Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Tipping point

Posts

Re: Tipping point

#26

I did!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the place is descriptively called "ShellacFinishes".

Re: Tipping point

#27

Got me

David Yoho

I thought you missed hitting the space bar!

Re: Tipping point

#28

Re: Tipping point

walta

When I pad on shellac I add 3 drops of mineral oil per ½ cup of shellac.

To my eye part of the charm of a shellac finish is that it is not perfect. It is thicker in corners and it is not evenly applied.

If your mind eye sees perfection I think you should worship the gods of sprayed lacquer. No not rattle cans, we are talking big air compressor, air dryer, spray gun applied in a dust free air conditioned dedicated room.

Walta

Re: Tipping point

#29

not necessary

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"If your mind eye sees perfection I think you should worship the gods of sprayed lacquer. No not rattle cans, we are talking big air compressor, air dryer, spray gun applied in a dust free air conditioned dedicated room. "

I got perfection spraying at 92 degrees yesterday on the driveway. It takes a tiny air compressor to feed a spray gun. I once painted someone's front door (on saw horses on their front lawn) with a portable used for a nail gun that had a 1/2 gallon tank. It would have gone quicker with a large compressor.

Re: Tipping point

#30

Re: When I was a very young lad

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

My father made a statement I have never forgotten (don't know how it stuck as I was 10 years old when he passed). His statement makes a lot of sense. "The difference between a Professional and an Amateur is that a Professional knows how to cover up his mistakes". As a pro contractor for many years as a second job, I smiled several times as I recovered from an error and remembered this adage.

There were times that I lost the profit (and in some cases money out of my pocket) from a job when learning to correct issues, but as far as I know I never left a dissatisfied customer in more than 25 years of contracting. As I gained experience in installation of HVAC, Electrical work, some construction and other tasks, I had far fewer "errors" to correct and did make more profit. If you don't learn from your "mistakes" you never progress in the work you are doing and your quality never gets better!

Re: Tipping point

#31

Kneale Brownson

If it's "perfect", it looks plastic.

Kneale Brownson

This is woodworking. The CRAFT is in the WOOD, not the finish.

Re: Tipping point

#32

Another occaison to be disagreeable

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You folks are keeping my fingers busy this AM.

There are few that would call the finish on a Steinway piano a "plastic" finish. Filled grain and a glass smooth rubbed out finish are an essential part of some formal finish schedules for certain applications. The Federal wall cabinet pictured in my earlier post has such a finish on its top (but not on the sides).

The first thing I see people do when examining something I have made is to run their fingers across it. They respond favorable if the finish is silky smooth and appears uniform.

The standard of traditional finishes, the French Polish, was a route to silky smooth surfaces.

Brush marks, runs, dust nibs, thick and thin spots have no place in finely crafted furniture. Don Williams the guru of furniture finishing ( he actually does it rather than sells it) allows that 1/4 to 1/3 of the time to build a fine piece of furniture is in finishing it. The attractive variation in the finish comes from variation in color and in cases luster.

Re: Tipping point

#33

Disagree

David Yoho

This is woodworking. The CRAFT is in the WOOD, not the finish.

Maybe I'm not reading you the way you intended but I have to disagree with your statement.

While the "craft is in the wood", meaning to me craftsmanship, applies, I take issue with the "not the finish" part. Do you think professional finishers don't think there's any craft to what they do?

I believe woodworking for most of us is comprised of two important and different parts - building and finishing. We can do the absolute best job building something to the point it could win an award of some kind. However, all that work is useless if the finish stinks it up. A great finish can often make mediocre woodworking look good but a bad finish can destroy the best woodworker's effort.

Re: Tipping point

#34

Clint Searl

Shellac? Serves you right!


Re: Tipping point

#35

also sanding

Steve Jenkins

A poor sanding job will detract as much as poor finishing or construction

Re: Tipping point

#36

Re: The best use of the Forum .....

TomD

I think you have a point about oddly shaped pieces. I have seen a lot of videos where the spiral in the leg, or whatever was just daubed there was no real polishing involved. On the flat though, there isn't any reason one can't get a spectacular finish from French polishing.

As far as the best use of the forum, photographs are rarely good at showing subtlety in finishes, colours, but they are good at shine, so I think photos are not the best judge in such matters.

Re: Tipping point

#37

Kneale Brownson

Re: Disagree

Kneale Brownson

I hate the thought of someone who makes something nice scrapping it because of finishing problems.

Re: Tipping point

#38

I agree

David Yoho

In an earlier response I also conveyed that sentiment. I think Joe experienced the same thing many of us here have at one point and that is more frustration than one can handle after pouring so much effort into a project. The best thing to do is walk away and give it a break.

I knew when posting my earlier response that he lived close to Jeff Jewitt and had met him before. My hope was that he could squeeze in some time with him to see if he could get answers to his problem. Joe's got skills. I believe with a little face time with Jeff he could take his clock on and finish it.

Hopefully he will.

Re: Tipping point

#39

Re: Shellac? Serves you right!

John Pappas

Clint, that's a rather snarky comment that adds nothing intelligent to the conversation. Note that all the other comments were meant to help Joe by offering advise or alternatives. That's really the spirit of this forum.

Re: Tipping point

#40

Clint Searl

Re: Shellac? Serves you right!

Clint Searl

John, it's just my shorthand for suggesting that shellac is an archaic finish whose few positive qualities are matched, if not exceeded, by contemporary film finishes. And its negatives far outweigh any positives. Does there remain any commercial furniture manufacturer that uses it? It's use is an affectation of those who refuse to recognize the facts.

Re: Tipping point

#41

Ellis Walentine

Make the best of the situation?

Ellis Walentine

Hi Joe,

I've been sitting this one out hoping there is a magic bullet I don't know about. Personally, I would have used Waterlox or even Danish oil on the clock, and it's not too late for either of those. You'll have to remove the uneven shellac with solvent alcohol and rags until you've taken it back to bare wood. Then wipe a few thin coats of Waterlox or Seal-A-Cel on there and you're home free.

Krenov called shellac "polish" and applied it thinly with a little rag. The result is a soft, barely visible finish that offers a bit of protection from dust and fingerprints but not much more. If you need protection from water and abrasion, you'll need to go to a hard film finish of appropriate thickness.

Ellis

Re: Tipping point

#42

Re: Shellac? Serves you right!

don stephan

The appropriateness of any particular finish depends on a number of factors. It's generally accepted that shellac has the greatest clarity. It has the greatest adhesion, so highly figured wood can be sanded far beyond what is recommended for "modern" finishes. It is repairable. It likely is not as efficient for production situations. All of these and many more considerations affect the choice of a finish for a particular project.

Re: Tipping point

#43

Clint Searl

Re: Shellac? Serves you right!

Clint Searl

All of those characteristics can be credibly challenged, especially in the context of what's relevant to finishing woodwork.

Re: Tipping point

#44

Re: Shellac? Serves you right!

paul in AZ

clint: I take it that if a process isn't used by a commercial operation it is not to be used because it is an outdated "affectation". Does this include hand cut joinery?

Re: Tipping point

#45

Re: Shellac? Serves you right!

TomD

"Does there remain any commercial furniture manufacturer that uses it? It's use is an affectation of those who refuse to recognize the facts."

That seems more likely to recommend shellac than anything else. For amateurs it is self-evidently ridiculous, and even for pros the game is to find the inexpensive to produce distinctions that can sell one's work with the largest upcharge. If one can make a case for shellac or hide glue over mass produced "alternatives" and get paid more for doing the same thing, that's the game.

It is certainly true that if one manufactures woodwork for particularly ill informed or uncommitted admirers, perhaps making wooden toilet seats, then durability of the finish can be a major factor. But a quality consumer knows better.

I would be surprised if you couldn't find commercial users of shellac on woodwork, at least for various undercoats, but it may be that it is no longer used. The continued availability of the material in non-food grade sacks makes me wonder though.

Re: Tipping point

#46

Shellac can be done....by some

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


This piece displayed at the recent SAPFM meeting is done with shellac. I would have liked to see the details of doing it.

There are two high end makers in our club that shellac stuff. But it remains elusive to me how to do complex surfaces short of spraying them.

Re: Tipping point

#47

Re: Second that

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"I wish I was close by enough to get with Joe on this."

Thank you. That is a generous offer.

Re: Tipping point

#48

Re: Tipping point

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks all for the suggestions and words of wisdom.

My wife took the clock (with its new dents and dings) out of the garbage.

I thought long and hard about walking away from woodworking and picking up a new hobby. I came really really close. I had never thrown a project into the garbage before. Can't think of a new hobby I can afford though... I'll stick with this a bit longer.

I took somebody's suggestion and tried to clean off the shellac with DNA (off just the two doors that were really messed up from trying to brush the shellac). That was a mistake; the mistake being I did not think through what was going to happen when I started wiping the shellac off with DNA. It took the color and everything off. I ended up with a clock case and two doors that are totally different colors. Uhg. I should have just scuffed sand everything and put poly over it. The mistake was mine, not of the person who suggested it.

Anyway, I had just enough trans tint dye left to put on to the doors. Color was close. I started to wipe on poly which warmed it up and the color is getting closer with each application. i.e. the doors are getting pretty close in color to the rest of the case which I did not remove the shellac from.

For the clock case, I will just scuff sand it and wipe on poly.

My next challenge is going to knock the gloss back a bit from the high gloss poly. I know I am going to rub right through it... :) Somebody will suggest to "rub it out" to the desired sheen. I hate that phrase "rub it out", it is such an ambiguous phrase.

Thanks all for the support and help.

This is the only woodworking forum I frequent. Always has been because of the great knowledge and support offered free of charge.

Thanks.

Re: Tipping point

#49

Re: Tipping point

John in NM

Stick with it Joe, seeming errors and fiascos are the quickest and most effective way we learn to avoid the problem next time around. At some point I came up with the theory that an expert wasn't someone who never made mistakes, rather someone who could effectively recover from the inevitable mistakes.

I don't much like the phrase "rub it out" either, but there is something to it. And you're right, it's very easy to go through the film. Even using tripoli and rottenstone I've managed to go through a film finish. The trick then is to recoat, perhaps with some thinned down stuff depending on the product, and then evaluate your sheen. Keeping the goals of smooth and just the right sheen is helpful - get it smooth first, and then worry about the sheen - since it takes much less effort to knock the gloss off than to get a smooth surface.

Re: Tipping point

#50

Re: Tipping point

John Pappas

Joe, I'm really pleased that the clock will be completed, not wasted. I will predict that in the end you will look at this clock as a special piece in which you have a lot of pride......and an interesting story to tell as well.