Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Bandsaw question

Posts

Bandsaw question

#1

Bandsaw question

Edward in Vancouver

Couple of years ago I picked up a Rigid 14" bandsaw, brand new. It ran rough, and I ended up "balancing" both wheels with hot glue and pennies. Even so, It still ran a bit rough, most noticably when the motor was running down after I flipped the switch. With the belt taken off though, the motor ran smooth.

In any case, I am able to resaw and make cuts fairly smoothly, but I keep on breaking blades--right at the weld. Doesn't matter what brand, but I always use 3/8 3 tpi, and after say, a dozen uses, the blade always snaps at the weld.

Last night it happened again-- a straight cut in some 3/4'' doug fir, and the blade snapped right at the weld. I unplugged the machine, took off the broken blade, had a long think, and then grabbed a screwdriver and my cheap-o dial indicator. I popped the tire off the top wheel and did some measuring. The wheel is not perfectly round, out by 4-5 "ticks" on one small area (the indicator is divided into 100 "ticks". Hey, I'm a pastry chef, not a machinist....).

Would this be the reason I'm prematurely breaking blades, an out-of-round wheel putting stress on the weld with every revolution?

If so, how can I correct this? Can I leave the wheel mounted and take a file or dremel to the "hump"? Mount the wheel on my beaver 12" gap-bed lathe and "true" it with a file? The wheel is cast aluminum.

As far as I know, Rigid discontinued the model right after I bought it, which probably explains the cheap price I got it for. Seriously doubt if they have spare wheels, and if they do, if the are of the same quality or not.

Thanks in advance,

Edward

Re: Bandsaw question

#2

Re: Bandsaw question

del schisler

i think you could do that, a file should do fine , i have a delta 14" band saw and i have use 3/8" and they break with me also, so i don't use them any more , i use 1/4" and they don't break , i also do a lot of resawing but use 1/2" for that. when you true the wheel rebalance and you should be in good shape

Re: Bandsaw question

#3

Re: Bandsaw question

John in NM

First thing I would do is try a different blade - same size, different manufacturer or source. The weld is the weakest part of the blade, and it is even weaker if not annealed properly after welding. Perhaps you have tried this already, but it seems worth mentioning.

Alternatively, you could simply try running the blade with less tension. That would help if they are breaking due to varying radial loads that the out of round or off-center wheel gives you.

As to filing the wheel, I think that would take a much more repeatable measuring setup that what you've described, but the basic concept is doable. It would take a lot of patience with the file though, and I would recommend doing it on the saw rather than a lathe unless you have a proper machine lathe for it.

Re: Bandsaw question

#4

Re: Bandsaw question

Keith Newton

If they are all breaking at the weld, that sounds like a blade issue to me. I'd be trying to get the supplier to replace them, or switch to another brand.

Re: Bandsaw question

#5

Re: Bandsaw question

John Veerkamp

Aluminum will machine easily on a wood lathe. If you can mount it security and centered this should work fine.

Re: Bandsaw question

#6

Re: Bandsaw question

don stephan

Just wondering if professional balancing would be valuable enough to take the wheel to a machine shop to true and then balance.

Re: Bandsaw question

#7

Re: Bandsaw question

Clementine

I have the same bandsaw. It helped the vibration a lot when I went to a segmented link belt-see Google for sources. Since you know the wheels are out of round, I think any decent small machine shop could true them with no trouble. They may be still out of balance even after solving the roundness problem. Think about how a tire shop electronically balances a wheel; maybe there's an idea there for your situation. I also resaw with a 1/2" 3 tpi blade, one of the better brands. "The blade is everything", you'll hear a lot with about any brand or model of saw, and that's true. Quality does make a difference. I also relax the tension; so for a 1/2" blade I set the tension at 1/4", and that works fine for me.

Re: Bandsaw question

#8

Ticks?

Dick Coers

Are you sure about the increments? 4 or 5 hundredths, .04, is over 1/32". That is a big issue. Four thousandths, .004" from most dial indicators is not. If all your blades break, I'd suggest that over tensioning and technique may be an issue. Does the motor ever bog down when you cut a curve? I always teach folks to cut curves with just your fingertips on the board, so you don't muscle through the cut.

Re: Bandsaw question

#9

Sounds Like Tension

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Proper initial tension is important. Simplest way is to use the "flutter test".

1. Install the blade with enough tension to hold it on the tires and back off (or remove) the guides

2. Turn on the saw and gradually add tension 1/2 turn at a time but watching the blade.

3. You will get to a point where you will see the blade start to flutter.

4. Add small amounts of tension until the flutter stops.

5. Add 1/8 or 1/4 turn and your blade will be properly tensioned

6. Replace the guides

After you finish cutting, relax the tension by 2 full turns on the tensioner

Band saw blades get quite worm in use, especially when resawing as so much of the blade is in the wood. When cutting stops the blade cools and contracts putting increased stress on the weld. Leaving the band under tension will accelerate metal fatigue at the weld.

Re: Bandsaw question

#10

Re: Sounds Like Tension

Dick Coers

I don't agree with the relaxing blade tension. I haven't take the pressure off a blade in over 40 years. But I use my equipment and dull most blades before any issues show up. I feel the diameter of the wheel is the greatest stressor of the weld.

Re: Bandsaw question

#11

Re: Sounds Like Tension

john lucas

Like Dick I've never de-tensioned my blades and maybe like him I go through them fairly quickly because my bandsaw gets used a lot.

I'm guessing improper tension and possibly forcing the blade through the cut. This bends the blade, especially if your resawing and would put a lot of stress on it.

If the wheels are really out of round I suppose they could put stress on the blade but like someone else said, if it's .004", which is probably is unless it's an unusual dial indicator, then I woudn't think that would even remotely be the problem.

Re: Bandsaw question

#12

Out-Of-Round Spot

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

on the wheel(s) would result in a lateral shift of the blade resulting in a widened kerf or faster wear on the guides. Don't see where it would put extra stress on the blade. Plus, with tension on the blade the flex in the tire material would reduce the effect even more. I'd put the dial gauge on a mounted and tensioned blade to see if there was any actual lateral shift when turning the wheels/blade by hand.

Re: Bandsaw question

#13

While a file will work....

Ron in Sterling, CT

clean it very often, as it will load up quickly with Aluminum. If not kept clean, it will pack up, then be a bear to clear of Al filings.

Ron

Re: Bandsaw question

#14

Re: Sounds Like Tension

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I agree with Mark, It sounds like you have a tension problem. The slight out of round condition you describe should easily be taken care of by the tension spring, that's what it is there for. HOWEVER if you over tension and compress the spring to solid height, the balde will see extra tension every time the high spot comes around to where the blade is on it. You do not want to fully compress your tension spring ever.

Lee

Re: Bandsaw question

#15

Re: Sounds Like Tension

John K Jordan

Also, I read somewhere that if the blade is running forward and not centered on the crown of the tire it can be less stable and wander more, especially if the blade is wide since it is being supported more in the back than the front.

Re: Bandsaw question

#16

Agree...

John in NM

Lots of stuff can contribute to chronic blade breaking, but I've yet to see any evidence that keeping a blade tensioned would do it. Steels and welds simply do not fail in a way that the de-tensioning theory requires.

Re: Bandsaw question

#17

Re: Agree...

Barry Irby

I added a carter gizmo to my Delta bandsaw to allow easy detentioning. I never bother anymore. It occurred to me that thousands of "commercial" bandsaw have been in use for a very long time and have never been detentioned.

I have a 14" bandsaw and have run at least fifty blades on it until they were too dull to use and only ever broke maybe two or three. I have used cheap local blades and some from Highland hardware and some I bought ten at a time. You have some other problem.

Either really poorly made blades, very badly aligned guides, or???? I might take the wheels to a local machine shop and have them trued and balanced if the fee were reasonable. And I would buy some inexpensive blades of a different brand and give them a go.

Re: Bandsaw question

#18

Re: Sounds Like Tension

Edward in Vancouver

Thanks for all of the replies.

I dressed the wheel lightly with a file, popped the original tire back on and took another reading, this one was way out of whack, the needle jumping all over the place. I pulled off the tire and had a good look at it, this thing is lumpy and uneven thickness all over.

Not being an expert with a dial indicator, I did notice one thing--my table is flimsy. By simply putting thumb pressure on the table I could influence the dial indicator reading significantly.

Meh, I gotta figure out if I want to play with this machine or use it. I have invested time two years ago into "balancing" both wheels: I marked each spoke with a number, spun the wheel, and watched where the wheel stopped. By using a combination of drilling shallow divots and hot-glueing pennies to the rim, I was eventually able to have both wheels stop at random spoke numbers. Not a "pro" job by any means, but it sure ran a heck-uva lot smoother afterwards.

The original fan belt was lumpy too, and I replaced this by scavenging my drill press for it's link belt, runs smoother as well.

Re: Bandsaw question

#19

Re: Bandsaw question

BrianMonumentCO

A couple of questions I have not seen an answer for;

1. are the upper and drive wheels in the same plane?

2. do you have tires on the wheels?

3. does the blade track consistently on the tires?

4. most importantly are your thrust bearings and guides adjusted correctly.

thrust bearings could be throwing the blade out!

5. Do you buy cheap or good blades.

6. do you feed the wood fast or reasonable speed

Hope these questions help

Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: Bandsaw question

#20

Re: Bandsaw question

John K Jordan

>1. are the upper and drive wheels in the same plane?

>2. do you have tires on the wheels?

>3. does the blade track consistently on the tires?

>4. most importantly are your thrust bearings and guides adjusted correctly.

You make some good points. I think insuring the wheels are coplanar is important otherwise the blade might be in a lot of stress every rev. I know some think this is unnecessary but my 14" Delta cut SO much better when I aligned the wheels (as per either Duginske's or Lonnie Bird's bandsaw book.) It came badly adjusted from the factory - required a thick washer to shim the upper wheel.

I also upgraded the tensioning hardware, new tires, and added a riser block. A good test for this bandsaw was resawing a 12' long 2x12 Douglas Fir board into 4 equal boards for a friend to case in a structural beam - I almost couldn't believe we pulled this off!

The OP did mention tires on the wheels, at least the upper wheel.

I mentioned the tracking. If the wheels are aligned and tensioned properly the blade should run nicely supported in the center of both tires. I know some like to run the back of the blade in the center of the tires but I can't see the sense in it.

And about bearing guides, should mention they should also be clean and spin freely! I am guilty of not checking the lower bearings on my 18" Rikon as often since they are harder to see...

JKJ

Re: Bandsaw question

#21

De-tensioning +

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I use Suffolk (Timberwolf) blades on my JET 18. Both Suffolk and JET recommend taking a couple of turns off the tension when the cutting is done. Duginsky also recommends doing so for the benefit of wheels, bearings, and tires. Leaving full tension on the blade tends to effect the tires more as their concentricity is effected. Have a "thumping" sound when you first start the saw? Chances are your tires have developed a slight flat spot at the top and bottom and will need to be run a bit to smooth them out, just like a car tire that has not been driven for a long time.

As the OP states his tires are "lumpy", replacing them with a set of high quality tires could improve performance a great deal. After all, it is the outside surface of the tires that must run true with the center of the axle shafts for smooth cutting with minimal kerf. Just cleaning the tires' surface with a bit of 120 grit wrapped on a stick can make a difference.

Funky pulleys are another source of vibration. When I rebuilt my JET with new bearings etc. I took the two drive pulleys to a friend's shop and got them recut a smidge. I also use a link belt on my saw. After my rebuild the saw's performance was seriously improved.

Re: Bandsaw question

#22

Step 1  solve the blade problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Any place worth buying blades from guarantees the weld. If the blades are breaking at the weld you know the weld is flawed. You can not presume any other deficiency until this problem is eliminated.

According to my saw shop (Misenheimer in Morristown TN) band saw blades break from flexing. A 14 " wheel is the smallest wheel that will yield any reasonable blade life. I break blades frequently on my 14" saw and never on the 20" saw, for example.

Any blade that breaks at the weld Misenheimer will reweld for free. If the break is elsewhere the blade is fatigued and not worth rewelding.

Re: Bandsaw question

#23

Re: De-tensioning +

Dick Coers

Duginsky also recommends doing so for the benefit of wheels, bearings, and tires. Leaving full tension on the blade tends to effect the tires more as their concentricity is effected.

Does that mean I should jack up my car every time I come home? You know to save the bearings? If those bandsaw ball bearings are affected by blade tension, some engineer should be fired. I suspect a cheap rubber tire may be affected if it's not used for months. But every time you leave the shop you should take off the tension? Just not going to buy that! Do you take the tension off your table saw belt? Drill press? Shaper?

Re: Bandsaw question

#24

Relax, Dick, Not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

selling anything here, just passing on information from what I deem reliable sources. You're free to choose to ignore it.

Nor is this the "full detension" you describe, just backing off two turns on the tensioner wheel, and yes, I do it every time on the band saw. There's no way to do that on the other tools you mentioned, so lets not use extreme examples to argue a point. The issue was taking a bit of stress off the band saw. Takes all of about 3 seconds to do.

As always, your mileage may vary ;)

Re: Bandsaw question

#25

True True

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

in 16 years I've only had one of my Timberwolfs break and it wasn't at the weld.