Improvements
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
in abrasive technology since I last looked which was, admittedly, "several" years ago.
Thanks for the info, Bill.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Improvements
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
in abrasive technology since I last looked which was, admittedly, "several" years ago.
Thanks for the info, Bill.
Re: Focusing the discussion back to woodworking to
William Duffield
I guess the implication here is that Lee Valley could make an excellent kitchen knife using their PM-V11 steel, but they wouldn't be successful selling it in their Home and Garden catalog. 
Re: Focusing the discussion back to woodworking to
Jesse Cloud
Not sure of that. I think a good kitchen knife might have broader appeal than say inlay string cutters or router planes, both of which I have bought. I would probably spring for one if the price were equivalent to that of japanese knives.
Looks like a person could build one of these
Re: Focusing the discussion back to woodworking to
William Duffield
Sorry, I guess my feeble attempt at irony was a little too subtle. Of course, anyone following this forum and in particular this thread could make a good case for buying a set of these hypothetical PM-V11 kitchen knives. However, If they were offered in the Home and Kitchen catalog, a lot of non-woodworkers might complain that they were unsharpenable, resulting in bad reviews and returns. My guess is there are a lot more people who follow the Lee-Valley kitchen tools than follow their woodworking hand tools. How many foodies would be willing to invest in Leonard Lee's book on sharpening, a sharpening jig and a basin full of water stones? Of course, they do offer Japanese stainless clad tool steel kitchen knives and sharpening accessories in the referenced catalog, so some foodies must make the leap from ceramic sticks. (Ref. page 202 of the 2015 U.S. edition).
Personally, I would probably not buy a set of these, because SWMBO abuses knives by slicing and chopping stuff up in the bottom of the skillets and even on ceramic dishes and platters. Thus, I buy my knives at IKEA*.
I "magically" sharpen knives for myself and family using a set of DiaSharp credit card plates, but I don't use a jig, so it takes me a bit longer. I can carry them in my wallet, thus the "magic", as I don't need to disappear into the shop or drag out a lot of paraphernalia to get job done.
*My favorites are their GYNNSAM line of vanadium-molybdenum stainless, but I was recently told these are discontinued. There is no elitist value in these.
Kitchen Trick
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Should always use a wood or PTFE/nylon cutting board, but if you must cut on a hard surface, put the item on a double layer of paper towel. The paper will cushion the knife edge while allowing it to cut the food cleanly. Especially useful when "chopping" leaf vegs like parsley or basil.
can there be......
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
....a woodworker without several cutting boards at hand!
Sure
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
when Memsahib's using two and asks you to slice the tomatoes and basil!
Re: Kitchen Trick
William Duffield
Who woulda thunk it? I never would have guessed that paper towels would be sufficient to protect my blade edges, given the standard demonstration of sharpness by slicing up paper. But, as Bill suggests, I have no shortage of wooden cutting boards in my kitchen, mostly maple. I just rescued one of them from the dishwasher. 
Re: Focusing the discussion back to woodworking to
Jesse Cloud
I have a IKEA bread knife that I bought about 25 years ago. I use it daily, have never sharpened it and it still slices through the bread like butter. I think I paid maybe $5. They do have some hidden treasures.
Re: Kitchen Trick
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Even on a cutting board, if you use the paper towel under parsley or basil, the leaves don't smear on the board and the board stays clean. Cut the stuff and shake it into the other ingredients. Done 
Re: Kitchen Trick
Brian Holcombe
I've gone one step further an insist on a softwood cutting board. Even the henckles that my wife uses are not appreciably dull after several months of use.
They can get sharp, but dont stay very sharp very long. They seem to work best with an almost serrated edge left by a 1k stone and maintenance with a steel. So they stay sharp enough to cut vegetables, ect, ect.
When I want to cut fish to make sushi I use my Heiji which is not even stored in the kitchen for fear that someone other than myself will use it. The Heiji yanagi has an incredibly steep bevel angle. It's practically like using a straight razor and people who press firmly into a cut will dull the edge in a hurry. Draw cut properly and it stays razor sharp for a very long time.
Eventually I'll get either a Heiji or Shigfusa gyuto for regular use in the kitchen, but by regular use....i mean for my own regular use....not others who put the knife into the sink after use. 
Re: The Idea
R. Payne
Not exactly. If you use 2000 grit you'll get no finer than 2000 grit. It may be worse.
I've got one PM plane blade that sits unused on a shelf because, even with diamond (stones and grit to 0.5 micron), it doesn't work as well, doesn't leave as fine a surface as (old) carbon steel irons.
I've got several knives in PM steel of various flavors. They don't take as fine an edge nor do they hold it as long as the knives I carry. The knives I carry I made myself for me to my specifications, including heat treat which I leave at nearly full hard (new file barely scratches the edge).
For the standard stuff you can buy from the store today, you may not like the carbon. But carbon steel can beat anything I've tried.
BTDT
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
My Shuns are cleaned, dried, and replaced in the cushioned drawer after each use.
When cutting fish, there is always the slight "hissss" as the blade goes through the piece.
Re: Looks like a person could build one of these
John K Jordan
That's what I thought. No legal or moral issues in making one for for personal use.
If anyone want's to try it: they use a thin sheet of graphite under the belt where the knife presses, one belt wheel is flat and one domed, the guide looks like HDPE with grooves machined at different heights, the while guide end is spring loaded to tension the belt and swivels to adjust tracking, the blade clamps should be trivial to make but the dimensions probably need to be right.
It might be cheaper to buy than design and fabricate from scratch although the thing is pretty expensive if you pay the asking price. Fortunately, a dealer friend sold me one at cost. He keeps several in stock all the time since once people see how sharp their knife is some want one whatever the cost.
JKJ
Except
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
this only seems to work with a sharp, straight-edged knife. If you need to use a sawing/slicing stroke or serrated blade, you'll cut through the paper as well, even with a "so-so" edged blade.
Re: Masakage knives, A question
Jesse Cloud
FYI, Williams Sonoma has Shun knives on sale "Up to 70% off." I don't know what they usually go for, so I am skeptical. But if you are interested, its available both online and in stores. And theres free shipping with the promo code FREESHIP.