Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Tipping point

Posts

Tipping point

#1

Tipping point

joe in a Cleveland suburb

I reached the tipping point tonight on my clock. Gave up and tossed it in the garbage. I've been "woodworking" for about 20 years and still can't put a good finish on anything.

I've been trying to brush shellac on the door and panel. No matter what I do, no matter the advice I get, it looks like crap. Can't do it.

I've bought countless videos, watched countless YouTube videos, read countless WORTHLESS magazine articles, countless web articles and forum posts, and it just doesn't click for me.

I've bought so many 'best' brushes for shellac I don't know what to do with them all. I bought Everclear and on and on.

All of this best stuff ends up with the same result: lap marks, tide marks, and worst of all ridge lines from the brush. I have sanded everything down and restarted so many times it is rediculous. I'm damaging the dye that was applied.

I've been trying to get this right literally for weeks.

I've tried 2 pound cuts, 1 pound cuts, all DNA on and on. Wipe on. Pad on. Hot days. Cool days. Humid days. Dry days. A/C on. A/C off. Same results.

I won't even start on about rubbing out. I can't get that right either. Other than to say nobody ever addresses how to deal with any surface other than a flat piece of wood. What about frame and panels? How do you brush and rub out, or pad on either shellac or varnish surfaces that have rails and stiles? Corners? Anything other than a simple flat surface. I have never seen that problem adressed in a magazine article or video.

Perhaps I am too much of a perfectionist, but the finishing portion of building anything is so frustrating for me it's seems to be no longer worth it. I'm done. I don't know what else to do.

Thanks.

Re: Tipping point

#2

I've never gotten the hang of shellac either...

John in NM

Perhaps I'm just quick to give up and move on. Like so many other aspects of woodworking and the internet, I found that it was a lot of sexy sounding stuff and a very difficult product. Some like the challenge and tradition, and I get that even if I don't usually practice it.

Waterlox is the one I like. Can get just about any sheen I want, only trouble is filling the grain when desired, that gets time consuming. I find it to be just about the easiest finish I've tried, but that may be years of using it more than ease of use. I guess the only other problem is the price - something like $65/gallon last time I bought some, and you have to put it in jars to keep from having 7/8 of a gallon of jelly after a month.

Others like spray on varnishes - I would bet those are as easy and versatile if one buys the equipment and gets over the learning curve.

Re: Tipping point

#3

You're not alone

David Yoho

Joe, when it comes to shellac I've given in too. I've sprayed it once with decent results but I generally don't spray finishes due to space constraints and lack of dedicated spray area. So now I only use Seal Coat and then it's usually on small things to act as a barrier coat or tie coat. I wipe it on when I use it. I also would not use it as my primary finish because I just don't have the skills down to pull it off and look right.

My go-to finish of choice is either Waterlox or General Finishes Arm-R-Seal. I'd been using Waterlox for a number of years and it wasn't until about 8 years ago, after meeting Charles Neil, that I found out how to apply it to get optimum results. The answer was right there in front of me and seemed so simple once I saw what I wasn't doing. Now my varnish finishing results look more like they were sprayed than wiped on. The Arm-R-Seal is much less expensive than the Waterlox and gives almost the same results. The technique I picked up from Charles works great but there's more waste involved, which makes its use more expensive than other choices. However, it's my preferred choice for anything I build that needs a high end look and finish.

There are any number of other great finishes folks use and most are sprayed on. I'm not in a situation where spraying is easy in my own shop. Yes, I can and have done it, but ultimately it depends on the size of the project as to whether or not I do it.

Joe, if you're like me and most guys, since men are visual it's often better to see something done. Videos are good but seeing it in person with someone who knows what they're doing is really the best way to learn. Perhaps you would benefit from a lesson or demo on applying shellac. Perhaps that answer you need is right there in front of you but you just aren't seeing it on your own. If there was any way to get in front of someone with the require skills, I would do it.

Re: Tipping point

#4

How about a hint?

John K Jordan

>The technique I picked up from Charles works great but there's more

>waste involved, which makes its use more expensive than other choices.

Maybe not a full tutorial, but a general idea of the technique, perhaps what not to do?

JKJ

Re: Tipping point

#5

Re: Tipping point *LINK*

mdclor

Joe, I suggest getting an inexpensive spray gun and learning to use it. I seem to recall that you have limited space and close neighbors, but you could make a spray booth with cardboard and spray inside your garage or basement if you use a waterborne product. Target Coatings EM6000 is a great lacquer product and each successive coat "burns into" the previous coats thereby eliminating witness lines, etc.

Stop beating your head against the wall and use the door. ;)


Cheap spray gun

Re: Tipping point

#6

Since you are in Cleveland

Ray Thompson

Give Jeff Jewitt a call and see if you can spend some time with him somehow. I had miserable results with shellac until I spent a day with him. I have since moved to other finishes but can now do shellac if I have to.

Ray

Re: Tipping point

#7

Hint

David Yoho

John, I'll give you the highlights. It's as easy as pie.

Originally I was brushing every coat. The hardest places were vertical surfaces and areas where there were moldings or frame and panels. I experienced sags, runs, and areas that just looked too "gloppy" (not smooth and refined).

What I picked up from Charles was to start the first coat heavy by applying it with a foam brush. Once the stuff had enough time to absorb into the wood, come back with a good cloth (I've found muslin to work best) and wipe away all excess and leave it to dry.

The next day the second coat is also applied with a foam brush but not quite as heavy. Again, let it soak in a bit before wiping away the excess.

I like to let the first two coats dry a day, but after that successive coats can be applied within hours. I like letting the solvent have a chance to flash off with the Waterlox or it seems to hold its odor longer. Starting with the third coat I just wipe it on without loading the cloth up much. The thin film left behind is what allows quick drying so it's ready to apply another coat sooner. Also, because the coats are thin and dry faster, there's less chance for airborne dust to stick.

It takes more time to build a good film this way and there's a lot of product taken away with the wiping. One tip I use is saving my wiping cloth sealed up in a zip lock bag and placed in the freezer. Our freezer is out in my shop so this works well for me. The next time I need it I just remove it from the bag and go to work. I throw it away in a proper fashion once the project is done.

This is pretty much what I do. It works great and the outcome is very nice. The blanket chest on my Gallery page was done this way. I have a large bookcase in the shop right now that is almost done. The final coat was wiped on this morning. There are no streaks, sags, runs, or plastic-looking areas. If you didn't know better you'd think it was sprayed.

Re: Tipping point

#8

P.S.

David Yoho

I forgot to mention besides brushing Waterlox I was also trying to wipe it on. The problem there was I was loading my cloth up with too much product and leaving behind too much. The real key was to only leave behind a thin film each time.

Re: Tipping point

#9

The best use of the Forum .....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....is to seek advice. But one must be cautious as to where to look for it. Best to look where people actually make stuff. Maybe you have fallen under the spell of the Neanderthals with this shellac thing. Go to the Gallery and look up Mayberry. That piece is Minwax wipe on varnish. Several in our club use it with great success. Their finishes are flawless. It is trivial to apply.

We have gotten demonstrations at our club applying shellac. It is always a flat surface. When I ask about a frame and panel I get a description of how to do it, never a demo. That said, a frame and panel door can be readily sprayed with shellac. (see pictures). Spray the panel. Assemble the door. Spray the works, or alternatively mask the panel and spray the frame- depends on my mood.




I will be spraying the new Spice Boxes shortly. I sprayed the panels yesterday.

Re: Tipping point

#10

Re: Tipping point

John Pappas

"I reached the tipping point tonight on my clock. Gave up and tossed it in the garbage."

Joe, I hope you are just joking. I recall a very nice looking clock. Too nice to throw away. Whatever the situation, I am sure something can be done to finish this clock in a satisfactory way. Take a deep breath, and accept the challenge. I recently had a lot of frustration sharpening a small back saw. Long story, but I did suffer equal frustration. In the end, the saw works just fine. Hang in there!

Re: Tipping point

#11

Deal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

While shellac is an integral, even required, part of my wood finishing, I do not "do" shellac finishes. I gave up on that many moons ago, admitting that a French Polisher I will never be. :D

Brush the stuff? Never

Pad it? Only when out of reach of the compressor.

I now apply the shellac component of m,y finishes by spray gun, specifically my little CA Tech. Tech Jr. mini HLVP gun.

Re: Tipping point

#12

Thanks!

John K Jordan

To the shop! I'm making a wedding present for my niece and was getting frustrated with the finish. This sounds like the basic technique I use with Tru-Oil but most of my experience is with smaller turned pieces.

JKJ

Re: Tipping point

#13

rattle can

Jerry Gibbs

I made a clock roughly 12"x8"x6". I sprayed semi-gloss lacquer from a rattle can with excellent results.

Re: Tipping point

#14

Re: rattle can

Jesse Cloud

Well, now that Jerry has admitted to using a rattle can, I can 'fess up. I have no space/electric/safe place for a big compressor. My garage/shop also houses a gas water heater and a gas boiler, so not safe for spraying.

I take the work outside, spray with a rattle can of shellac. Yes, it leaves nibs but won't run if you are watching closely.

After a few coats (dries very quickly here in the desert), I give it a day to cure then rub it out with 0000 steel wax and wax. Just about foolproof.

Here's a pic, sorry its just a phone pic.

Re: Tipping point

#15

Re: rattle can

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I made 19 clocks over three months for relatives and friends. 12"w x 18"h x 4"d with base about 14x8. Used Minwax walnut color wiped on

and nothing else.

Still have the one I gave my Mom....and it is battery run and only change the battery once a year.

Re: Tipping point

#16

Today's experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I sprayed the first coat of shellac on the Spice Boxes. It is 90+ degrees, horrible spraying conditions. Made up a 25 wt% solution of garnet shellac and shot it. (let's retire the archaic pound measure of concentration) Took about 1 minute to do a box. It dried glass smooth, dust free in seconds.

That said all is not well. This is new shellac. It dried yellow instead of garnet color as I have experienced with previous shellac. This is a sealer coat so it is not an unfixable problem but now I have to wait on an order of different shellac. I was looking for the reddish color of garnet or orange shellac not the yellow hue of varnish or I would have used varnish. Lots of ways to have finishing problems.

Re: Tipping point

#17

Tone It!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bill,

You can use alcohol-soluable dye (TrandTint or Moser's) to tone your shellac to any color you wish. I quite buying Garnet (or Dark Garnet) when I had too much spoilage. I now use only Ultra Pale and then add TransTint dyes (drop-at-a-time) to get the exact color I want from the gun

Re: Tipping point

#18

Nope. In the garbage it went.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

My wife may have saved it. I don't know.

Re: Tipping point

#19

Shellac On, Shellac Off

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

All it takes is alcohol and a rag. The coating with redissolve and get wiped away with the rag that gets rinsed out as it loads. Won't take long to get back to bare wood, then go with a nice wipe-on oil varnish and call it d-o-n-e.

Re: Tipping point

#20

rescue from mistake is valuable learning experienc

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I hope wife has more wisdom

Re: Tipping point

#22

there is a problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't remember who I loaned my dyes to. I have just the reddish brown I need, somewhere.

Re: Tipping point

#23

A recomendation for ShellacFinishes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I ordered some orange shellac from these folks and 4 hours later my order was shipped and I have a tracking number. That is impressive.

Re: Tipping point

#24

Uhh... Bill...

David Yoho

You meant to give us the name of the place????

Re: Tipping point

#25

Second that

David Yoho

I wish I was close by enough to get with Joe on this. I know I could fix it. I know what he's saying about the underlying dye beginning to be affected and how it must look.

That said, I hope either his wife retrieved it or he thinks better of it and does it. The best lessons learned in the shop is while fixing mistakes - PERIOD. I also don't think Joe is a quitter. Frustrated beyond crazy - yes, but not a quitter. Not after all the fine work he's put into that little labor of love. I hope he thinks better after some time to regroup and takes this thing on to the finish.

Joe may have had his heart set on doing a traditional finish to match the time period and style of this clock. At this point he either needs to get in front of a seasoned finisher or try a different finish. Either way I have confidence Joe can fix this thing. This is a great opportunity to learn something while finishing what he started.