Re: Are other points missed?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
The BU plane was not unknown to Stanley or the planing world for that matter. Lee Valley early on offered a wide selection of these planes to suit any planing desire. So the opportunity was there for the planing world to have another chance to gravitate to BU planes, the first being when planes got invented and then over the next few centuries. Yet to fill an unmet need LV has spent a Herculean effort to recently introduce a BD plane.
So, a skeptic might reasonably ask, if a BU plane is cheaper and more useful why do they remain a minor player in the world of planes, so much so that LV felt obligated to offer a BD plane line with much fanfare? The apparent conclusion is that the BU plane has some disadvantage(s) that the ubiquitous BD plane does not. When in doubt go where the crowd voted with their money was the route I personally took. But I remain open to data showing that the BU plane is better for what I do. Anyone care to bring one by?
Bill, firstly, the BU planes were copied first by LN and then by LV. LV, however, have produced more of these. Further, where LN copied the origonal Stanley designs - with all their foibles - LV have introduced a host of advanced features to their range.
The reason why there has been such a long gap in time between the largely unsuccessful production of the original Stanley planes and the modern LN and LV versions is twofold. One reason is the advent of durable ductile iron used in the body rather than fragile grey iron. The early Stanley were known for chipped mouths (I have one). The second reason is that the method of use changed. The early Stanley planes received a 25-30 degree bevel which, on a 12 degree bed, created a plane that had a low cutting angle. This was only good for end grain ... hence the term "block plane". In modern times the bevel angle was raised to 38 - 50 degrees, and this created a high cutting angle, one that could take on and beat interlocked face grain. Suddenly we had planes that would really preform!
Why do more BD Stanleys exist than BU LV/LN planes? Simply because the Stanley's are cheap and plentiful. Plus, my perception is that the average woodworker in the USA does not work complex grain. Walnut, Cherry, and the like are easy stuff compared with the likes of Australian hardwoods. Here many use planes with high cutting angles, such as the HNT Gordon range. Until the recent renewal of interest in the chipbreaker, only high cutting angles would hack it. BU plans made high cutting angles easier to achieve. These planes are still easier to use, but they are a lot more expensive than a vintage, multi-owned Stanley that comes out of a swap meet.
Regards from Perth
Derek