Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

how to best make mortises

Posts

how to best make mortises

#1

how to best make mortises

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have endured a drill press and hollow chisel attachment for as long as I intend to. What is the best versatile tool to make mortises. My most common need is 1/4" by an inch or less deep, 5/16" by 1 to 1 1/2" deep and rarely 1/2" like for a bench leg. The 1/2" is not essential.

Accuracy of the position and width of the mortise is most critical so what ever holds the piece to be mortised needs to be secure. I am willing to pay for this accuracy.

What is the best floor or bench hollow chisel machine or is there an alternative?

Experience from someone picky about mortise accuracy will be appreciated.

Re: how to best make mortises

#2

Re: how to best make mortises

Stuart Johnson

I have a bench top Delta and while it works I'm not a big fan. Look on Youtube and you'll see a lot of different jigs for routers. I think if I was going to do a lot of mortises I would build one.

Re: how to best make mortises

#3

Re: how to best make mortises

John in NM

Absolute best is probably an oscillating chisel or swing chisel mortiser, though they can be hard to find and are expensive. Google "Maka mortiser" to get an idea what I'm talking about.

Next best for clean & accurate is probably a horizontal slot mortiser, if you can tolerate the round ended mortises.

Best bet for bullet proof, cheap to run, and accurate is the hollow chisel. I find them to be somewhat of a compromise on clean and accurate, but they are very cheap and require minimal maintenance. That's why you see them everywhere.

Re: how to best make mortises

#4

Tage Frid router jig

Keith Newton

Bill, do you have a Tage Frid plunge router jig? That sounds like a good alternative. I made a few alterations on his design, and still use it some after 30? years. I have a PM chain mortiser, but the 1/4" I think has a minimum of 1.5" length, and would have a round bottom.

If you google my subject line, you can find LOTS of images that I find a bit confusing how some people ended up at some of these variations. I'll take a few pics of mine and send them to you along with a few suggestions to improve on it, and even throw in a few toggle clamps. I ended up buying a big tub of them from a closed factory sale. Having a quick easy clamping system always makes them easier to use.

Re: how to best make mortises

#5

Re: how to best make mortises

mdclor

Bill, I have a Jet bench top mortiser and don't like it because the hold down is crap IMO. I have used an older Powermatic floor model and that worked great and was extremely accurate. Currently, I use a MortisePal (which I love), but they went out of business so are no longer readily available. FWIW

Re: how to best make mortises

#6

Bart Goldberg

Re: how to best make mortises

Bart Goldberg

Bill, I saw a really nice Powermatic Benchtop Mortiser at this past weekends woodworking show. I would recommend that one if you decide on a benchtop model.

Bart

Re: how to best make mortises

#7

I remember that hold down...

John in NM

It is awful!

I took the hex rod out and drilled a small depression for the set screw in the base, that helps a little, but not enough. I also didn't care for having to hold the piece tight up to the fence - thumb gets awful tired after 10 or so mortises.

Re: how to best make mortises

#8

Machines

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Early on I built myself a horizontal router "table" to use with up-cut spiral bits as a mortiser. I had issues in my small shop with holding the workpiece accurately (I'd get some flex, etm) and then I'd still have to either chop the ends square or round over the tenons.

Not having the room for either a floor machine or a large bolted-down bench tool, I went for the import JET (JBM-5). You can see my old review at

http://www.woodcentral.com/bparticles/JBM-5.shtml

Since then I've made some improvements, not the least of which is a bolt-on cross-slide vice from H-F that, with a bit of modification, works just fine so long as you're not looking for router-smooth walls in the slot. Given the nature of the hollow chisels, you'll also have a bit of clean-up on the bottom of the cuts, and you do need to keep them cone-honed.

Last Comment: Neither mine nor any other that I've tried will do an acceptable job on through mortices as they will tear out the exit hole badly. For that job I cut the square slot about 90% through, true/clean it up with a bench chisel, and then use a small (1/4") roller-guided router bit from the opposite side to get crisp clean edges on the outside.

Re: how to best make mortises

#9

Tool vs toy continuum......

roger lance

Bill.....this could be like your baseline chisel discussion in regards to what is "best". I've used a plunge router and jigs, a benchtop Delta, and even tried some handtools; but, since I got this, I'm not looking for anything else.....


its not perfect....but its a real tool.....and I have not found anything that it cannot handle. Features you'll want: an X-Y table, 1 horse motor, and strong hold down. This Powermatic has been "improved".....but if you can find a used one or older floor model, you'll be happy.

Re: how to best make mortises

#10

Re: how to best make mortises

Barry Irby

A friend and I worked our way through college building cabinets. He is still in the business, 40 plus years alter. He made a oscillating chisel/swing chisel mortiser for making cabinet doors and frames. He buys most of his doors now, so I am not sure it gets much use anymore, but it sure makes pretty mortises. I never could get the action of the chisel straight in my head.

At Highland Hardware in Atlanta I saw a device that had a table and a clamp for a router. There were three arms on it to control the three axis. Clamps and stops were in abundance. Never saw it work, but I wanted one. A fellow wood worker was standing there admiring it as well and he agreed he wanted one too, because it had a High Gizmology Factor. It was $1800 fifteen years ago.

I too dislike my drill press mortiser.

Re: how to best make mortises

#11

I believe you are describing.....

roger lance

a JDS Multi-Router which now sells for about $2,500+. Its still considered a very good tool.

Re: how to best make mortises

#12

Yes, those are good machines too

John in NM

One shop I worked for had a Multi-Router, they are very versatile machines, though I'm amazed they still run so much $$$. These days you could retail that machine for half the money, easily, between getting the machining done at a CNC shop and with how cheap linear bearings are now. In the early 1980's it was a different story. I'm a little surprised the Chinese aren't making a copy by now.

Re: how to best make mortises

#13

Re: Festool DF-700 Domino

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Nothing else comes close in speed and ease of use, versatility, or accuracy.

If you want to also make the smaller (4 mm, 5 mm and 6 mm wide) mortises that are usually done by the DF-500, Seneca Woodworking has an aftermarket adaptor that will allow you to use the DF-500 mills on the DF-700.

http://www.senecawoodworking.com/blogs/news/7877875-announcing-the-new-rts-500-bit-adapter-for-the-festool-domino-df700

Note that it is for loose tenons, so you don't need another machine to cut tenons in the joining board.

Re: how to best make mortises

#14

Re: how to best make mortises *LINK*

David Yoho

Bill, I started off years ago making mortises by hogging out the bulk of a mortise at my drill press with a forstner bit and clean and square up with bench chisels. Later on I bought a Delta bench top unit and several sizes of Clico hollow chisel bits. I use the Delta most of the time now but I also don't do that many M&T joints.

I know Ellis has always been a fan of the loose tenon method. I've always thought this was a good idea if making a lot of mortises, especially large ones.

I think based on your criteria you would start your looking at a machine like the one Roger has. No matter what you end up with, buy the best hollow chisel bits you can find. If you have some that you like then all you need is a machine. I like the Clico brand of bits, which are available from a WoodCentral friend and advertiser - Tools For Working Wood. They are pricey but I have found them worth every penny.


Clico Hollow Chisel Mortising Bits at TFWW

Re: how to best make mortises

#15

Ellis Walentine

Horizontal mortiser fan here

Ellis Walentine

In my old shop, we had two horizontal mortising machines. One was an Advantage Machinery brand slot mortiser with XY joysticks, a nifty protractor-head tilting table and a 3600rpm motor. The other mortiser was a revamped Whitney horizontal mill that we retrofitted with a Reeves drive and draw collets for upcut milling bits. That thing was a beast. We had bits all the way up to 7/8" diameter that cut over 4" deep for the giant driveway gates we used to make. We also had an industrial pin router that we jigged up in infinite ways to cut mortises, rout patterns, make moldings, etc. -- an excellent multi-purpose machine. On the light duty side, per your outlined requirements, you could probably improvise your own Multi-router unit from plans in our Articles department by Dan Barber.

You can tell I'm a fan of slot mortises because I believe strongly in loose tenon joinery and it is easy to make tenon stock with rounded edges. The two hollow chisel mortisers I have owned each had their problems. The benchtop machines I've tried and owned were short on accuracy, capacity and efficiency. If you get a hollow chisel mortiser, it should be a more serious machine, with good clamping and a head that retracts the bit efficiently. That Powermatic that Roger posted looks like a good one, and there are older, "heavy arn" types that still do a great job.

I still prefer horizontal slot mortisers.

Ellis

Re: how to best make mortises

#16

Re: Festool DF-700 Domino

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

If the Festool machine didn't exist, I would recommend the Powermatic floor mount machine that Roger show a picture of. It is the best hollow chisel mortiser I've ever used.

And to add to David Yoho's recommendations, Joel at TFWW carries the Festool Domino, and the full Festool line. He's a good guy to do business with.

Re: how to best make mortises

#17

Re: I believe you are describing.....

Barry Irby

Sounds right....At $1800 fifteen years ago it wasn't even a dream. Nor is it at $2500 now. And that is without the router. Sigh...., I will put another dollar on the Lottery.

Re: how to best make mortises

#18

Re: how to best make mortises *LINK*

Lars Parrington

I use a small plunge router. It is outfit with a shortened 3/4" template bushing, and has a good vacuum attachment. I use it in combination with very simple jigs that clamp to the workpiece. It is sort of a poor-man's domino. Not as fast, but much cheaper and more versatile.

For a more complete description and more pictures, see the link below (scroll ~2/3 of the way down).


img

http://lllars.appspot.com/furniture/cabinet_bench/index.php

Re: how to best make mortises

#19

Re: Tage Frid router jig

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've been using Frid's jig for 30 years, too. It's the only way I dig mortises.

Re: how to best make mortises

#20

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: how to best make mortises

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

I owned a Jet benchtop mortiser and it was not what you are looking for. I would suggest you look for an antique stand alone model or spend the money for a larger machine.Those benchtop mortisers aren't much better that what you use now.When I discovered I couldn't afford an adequate machine I became content in making all my mortises by hand.---Jack

Re: how to best make mortises

#21

Kneale Brownson

Yup, A cross-slide vise....

Kneale Brownson

makes a wonderful addition to the basic hollow chisel mortiser. I have one on my Delta. Any hollow chisel setup will not produce router-like smooth sides and will require a bit of clean-up with a chisel, but it'll take a lot of the work out of mortises.

Re: how to best make mortises

#22

Re: Horizontal mortiser fan here

Jesse Cloud

I've worked with all the above, except the JDS, and a horizontal slot mortiser with a good table would be my pick. After that the Festool Domino, which is what I use now.

Setup on the horizontal mortiser takes a little while, but once you have it down, you can turn out perfect mortises without fail. Dial in the fit of your own shop made tenon stock on a router table and its hard to do wrong.

I would pursue the Old Iron sites, might take some time and skill to tune up, but definitely worth it.

Re: how to best make mortises

#23

Re: how to best make mortises

TomD

You already got a lot of answers to this in the other thread. Except the question of accuracy. Decent quality machines will do accurate mortices with any of the hollow machines. You have to set them up properly, but they cut clean squares. If you want accuracy, you do the usual things to get it. Buy solid over features, buy quality over price, age over beauty. I really don't know who would actually be able to tell you which knock off machine was going to be delivered and be better than the next. Even a side by side review will not tell you which machines, if they are not consistent, is the best. You may just get the same random distribution in the cross brand sample as you would get in the same number of machines from one of the manufacturers.

I do think routers and oscillators are going to be fractionally more accurate, and in super duper versions much faster. The hollow chisel was still the backbone of a lot of shops in the golden age. It is one of the great tools out there because it combines a lot of efficiency with the quiet and air advantages we associate with hand tools (and a lot better than the noise of hand mortising). I hate mortising with routers.

Chisels are another issue. I bought taiwanese, when they were the center of cheapness, and they have been fine. Set up on the chisels is easy. You simply make sure the junk ejects into the mortise hole, that they are square, and that your drill is set so that it clears the chisel as far as possible without nipping the side of the mortise hole.

Re: how to best make mortises

#24

Re: Lee Valley

TomD

I don't know anything about these chisels, but the photo is an accurate depiction of what the mortises look like when you use a desk top machine.


Re: how to best make mortises

#25

Re: how to best make mortises *LINK*

Lars Parrington

Here's an article I just stumbled upon while looking up TF's jig. This is basically the same method I use, but explained better. One thing he's missing is dust collection on his router, which I'd consider to be essential.


http://www.craftsy.com/blog/2015/01/router-templates/