SawStop Lawsuit
Richard McComas
http://www.woodworkingnetwork.com/news/woodworking-industry-news/sawstop-wins-round-supreme-court-lets-antitrust-lawsuit
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
SawStop Lawsuit
Richard McComas
http://www.woodworkingnetwork.com/news/woodworking-industry-news/sawstop-wins-round-supreme-court-lets-antitrust-lawsuit
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
don stephan
Copied and pasted the link but it didn't work in Internet Explorer 11
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
Keith W
This is what's wrong with this country. Someone tries to force others to use their technology, and they're allowed to sue anyone that tries to boycott their greedy ways.
Foreign Conglomerates
Matt Robinette
That is what is great about this country that you can sue a company or group much larger than yours and protect your intellectual property. The group is just pissed they didn't develop it first or care enough about user safety to spend the R&D money. Hell they kept putting those cheap splitters and guards on when they knew they were crap. They could have include a true riving knife and quality guards on the saws 30 years ago and not have this fly in the ointment today. As I see it the big companies are run by bean counters bought and sold in leveraged buyouts and stripped of anything that is worth while and then spat back out. Look most of the quality legacy companies are now just re-branded tools in a group of manufactures held by some investment group. Yep I sold my Jet 3hp exata Rip and bought a Saw Stop 2 years ago and don't regret it for a second. It is what American manufactures should have built 25 years ago. A true world class tool.
Give me one drop of water the rich man cried from hell.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
CJ in MPLS
From the article, SawStop has not yet won its suit. It would appear that SawStop was rebuffed at the district level and had the 4th Circuit overturn that ruling. The Supreme Court let the SawStop win stand so the case will go back to the District Court for trial. Often parties will settle when it gets to this point, however it would seem that the defendants here have gotten themselves out on a ledge. Settling in this type of situation becomes more difficult.
While antitrust law has been greatly deprecated over the last 20 years, it remains illegal for a group of companies to get together to keep a technology out of the market place. If the members of the Power Tool Institute did not, in fact, collude to keep SawStop technology out of the marketplace, then SawStop loses. If the Power Tool Institute did collude then they will, and should, take it in the ear.
From a pure trial theatrics point of view, I think SawStop has a very good case going in. A jury is made up of folks from all walks of life but in general they won't have much independent knowledge of the facts of the case. Here they'll see the SawStop technology work, they'll see horrifying pictures of amputations and then they'll hear evidence that the Power Tool Institute members wanted to keep this technology out of the market place, likely for economic reasons. Unless the SawStop folks come across as huge jerks (which, I grant you, is purely subjective), I imagine that SawStop will win this one. It will be interesting to watch nevertheless.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
BrianMonumentCO
Problem with saw stops case is that the efforts to keep saw stops PATENTED technology OUT of UL safety standards is in line with competition goals. It should be illegal for the government to mandate the use of any patented technology.. The anti trust case is weak in my view due to the forcing of a MONOPOLY by the courts. A win for saw stop is a violation of anti-trust laws anyway. as it creates a monopoly.
Anyway saw stop should be coming up on the end of their 20 years of patent exclusion.
With so may additional patents (wikipedia says 50 additional patents. I did a search (not a legal patent search) a couple years back for the guys patents and found that most of the patents he held had nothing to do with the saw stop technology related to a table saw.
The UL and OSHA MUST NOT include saw stop technology in their safety guidlines/rules. As it supports monopolistic behaviour.
And the irony is...
John in NM
That the motivation for the government limiting monopolies is the same as the motivation for anti-trust laws 
Shopping for a little controversy Richard?
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
CJ in MPLS
Remember that patents are a permitted monopoly and are not an antitrust problem. This wasn't always in the case in the US, but antitrust rules have been pruned back a bit over the last while. Besides, patent law has rules in place to cover the enforcement of "standards essential patents". The thing you are worried about already happens and the companies that own the essential patents aren't allowed to create monopolies. In fact, they are required to give mandatory licenses at reasonable rates. I wouldn't worry on this account.
Re: Shopping for a little controversy Richard?
Richard McComas
Dick, I'm just posted a link to a publication of an article on going issue of interest to many woodworkers. It's just an update to articles that have been previously posted on many different forums.
If my goal is controversy then I could start a thread about thin kerf blades verse standard. I've seen plenty of augments over that one.
If it's controversial to you then.......I guess it is.
Have a good day.
Not controversial to me, but lots of others
Dick Coers
For some folks, it goes way past the machine and get pretty vocal about their hatred of the owner. I think it is a wonderful invention. I also carry one less knuckle on one had when I ran it through a machine. I was lucky, but wished all machines with a blade had flesh sensing tech.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
BrianMonumentCO
I am not really worried about it.
I have a 30 year old plus Delta UNISAW.
I intend to keep it.
I have not been injured by it.(Knock on wood.)
I did cut the outer layer of skin off the end of a finger using a Delta DJ-15 jointer.
It healed, but still have a tingle on the end of that finger.
I will keep the finger and the DJ-15 as well as other power tools that are not compliant with OSHA safety BS.
But then again I am not a professional shop. Just a dissatisfied citizen.
I don't believe that we need a nanny state government regulations about workplace safety.
Re: Not controversial to me, but lots of others
BrianMonumentCO
Big questions to go with that is how much money and loss of freedom of choice are you willing to pay for it.
With the partial news of that post being that saw stop won a patent infringement agasint Bosch (IIRC).
All to enforce a patent monopoly which should be nearing its end.
That has prevented other companies from making other models of a flesh sensing saw.
Re: Not controversial to me, but lots of others
Richard McComas
"For some folks"............................Political correctness is the order of the day. Look where it's gotten us.
End of subject, I'll be moving on from this thread as I don't want to get into any matches.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
don stephan
I have difficulty distinguishing between the development of the Saw Stop technology and development of auto and truck seat belt technology. Although I've not been in a bad accident since I was about 3, I wouldn't want a vehicle without seat belts. I've not been damaged by a running table saw, but wish I could afford a Saw Stop.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
Kneale Brownson
If SawStop gets it way, you may not be able to afford ANY tablesaw.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
William Duffield
If I remember correctly, SawStop has offered to license its patents to other table saw manufacturers. The other manufacturers evidently decided it would be risky to put the technology in their new saws because that would expose them to lawsuits for any of their saws that did not include the technology after it was made available to them, and maybe even older saws. Only after the other manufacturers tried to bury him did Steve Gass decide the right thing to do was build his own saw.
Bosch evidently has a different idea, probably at least partially based on the lawsuit that Ryobi subsequently lost. In my opinion, that decision was wrong, and Ryobi should not have been blamed. It was due totally to the stupidity of the worker who was hurt, and the negligence of his supervision.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
BrianMonumentCO
Licensing a patented item is still not a part of TRUE competition.
It is a part of monopolistic behaviour. Our DOJ should crack down on that.
But exploitation of a patent is part of the process of invention and legal under our Constitution.
I always remember the damage done to the aviation industry and the Wright brothers business by them doing nothing more than attempting to enforce their flight patents. They cast such a broad net that they would have sued a bird for violation if they could......
Then again Wright aviation or whatever it was called has essentially disappeared around world war 2.
IIRC it got itself bought up by Curtis.
I don't believe that patents are as important as they could be.
They tend to stifle growth and evolution of certain industries.
Firearms industries comes to mind. Colt vs S&W... Colt had a revolver patent. BUT S&W had the bored through cylinder patent. IIRC the patents did not overlap for much if any time. S&W patent was more powerful as it locked Colt out of self contained ammo for the duration of the patent.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
CJ in MPLS
Depending on how you define it, 'true competition' may simply not be possible in the US. Patent rights are right there in the Constitution, which kind of sets the floor somewhere above what I suppose one might consider true competition. The better way of viewing it is that our laws explicitly state that intellectual property will be one of the areas in which we compete.
Re: Not controversial to me, but lots of others
CJ in MPLS
There has been no final decision in this case as yet. A decision is expected in August.
There has been a resolution of one element of the ITC complaint relating to whether there is a domestic industry: "On January 27, 2016, Complainants filed a motion for a summary determination that they satisfied the economic prong of the domestic industry requirement. On February 8, 2016, Bosch responded that it did not oppose the motion."
Note that Bosch did not oppose this aspect of the case.
From an FAQ on ITC complaints seeking to bar import of infringing articles:
To prove a violation of Section 337, a complainant must establish (1) unfair competition or an unfair act, e.g., patent or trademark infringement, (2) importation, sale for importation, or sale after importation into the United States of the accused products, and (3) the existence of a domestic industry relating to the product in question. In investigations that are not based upon alleged infringement of federal statutory intellectual property rights, a complainant also must prove (4) that the alleged unfair act has caused or threatens to cause injury.
At Which Time
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
my JET left-tilt 3hp Exacta w/ extension table, custom outfeed, and mobile base will be worth 4 times what I paid for it. This is just the excuse I've been waiting for to buy a SawStop!!
Anyone wanna make me an offer before the price quads?
[Pick-ups only, thanks]
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
BrianMonumentCO
But once a patent is issued for an intellectual thing that is it for 20 years.
There can be no evolution in that specific area until 20 years is up unless it is COMPLETELY different.
But we know that some patent holders will attempt to "expand" their patent to include a whole lot of adjacent area. Recall what the wright brothers did.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
CJ in MPLS
Forgive the liberty, but your complaint doesn't really appear to be with SawStop, but rather with US patent law itself, SawStop merely being an example of the problem. If this is the case, your stance is not unreasonable, though it is one with which I don't agree. For every person that objects to the vigorous application of patents, there is another that is mad because someone is stealing their ideas or the ideas of another (which isn’t the correct way of stating this, but you get the idea). This is at least partly why internet posters are so interested in attribution to determine whether the content is original to the poster.
In this instance I don't really see the problem with SawStop using all of the tools at its disposal. For better or for worse, the law is what it is.
I took a quick look at the claims of the patents cited in SawStop’s USITC complaint and I’m of the opinion that Bosch’s best course would be to take a license from SawStop. SawStop has done a good job of covering their bases. Note that the ‘450 patent to SawStop was filed in 2010 and as a result, absent invalidation, will expire in 2030. The claims of this patent would appear to read directly on the REAXX product.
SawStop patents
7,225,712 - systems that keep track of blade movement and disable the safety device when the blade is moving and for a short time after it stops (no triggering when the blade isn't moving)
7,600,455 - tool that has a detection system, a reaction system, and a control system in which the detection system figures out if you trying to cut your finger off, the reaction system acts to prevent this and the control system figures out whether the reaction system is functional and shuts down the tool if the reaction system is not functional
7,610,836 - single use components in the safety system
7,895,927 - retracting a saw blade below the table surface within 14 milliseconds after the saw detects that you are doing something unwise
8,011,279 - saw that retracts the blade and/or stops the blade upon sensing contact with the user and wherein an actuator moves the blade by about 1/32" within 3 milliseconds after sensing contact
8,191,450 - the reaction system is configured to pivot the cutting tool at least partially away from the cutting region upon detection of the dangerous condition by the detection system
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
BrianMonumentCO
I NEVER actually said that I had a problem with SawStop EXCEPT where they are pressuring OSHA and the government and UL to create safety standards for the industry and hobbyists that FORCE us to use SawStop technology ONLY. If such as standard is adopted the patents MUST be invalidated or forced into a significantly less expensive licensing model. Otherwise we simply as consumers pay through the nose for this guys invention.
Please note that I stand on my bet that not all of the 450 patents this guy has pertain to the implementation of a safe table saw.
The first patent you listed implied that a safety device already existed. This means the list is incomplete at best.
Sawstop was founded in 1999. If the patent for the core technology was granted in 2010, I wonder why it took them 10+ years for a patent.
I would have thought they could have gotten a patent earlier.
Re: SawStop Lawsuit
Rob Sandow
A few years ago I sold my Powermatic 66 and replaced it with a Sawstop. I don't think the technology should be required and disagree with the Sawstop people for their law suits. But I like my fingers, so that was my motivation.