Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Options to eliminate sanding?

Posts

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#26

Re: Cabient shops speak up

Jesse Cloud

I have seen many of Merle's pieces in person. There are very few cabinet shops that wood come close to the quality of Merle's finishes.

I have never seen Merle sanding, but I suspect a big part of the issue is that Merle sets very high standards for his work.

@Merle - I'm not pretending to be a masterful woodworker, but you have seen some of my work. I spend maybe an hour or two sanding on a big project. And yes, it is incredibly boring. BTW, with the Festool sanders, you might experiment with lowering the vacuum speed. I very strong vacuum on all those holes actually interferes with good dc. You may be sanding you saw dust instead of sanding your workpiece.

Another tip that made a big difference for me is to spend the time to clean your piece (blow it with air, etc) between grits. A little leftover lower grit will scratch up your finer grit work and make the job take way longer.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#27

Re: Cabient shops speak up

mdclor

Jess, thank you for the compliment. You are another woodworker whose skills greatly exceed mine so I am truly flattered.

I have learned to reduce the suction to less than the half way point.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#28

My current status

mdclor

I decided to GREATLY reduce the amount of sanding I was doing based on the many very helpful suggestions-no more pencil lines, no more twice with the same grit, using only 2 grits where appropriate instead of three. I thank everyone.

Today I finished all the major sanding although there may be a bit of touch up required if I find a surface I missed. I might have been trying to stretch the paper a bit too far and that had a big impact as well.

I have been sanding prior to glue up for a long time and I also finish panels before gluing them into their frames.

However, in spite of the significantly reduced time requirement, I think I will dig out my scraper and plane once I get my current projects completed and practice using those until I attain a degree of competence because I think that process will be faster than sanding.

Again, my thanks to all.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#29

Good plan, wrong reason

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I will dig out my scraper and plane once I get my current projects completed and practice using those until I attain a degree of competence because I think that process will be faster than sanding. "

It won't if you are starting with a level surface. The scraper and plane excel at removing controlled amounts of wood for the purpose of leveling pieces that are misaligned or for fitting lengths, widths and thicknesses in a controlled way. For a panel or part already smooth or level even hand sanding is going to favorably compete with scraping or planing. So if for no other reason than fitting parts, knowing how to use a hand plane is a huge advantage.

Using a hand plane, and it matters little what plane you have, requires knowing how to sharpen and how to mitigate tear-out. For most work an old Stanley #4 or #5 will do as well as any. But if you want to avoid the uncertainty of whether a used plane is good, buying a new quality plane- LV, LN or Clifton- will get one started reliably. Learning to sharpen will be easy with a mentor and confusing without. Learning to mitigate tear-out is a matter of learning how to set the chip breaker. See Weaver's article in Articles section. For this reason alone buying a bevel down plane is recommended.

And remember, when every part of the surface is uniform in luster it is time to move to the next finer grit. If you stain this requirement is critical and much less so if you don't stain.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#30

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

TomD

Normally if your sanding isn't effective, it comes down to one of 4 things

1) Technique, that is a lot of stuff, most of it fairly simple: even coverage, letting the machine do the wrokd, know how and where the tools cut most effectively. Lots of little details.

2) Paper. Right paper for the job; good quality; For finishing, you need to toss the paper when it stops cutting at grit, not run it down till it is worn out. The idea is to sand at say 220, if you wear that paper all the way out, it will cut like 320, but leave big scratches. On a ROS, most of the cutting is in a middle band, not the center or the edge, since it orbits on two centers. Knowing the right place to look for wear on the paper is key. You can sometimes use the paper you had to pull for other kinds of sanding, but for finishing it doesn't last long, depending on the quality.

3) You have to start cutting at the right grit to establish your first pass. Too coarse and you make more work, too light and it won't get you going. Then you need to run the right steps between the papers to get your surface to the point where you can finish. Over sanding to some crazy grit like 400 isn't going to make your finish work better. The finer grits take a lot more time than the coarser, ones, so if you are dropping down fast rhough surper fine grits you are kidding yourself, and wasting time. As with anything, else, if you don't know where to start, what drops to make, and where to finish, test on a sample.

4) Good tools. As Bill mentioned the pneumatic ROS's have a better low end. I have a really good one, but my current compressor won't run it for long. There are decent electric ROSs I and a lot of other boat builders use the PC angle, if they still make it. It will remove some serious material. Some of them will only dust the surface.

This is different from mine, but it may be the same quality:

http://www.portercable.com/Products/ProductDetail.aspx?ProductID=21423

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#31

Re: Belt sanders

TomD

Belt sanders will level a flat surface like a table in a few minutes. They don't seem that popular any more, so maybe there is a deal to be had. They will do the heavy lifting, and you can use a less powerful tool to do the rest. Plus belts don't spray dust all over the place, compared to some.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#32

Re: Belt sanders

TomD

Sharpening and sanding are very similar processes. The fact you are having difficulty with both suggest you haven't quite got the memo. These are processes, that require one to be methodical, skilled, and understand working carefully completing all of one step and not until then moving on to the next one. A way to get quickly up to speed is to practice. The tendency to learn on large projects where it is hard to spot all the details is like fishing a very large river where familiar holding areas like are lost in the overall confusion of moving water. Evven an hour or two devoted to a few test pieces, or tools may be all it takes to learn how to move through the grits while keeping ones angles. Whether on finishing or sharpening.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#33

I haven't read every reply yet but here's my take

john lucas

If you have a surface that takes very long to sand you either aren't starting with course enough sandpaper, your buts from the tools are too rough, or both. I do a fair amount of carving using everything from chainsaws and rotary carvers to hand tools. This often leaves a surface that needs refining with sandpaper. I've learned over the years that if you start with course enough paper you can rid yourself of all the bad problems quickly. Then all the other grits go very quickly. Trying to sand out torn grain or tool marks using 120 or 150 can take forever. A quick pass with 80 or 100 grit usually eliminates these problems quickly.

As mentioned above you have to learn to get not only a flat surface but a surface that is evenly scratched. Sanding with course grits can easily distort the surface so time and care must be taken at this step. Once you have a smooth evenly scratched surface it will be very quick to go through all the other steps.

If you start with the original saw or planer cuts and work on improving those it will take a lot of effort out of the sanding process. I put off buying top of the line saw blades for years. After I finally bought one I can't believe I didn't buy one years ago.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#34

What I do ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well, I'm from the "dark side" :) So, of course I would argue for planes and scrapers.

I do have machines to process the timber (lumber) into boards, and they do a pretty good job at this. But even the spiral cutters on my Hammer A3-31 clearly benefit from planes and scrapers. Jointing boards with a handplane after a machine produces invisible joins. Developing the skills to use handplanes opens up a new world of shaping wood, not just finishing it.

I do not view woodworking as handtools vs powertools; it is not one or the other. It is how you blend the best of both.

Firstly, you need to decide what tasks you wish to use a handplane to do. If it is smoothing (to replace the sander), then the plane to get and practice on is a #4 size and NOT a #5. The shorter the plane, the less damage you will do to the work. A short plane rides the surface, while a longer planes will take remove the surface to obtain a level.

I am a great fan of the #4, but if you are starting out and can afford it, get a BU plane. Both LN and LV offer superior versions. They are easier to set up and almost foolproof in their results.

Secondly, learn to sharpen and use a card ("cabinet" in Oz and the UK) scraper. There is a simple trick to this that many just omit and then struggle. Let me know if you are interested, and I will post my method. You will be amazed at what a scraper can do.

Do I sand? Not much, but I do - there is no religeous reason not to. I actually have a Festo ROS. I cannot recall when it was last used. Just never felt it necessary ... and my lungs thank me.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#35

Re: Belt sanders

Bill Howatt

Ensure your first attempt(s) at using a belt sander is with a piece of practice wood rather than the real workpiece. They can be quite aggressive with the coarser grits.

Remember that sandpaper is a cutting tool and it dulls even though it may still look OK. Like other cutting tools you have to assess its performance while doing the job.

Bill

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#36

Re: Cabient shops speak up

William Duffield

When using my Festool Rotex sanders, I usually turn the dust collector all the way down. Another disadvantage of high suction is it sucks the sander down onto the work, increasing friction, heating up the pad, contributing to premature failure of the paper and the H&L backing. If it happens when sanding the finish, it can melt it and load the paper.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#37

Re: What I do ..

mdclor

Derek, you stumped me with the "BU plane". Does that stand for "butt ugly"??? :D

Please do post or email your scraper sharpening procedure. Thank you!

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#38

Re: Cabient shops speak up

mdclor

William, I don't know if it makes a significant difference, but I have a Nilfisk Alto Attix shop vac not a Festool. However, I will try reducing it all the way next time I do any sanding. Thanks.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#39

Re: Belt sanders

mdclor

Bill, I have a belt sander but I only use it to flatten my work bench. That has happened twice in 17 years. haha

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#40

BU...

John in NM

in this case means Bevel Up.....

I do find them butt ugly though, and thus have stuck to my old Stanleys with improved blades and stuff like that. Aesthetics is mostly irrational and it is unfortunate that it still often trumps the rational evaluation of function. I've little doubt that those BU planes work very well, but I just don't like them. I guess that goes to show that plane use is pretty much an aesthetic activity in my world. I like doing it, but function is really secondary after some nebulous standard of result is achieved.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#41

Re: Cabient shops speak up

William Duffield

The only thing that's really important is that the shopvac connects to the sander. :) If you have trouble lowering the vacuum enough, you might hook up a Y coupling in the hose with a valve on the other branch to control how much air to let in. Festool just makes it easier, with a motor control on the vac.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#42

A vote agains the BU plane

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If this style was such a good idea for working wood they would not be rare as hen's teeth relative to the ubiquitous Stanley 4's and 5's. Going bevel up means you will not have the advantage of the tear-out mitigating effect of the properly set cap iron.

Hand planes were essentially unused in my shop because of fear or sudden and unanticipated tear-out. After I learned to employ the cap iron (AKA chip breaker, the misnamed thingy that holds the blade down which under no circumstance breaks chips) a hand plane has become an often used tool, primarily for fitting parts, not surface preparation.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#43

You miss the point Bill

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

If this style was such a good idea for working wood they would not be rare as hen's teeth relative to the ubiquitous Stanley 4's and 5's. Going bevel up means you will not have the advantage of the tear-out mitigating effect of the properly set cap iron.

Hand planes were essentially unused in my shop because of fear or sudden and unanticipated tear-out. After I learned to employ the cap iron (AKA chip breaker, the misnamed thingy that holds the blade down which under no circumstance breaks chips) a hand plane has become an often used tool, primarily for fitting parts, not surface preparation.

I recall you saying that you had avoided handplanes for so long as their performance was unpredictable, and you could not count on a smoother to prevent tearout. This situation turned around for you a couple of years ago when we began to discuss how the chipbreaker aids in controlling tearout with a Stanley handplane. Correct?

Am I also correct in stating that you had not used a modern BU (bevel up) plane in all this time? Because, it you had, you would have discovered that, while tearout was now controllable with the chipbreaker placement in a Stanley, tearout had been controllable with a BU plane (with a high cutting angle) for many, many years before this point in time.

Just in case others here are not aware - since I frequent the handtool forum (which appears dead) - 90% of the wood I work with is Australian hardwoods, which are interlocked and vulnerable to tearout. With BU planes I controlled tearout with ease.

My recommendation for a BU plane in this thread is that I know how easy they are to set up and how reliable they are to achieve superb results. That is not to imply that they are better than a Stanley (or LN or LV) - but they are ideal for a beginner with handplanes. They are not beginner planes. They are planes for all. But a beginner will find them easiest to get the best results .... with a high cutting angle.

Bill, the point is that this is not about you. It's about the OP.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#44

Re: A vote agains the BU plane

William Duffield

It doesn't break chips, per se, it bends them and breaks their spirit, before they can do their dirty work. If you don't have the advantage of a GoPro and a 10x microscopic lens (or the Kato-Kawai viedo), it would be difficult to understand the difference.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#45

It does neither

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the force graphs are studied as well as shaving shape it is clear that the mechanism for tear-out mitigation in the end is the same as for a tight mouth, just more effective. The exiting shaving is dammed by the leading edge of the cap iron. The stiffness of the saving exerts a downward force on the shaving forming ahead of the blade tip, pushing it down and thereby keeping it from lifting and splitting ahead of the blade tip.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#46

It is irrelevant here ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

For a first time handplane user, the bevel up (BU) plane is a no-brainer. A bevel down (BD) plane requires a steepish learning curve. The BU requires almost none.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#47

Are other points missed?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Discalimer- I have slight experience with a full sized BU plane and some experience with block planes.

Prejudices- Several times in my quest to learn to build more complex and better furniture I have been led astray by the claims of hand tool enthusiasts. I am sure their purpose was not to knowingly deceive but rather that their woodworking and motivation for wood working was so different from mine that they couldn't see issues I would face in using what they advocated. You, at least, have demonstrated that you build stuff so your credibility begins higher than typical.

Aside from a discussion of its planing performance the BU (bevel up, the orientation of the blade bevel in the plane body) plane has a couple of advantages apparent to anyone. They cost less so they must be easier to make. The blade orientation would make practical coating the wear side of the blade with TiN or similar high abrasion coating and dulling would become greatly less.

The BU plane was not unknown to Stanley or the planing world for that matter. Lee Valley early on offered a wide selection of these planes to suit any planing desire. So the opportunity was there for the planing world to have another chance to gravitate to BU planes, the first being when planes got invented and then over the next few centuries. Yet to fill an unmet need LV has spent a Herculean effort to recently introduce a BD plane.

So, a skeptic might reasonably ask, if a BU plane is cheaper and more useful why do they remain a minor player in the world of planes, so much so that LV felt obligated to offer a BD plane line with much fanfare? The apparent conclusion is that the BU plane has some disadvantage(s) that the ubiquitous BD plane does not. When in doubt go where the crowd voted with their money was the route I personally took. But I remain open to data showing that the BU plane is better for what I do. Anyone care to bring one by?

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#48

Re: Just a Nomenclature Problem

William Duffield

Yes, of course. That was immediately obvious to me the first time I saw the video.

The differences are that the chip provides a "mouth" opening that is the exact thickness of the chip, or effectively zero. An adjustable, metal mouth block needs to be precisely adjusted to mitigate tear out without jamming. If you get the chip breaker a little too close for the thickness of the shaving, it just gets a little harder to push the plane and the chip comes out corrugated. The chip is used once and thrown away, but a metal mouth block continues to wear on the bottom front edge, reducing its effectiveness at holding the chip down, and there are a limited number of times you can take it out and resharpen it, since it needs to be machined while installed in the plane to be coplanar with the bottom of the plane.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#49

Re: It is irrelevant here ..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I hope we remain friends but it is your (this) post that is "irrelevant here". I am correcting a misconception of how the cap iron effect, as Kato and Kawai name it, works. It is important to know how it works for knowing how it works can enable some to better employ it and perhaps further the understanding and prevention of tear-out.

Selling the BU plane concept was the topic of a previous post where comments on its advantages belong.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#50

Re: Are other points missed?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, I am not trying to convince you that the BU is better than a BD plane. I am stating that it is easier to achieve high quality results for the newcomer to handplanes.

Let me be clear - my original post was not aimed at you. It was for the OP.

I really would like to avoid a debate about handplanes. It serves no one any good, and it just obscures matters. If I wanted to lecture on the pros and cons of planes, blades, steel, cutting angles, chipbreakers, etc, etc ... you know I could do so with ease. But it would not be helpful in the least.

Regards from Perth

Derek