Re: Options to eliminate sanding?
TomD
Normally if your sanding isn't effective, it comes down to one of 4 things
1) Technique, that is a lot of stuff, most of it fairly simple: even coverage, letting the machine do the wrokd, know how and where the tools cut most effectively. Lots of little details.
2) Paper. Right paper for the job; good quality; For finishing, you need to toss the paper when it stops cutting at grit, not run it down till it is worn out. The idea is to sand at say 220, if you wear that paper all the way out, it will cut like 320, but leave big scratches. On a ROS, most of the cutting is in a middle band, not the center or the edge, since it orbits on two centers. Knowing the right place to look for wear on the paper is key. You can sometimes use the paper you had to pull for other kinds of sanding, but for finishing it doesn't last long, depending on the quality.
3) You have to start cutting at the right grit to establish your first pass. Too coarse and you make more work, too light and it won't get you going. Then you need to run the right steps between the papers to get your surface to the point where you can finish. Over sanding to some crazy grit like 400 isn't going to make your finish work better. The finer grits take a lot more time than the coarser, ones, so if you are dropping down fast rhough surper fine grits you are kidding yourself, and wasting time. As with anything, else, if you don't know where to start, what drops to make, and where to finish, test on a sample.
4) Good tools. As Bill mentioned the pneumatic ROS's have a better low end. I have a really good one, but my current compressor won't run it for long. There are decent electric ROSs I and a lot of other boat builders use the PC angle, if they still make it. It will remove some serious material. Some of them will only dust the surface.
This is different from mine, but it may be the same quality:
http://www.portercable.com/Products/ProductDetail.aspx?ProductID=21423