Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Bandsaw question

Posts

Re: Bandsaw question

#26

At least check the wheel geometry FIRST

BrianMonumentCO

It is a waste of time to investigate the weld from any quality commercial band saw blade company.

They wont stay in business if they do lousy welding.

If the blades are welded by "joes bar and grill and welding" then you MUST try a real commercial blade.

But fixing the weld is a waste of time if the wheel geometry is wrong.

Pretend for the moment that the core problem is that the upper wheel is NOT coplaner with the drive wheel, the blade will be under constant twisting and the weld will fail.

Another failure point is the thrust bearings if they are too far forward they can cause twisting of the blade.

Mark Duginske's book on woodworking machinery and I think he has a book on just bandsaws as well should be consulted for tuning the bandsaw. ONce upon a time there was a VHS about this subject as well.

Re: Bandsaw question

#27

Re: Relax, Dick, Not

John K Jordan

Both my woodworking bandsaws have quick detensioning levers and I use them unless I think I will be using them again fairly soon. The way I look at it, it might help and it can't hurt.

My bandsaw mill does NOT have a quick way, but requires 6 full turns on the tensioning screw each time. I remove the tension every time I'm done sawing. May be a coincidence, but the one time I forgot the blade broke the next time I fired it up.

JKJ

Re: Bandsaw question

#28

I'm relaxed


Re: Bandsaw question

#29

Re: Sounds Like Tension

R. Payne

Personal experience, (old 3-wheel band saw) If I don't detension the blade breaks before becoming dull. If I do, the blade lasts long enough to get dull. Can't speak for a 2-wheeled saw.

Re: Bandsaw question

#30

disagree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Fact: the weld is not the equivalent of a fuse put there to fail if some adjustment of the saw is not optimum. The weld should be as strong as the rest of the blade when done right.

If the break is always at the weld the primary mode for failure is poor weld quality. How can one diagnose if some other property of the saw will lead to breakage? Once can surely measure many things about the saw that are not perfect, and may be totally irrelevant to blade life. One can not tell if any other aspect of the saw will lead to breakage until the weld issue is solved. It is the equivalent to fretting whether there is an overload in a circuit when the fuses blow because they are not up to specifications.

Alternatively spend endless time diddling with various adjustments of the saw that likely will have little effect on extending the life of the defective weld.

Re: Bandsaw question

#31

Re: disagree

BrianMonumentCO

If my bandsaw was breaking blades at the welds.

1. I would check all the things I stated in my last post PRIOR to running down the welds.

The bulk of the checking could be accomplished in less than an hour.

2. The weld joints are not always of the same quality metal as the field material (rest of the blade).

Differences come from ;

A. poor technique

B. poor choice of filler materials.

I certainly DON"T buy my blades from Joes bar and grill and welding.

In any event failure to check the possible sources of stress on the blade is short sighted.

Do you really believe that failures at welds happen SOLELY because of bad welds.

I would really expect to find a source of STRESS that affects the blade.

Unless you are buying blades from Joes bar and grill and welding.

The welding by a quality blade maker is probably well in excess of that needed for a bandsaw.

Re: Bandsaw question

#32

There is no filler in a blade weld

John in NM

A blade welder works like a spot welder basically. Clamps hold the two ends of the blade stock, one clamp + and the other - . When pushed together they touch and the current melts the steel. No filler rod involved at all.

You are quite correct about technique however. After welding the joint must be annealed just enough and then ground flat with the rest of the blade. Under-annealing makes for a brittle joint. Over grinding makes for a weak spot, as do the various ways of misalining the blade ends in the clamps prior to welding.

The ones I weld tend to break, though its a minor point since they are pretty dull by then and only cost me something like $4.

Re: Bandsaw question

#33

Re: There is no filler in a blade weld

John K Jordan

>Re: There is no filler in a blade weld

I was told I could weld blades with either my mig or tig using 308L filler. I might try this.

I understand the blade welder built into some metal-cutting bandsaws (Doall, etc) is basically a resistance welder/anealer. Do all industrial blade welders work that way?

Next time I see him, I'll ask the guy who runs the bandsaw blade shop where I buy my blades. They make a lot of blades, mostly from Lenox stock.

JKJ

Re: Bandsaw question

#34

tig would work

John in NM

You could tig one easily enough, just need an alignment jig of some kind. I used to mig big ones in an emergency, but they were large and thick - for the large horizontal bandsaw in the welding shop I worked for.

As far as I know, industrial blade welders all work the way I described, at least the 3-4 I've seen do. The reason would be that it is super fast compared to manually welding a blade.

Re: Bandsaw question

#35

Re: Bandsaw question

Mark Hennebury

It's something to do with the weld;

1. Either a bad weld. (not likely)

2. Not properly annealed after welding ( a possibility)

3. Ground too thin at the weld, (this would be my guess.)

Check the thickness of the blade at the weld.

Small wheels are not the problem nor twisting stress; Millions of metal cutting bandsaws have very small wheels, all twist the blades to allow crosscutting long tubing and they don't have any problem.


Re: Bandsaw question

#36

Love the stand!

John K Jordan

I like your stand for the portaband, carrying handles and all! Now I want to make one for mine.

I have a big Jet horizontal saw that came with a table and tilts to vertical but the small saw would be more useful more often.

JKJ

Re: Bandsaw question

#37

Sorry, its not mine

Mark Hennebury

I apologize, the photo is not of my machine.

I should have said that the photo was just one that i pulled of the internet to show a small machine.

Re: Bandsaw question

#38

You get finder's credit!


Re: Bandsaw question

#39

Re: disagree

TomD

No way the weld is as strong as the rest of the blade. Welds are always a weak point like 30 percent, and bandsaw welds are basically unshielded resistance welds. Of course, presumably they are strong enough and unusual patterns of fracture are not acceptable.

Re: Bandsaw question

#40

thickness of blade stock

Dick Coers

I can't imagine the blade stock for the porta-band is the same for full size bade stock. You can't compare life of the blade, due to bending or twisting stress, when you aren't talking about the same thickness of stock.

Re: Bandsaw question

#41

i wasn't comparing anything

Mark Hennebury

i simply pointed out many saws, from very large to very small seem to function without chronic blade breakage and offered my opinion that it was most likely a problem with the weld.

That was just a stab in the dark based on limited information and knowledge of, the actual machine, blades and operation etc..

Re: Bandsaw question

#42

Sorry, I must have misunderstood


Re: Bandsaw question

#43

But

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

metal cutting blades run very slow, a small fraction of wood cutting speeds. This slow speed does not fatigue the blade significantly. The Lenox rep confirmed that 14" wheels work the blade near its limit which is why 14" band saws are the typical limit for small wood cutting saws.

Re: Bandsaw question

#44

Re: But what?

Mark Hennebury

I just followed a line of logic, my logic. with the understanding that a logical path has no relation to reality of facts, but merely my biased interpretation of said facts.

1. There are a lot f small bandsaws on the planet ( supposition)

2. Some run slow for metal, some run fast for wood. ( i think this could be considered a fact)

3. I assume that they work. ( never had one myself, mine has 30" wheels)

4. Based on this line of reasoning, i made the assumption that the size is not the cause of the abnormal blade breaking problem. ( i reasoned that if all small bandsaws broke the blades often, then that would make it normal)

5. Assuming that the said bandsaw owner has the correct gauge blades for the saw ( big assumption) Then i would look at the weld first to see if there was an obvious problem, like maybe the person ground it down too much, and thinned it out which would account for it breaking more than normal ( something that i have seen on several occasions)

This was just a suggestion, based one my experience. A quick glance to check the thickness of the blade at the weld, might find a solution to the problem, or at least eliminate one possible source.

There are many small wood bandsaws as well as metal ones.


Personally i prefer to buy big old machines and tune then up, but not everyone is interested enough to do that. So i am not really familiar with the smaller modern machines, but i have had experiences with bandsaw blades breaking on the welds due to bad grinding, and thought that it would be the first place that i would check, if i was sure that i had the correct blade gauge for that size machine.

Re: Bandsaw question

#45

There's nothing like a bandsaw thread

Jesse Cloud

to stir up a fuss.

You can get a heated argument on most any aspect of a bandsaw - tuning, wheels, tension, blade geometry, etc.

I never have seen one that ended in anything close to consensus.

I'm staying out of this one - good luck guys and don't say anything you will regret in the morning. ;)

Re: Bandsaw question

#46

I've now given up, so one less 


Re: Bandsaw question

#47

Re: tig would work

TomD

They sell those kits that use hard silver solder, flux, and a propane torch. That stuff is super strong, of course it has to be scarfed.

I doubt there is much true annealing happening with these machines. As you metalheads know, the bandsaws with the built in welders are used to break, insert, weld, cut, break, weld, cut, etc. Like piercing work with a fretsaw. Nobody is hanging around to let the stuff cool slowly, though in some cases the blade may not be run all that long on the weld, and if it breaks, hit it again. Most likely the band is simply made of stuff that has a low carbon content or is annealed to start with, makes no difference to the stiffness of the metal. Then you can use more electrical resistance to harden the teeth, or they are bimetal, etc... Just make the band so it likes to be welded, but whatever is done the weld is going to be a weak point. But not necessarily weak in comparison to the design specs. Breaking a decent sized through simple loading in tension would crush the saw.

Re: Bandsaw question

#48

Re: "blade"


Re: Bandsaw question

#49

blade thickness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the thickness of the blade stock figures into life and fatigue. I recall the Lenox technical person telling us what thickness would work for 14" saws and a thicker blade would work on larger wheel machines where the flexing fatigue is less.

Re: Bandsaw question

#50

The blade makers can provide resolution

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

To that end we had the Lenox technical rep give a band saw blade talk at a club meeting. Lenox has the capability of studying issues related to blades to come to definitive conclusions. Got a question....call them and ask.

I wish I had paid closer attention to how he unfolded a 1.5 " blade safely, one coil at a time.