you have a lathe to make handles, the rest is easy.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#6

I agree

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I got a set of Hirsch bevel edge farmers based on your recommendation and have been very pleased with them. I also have a set of Bergs and a smattering a of others, Japanese something from Hida, Stiletto, Stanley #60's, Witherby and some others. Veritas might be better but I'm done acquiring stuff.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#7

how about some old chisels?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

The very best chisel I have is an old E.A. Berg. I have a mix of different brands and tend to prefer tang over socket but I've made an exception with the Berg's. A number of years ago I found myself reaching for that Berg for more and more tasks, it is a delicate bevel edge chisel but I would use it for heavy mortise work with a mallet as well as cleaning up tenon cheeks and paring dovetails. It finally dawned on my why I tended to grab it over the others I own and it was because it was sharp. You see I'm not one of those guys that always sharpens a tool before putting it away, I tend to sharpen a tool when it is dull. and that 1" wide Berg rarely needed to be sharpened. Once I figured that out I assembled a complete set of E.A. Berg chisels. Berg also sold chisels labeled as beaver with paper labels on the handles and stamped Eskilstuna on the blade. These are the same chisels as those stamped EA Berg.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#8

Agree also

Hank Knight

I agree ith Bill's suggestion to stat small - one or two at a time to try out. Decide what feels good to you, then buy more. Here are several additional suggestions:

1. Don't buy a ready-made "set" of chisels. If you start with a few and add others as you need them, you won't end up wasting money on sizes that get little use.

2. Consider the old brands: Witherby, Swann, some of the Stanleys, Berg if you can find them. The steel in these is better than the steel commonly available today (not counting the high end chisels by Lee Valley, Lie-Nielsen and others). It's easy to sharpen and holds an edge well. You can find the old stuff on eBay. Old tool dealers always have them and estate sales are sometimes treasure troves for this stuff. It may take you a little while to assmble a good user set this way, but it's worth the wait.

3. If you decide to go the Japanse route, try to avoid getting sucked into the Zen of Japanese tools. People who are into Japanese tools, and I include myself in that group, spend hours and gallons of ink extolling the virtues of their favorite brands, the comparative advantages of the particular steel used and the smithing techniques of their preferred makers. There's a whole new termanology in Japanese that applies to Japanese chisels alone. It gets very esoteric and can be an expensive distraction if you find yourself chasing down everyone's various recommendations. I'm a fan of Japanese tools, chisels especially, and I enjoy those discussions; but I'm glad I came to the Japanese party late, after I knew a good deal about chisels. Even then I've spent a fair amount of money and I've re-done my sharpening regimen several times to take advantage of the fine steels found in these chisels.

Good luck with whatever route you choose. There are a lot of good chisels available today. I'm sure you will find some you like.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#9

Re: Agree also

Brian Holcombe

Ok don't buy a set, but I'm glad I went the J chisel route. I spent a few thousand dollars on the wrong stuff (or stuff I just don't love that much), then stumbled upon a great dealer and spent on chisels I love, only then did I buy a full set.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#10

alternative view

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Maybe others have been lucky buying old chisels but in every case I have bought one it has taken hours of effort to get it back to perfect working condition. Rounded backs and pits are the bane of used chisels. I suspect that all the good ones are in collections. I'd rather spend the time building stuff.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#11

Re: Agree also

William Duffield

Brian, After watching your latest video on beveling drawer edges and pulls, I think I can appreciate why you like your Japanese chisels so much.

Lee, when you are evaluating chisels that fit you ergonomically, I'll suggest you try at least one Lie-Nielsen bench chisel. While I'm sure there are others that will take and hold an edge better, I haven't found any that I'm more comfortable using.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#12

But then.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I hate them. They are top heavy and they give me hand cramps when using them for chopping out waste like for dovetails. I don't like any socket chisel for this reason.

Did we mention that chisels are personal :D

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#13

Very much so...

John in NM

I'm always torn between fancy, nice tools, and excellent bargain tools (low $$$ for the performance). Usually I come down on the bargain side.

Stephen Shepherd gave the LV Narex brand a good endorsement a few years ago, and I have to say I've been pleased with the ones I bought. Good user tools for not much money. Hold an edge better than others in the low price range, though one might want to reshape the handle (I have big hands so I never bothered).

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#14

Re: Agree also

Brian Holcombe

Konobu Tsuki's would make a believer out of most, probably even Bill :D

Bill, Japanese chisel have a tang and ferrule, they are not socket chisels.

Above all else I do believe chisels are a personal choice, come to think of it I have tried Lie Nielsen, Blue Spruce, Ouchi, Yamahiro, Tasai, Takahashi, Kikuhiromaru (new and old stock), Konobu, Koyamaichi, and probably a few I'm forgetting.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#15

Re: Agree also

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We were talking about LN chisels.

I know what a Japanese chisel looks like and I don't like them for the reason that they are not multitaskers. While the short ones are dandy for chopping dovetails by pounding on the handle, this handle is hostile for pushing. I have become attached to my homemade miltitaskers even in the face of a gift of one of the new LV chisels .

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#16

Re: Agree also

Brian Holcombe

Ahh, sorry about that Bill.

I used a set of LN chisels for about a year, they were ok but I much prefer Japanese.

I've seen a lot of don't like to push against the hoops, it doesn't bother me, but I suppose I prefer my dedicated paring chisels for times when I really put a lot of pressure into the cut.

https://youtu.be/llkcMH8qHPI

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#17

Re: But then.....

William Duffield

I guess I haven't used enough different styles of chisels to know any better, but I find the balance of my L-Ns, from 3/16" to 1", to be perfectly acceptable, with the exception of the 1/8", which is top heavy. But it is so light it doesn't get annoying. The Maine ironwood handles are so tough that they don't need hoops to protect them from hammer blows, even though I don't hit mine with a steel hammer. They're much better balanced than my Marples Blue Chips or the other plastic handled beater chisels that I reserve for abusive situations.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#18

Re: New Chisel Dilema

lee

Thank you all, some great responses. I have decided to buy a 1/4" Veritas PM-V11 chisel and to see how it feels. Its quite the investment but I am sure I wont regret it.

Many thanks again

Lee

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#19

Re: New Chisel Dilema

Matt Robinette

I would ask what you find lacking in the tools you are using now. How they retain their edge or how they feel in your hand or respond to being struck. It maybe your sharping method and you can always make new handles. It has been my limited experience that less expensive tools will take a sharp edge but not keep it as long as better steel which usually equals more money. So Narex may not have the cachet of more costly tools but I don't believe Lee Valley would sell them if they could not be used for fine work but may need a bit more attention paid to sharpening. Often a increase in the bevel to 30-35 degree from 25 the edge will last a bit longer.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#20

Re: New Chisel Dilema

lee

I have had issues with the chisels keeping sharp for a decent amount of time. They seem to go blunt fairly quickly. Initially I am very happy, but they do not hold their edge for long. My sharpening technique I am sure can be improved, but i do believe that I am at lest doing a fairly decent job at it.

My hope was that investing in a better chisel will somewhat remedy this?

lee

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#21

Re: New Chisel Dilema

Matt Robinette

Even the finest steel will néed frequently sharpening in more difficult gained wood. Pm-v11 by Lee Valley is at the present time on the leading edge of metallurgical science in the woodworking world. It also sells at a price point reflecting it's advanced nature. So there is that and it is a wonderful product as it sharpens to a fine edge like O1 but wears like it is A2. So if you are asking about the best the PM-v11 is it.But that is likely to get disenting opinions to fine ancient Japanese Damascus steel and even proponents of O1 and A2 steel tools. Wading thru the hyperbole can be fun if you turn a deaf ear to it and try the different steels for yourself

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#22

Re: New Chisel Dilema

Mark Nowicki

Another option would be to buy a bunch of "cheap" chisels and just reach for the next sharp one.

For a price of one P(rice) M(ultiplier) V(olume)11 chisel you can have about 10 Husky brand chisels (made in Canada) available at Home Depot, or Stanley FatMaxes (made in England), available everywhere.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#23

A few more comments

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Even the finest steel will néed frequently sharpening in more difficult gained wood. Pm-v11 by Lee Valley is at the present time on the leading edge of metallurgical science in the woodworking world. It also sells at a price point reflecting it's advanced nature. So there is that and it is a wonderful product as it sharpens to a fine edge like O1 but wears like it is A2. So if you are asking about the best the PM-v11 is it.But that is likely to get disenting opinions to fine ancient Japanese Damascus steel and even proponents of O1 and A2 steel tools. Wading thru the hyperbole can be fun if you turn a deaf ear to it and try the different steels for yourself

Actually Matt, PM-V11 hones like O1 but lasts several times as long as A2.

I agree with your comment that PM-V11 is "on the leading edge", but qualify this to refer to steels used by Western manufacturers of plane and chisel blades. This is more apparent when used on abrasive woods. According to the tests I have completed, PM-V11 in chisels is just shaded by Japanese white steel for impact resistance, that is, when chopping into wood. There are advantages for PM-V11 and disadvantages with laminated white steel (the most obvious being that one does not wish to hollow grind laminated blades - but see my comment below. Another being that Japanese bench chisels are optimised to be used with a gennou). At the end of the day these are both great choices.

Should one wish to go down the Japanese chisel route, and do so inexpensively, my experience is that even the cheaper end of the Japanese chisel range are substantially better chisels than those in the range of Narex. I have some expensive Japanese paring chisels (Kiyohisa), but also from the lower end of the Iyoroi brand - good middle-of-the-road chisels. I've used these for 20 years, and - horrors! - even hollow ground them. They have never chipped and just take and hold a very sharp edge.


I pointed out earlier (in my original post above) that the best chisels are not simply about the steel - steel is important, but comfort and control are equally so. Good ergonomics weigh heavily with me.

The handles on the Veritas chisels are excellent (very close to the Blue Spruce), and I much prefer them to those on the Stanley-copied LN 750. The 750-style is a style that seems (in my opinion) optimised for use with a mallet, rather than being used to pare by pushing. This is a personal statement, and I know that there are many who love their 750s. I, too, have a set of Stanley 750 chisels that I enjoy using, but they are not exactly standard, having handles I replaced with ones I made to my own taste ...


I am not recommending this as an option for Lee - collecting vintage chisels and making new handles is not for everyone. Plus, unless one finds old chisels with nearly full length blades, then you have no assurance that the steel will not be debauched in some way. Most buyers are better off buying new chisels. The one recommendation I do make is that, given the opportunity, try a few styles before you buy. I'd rather have comfortable users with average steel, than uncomfortable handles with superior steel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#24

A discussion of handles

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The picture shows some of the handle possibilities to be found. Starting at the bottom is a chisel I made, then a LV, Two Cherries, and others. The breadth of shape is apparent. What shape suits one will depend on what they use the chisel for, the size of their hand and the phase of the moon, I suppose.

Oddly, no commercial chisel offers the simple barrel shape I used. At the time, I made a barrel shape because it was quick to do and I needed a set of chisels. I have come to prefer it above all others. I have one set of chisels and they must be multi-taskers. I think the barrel shape functions well for a variety of chisel needs. I pound on them and pare with them.

The Two Cherries shape is favorable but it is too big for my hand and I have no need for the hoop on the top.

Re: New Chisel Dilema

#25

Re: A discussion of handles

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Oddly, no commercial chisel offers the simple barrel shape I used.

Yeah Bill, that is wierd. :D

The downside to the barrel handle is that it lacks the control when pushed that a handle like the Blue Spruce or Veritas has, that is, a place to rest a thumb. This adds control and power.

Here is a Veritas handle ..


By comparison, your barrel handle has more in common with a Japanese bench chisel which, as I have mentioned before, is orientated for use with a gennou. Here is a Koyamaichi bench chisel being used for dovetailing..


Regards from Perth

Derek