Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Sharpening Kitchen Knives

Posts

Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#1

Sharpening Kitchen Knives

don stephan

Certainly, kitchen knives is not directly about woodworking. But when She Who Must Be Obeyed (SWMBO) is not happy, quality woodworking time suffers.

Anyone have experience positive or negative with the crossed stick knife sharpeners? I've never developed a skill to freehand hone knife blades, and can't afford to practice on SWMBO's weapons.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#3

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives *LINK*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

My favorite sharpener is the IKEA skarande. Opposing wheels in three grits, water flushed grind, cheap and easy to use. Only $12.99! Sharp enough to cut flesh without any pressure.


IKEA sharpener

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#4

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

John in NM

I think I'd go with any of the style that Mark and Bill suggested. Those rod thingies don't seem to me to solve the basic geometry problem as well as the little roller sharpeners.

Those rods also always look really fragile to me! I could see either of the two posted being tossed in a drawer after use for years and never suffer from it.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#5

I use a Lansky *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

I can't speak to the crock sticks. I use one of the Lansky knife sharpener tools. Here's why:

In my shop, when I want to sharpen a plane iron or chisel (beyond a minor touch up), I use a jig which holds the tool at the same angle squarely, and repeatably. I use the Veritas Mk II plane sharpening jig to do this. This tool takes the human factor out of the job, and therefore the end result is excellent.

Any time a human has to do more than one thing simultaneously, the results are less than perfect. If you can isolate your task to one motion (no holding the right angle), you are way ahead.

A hunter friend of mine showed me the jig he used to sharpen his knives. It was a Lansky classic knife sharpener set. The jig provides a clamp for the knife to be held in place, while the stone has a rigid wire that rides in a slot on that clamp. This ensures the knife can be held at precisely the same angle for each stroke. Further, the next time you sharpen, it is still at the same angle (if you took note of what the angle was you used).

Soon thereafter, he gave me one for Christmas, and we have had reliably sharp knives ever since. If I were to buy one today, I'd opt for the diamond version below. Lansky does also make a selection of different options and individually available hones for specific tasks.

Some hold the jig in their hand to sharpen, but I found that awkward for me, so I made a base for my jig to sit on the table that would not tip over while holding a knife. This also makes sharpening a breeze. Basically, it is like their plastic stand, but made of a piece of oak with a wider footprint.

If there is any issue with the jig, it is that longer knives should be done in two operations in order to keep the same angle, one pass for the tip of the knife, and one for the area near the hilt. This is only an issue on knives over about 8" or so, and you could argue that the need to double clamp allows two different cutting angles, which can provide more versatile sharpening options. I think I use the 20 degree angle for our kitchen knives, and 17 degrees for the filet knives. The first time you sharpen, you will need to decide on a cutting angle, and do some extra honing to each knife to bring it within that angle. Expect maybe 8-10 minutes per knife the first time. After that, it goes much quicker, and the results are nothing short of amazing.

Do be careful, however, as a truly sharp kitchen knife takes some by surprise. We have had to bandage up a dinner guest once who wasn't expecting such a sharp knife. Once bandaged, the person did very much like the sharp knives though.

Also be ready for dinner guests to ask you to sharpen their knives :D

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa


Lansky sharpening set

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#6

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

Ralph Lipeles

I use a set of the Norton rods twice a year on our kitchen knife set and they do a great job. The knives are razor sharp. If I get a knife that has an abused edge I first do reshape the edge with a 1 x 42 belt sander. 100 grit for making the edge followed by 320 grit final cleanup.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#7

Now there is a topic- Rant on

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Summary : it all depends on the steel

I had never sharpened a kitchen knife to my satisfaction until I ran across a vintage Japanese knife at a flea market for $7. At last a kitchen knife with steel like we use for woodworking, which consequentially can be (and must be) sharpened like a woodworking tool.

I think American kitchen knives are made from steel that either is junk and can't be sharpened, or is made for American chefs that sharpen with a "steel". As a result American made knives can not take and hold an edge like a knife made from tool steel (tool steel is steel for tools not to be confused with HSS, high speed steel, used to make tooling with high heat resistance) and heat treated for long edge life and keen edge. The American way is to make a soft knife (substantially less than Rc60) that is easily sharpened by any means.....and quickly dulls.

Apparently the Japanese way is (or was) to make a knife like a chisel. High quality tool steel and high heat treat hardness. It will take a good abrasive to sharpen it but it takes a razor blade edge and holds it. Not many US kitchens are equipped with a water stone and strop.

I was boning out a deer yesterday. I have a "quality" professional American made boning knife. I had to sharpen it several times. A few passes over a bone and it was too dull to deftly remove membranes and the like. The skinning knife I made from CPM 3V is immune to bone and I can skin several animals before it needs light touchup on a strop, for example.

And then there is the wife. She doesn't like a sharp knife. Says it is too easy to get cut. I says improve your technique. We don't coexist in the kitchen. :)

Summary: what ever you use for woodworking will work for a knife to get it as sharp as its likely crummy steel will allow. Alternatively, if the knife is designed for a chef the edge straightening procedures like the "steel" and the ceramic rods will improve the edge, but not to the satisfaction of a woodworker that uses planes and chisels.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#8

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

Gary Smyth




I like sharp knives but most of the time my knives require little more than a slice through cranberry sauce. But a few years ago I got huckstered into a spyderco triangle "system" at a boat show. It seemed so easy in the demonstration I bought a set. While I kicked myself all the way home for the price paid (show price $41.00) for me it does the job and I've had it for a couple of decades. Two sets of sticks, course and fine ceramic. It will also do scissors and hooks in fishing flys. Ten strokes or so (on the point, not the side as shown in the photo) and I'm good. There is a you tube video too. My knives are supermarket butcher knives recommended by the butcher (no name visible) and aside from several old inherited Chicago wood handles, are what is out there. The butcher also got me a Chantry honing device. They had several of them mounted permanently at the cutting tables. The label says sharpener, but basically it is two (replaceable) rotating steels and they hone rather than sharpen. To use just draw the knofe through the slot. using no pressure. Both clean up in the dishwasher if needed.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#9

Re: Now there is a topic- Rant on

Paul in NJ

"The American way is to make a soft knife (substantially less than Rc60) that is easily sharpened by any means.....and quickly dulls".

Whenever I have been in a real butcher shop where they actual cut meat, they always used simple carbon steel knives, no stainless or exotic steels. They always started with a few swipes on a sharpening steel, the smooth kind not serrated. It they needed a quick touch up, a few more swipes, no muss to fuss. Seemed sharp enough to me watching them work.

The other half likes stainless in the kitchen, no rust. German made knives, Henckel I believe. They take a nice edge and hold it for a while. I have no problems honing on oil stones, no jigs. It took a while to develop proficiency. It only takes a minute or so per knife if you don't let them get too dull, just like my planes and chisels.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#10

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

E Snow

I wonder what techniques you've tried freehanding, and more importantly with what?

Oil stones sold for knife sharpening are on the low end of decent in my opinion. Perhaps better identified as a hone as they really don't move any metal which leads to overwork and eventually bad geometry.

I keep some small ~2.5x7" two sided water stone in my kitchen, 320/1000 and 600/2000. Both super cheapo fast wearing corundum. It has always worked great by cutting quickly and being small enough to move the stone over the knife for knives with odd geometry. Sort of like sharpening the bevel of a carving gouge, at times easier to move the stone than it is moving the gouge. For what its worth my arsenal is a mix of japanese pieces and victoricox/forschner, some I stop at 1000 other at 2000, most are touched up 3-5 times with a hardened steel (barely textured and not abrasive) before going back to the stone.

I think that fast cutting is the key to easy and consistent for a knife, the more times you wobble over the stone the more unflat the primary bevel will become on the knife. Typically, I can be done with 5 ish strokes per side. Also, there are plenty of aids out there to help hold the bevel but realistically it comes pretty quickly. Might be worth the $8 to try if you've already got the stone/stones.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#11

I loathe SS kitchen knives

John in NM

I have two old carbon steel knives I keep at work. They get amazingly sharp and stay that way a long time. Ugly as can be, but that is immaterial.

At home we have a variety of SS knives. They sharpen ok, but then I just wipe them on a coarse stone and leave it at that. No point to putting a good edge on a knife that will never hold it.

My favorites of the bunch are these really cheap ones that a friend of Jean's sells as a church fundraiser. Thin and springy knives, most around $10 or a little more IIRC. They don't hold an edge either, but they are fast to sharpen since there isn't much bevel.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#12

loathing stainless unjustified

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

OK to loathe the stainless steel kitchen knives commonly available. But most of the better pocket and tactical knives will be stainless steel. Do you use carbon steel razor blades? Most don't because a high quality stainless cutlery steel optimally heat treated is as good as it gets. The problem is that the typical stainless kitchen knife is of a composition and heat treated to a hardness that makes it easy to "sharpen". The result is a knife that has poor edge retention, if in fact one can get something a wood worker would call an edge to begin with. The new to Lee Valley wood working tool steel is a stainless. There is no doubt that it would make a dandy knife, if in fact others are not already using the steel for knives and calling the steel by another name. In fact, any steel in the 440 series of stainless makes exceptional knives. Want better dulling resistance, then the stainless steels with vanadium like S30V excel but take diamonds to sharpen.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#13

not in my experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We have two restaurant supply places locally that carry knives for chefs (which I equate to butchers when it comes to meat cutting). Neither store carries a carbon steel knife. The problem, for me, is that these knives are heat treated to be soft enough to sharpen with a steel. Easy to sharpen and easy to dull. Personally I would rather have a knife that holds an edge longer and I am willing to sharpen it with a water stone.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#14

Kent B

Heretic's View

Kent B

Chef's Choice sharpener. Excellent results. Quick, and reliable, fits in a corner of a kitchen shelf [v. out in the shop]. Zero mess. On my second one - the original design [15 yrs ago?] did not allow for swapping wheels when they were used up.

And - I have Shaptons, a couple Ark oil stones somewhere, a couple large pieces of 1/2" float glass, and a WorkSharp. Use different things for different shop tasks.

But not the kitchen knives. I did not want to let anyone else in the house know that my shop stuff had a greater purpose - that way lies madness.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#15

Re: loathing stainless unjustified

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'll match my Shuns against anything you choose for use in the kitchen.

They're not butcher's or skinning knives; I've no use for such.

But I can fan a tomato in 1/8" slices, shave shallots into angel hair wisps with little or no effort, render shrooms for near-paper thin garnish, or carve a turkey breast to fit back on the ribs just for show. They sharpen with a few swipes through the ceramic "V" in the Wusthof.

Actually inherited grandfather's real butcher knives. Good carbon steel circa 1920's and mere whips of their original profiles after two generations of sharpenings, but the boning knife will shave hair with a couple of swipes.

Interestingly, Grandma used to sharpen her knives on the limestone window sill in her Bronx, NY apartment building. Oh, my, the smells from that little kitchen will last a lifetime . . . .

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#16

Re: loathing stainless unjustified

R. Payne

440 series makes terrible knives. I've yet to meet a stainless that will compare to high carbon. The carbides formed by the elements that impart stain resistance are just too large compared to the steel matrix to take a fine edge.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#17

Re: Heretic's View - Agree and Disagree

John McGaw

I'll second that. I have a model 100 and have had it for years. It can put a perfect edge on any kitchen knife in a minute with no trouble and little chance of anything going wrong. My everyday stainless, yes I have stainless knives, are always sharp. Oh, I have a high-carbon set too but they are a PITA to keep clean because they stain and have wooden handles; I can and do just throw the stainless into the dishwasher.

I'll have to disagree with those who claim that people using a steel are sharpening their knives. No, they are perfecting or refining the existing edge by straightening up the bits of metal that get rolled over in use. Sharpening involves removing metal to shape an edge and a steel can't do that otherwise we'd all be using steels in our shops since they never wear out in use.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#18

Let me make an introduction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The carbides formed by the elements that impart stain resistance are just too large compared to the steel matrix to take a fine edge. "

This statement would have been true many years ago before the invention of particle steel technology. Meet the stainless steel now available from Lee Valley. Nothing finer for plane blades and chisels. But really any of the particle steels sharpen as well as anything, be they stainless steel or not. The chromium content that makes them stainless is irrelevant to their sharpening properties. A2 has a chromium content that makes it almost a stainless steel. Nobody is complaining that it can't be sharpened given the correct abrasive. Steve Elliot has some nice data on the topic.

And then there are the stainless steel razor blades. You think they are not sharp enough, or as sharp as sharp can get?

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#20

Not stainless itself, kitchen knives made of it...

John in NM

Stainless is useful stuff, just makes a lousy knife in most of the commonly used alloys or treatments. 440 might make a dandy knife, but I have yet to come across one.

No clue what my razor blades are, they are disposable. Kitchen knives should not be disposable.

Most of my pocket knives are carbon steel. I believe I have two stainless pocket knives, one I keep in a tool belt for cutting shingles, another is stuffed in a backpack pouch somewhere as a backup.

I like carbon blades because even the commonly available ones sharpen easily by any means you like and retain their edge well. If stainless can do the same, shame on manufacturers for not bothering to heat treat well. I suspect that the problem lies in the material rather than the treatment.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#21

What I found best.

John K Jordan

Don, I don't want to jump into the degenerating knife fray, but to answer your question: I find the crossed stick "sharpeners" marginal honing tools at best. They don't usually sharpen well. The angle is usually fixed which is useless if it does not happen to match your knife's edge angle. Even if it does, the honing is minimal. The positive thing is it holds the angle constant which is absolutely important.

I have one diamond sharpener with a similar design but it is fairly complex, spring loaded, etc, and hones at a different angle as honing should.

I have and have used many sharpeners including the small belt sanders that run on a triangular wheel arrangement. Some work better than others. I have sharpened knives on the Tormek wet grinder, wet stones, diamond and ceramic stones, scary sharp sandpaper, etc.

NONE work as well as the belt sharpener I use now. Unfortunately, it is a bit expensive. I think it is priced to be used in a knife sharpening business but I love it for the shop and home. A guyI know has one which he takes to gun shows. He sharpens pocket knives all day at $4 a knife. It is very quick to sharpen. I was a doubter until I tried the thing.

It gets my knives so sharp I can push a post-it note sheet into the edge and it will cut it cleanly. When I sharpen my wife's kitchen knives she says they almost fall through the meat and veggies. It gets knives so sharp that when I sharpen knives for others I have to warn them or they are likely to get cut. Everyone is impressed, even after they forget and cut themselves.

The one I bought is labeled RealSharp but when looking for it on the internet I found the identical thing by some other names. I don't know if they are all made by the same people and sold under different names or if someone stole the design, but they all look identical. This thing uses three belts, one to grind the bevel, a very fine belt to hone then add a microbevel, and a non-abrasive to strop/polish using a compound. It comes with clamp jigs preset to common edge angles. The whole thing looks a bit homemade but it is actually quite well made, just no commercial glitz added.

I'm sure this isn't what you were looking for, but you might be interested or someone else might! If you lived close (East TN) I'd say bring over all your knives and take them home sharp!

YouTube videos of the thing in operation:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MurfMUE5ZG0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOAjJ0rulhM

JKJ

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#22

Re: What is a Shun?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You can google them but

http://shun.kaiusaltd.com/

SWMBO bought a set of Cutcos when our son's bud was "working his way through college". I suffered those things for years but finally got to use a Shun at a foodie friend's cooking party. Went out and bought the ones I'd use and have never looked back.

Pay $140 for a 6" utility knife? Nuts, right?

Opens a new world of enjoyment in the kitchen.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#23

Re: Ditto on Shun

Hank Knight

We have a Shun 7" santoku. It is by far the best kitchen knife we own. We have a bunch of Wustofs. They are the Ford of kitchen knives; the Shun is a Ferrari. I sharpen my Shun on water stones and finish with a fine Honyama stone. Taking time to put a good edge on the Shun is worth it; the knife keeps the edge for a long time.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#24

The Idea Persists

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

that the molecular structure of a metal determines the sharpness of the edge. Unless we consider abrasives with granules the size of molecules, the point is useless.

Every edge ground with the same abrasive (120 or 12,000) will have the same fineness of the edge. The crystalline structure of the steel makes no difference until the size of the abrasive particles meets or is smaller than the metal's basic structure.

Yes, theoretically, good carbon steel could be sharpened to a finer edge than ASP 2060. Haven't even heard of anyone trying to do that. Far beyond the capacity of most anyone doing knives or woodworking tools to even approach by several factors of magnitude.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#25

Re: Heretic's View - Agree and Disagree

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have a Trident Diamant "steel," and I'm not sure it would really be called a steel. It's shaped and used like a traditional steel but it has an oval shape and is coated with diamonds. It most assuredly does get knives very sharp and not just by refining an edge; it removes steel.