Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Sharpening Kitchen Knives

Posts

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#26

razor blades...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They are all made from some sort of cutlery stainless steel. They prove that a stainless steel can be made to take and keep a fine edge. Ditto for the steel from Lee Valley.

I have two excellent hunting knives made from one of the 440 series stainless steels. One is a Kbar the other generic. They are as good a knife as I have used. And I have some exceptionally crummy stainless steel knives.

I sharpen enough hand tools that I have come to consider myself experienced in assessing whether a piece of steel will sharpen well and how well the edge lasts. My hand tool experience has made me picky about knives. One should not need to float a loan to get a good kitchen knife. The steel and heat treating for a knife is at most a few dollars. The rest is handle and name. I don't know why moderately priced knives are not available with good steel, stainless or otherwise.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#27

Re: razor blades...

John in NM

I don't dispute that stainless can be made very sharp. Others have claimed it can't however, perhaps you are just reading quickly as we all do now and then.

I did claim that it takes more effort (for me at least) than does carbon steel and that if the effort is expended the blade will not hold its edge for long in use compared to a humble 1095 knife. You could sharpen mild steel, iron, or bronze to a shaving edge, but they won't hold that edge long.

I have found carbon blades to hold their edge excellently in the kitchen. Last one I bought was a nice carbon steel Ontario butchers knife. Cost $5 in a junk store. I was going to send it to you after the last one of these discussions, but I liked it too much and kept it :D Ontario still makes them, cost $15 or so new.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#28

Masakage knives *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

I recently bought a couple of these Masakage knives for my wife, but i haven't tried to sharpen them yet.

VG10 Stainless steel

Rockwell Hardness 61:62

Octagon handle of Rose wood and black pakka wood




Masakage website

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#29

Re: Heretic's View - Agree and Disagree

John McGaw

I'd say that what you have and the traditional steel are vastly different critters. I've never heard of a diamond-coated steel but I can see where it might do a good job although I'd worry just a bit about the effects of sloppy handling -- get the angle just a bit off and...

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#30

Re: Masakage knives, A question

Barry Irby

That's a beautiful knife. I wonder about the handle. Its beautiful but how about function? Does it feel good in your hand? Can you sense the orientation of the blade? Just doesn't look like a "form follows function" design to me.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#31

Re: Masakage knives

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Foodie friend's son is a 5-Star and has received several.

Above my pay scale ;)

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#32

Re: Sharpening

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Shuns come with a "limited" "lifetime" warranty for resharpening by the factory. Resharpening is to be differentiated from "refreshing" the edge which is all I actually have to do. One of my knives developed a small round nick in the edge after several years. Sent it to the company, and they sent me back new knife.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#33

Focusing the discussion back to woodworking tools

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The steel from Lee Valley settles the issue of whether a stainless steel can take and hold a superior edge. (Owners of high quality Japanese stainless knives already knew this fact.) Chopping wood challenges an edge way more than cutting celery. This LV steel has been found by all to have superior edge holding capability for plane blades and chisels compared to carbon steel, and with the right abrasive it can be sharpened as good as it gets.

I don't move in the world of tactical knives and knife competition but I know someone that does. CPM's S30V stainless vastly exceeds any carbon steel for durability. The carbon knife user could come to the conclusion that it won't take as keen an edge, but this observation requires qualification. Because of its exceptional wear resistance it can not be sharpened with an Ark stone.

In fact this notion that "tool steels" will not take as keen an edge has been disproven by Steve Elliot and others. The problem is these steels are often highly abrasion resistant. Sharpening routines that work for a vintage chisel may not sharpen these steels . Hence the employment of water stones and diamond stones for these steels, either in knives or plane blades.

I believe the problem with kitchen knives is that the average cook/chef doesn't know how to sharpen and doesn't want to learn. Knives are made for this customer, not us woodworkers who know how to sharpen and have the tools to do so on any steel.

Even the ordinary carbon steel knife could be greatly improved by making it from a better carbon steel and heat treating it to high hardness. The problem then would be it could not be "sharpened" by the ineffective means found in most kitchens, the ceramic rod thingies for example.

The problem is not that the best kitchen knife can not be made from a stainless steel. The problem is that western knife manufacturers target a customer that lacks woodworking capability for sharpening a knife. Some combination of inferior steel and/or heat treatment yields a soft easily sharpened product most are satisfied with. Sadly, a $25 knife could be made that would be as good as any (but lack styling and oriental mumbo jumbo that pushes the price to over $100 unless you happen upon a flea market find).

I have sharpened dozens of kinds of "western" kitchen knives and my woodworking chisels and plane blades for comparison. It is two different worlds. I have yet to see a western stainless steel kitchen knife that will sharpen as well as a decent plane blade. I have seen carbon steel kitchen knives that take an edge as good as a plane blade, but the steel is soft and they don't hold an edge. I have two 440 series knives that do sharpen as well as my best woodworking steel.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#34

that is the secret

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Rockwell Hardness 61:62

For some reason the western world doesn't make knives of this hardness. This is the hardness of our best woodworking tools. Make a chisel in the Rockwell range of the typical western knife and we would find it useless for cutting wood for any meaningful length of time.

Sadly, to get this hardness, and performance, one has to buy a Japanese knife and pay for the exceptional beauty and oriental mumbo jumbo of towel headed smiths working under a shade tree at the family forge, or some such. There doesn't need to be more than $5 worth of steel in a superior kitchen knife. Most of the sales price is marketing and beauty.

If you want as good as it gets western stainless knife (which isn't saying much) go to a restaurant supply and buy one of the white handled affairs. In my hands the steel is equivalent to the $100 German Wusthof and the cost is $25. I follow sharpening by studying the process with high magnification. The resulting edge sucks compared to a plane blade. But you can "sharpen" it with a steel or ceramic thingy.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#35

Re: Masakage knives, A question

Mark Hennebury

I gave them as a present to my wife, a 180mm and little 75mm similar to this on

I have not used them, i won't. I wouldn't want anyone messing with my tools. They seem to be very nice knives, i read a little about them and spoke to the sales people in the store for quite a while before i decided on these ones ( they had a lot of choices) I really don't know how "good" they are, but i assume that most high end knives are pretty good at doing what they are supposed to do. The idea of a present is to make the person feel special and i thought that these did that. They have the function but also the beauty and exotic mystery. So to me they filled the bill.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#36

I think you know

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Woodworkers feel enough sharpened edges to know a good one when we feel it.

I was in a store selling knives and kitchen stuff. As I dithered by the knife selection the knowledgeable sales person arrived and asked if I would like to inspect their Japanese knife offering. With nothing better to do I accepted the offer. I am not smitten by the handle style they use but the steel was clearly better than any western knife in the case.

The western world could make as good a functioning knife from inexpensive O-1 or 440C steel if there was a will to do so.

PS. gorgeous knife Will you get to sharpen it?

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#37

Re: I think you know *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

I will probably have a go at sharpening it soon, although i find that a little intimidating as i have only sharpened woodworking tools which are mostly straight.

The knife store had an exceptionally nice collection of Japanese sharpening stones as well as a large collection of knives from many makers, it was quite an interesting store. I have added a link in case anyone should like a look.

I think that a large part of anything that we do for enjoyment has a lot more than just function; there has to be some mystery, something exotic about it, to create a fantasy of "special" that adds to the enjoyment of using or doing something. Weather its Japanese chisels, kitchen knives, or hand made handplanes. Handplaning is a lot more fun when the handplane is special... even if its only in your mind.


store website

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#38

Re: Now there is a topic- Rant on

BradChenoweth

Hi Bill,

Have you ever used a Warther knife? Made from CPM 35SVN steel, Rockwell 58-60. Beautiful knives. They probably don't hold an edge as well as a high end knife, but they are a treat to use, for me at least.

Handmade right here in Ohio by a longtime family business. If you ever get to Dover, Ohio, the Warther woodcarving museum, located at the same place as the knife shop, is a real treat. "Mooney" Warther was an incredible talent!

www.warthercutlery.com

Brad, lovin' the warm temps in NE Ohio

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#39

Dang it..

Brad Chenoweth

Should have been S35VN.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#40

Re: Dang it..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Looks to be an improved s30V alloy but better toughness. Should make a dandy chisel....With 3% vanadium a bear to sharpen though unless diamonds are employed. The 3% vanadium will impart exceptional wear resistance. Good for planes blades too.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#41

Re: The Idea Persists

R. Payne

I have to disagree. I used to have, before the last computer upgrade, an image of a several sharpened edges of various steels that had been treated to show the carbides. The edge was much finer (from standard sharpening) than the carbides, the size of the carbides matters even in particle metallurgy. Stainless cannot get as sharp as carbon. Stainless razors are not honed at as fine an angle as carbon steel razors.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#42

Back?

John in NM

The discussion started with kitchen knives. My comments on stainless are only in reference to kitchen knives, and readily available ones at that. S30V is not 440. Anyone making kitchen knives out of S30V? Any of them you find in the $15 price range? (for comparison to the 1095 Ontario one I mentioned)

Now if you want to argue that 440 can be treated to compare favorably to a regular O1 or 1095 steel, go right ahead. I think if it could be done, someone would be doing it and selling a product, but that is just a rule of thumb.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#43

Re: that is the secret

don stephan

"oriental mumbo jumbo of towel headed smiths" doesn't sound very complimentary.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#44

Re: The Idea

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You put any metal to a 2000 grit wheel, you'll have a 2000 grit edge. Same at 4000 grit. Same at as fine as you wish to go until your abrasive is smaller (and/or softer) than the metal matrix's hardest and largest components.

I did state that carbon steel "can" be ground to a finer edge than high alloy CPMs. The photo-micrographs have been around for years. That's because of the size of the metal's structure. But neither I nor anyone I've met in many years have the capacity and equipment needed to grind carbon steel to that fine an edge which, by the way, would be so fragile as to make it worthless other than to prove the point of how fine it can be ground.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#45

they make an exceptional product

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

And people are willing to pay a lot for it. I admire both factors.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#46

data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Steve Elliot's research confirms that high alloy steels, M2 for example or CPM 3V, can be sharpened using an abrasive that will cut the carbides, to as high a level as carbon steel......and they stay sharp much longer in use. End of story for wood working. I have a photomicrograph of a diamond scratch cutting through a vanadium carbide region of CPM 3V. On the other hand vanadium carbide would cut through the relatively soft Ark stone.

Now attack one of these high abrasion resistant steels with an Arkansas stone and one will conclude that they can't be sharpened to as high a degree as carbon steel. Modern high performance alloys demand modern abrasives. The two are inseparable.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#47

i'll just leave this here

Brian Holcombe

Hehehe


The kasumi finish is my doing and was a real effort. Worked from 140 diamond plates on through finger stones (uchigumori). Micro bevel is done on a Nakayama asagi.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#48

Re: Masakage knives, A question

Barry Irby

Thank you for the better pictures. My original thought was that the handle was a true octagon, not just octagonally shaped. The expanded flats on the sides woudl give you a sense of the orientation of the blade and woudl be better than a true octagon.

I still am somewhat disappointed in the handle. The blade looks fantastic and really "sells" the exotic nature of the steel and looks like something I could never do no matter how hard I tried. The handle makes it look like I should buy it unhandled version and install one myself. I can and have done handles as good as or better than that.

They are beautiful knives and I am tempted to get some.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#49

Same impression

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The first time I looked at a Japanese knife my thoughts turned to rehandling it. The "foreign" looking handle on Japanese knives has been a factor that has kept me from investing in one until I found one for $7 at a flea market. I have the same reservations about the handle on Japanese saws. That said, now that I have a knife I am going to work with it. We must accept the fact that lots of people like or at least accept that handle style. I expect the wonderful steel is going to make me overlook any handle insecurity.

Re: Sharpening Kitchen Knives

#50

That's a beautiful knife