Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Bandsaw question

Posts

Re: Bandsaw question

#51

annealing

John in NM

Blade welders have an annealing setting that re-heats the blade more slowly than the weld did. The one on my welder doesn't work (free welder) so I do it with a propane torch. I suspect tempering would be a more accurate description, though without know much about the blade steel it's hard to say what is really going on.

Re: Bandsaw question

#52

You bet

John in NM

I think it's caused by discussing purely empirical observations without a truly pressing need for a resolution - so we end up with a debate centered around pet theories. Might as well be voodoo :D

You think bandsaw threads or sharpening threads are bad.... try sitting in on one of our weekly phone conferences at work! :D :D :D

Re: Bandsaw question

#53

Re: annealing

TomD

That is interesting, you are probably right about it being tempering. Annealing requires a very slow cooling cycle, often buried in something like ash or perlite that will hold back the heat.

Though tempering implies that the parts could be hardened in the first place, which requires a certain amount of carbon in the stock, and the alloy to be air hardening. I guess it is one of those can't hurt things. Normally sensible heat treating requires a detailed knowledge of the steel in question and an approach to temp that goes beyond "let's goose it".

Spot welding is an interesting process, as few welds are any good unless some kind of shielding is used. But the contact in spot welding seems to be shielding enough, which is brilliantly simple.

Re: Bandsaw question

#54

Re: annealing

John in NM

I believe the steel is usually just O-1 or something similar. As I understand it, the butt weld is so fast that you can get away without shielding, but there is still enough oxide contamination that the weld gets brittle. I'm not sure what the annealing does exactly, but it does seem to help. One does anneal blades hotter than typical tempering though, and the idea is often to do it slowly, so perhaps it really is annealing (been reading a bit today :D )

Re: Bandsaw question

#55

I'm up for it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

try sitting in on one of our weekly phone conferences at work! What does it pay

Re: Bandsaw question

#56

uncoiling without blood

John K Jordan

I finally learned how to coil them without a trip to the ER but to uncoil one of my big WoodMizer sawmill blades I put on thick gloves and face shield and toss the thing away onto the soft grass. Works for me.

JKJ

Re: Bandsaw question

#57

Re: You bet

Jesse Cloud

Oh lord - I remember those at my work. When people are in the same room they can see the body language of others. When you are just talking into a phone you have no clue that everyone thinks you are a fool, so you go on and on...

I don't think they could pay me enough to go back to that!

Re: Bandsaw question

#58

Actually, pay's pretty good...

John in NM

If only we could get rid of the pointless activities it would be close to ideal :D

Re: Bandsaw question

#59

I follow Mark Twain's advice during phonecons....

John in NM

Sure makes for a dull hour though :D

Re: Bandsaw question

#61

Re: I follow Mark Twain's advice during phonecons.

Jesse Cloud

Would that be "It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." ? :D

Re: Bandsaw question

#62

Re: De-tensioning +

David Bair

"Does that mean I should jack up my car every time I come home?" Actually, back before radial tires, bias ply tires would get a flat spot if left parked for any thing longer than a week. You had a bumpy, noisy ride for a few miles before the tires heated up enough to lose the flat spot.

Re: Bandsaw question

#63

Re: De-tensioning +

Dick Coers

I'm certainly old enough to remember those. My direction was headed towards wheels and bearings when the got added into the damaging affect of blade tension.

Re: Bandsaw question

#64

That's the one!


Re: Bandsaw question

#65

I would bet...

John in NM

That it was the advent of synthetic petro-rubbers more than radials. I still have a truck that takes bias ply tires, and these at least do not get flat spots. When tires were made of latex, I could easily see that happening though.

Re: Bandsaw question

#66

Blade Weld follow-up

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Text from "WoodSlicer" advertisement

"welding produces a metallurgical structure identical to the rest of the blade....no more prone to failure. " Guaranteed against breakage at the weld"

To repeat, if the welds are breaking you know the weld is defective. You cannot detect if any saw adjustment is significantly contributing until the weld deficiency is solved. If, when, blades prematurely break randomly, then look for some aspect of the operation that is contributing out of specification stress.

Re: Bandsaw question

#67

Except...

John in NM

1. The weld is prone to contamination by air since it is not a shielded weld. Welding typically uses inert gas or a flux material to shield the molten steel from the oxygen in the air. Some kinds of fast resistance welding do not.

2. The weld is not subject to the same hardening and tempering routine as the rest of the blade.

These two points are not insurmountable of course, as the vast majority of blades are adequately strong at the weld - even soldered joints are adequately strong if done well.

However, anyone who tells you the weld is identical to the rest of the blade is misleading you, even if it is Woodslicer doing it. Woodslicer's quote strikes me as a marketing fib - one that is true enough for the average consumer but certainly not true in any engineering sense. The weld is not identical and it does tend to be weaker.

Re: Bandsaw question

#68

Re: uncoiling without blood

Keith Newton

I don't have any grass around my Mizer, only asphalt.

What I do, is pull enough space in the outer coil to slip the toe of my shoe through, to hold it down. Then I can manage the other part in a more controlled way.