Focusing the discussion back to woodworking tools
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The steel from Lee Valley settles the issue of whether a stainless steel can take and hold a superior edge. (Owners of high quality Japanese stainless knives already knew this fact.) Chopping wood challenges an edge way more than cutting celery. This LV steel has been found by all to have superior edge holding capability for plane blades and chisels compared to carbon steel, and with the right abrasive it can be sharpened as good as it gets.
I don't move in the world of tactical knives and knife competition but I know someone that does. CPM's S30V stainless vastly exceeds any carbon steel for durability. The carbon knife user could come to the conclusion that it won't take as keen an edge, but this observation requires qualification. Because of its exceptional wear resistance it can not be sharpened with an Ark stone.
In fact this notion that "tool steels" will not take as keen an edge has been disproven by Steve Elliot and others. The problem is these steels are often highly abrasion resistant. Sharpening routines that work for a vintage chisel may not sharpen these steels . Hence the employment of water stones and diamond stones for these steels, either in knives or plane blades.
I believe the problem with kitchen knives is that the average cook/chef doesn't know how to sharpen and doesn't want to learn. Knives are made for this customer, not us woodworkers who know how to sharpen and have the tools to do so on any steel.
Even the ordinary carbon steel knife could be greatly improved by making it from a better carbon steel and heat treating it to high hardness. The problem then would be it could not be "sharpened" by the ineffective means found in most kitchens, the ceramic rod thingies for example.
The problem is not that the best kitchen knife can not be made from a stainless steel. The problem is that western knife manufacturers target a customer that lacks woodworking capability for sharpening a knife. Some combination of inferior steel and/or heat treatment yields a soft easily sharpened product most are satisfied with. Sadly, a $25 knife could be made that would be as good as any (but lack styling and oriental mumbo jumbo that pushes the price to over $100 unless you happen upon a flea market find).
I have sharpened dozens of kinds of "western" kitchen knives and my woodworking chisels and plane blades for comparison. It is two different worlds. I have yet to see a western stainless steel kitchen knife that will sharpen as well as a decent plane blade. I have seen carbon steel kitchen knives that take an edge as good as a plane blade, but the steel is soft and they don't hold an edge. I have two 440 series knives that do sharpen as well as my best woodworking steel.