I use a Lansky *LINK*
Grant in Iowa
I can't speak to the crock sticks. I use one of the Lansky knife sharpener tools. Here's why:
In my shop, when I want to sharpen a plane iron or chisel (beyond a minor touch up), I use a jig which holds the tool at the same angle squarely, and repeatably. I use the Veritas Mk II plane sharpening jig to do this. This tool takes the human factor out of the job, and therefore the end result is excellent.
Any time a human has to do more than one thing simultaneously, the results are less than perfect. If you can isolate your task to one motion (no holding the right angle), you are way ahead.
A hunter friend of mine showed me the jig he used to sharpen his knives. It was a Lansky classic knife sharpener set. The jig provides a clamp for the knife to be held in place, while the stone has a rigid wire that rides in a slot on that clamp. This ensures the knife can be held at precisely the same angle for each stroke. Further, the next time you sharpen, it is still at the same angle (if you took note of what the angle was you used).
Soon thereafter, he gave me one for Christmas, and we have had reliably sharp knives ever since. If I were to buy one today, I'd opt for the diamond version below. Lansky does also make a selection of different options and individually available hones for specific tasks.
Some hold the jig in their hand to sharpen, but I found that awkward for me, so I made a base for my jig to sit on the table that would not tip over while holding a knife. This also makes sharpening a breeze. Basically, it is like their plastic stand, but made of a piece of oak with a wider footprint.
If there is any issue with the jig, it is that longer knives should be done in two operations in order to keep the same angle, one pass for the tip of the knife, and one for the area near the hilt. This is only an issue on knives over about 8" or so, and you could argue that the need to double clamp allows two different cutting angles, which can provide more versatile sharpening options. I think I use the 20 degree angle for our kitchen knives, and 17 degrees for the filet knives. The first time you sharpen, you will need to decide on a cutting angle, and do some extra honing to each knife to bring it within that angle. Expect maybe 8-10 minutes per knife the first time. After that, it goes much quicker, and the results are nothing short of amazing.
Do be careful, however, as a truly sharp kitchen knife takes some by surprise. We have had to bandage up a dinner guest once who wasn't expecting such a sharp knife. Once bandaged, the person did very much like the sharp knives though.
Also be ready for dinner guests to ask you to sharpen their knives 
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa
Lansky sharpening set