Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Commercial dust collector

Posts

Commercial dust collector

#1

Commercial dust collector

John Foster

This is a work( truss shop) question, (no way do I have equipment like this) At work we have a MangoTech Apollo mitre saw in a far corner of the shop, as well as two Monet Desauw component saws . We are currently shopping traditional dust collection, which could top $100,000. Largely because we are in a cold climate and have to filter the air as opposed to just blowing it out and losing the heat. Does anyone have any experience with the larger Felder Clean Air machines or the Hocker Vacmobils? I am thinking that it may be cheaper to have a premium dust collector at each machine, rather than a large central system. Unlike a furniture shop with very many machines, we only have a few large ones.

thanks John

Re: Commercial dust collector

#2

Re: Commercial dust collector

roger lance

Without question, it would be far more economical to have individual dust collectors at each machine given that you only have a few machines. You know if you have the room to place individual units close to each work station or not. I'd certainly look at that option.

Re: Commercial dust collector

#3

Re: Commercial dust collector

Joseph Mulherin, sr

John, have you personally made a cost estimate of the units needed as you say for the few machines

needed for the management to consider? Have the others in your place help with the estimates of run time for each unit and the electrical usage cost.

This would count good on you for the suggestion.

Re: Commercial dust collector

#4

Re: Commercial dust collector

Larry in NW Ohio

John If you would contact Oneida, They may be able to help you. I know there are more Dust collector Companies, but I can not think of any more right now. Good Luck with the project, sounds like fun. Larry

Re: Commercial dust collector

#5

Re: Commercial dust collector

John Foster

I have contacted Oneida, they have interesting equipment. The downfall is that their Canadian dealers only carry handyman level machines ( 5hp and less). They will supply the larger machines directly to Canadians, but it is not so convenient dealing over long distances.

Re: Commercial dust collector

#6

Re: Commercial dust collector

John Foster

I am starting to work on numbers. The component saws work 8-10 hrs. a day; the Mango a bit less. We are a few weeks overdue for a dept. heads meeting, we have a health and safety meeting next week. After those meetings, and hopefully an estimate from the company that one of the lead hands got in to price a central powered-ducted system we should have a bit of direction. I am not actually production staff anymore, I switched to health and safety coordinator in November. Fortunately our owner and the managers take safety seriously, and they are willing to do what it takes to have a healthy/safe workplace.

Re: Commercial dust collector

#7

Really, $100,000

Dick Coers

That's a really high quote! How many hp was the blower? Around here, you want the insurance company involved in an industrial installation. Having the blower, and bag house (with blowout panel) outside will give you a better rate. I was involved with designing the system for the last commercial shop I worked in. Sorry, don't remember the pricing. You don't need sophisticated filtering to bring the air back in, if the cyclone is designed correctly. Having several units running inside is really going to create the noise. No one will be able to take out the ear plugs during the shift!

Re: Commercial dust collector

#8

Re: Commercial dust collector

walta

I would be surprised if your local fire department doesn’t get have some input.

In general they will fail any new large installations without tens of thousands dollars in fire suppression equipment.

Walta

Re: Commercial dust collector

#9

Have you looked at torit?

McKay

When I taught school, we had a very large torit that filtered the air and blew it back into the heated area. There is no comparison of a large unit like the torit and individual units. The comparison would be akin to using a 1/2 ton to pull a semi sized trailer. The torit had shaker bags and the air coming in was cleaner than the air in the shop before it was turned on. Also no noise in the shop. I could lecture w/o any problem. $100,000 sounds reasonable.

Re: Commercial dust collector

#10

JL

Re: Commercial dust collector *LINK*

JL

A suggestion - there is an outfit called Industrial Recovery Services.

They auction off machinery (and lumber).

Look at some of the systems they are auctioning and see if they might fit your application - and then check on what it might cost new.


IRS auctions

Re: Commercial dust collector

#11

Re: Commercial dust collector

don stephan

As suggested, make sure fire department, insurance provider, building department and electrical inspection service will approve individual units. At minimum, might be required to have electrical interlock so machines don't have power unless dust collector(s) powered.

Re: Commercial dust collector

#12

Re: Commercial dust collector

Larry in NW Ohio

John WhenI was working yet, I worked at a woodworking plant and we had all of this DC equipment, but they closed down about in about 2002. Since then most of the equipment was sold off, and things went cheap. After 2 or 3 owners of the buildings the city finally bought everything. To me it looks like a lot of the dust collection equipment on the roof is still there and that the air cleaner with the bags that filter the air and run it back into the building. If someone would want the equipment, they could get it quite cheap. Larry