Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Table Saw Blade Change Problem

Posts

Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#1

Table Saw Blade Change Problem

Stuart Johnson

Today when I was changing from a rip to cross cut blade the shaft would turn but the nut wouldn't release. I was finally able to get a wrench more or less onto the nut side of the flange and got it loose. I've never had this issue before. What would cause it and how do I prevent it from happening again?

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#2

I don't understand the stiuation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The assembly should be nut, flanged washer, blade, flanged arbor shaft. To change blade lock the blade by any means (I use a stick wedged in the teeth) and remove nut with wrench. What part of this procedure is failing? If you lock the blade and apply a wrench to the nut what isn't happening that should?

Many vastly over tighten blade nuts. They are threaded to self tighten in use. Only a modest snug with the wrench is necessary, or desirable, for installation.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#3

Re: I don't understand the stiuation

ben d.

Assuming the threads on the shaft are at least inside or flush to the blade which should be, check the nut itself. On one side most have a sort of flange that is not the full width of the nut and the other side does not. The flanged side of the nut, not flat all way across should go next to the blade.

ben d.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#4

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

Ralph Lipeles

I have 2 suggestions. First get an exploded view drawing of the arbor assemble and see how the arbor shaft is retained. Something may be loose or missing. Second, There may be dirt or corrosion on the shaft that will cause the nut to rotate the shaft when wrenched, rather then unscrewing.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#5

Strange

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Virtually every table saw I've ever used has had a pair of flats milled on the arbor/motor shaft to the left of the inboard flange to be used to lock the shaft with a second wrench/spanner when removing the blade nut. What brand saw is this?

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#6

Re: Strange

Stuart Johnson

After the mess over on turning board I better not say which saw I have. It does start with a G and ends with a y. I've had it for 15 or 16 years with no problems.

There is a small flat on the shaft but I don't have anything that will fit it properly. My router wrench is thin enough but just the wrong size. It did hold enough so I could loosen the nut. What was happening was the shaft was turning even though the blade was being held with a wedge.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#7

Part

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

number may be P0732140 which comes with the saw. Known as an "arbor wrench." Call the g-man with your model number and git one what fits to replace the one you lost 16 years ago. Makes life easier and prevents damage to saw blade teeth.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#8

Re: Strange

Gary Bindel

I have the same saw. I made a wrench from an old saw blade.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#9

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

Dick Coers

I'm wondering if the nut isn't bottoming out on the threads, just as it gets snug on the blade. Does the nut have a washer face, or just the size of the nut? I was thinking about a shim under the nut to see it it bottom on the blade harder. Then maybe it will release with a more traditional method.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#10

Agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

At least on any saw I have used there is a flanged washer between the nut and the blade. If the nut is engaged with this flanged washer I don't wee how the nut would turn the shaft with the blade held stationary. If this saw lacks the washer, make one.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#11

Re: Agree

Stuart Johnson

I'm using a stabilizer between the nut and the blade. With the blade held tight so it wouldn't move the force on the nut rotated the arbor. The blade was put on after I had the problem the first time. It was snugged finger tight not with the wrench. I have ordered a thin 22 MM wrench to hold the back of the flange. This should work but I don't understand what has caused this to start happening.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#12

Summery

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The friction between flanged washer(in your case a stabilizer washer) and the blade is less than the friction of nut on threads and stabilizer.......right?

If this is the case I am bewildered. The contact area of nut to threads and nut to stabilizer is greatly smaller than stabilizer to blade, presuming the stabilizer is seating on the blade.

Experiments:

Eliminate the stabilizer, it is doubtful it is doing anything useful, and see if the problem persists.

Add an additional washer between nut and either the blade or stabilizer and see what happens.

Lube the threads. They could be gauling.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#13

You're not checking the thread length?

Dick Coers

So you have plenty of thread? The nut is not bottoming out? I guess I can't tell if there was supposed to be a thick flanged washer, and you replaced that with a stabilizer. Or, there never was a thick washer, or, you used the stock washer and the stabilizer.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#14

Sounds like

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

the nut was not putting enough pressure on the bade to allow the inboard surface of the blade to have sufficient friction with the inboard flange to "hold" the arbor still and allow the nut to be removed while holding the blade. Since disclosed that the nut was installed "finger tight" this sounds reasonable.

Anyway, employing an arbor wrench will solve the problem.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#15

Toss the stabilizer

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I agree with the previous comments that your nut is bottoming out on the threads before making full contact with your stabilizer. There have been long discussions on the value (more on the lack of value) of stablizers. Get the factory flange washer for your saw and use that with your blade and existing nut and I am sure you will have no more problems. On most saws the flange washer that goes between the nut and the blade is about 1/4" thick. Your stabilizer is likely much less than that.

As far as why this problem has just started to occur, there could be several reasons.

Are you using a different blade that might have a thinner core than your previous blades?

Did you put the stabilizer on backwards? Some are ground with a concave side so they exert pressure at their outer edge and not in the center by the hole.

Lee

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#16

maybe not

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Anyway, employing an arbor wrench will solve the problem. "

If there is this little friction of flange to blade the blade is likely to stall or slip in a heavy cut. There is something wrong here that needs to be found and fixed. What ever sort of flanged device, stabilizer or flanged washer, engages the blade should provide enough friction so as it not slip against the blade under any circumstances.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#18

Is this a coated blade to reduce friction?

Keith Newton

I suspect the larger washer is sprung just enough to allow the blade to slip under the stabilizer just enough, while the tension is high enough in the threads to allow the arbor to turn with the nut. You can try some WD40 under the nut without any risk. If the nut slips while under load sawing, it will only get tighter.

If that doesn't do it, keep a piece of wood along with the wrench, and a light weigh mallet. Place the wrench on the nut, with it leaning slightly forward, then jamb the block of wood into the front of the blade, while also into the front of the blade slot, locking the blade against turning. Give the wrench a quick tap with the light mallet. The quick tap will spin it past the friction zone much easier than muscle power.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#19

Re: Is this a coated blade to reduce friction?

Barry Irby

Is it possible there is something preventing the nut from tightening properly? A ship or grit under the nut? Or is the stabilizer washer thin enough to drop into the threads? Causing the nut to lock up without cinching the blade? It would have the same effect as the threads running out too soon as in where the stabilizer is thinner than the factory washer.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#20

Re: Is this a coated blade to reduce friction?

Paul Blackwell

I have a Unisaw with the same problem. I use the factory washer and nut. The blade has never slipped under load, but the only way I can remove the blade is to put the wrench on the nut, lock the blade with a piece of wood, and give the wrench a sharp rap with a hammer. This only started a few months ago.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#21

No Maybe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bill,

The "inboard flange" on the opposite side of the blade is machined as part of the arbor shaft; it's not some part that can rotate if the shaft itself doesn't turn. An arbor wrench fits flat surfaces that are machined on the shaft as part of and abutting the inboard flange. If the wrench engages the inboard shaft, you can't rotate the arbor shaft by cranking on the damn nut that hold the blade against it.


In the drawing the "shaft" "flats" and "inboard flange" are one piece of steel. The arbor wrench fits on the flats and the nut is removed exactly like using 2 wrenches on a router collet.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#22

Very Possible

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Referring to my drawing below, if the arbor shaft is not threaded all the way to the inboard flange (unusual) the nut could very well be "bottoming" at the end of the threads and not putting sufficient pressure on the blade. I would think, however, that the result would be the blade stalling in a cut, not to mention wobbling or cutting a wider curf. The stabilizer is not a substitute for the outboard shaped washer the is used to put real pressure of the blade.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#23

Re: Is this a coated blade to reduce friction?

BrianMonumentCO

Do you clean your arbor shaft when changing blades?

I normally use a brush to remove any sawdust.

I wonder if any junk is inside the threads and preventing loosening.

Conversely, if the shaft is highly lubricated, I wonder if the nut could tighten against the stabilizer/washer to the degree that it becomes hard to undo.

IE the motion of the shaft and the easy motion of the nut on the threads permitted it to overtighten.

In the case of the OP, I wonder if the nut has a good fit unlike the nut and threaded rod from a borg store have....IE a crummy fit that causes the nut to actually jam against the washer not tighten.

THe nut's threads would fit poorly in the arbors threads.

My Unisaw takes a bit of effort but I use two properly fitted wrenches one on the arbor flats and one on the nut to loosen the nut.

End of todays speculations.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#24

Interesting....not my Unisaw

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When installing a blade I give a modest tug on the nut while holding the blade with my fingers pressed against it. To loosen I wedge a stick in the blade teeth and with a modest tug the nut loosens.

I can't figure how the friction between the small nut and the shaft and/ or flanged washer could exceed the friction of the flanges against the blade. I hope someone has some insight.

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

#25

Re: Table Saw Blade Change Problem

Stuart Johnson

Slight update. I'm pretty certain the blade is now warped. When it is coasting to a stop I can see some wobble. I don't know if the is normal or not. The first blade to be stuck was a Freud thin kerf rip blade. It is fairly new but has been used a few times. The one that is stuck now and appears to be warped is a Freud cross cut.

As far as the stabilizer being the problem. I've used the same set up for a good ten years and have never had a problem. The only change in what I have done is the addition to the new rip blade. In the past I've always used cross cut or combination blades. This is the first thin blade I've used. I'll know more next week when I get a wrench so the blade can be removed. In the mean time I'm stuck with shop cleaning.