Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Options to eliminate sanding?

Posts

Options to eliminate sanding?

#1

Options to eliminate sanding?

mdclor

Maybe I should have posted this on the hand tools board, but I am not quite sure that I am ready to venture to the dark side yet.

Anyhow, I have gotten really tired of sanding. I worked at it for 5 hours today and I am not done yet. As I mentioned, I am not a hand tool kind of guy, but I am beginning to wonder if there isn't a better way.

I tried using a hand scraper years ago and found that I couldn't sharpen it appropriately to get the fine shavings everyone raves about. I am fair at sharpening chisels and the occasional plane iron with the Scary Sharp method but I would be reluctant to try planing a piece smooth enough for finishing. I remember producing some great divots in a piece when I was first getting into woodworking. :D

The current issue of FFW came today and the author, Jeff Miller, suggests a jack plane for smoothing. However, Lee Valley has a dedicated smoothing plane that I imagine would do a better job than the jack of all trades. However, I don't want to spend $2-300 only to find out that I still can't sharpen a blade adequately.

I have a drum sander but it isn't suitable for finish sanding.

So, with all this said, what do you recommend I try to totally eliminate the need to spend hours slaving over a hot sander?

Thanks!

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#2

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

McKay

A jack plane or #5 is a good plane because it is so long. Also, I camber my #5 for use as a scrub plane. A smoother is easy to handle. If you lighten your cut you should not have tear out. Do diagonal hand planing when using the 5 and then light on the smoother. Practicing on sharpening a scraper is well worth your time. I hand plane then scrape, then I burnish. Gives me a great luster that is silky to the touch. I used to think that the only tool to own was connected to the grid. I still have my power tools, but all of my finish work is by hand. You really can tell a difference.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#3

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

John in NM

One of them cutterheads I just installed.... carbide makes for a smooth finish. The test pieces I ran through after adjusting the feed rollers could get a quick hit of 220 and be done.

I do like smoothers though, I hollow grind and then buff the edge with a hard felt wheel and some grey compound for polishing stainless. Lots of the purists don't seem to care for that kind of technique, but it makes for a fast edge and is about as sharp as you can get.

You know, the other approach here is to try that pumice rubbed finish. That is so tedious it will make you long for an RO sander! :D

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#4

Sanding right (Long)

David Yoho

Merle, the last time I remember spending that long sanding was while trying to refinish a very old roll top desk made from some white oak that seemed harder than steel.

I have to wonder what you're working on that's taking that long. While tools like planes and scrapers are wonderful to use and can provide a surface ready for finish, I have always thought of them as useful in preparing the surface for finish sanding. As you have experienced, one must learn to sharpen properly and master their technique in use to wind up with acceptable results. I'm not saying to forget the hand tools. I'm saying perhaps your sanding needs help.

Projects that fall into the category of small or intricate shaped might require more sanding by hand, which can take time. However projects with larger flat surfaces are just right for using power sanders. As long as the wood is fairly smooth from the jointer and planer, sanding should not take all that long.

My experience says that all sanders are not equal and neither is all sand paper. I found after switching to my Festool random orbit sanders with vacuum and using their paper my sanding time decreased dramatically. Now all my other brands of power sanders pretty much sit on the shelf to see only occasional use. I generally start with 100-grit and move on to 150 before finishing starts. Sometimes all I have to use is 150-grit. I seldom see a need to go beyond 150-grit to achieve a suitable surface.

So maybe you would benefit from upgrading your sander of choice, what type and grit of papers you use, how the surface is prepared leading up to sanding, or a combination of all. Unless you are working on something like a chest of drawers with lots of surfaces to sand, it sounds like you're spending more time at sanding than you should.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#5

There is one good one

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The solution to your problem is an air driven random orbital sander. But it takes a serious air compressor to run it. I bought a rig when I was building the house and sanded miles of trim and cabinetry....quickly.

That said, we need more details on what you are sanding, why, and why it is taking so long. Not knowing you in detail I risk offering naïve solutions. Typically when beginners sand too long it is because they didn't start with the most effective grit or did not remain on the starting grit long enough, or they are sanding to too fine a grit. My rule of thumb is 80% of the time on grit one, and 20 on the remaining two. Anything can be sanded in 3 grit sizes(typically).

Or, the problem is poor machining that leaves problems to be dealt with by sanding too challenging.

But you said the problem was with the finish sanding and that in my mind would be 180 grit or thereabouts. If what came before 180 was done right this last grit sized for most work would be trivial. In any case sanding should not be a large fraction of any project.

Without knowing more about the need I can't comment on a plane as a solution to your need.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#6

Re: Sanding right (Long)

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Unless you are working on something like a chest of drawers with lots of surfaces to sand,"

I have built several of chests of drawers and didn't spend anything close to 5 hours sanding on any of them. There is more to this need we need to know about before offering solutions.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#7

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

mdclor

McKay, I know that you produce fantastic pieces and I would be excited to be half as good a woodworker as you are. Do you know of any classes where one might learn to do what you suggest?

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#8

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

mdclor

John, I use the Grizzly spiral cutter on my jointer and planer so I am about as good there as I can be, I think. Unless you are suggesting I use the carbide knife in a hand scraper.

I should have learned how you do this when I lived close to you.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#9

Re: Sanding right (Long)

mdclor

David, as fate would have it, I am working on white oak with a Festool ETS 150/3 with their paper. :D

I am making 2 mission style vanities, one is a simple 3' sink base and the other has a 2' sink base with a 4 drawer unit on each side. There is a lot to sand with all the stiles, rails, panels, edges, drawer parts, etc.

I have been following the procedure given in Teri Masaschi's book Foolproof Wood Finishing on pp 28 & 29. She advocates starting at 120G (lower if significant tear out) at a rate of moving the sander about a foot every 10 seconds until all milling marks are removed, then marking the surface with a pencil and sanding that off with 150G twice, then doing the same with 180G and finally hand sanding with 180G for hardwoods with vacuuming between grits. It produces a great surface.

Anyhow, thanks for the suggestions.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#10

Re: There is one good one

mdclor

Bill, I have an IR SSL3 compressor that will deliver 11.3 CFM @ 90 psi so it may be marginally able to power an air sander.

I used the term finish sanding to indicate the sanding required for the entire finishing process. I apologize if that was an incorrect usage of the term.

I think I have addressed your other points in my previous replies. I appreciate your input.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#11

Re: Sanding right (Long)

Craig

It sounds like you are sanding too much, nothing against Teri but that sounds like overkill. Even on the pieces you are describing there shouldn't be that much sanding. All my sanding starts with a Festool Rotex at 150 grit, then Festool ROS at 150 grit followed by either 180 by hand or 180 ROS and 180 by hand. It's quick and leaves a surface ready for finish.

The Rotex removes mill marks quickly thought you really shouldn't have many on an assembled piece. Nearly all of my sanding is done on the raw parts prior to assembly when they are flat and easy to move. Only touch up sanding occurs on assembled furniture. Less time spent moving heavy pieces to the right orientation to make sanding easier.

By the same token I run the majority of my parts through my drum sander with 180 grit paper prior to ROS or hand sanding. I find it gives a uniform flat surface and many of the mill marks from planing and jointing are gone, saving hand sanding time. The drum sander does leave heavier scratches than 180 grit though, something with the way it sands makes the marks more like 120-150 grit.

Craig

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#12

Re: Sanding right (Long)

David Yoho

Merle, sounds like you're using the same finish sander I do. It also sounds like you have lots of parts to prepare. I can't argue much with following an expert's advice. In that case it just takes the time it takes. However, I do like following Michael Dresdner's advise (like you are) of following power sanding with hand sanding with the same final grit, although he recommends using a garnet paper for that process.

Perhaps since the specific ROS you're using is mainly a "finishing" sander, and thus slower, maybe Bill's thoughts about using air powered would be faster.

I still question the need to go to 180 grit especially for oak. My thought and experience is starting at 100 removes mill marks sooner which allows moving on to 150 sooner. But, if you're satisfied with the results you get then I think it just takes the time it does. No point rushing this phase. After all, you're not doing production work where time is money.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#13

Way over done

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Those recommendations must be from someone that never had to earn a living making stuff and needed something different to write a book. Nobody sands that much in practice! The finish off a spiral cutterhead could be ready to proceed directly to 180 grit and done.

Off my straight knife planer on white oak I start with 100 grit if hand sanding or likely 120 off my air driven sander. 80% of the sanding time would be with the 120 and the remainder with 180 and done.

Sanding is complete when the surface looks uniform in luster. This target is essential. All the surface must be uniform. Any dull spots indicate torn grain that must be removed and any shiny spots indicate insufficient sanding. Did I mention that ALL the surface must look uniform in luster and at that point that grit has done all it needs to do. Move on.

I have seen one shop produce surfaces off a spiral cutterhead. I would have simply hand sanded that surface with 180 and been done.

In sanding it is customary to skip one grit size. So if one starts with 120 the next step would be 180. If 150 is needed after 120 it simply means not enough time was spent at 120 to do the initial surface preparation. 180 removes 120 scratches promptly even with hand sanding.

I never sand oak beyond 180. Example shown, stained. If there were sanding deficiencies they would be blazing apparent in this stained piece.


Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#14

Cabient shops speak up

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is being sanded here is a small part of a typical cabinet job. The place to seek reliable advice on what to do is a cabinet shop turning out quality work. Be assured they don't sand the way the book recommends or they would be out of business on the first job, yet they achieve equivalent results.

I have built several kitchens and didn't spend 5 hours sanding on any of them. And I am a picky sander.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#15

qualiying your claim

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"You really can tell a difference" [sanding vs hand tool surface].

This claim is often made by hand tool enthusiasts to justly their choice in surface preparation. Few, if any, would disagree with the comparison before any finish is applied. And for the minimalist finishes some use the difference may persist. But when a finish is applied that has some build, be it shellac, lacquer or varnish, the difference vanishes by all accounts. Magazines have reported the comparison and found no difference.

If anyone has results from any reputable study of surface appearance of typically finished surfaces after hand tool vs sanding preparation, please reveal them.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#16

What I do...

John in NM

At least for flat work, before the cutterhead change -

Sand out tooling marks with 80 grit on an electric ROS with a vacuum attached. This should go very quickly, and the vacuum makes it more so.

Sand out any 80 grit marks with 150 - still with vacuum. Good to tack wipe and inspect at this stage, returning to 80 grit if needed.

Finish up with 220. I still use the vacuum, but the dust is getting fine enough that it doesn't make as big a difference.

I will say that I am no fan of air sanders. They are faster due to being higher rpm presumably, but I do not find that any added speed is worth running a 3 hp or 5 hp motor on the air compressor to do the very low hp job of running a sander. Air sanders make sense when time efficiency is more important than hp efficiency. That is never the case in my shop, and I would argue that it is rarely the case in any hobbyist shop. In a production shop or a factory, it may well be the case.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#17

Re: Sanding right (Long)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

When I have a lot of marks, tearout etc. I sometimes start with a belt sander. For smaller areas I use the little Porter Cable belt sander with a 120 grit. Then I start in with a ROS sander.

A while back I posted about the Mirka DEROS sander. It is a phenomenal sander....better than my Festool sanders. I use Abranet abrasives and I can tell you that my sanding time has been reduced and the results have improved.

Hope this info helps.

T

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#18

Re: Sharpening a Scraper

Ralph Lipeles

Do some hunting on the internet about proper sharpening of a scraper. It's not like sharpening any other edge tool and also not intuitive. You probably were using an improperly sharpened scraper.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#19

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

E Snow

I don't see any issues with the sander or the paper you are using. May be overpaying for festool paper but if it is working for you and you have qty then no reason to explore alternatives.

What I fail to see is whether or not you are pre-sanding before assembly. Assuming you are sanding once assembled then sanding a vanity assembled would be pretty time consuming. Sanding most all of it in the flat should be pretty quick

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#20

There is no "One Rule for Everything"

Keith Newton

If your machining is good, you are wasting time by starting out with grits that coarse. Your just adding deep scratches that need lots of time to remove. I try to start out with the finest grit that will get rid of any milling marks quickly.

Last week, I had two friends drop by the shop with big table tops that would have taken them all week to sand out all the steps at the glue seams. I'm needing to order more belts for my stroke sander, so was down to my last 100 grit. It would have taken me hours with it, going with the grain, and the belt would have been toast by then. So I started out sanding 90º across the grain, which not only cuts much faster and easier, but the dust collects in front of and behind any ledges, so makes a good indicator of where it needs more work to level.

After everything feels good to my hand sweeping back and forth, I rotated the tops to sand finally with the grain, which only took about two minutes to get rid of the cross grain scratch.

Back 30 years ago before I got my stroke sander, I thought the way to use my hand held belt sander was to point it straight up the grain and move it up and down the board following the grain. I bought the SS at auction, and brought it to the shop without having anyone to teach me how to use it. It had been in a church pew manufacture shop, with two tables end to end, to accept 16' pews. I didn't want to use it that long, so I got rid of one table, and made a top that would handle 11' 4", and uses 6" x 30' long belts. It is powered by a 7.5hp with motor and the belt is moving about 60 mph.

The first board I put on to practice, I went straight up one side, then back down the other. Wow, it was fast and smooth, however it had cut a 6" wide trough, and there was a step along the edge of the belt that didn't match up when the platen moves along the same path as the belt without the table moving sideways. I had to learn to move the table in and out, while I moved the platen up and down the belt, going / one way up, then diagonally \ coming back to the starting point, covering the top in overlapping X patterns. The front and back of the platen round up like skis, so this doesn't leave a noticeable ledge.

After learning how to use this tool, I've adjusted how I use my old rockwell 503 as well. When I have to work a little longer on a bad spot, I can get there faster making X with the belt running across the grain, then X with the grain, than just going back and forth up and down the grain.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#21

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

E Snow

Hmm my message got chopped off somehow. If you put the 'less than' symbol in your message is truncated there after.

I don't see any issues with the sander or the paper you are using. May be overpaying for festool paper but if it is working for you and you have qty then no reason to explore alternatives.

What I fail to see is whether or not you are pre-sanding before assembly. Assuming you are sanding once assembled then sanding a vanity assembled would be pretty time consuming. Sanding most all of it in the flat should be pretty quick, less than 2 hr. My normal progression is to 150/180 depending on species and then only have to touch up with 150 or 180 post assembly for the occasional glue clean up that was not fixed with a toothbrush and water. Last step is the entire piece with 180 or 220 on a cork backed hand block to linearize and eliminate all trace of snail trails. As others have noted on occasion you may have to start with 120. As a note to this masking tape also can mask areas you don't want to get glue on or don't want to pre-sand because they are critical to the joinery.

The other frequent mistake in sanding that leads to too much time spent, is to overuse the paper. If it doesn't feel grippy on the fingers it is gone. Even a small piece such as wall hung vanity may require 3 disks or more of each grit. With harder material it may be way more, I know when I was sanding my hickory toolbox I was going through 2 disks a panel side. Max 2.5'x3'.

Don't give up on the scraper. I would mention that scary sharp is not helping you with the scraper. The nature of the paper is too soft for the edge type needed for scraping. Files and stones are key, burnishing and burr creation is less critical than edge prep here.

And finally, I would also caution you not to never consider a drum sander as a finishing tool. A drum sander is at best a thicknessing tool much the same as planer.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#22

Some info and answers

Howard Acheson

Here a couple of things from the files of a woodworking club I was involved with.

Sanding wood--hard or soft--beyond 220 does little more than burnish the wood making staining difficult. This is particularly true if you are using a pigment stain which sits on the surface and relies on "nooks and crannies" to impart color. Softer more porous woods can be sanded to to 220 but harder less absorbent woods may stain best if only sanded to 150. The best compromise is to aim for 180 grit.

A number of years ago a large cabinet/custom furniture shop I was involved with did series of adhesion tests with various finishes and sealers. As part of this test we explored adhesion based on sanding grit. We found about the same adhesion up to 180 - 220. Beyond 220 adhesion dropped off due to burnishing of the underlying wood particularly when non-linear machine sanders were used. This was tested on birch panels. We also found that the resulting smoothness of the first coat of finish was not materially affected by the smoothnes of the underlying wood for sandpaper grits between 150 - 220.. The smoothest surface substrate for final finishes was obtained by sanding lightly after the first coat of finish was applied and dry. Which makes the case for a thinned first coat of finish.

So our conclusion was that sanding beyond 180-220 was not necessary and could be actually detrimental.

But, most important was that there was a big appearance affect if the surface was not HAND sanded in the direction of the grain using the highest grit used on the sanding machine. A flat pad sander produced a much flatter surface than a ROS. However, both required final hand sanding with the grain for optimum appearence. If not hand sanded, swirl scratches could show. Final hand sanding using a sanding pad in the direction of the grain is a must.

To carry it one step further, sanding at 320-400 grit after the first coat and subsequent coats was the optimum. No improved appearence was noticed by between coat sanding beyond 400 for varnish. 400 was the sweet spot for thinner finishes. Between coat sanding was always done by hand whether for flattening or for adhesion.

I think you will find similar thoughts in the popular finishing books but YMMV.

Finally, the first coat of ANY finish will soak little shards of wood and cause them to raise whether the surface was sanded, planed or scraped. When the first coat of finish dries these hardened shards are what causes the surface to feel rough. Sanding with 320 paper will remove these hardened shards and subsequent coats will go on smoother. So, smoothness counts after the first coat of finish, but not much before that.

The finish left by the sizing machine determines the starting grit. Jointers, planers, belt sanders etc, should leave a finish that allows starting with 100 grit. From there, go to 120 grit and sand until the marks from the prior grit are gone, then move to 150 and finish at 180 grit.

Plywood is factory sanded to 180 grit. Therefore, it's best to not sand plywood except with 180 grit and sand by hand. Get the first coat of finish on and then sand with 320. That way you are sanding the finish, not the wood. This avoids sanding through today's very thin surface veneer.

On the issue of the resulting "smoothness" of scraping/planing verses sanding let me contribute this.

One of the woodworking magazines (I think it was either Fine Woodworking or Wood Magazine) did small test of whether scraping/planing produced a better surface for finishing. They planed, scraped and sanded (up to 180--220) and then applied a couple of coats of oil based varnish. They lightly sanded at 400 grit between coats. They then showed the samples to a number of their technical and non-technical staff. The results were that none could identify differences in the samples. They noted that when planed or scraped, the surface a sort of burnished, glassy appearance but that after the application of the finish, there was no visual apparent difference. In other words, it made no difference what tool or method was used for smoothing. Once a coat of finish was applied the samples all looked the same.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#23

Stock Finishing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I start sanding my stock on the Performax before cutting and assembly. I use the jointer and planer ( no Shelix :( ) to "hog" then surface with 120 making sure to keep the drum abrasive clean. RO and hand sand after that take very little time.

Parts (except for panel glue-ups) are done to 180 before final assembly. I've even been known to apply finish before final assembly.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#24

finishing before assembly...

John in NM

The shop I worked for used to do that - a wipe of Watco or something similar before assembly made glue removal a quick job. After assembly it went back to the sanders for full finishing. I found it expedient to tape all my tenons after the first batch came back with oily fingerprints all over the tenons.

Re: Options to eliminate sanding?

#25

Re: finishing before assembly...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

For spindle-crazy mission


IMHO there's really no other way to do it. Spindles cut, sanded, and the tenons formed then taped. Finished on a pin board with Watco, shellac, and waterborne lacquer. Finished ends waxed, then unwrapped and glued up on pre-finished carrier boards. Glue squeeze pops right off leaving clean joints and surfaces.