Re: SawStop Lawsuit
CJ in MPLS
I don't think anyone disagrees with you that if SawStop has 450 patents, that many of them don't relate to the safety mechanism in question. I'm not certain that this is pertinent however as it only takes one patent to make infringement stick.
Patents routinely take many years to issue. Three years of pendency is more likely than ten though. Keep in mind that 10 years of pendency is unfortunately all too common for patent applications. Cases that last 10 years often have what are called continuations filed. I've had a few of these pending more than 15 years.
I'm not really certain what you meant by the list being incomplete. I merely copied the patent numbers SawStop listed in their complaint. If you mean that the patent was putting the cart before the horse with respect to the existence of a safety device, I think you'll find that the patent application describes the safety device sufficiently for patentability purposes, i.e. it satisfies 35 USC 112.
What makes this entire matter rather interesting to me is that the parties involved are playing hardball. I expect that the push for OSHA to adopt flesh sensing technology is in direct response to the apparently concerted efforts of the Power Tool Institute. For example, I was reading a report written by USITC in which SawStop requested that import duties on table saws be lifted. The USITC contacted a number of manufacturers to see if they were in favor or in opposition. Only the Power Tool Institute folks responded and they indicated that they wanted import duties to remain in place. The amount of money per saw isn't likely to be overlarge, but if you buy a saw today in the US, tool companies other than SawStop have helped make your saw more expensive. This is kind of odd when you consider that table saws are not, as far as I am aware, manufactured in the US and would be subject to import duties. One could argue that this was an effort to avoid cost reductions that could make flesh sensing technology more affordable.



