Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

how to best make mortises

Posts

Re: how to best make mortises

#26

Cost Benefit Time & Arrgh

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Any of the choices needs to be viewed in some sort of personal window. A $1,200 machine takes more anticipated use to justify in my view. For the Shoe-Box Woodshop in part of my basement, the modified JET has done the jobs that I needed to do with efficiency and economy. I can't, however, brag that I own one. :D

If I were in a position where I was making a larger number of M&T Joints each week and had the space/coin issues sidelined, I'd be sporting a PM 719 with Clico chisels or one of those spiffy Festool jobs because the tool would generate value through increased productivity making them a worthwhile investment for myself rather than for my executor to sell at the estate auction ;)

Re: how to best make mortises

#28

How much...

mark Hennebury

Accuracy do you want, how bad do you want it and how much are you willing to pay?

There are many mortising machines types out there:

Router type slot mortisers for round end slots:

1.hand held routers and jigs; simple and cheap can be used for floating mortise and tenons, but not very accurate or repeatable. not my recommendation.

2. Horizontal Slot mortise machines:

fairly expensive, more accurate and more repeatable results, I don't like the fact the way you bang into the stops on either side causing the bit to whip at each ends causing a slight key-holing effect,.I don't like them at all

3. Automatic slot mortisers:

The best machine slot mortiser that i have used; A Balestrini 2CAP This is an automatic cycle slot mortiser. A brilliant machine with a crankshaft stroke system that gives an incredibly smooth transition at the end of each cross-stroke, leaving a crisp clean mortise. Rock solid machine with an infinitely variable depth feed. preset stops, Infinitely variable cross-stroke.

There are many used machines around, they have been made since the 50's many different brand names, Balestrini, Griggio, Greda, Rye, Pade...

They are available in single or double sided.

They are fully automatic, they are industrial quality, they will require three phase electrical, and the will require some modification if you want to get the best out of them, keeping in mind that they were made for the industrial production which is about "acceptable" quality and fast production.The spindle speed is too low ,the cross-speed is too fast. I took mine apart and machined the spindle to a smaller diameter, at it is a belt driven spindle this increased the spindle rpm, I also installed a gearbox to reduce the crossfeed

I also modified the mortising cutters. The results of all this effort was a machine that cuts extremely clean precise mortises in a very short time.

Great for doing furniture such as chairs and cabinet doors etc.. For chair legs and aprons, for back slats, These machines are great for angled and compound angled joints.Accurate and repeatable.

I will do another post for square end mortisers

Re: how to best make mortises

#29

Sweet looking chairs and table

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Would like to see more of the table.

Would be nice to see some of your furniture in the Gallery

Re: how to best make mortises

#30

Re: Sweet looking chairs and table *LINK*

mark Hennebury

Thanks Bill, i will post some in the gallery.

For Mortising other than a slot mortiser, i have always like the Maka Style swing chisel mortisers. Once again they are industrial machines, three phase electrics.

They have also been around since the 50'S and are available used at auctions etc.. from time to time. They came in several different versions; Maka made asmall series and a larger more industrial size. The small series were made in very small bench top models and floor models , in manual with a hand feed lever or automatic. When tuned up they are incredible machines, that do very clean accurate mortises. They can take an infinite variety of chisels, and can cut single or double mortises , stopped or through, even haunched mortises in one pass. The floor mounted machines can pivot from vertical to horizontal position.

These machines are incredibly fast.

Incredibly clean and incredibly precise.





http://youtu.be/KJUJ796jxls

http://youtu.be/J9bVhJR5TKg

http://youtu.be/fTcG3rzOprU


Mortise video

Re: how to best make mortises

#31

Question

John in NM

I've always wondered if those machines cut as nice a mortise in endgrain. I end up doing a lot of endgrain mortises with a hollow chisel and hate it :D

Re: how to best make mortises

#32

Re: Question

mark Hennebury

They do an excellent job in endgrain. I did many mortises in endgrain using loose tenons.

I also had a Balestrini tenoner which was a great machine, it was the partner machine that did roundend tenons. It was an impressive feet of engineering in my opinion, fully automatic and infinitely variable within the range of the machine so that you could adjust the thickness and radius, length and depth of the tenon, it had scribing knives to cut a clean shoulder and chamfering knives to ease the end of the tenon. Once again a great machine for complex joinery in curved parts, with compound angles.

Re: how to best make mortises

#33

Re: Gets old fast, and not fast before you are old

TomD

I used it a lot, and hated it. When they were new bought a TR12 and used that to make series productions of turned rattles, that turned out to be illegal up here, in much the same way that Kinder Eggs are now illegal in the US. Live and learn. Maybe, not sure, the plan was in Ellis' old mag, I will have to look into that. If so, I still have some rattle cheap.

Come to think of it the only time I saw a kid hurt herself with one was when a friend's child was given one and she enthusiastically hit the floor, and here skull in a reciprocating up and down motion.

Re: how to best make mortises

#34

Re: Question

TomD

I didn't even know that was possible... Not so many drills work well in end grain.

Re: how to best make mortises

#35

Re: Question

mark Hennebury

Hi Tom,

While i had the automatic machines i found many uses for them and produced some nice credit card and business card cases.

These had to have an extremely clean precise fit to function, a couple of thou one way or the other and they were no good. These machines were that accurate and reliable.

" border="0" alt="">


Re: how to best make mortises

#36

Maka also

mark Hennebury

The Maka style mortisers also cut very clean in end grain

Re: how to best make mortises

#37

Re: Maka also

John in NM

That's the kind I would like one day, it would be a real improvement over the hollow chisel.

Re: how to best make mortises

#38

Re: Maka also

Jesse Cloud

You can also use a variety of cutters. Some like brad point bits, I used end mills.

Of course if you are doing end grain on the end of a long piece, say a stretcher for a table, you will need to fashion some sort of fixture to hold it steady.

All the mortises on my bench were done with horizontal mortisers. Fit was great and it has held up to a lot of abuse.

The great thing with HMs is that once you tune in the size of the mortise and the size of the tenon stock, the next several hundred joints are going to fit perfectly.

The "automatic" version has a pneumatic drive so you step on a pedal and the bit drives down full depth. I prefer to do it manually and take smaller, gentler bites along the length of the matrix, no keyhole effect at the end of the mortise then, but admittedly it is slower.

Re: how to best make mortises

#39

Re: Question

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

The Domino's end mills also do a good job in end grain. You might look into one if you don't have the floor space for or can't find one of Mark's recommended machines. Festool manufactures tenons that precisely fit the mortises made by the Domino machines, so you can get away without a machine or other setup for making your own.

It seems like any floating tenon machine worth its salt would have to do a good job in end grain, since you aren't going to cut a tenon to fit it's mortise.

Re: how to best make mortises

#40

Re: Yup, A cross-slide vise....

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I agree, a cross slide vise will even make the drill press attachment gizmo an "almost acceptable" solution. That's what I used before I got my first Domino. I can't even give the mortising attachment away, but I find many uses for the cross slide vise. IIRC, mine is a Grizzly. For use on a drill press table, i've seen many recommendations to tap a hole in the vise and turn one of the cranks around, to make it more convenient to access the three controls, but I've never found it necessary. It might be necessary if you mount it on a bench top HCM instead of a drill press.

Re: how to best make mortises

#41

E-Z Modification

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

There's at least one write-up on it in the Articles Section.

Re: how to best make mortises

#42

A thankyou and my problem may be solved

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A thanks to all that offered information.

A friend who deals in old, and usually big, iron ran across a Powermatic 10 light industrial mortise machine. More than I need? Well yes, but the cost is less than a new P-719T machine. Quality old iron appreciates in time rather than depreciating like new machines. And, friend removed the only serious impediment. I don' t like messing with old broken machines. He assured me this one owner machine was in new condition. BTW, a large number of light industrial Powermatic, Delta Northfield machines will be available from this source getting out of it- saws, shapers, planers, etc located in NC somewhere, probably western or middle.

Re: how to best make mortises

#43

Re: A thankyou and my problem may be solved

roger lance

That sounds perfect.....once you get it up and running, post some pics..... :D

Re: how to best make mortises

#44

Re: Question

TomD

Very pretty work there! What kind of machines are those, not hollow mortise...? I could see cnc doing that.

Re: how to best make mortises

#45

Re: A thankyou and my problem may be solved

TomD

You are a lucky man!

Re: how to best make mortises

#46

Re: Matthias

TomD

Matthias Wandel has a whole slew of interesting wooden machines he has made, several of which cut mortises or similar joints. He made a wooden hollow chisel mortiser. This is his router based machine:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sw0FDdIWds4

And he has a pantorouter that will cut mortises and tenons. This one has even had a commercial aluminum version made.

Mathias works in construction grade woods so one never really know how pleasant hardwoods would be to work with all his tools, but they certainly are an interesting bunch of tools.

Re: how to best make mortises

#47

Re: Question

TomD

You are certainly correct there. Looking at that Maka work, I did wonder if it would cut conventional tenons if the tenon ends were paired together, and then cut like mortises, then switched to cut the other "mortise". If the cutter and stock were such that the mortise was 50% then the tenon would come out at 50% also, which some regard as a perfect match for strength.

Re: how to best make mortises

#48

Great score Bill!

John in NM

For hollow chisel mortises, nothing beats those old heavy machines!

If your pal comes across any of those Maka machines drop me a line :D