Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

Posts

Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#1

Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

Barry Irby

The hot water takes way too long to get to my kitchen sink, Takes about two gallons of water to get water to the sink. I learned there are recirculating pumps that can send the water back to the water heater through the existing cold pipes. You install and small pump and a cross connection between the hot and cold. then there is a temperature sensor and a switch. I think there were even timers available that would turn the system on at preset times. Lowe's had prepackaged kits that were about $250 probably five years ago. At the time I could not justify the cost and effort to save a few gallons of water. Now I have gone back to thinking about it and how much it irritates me to to keep waiting for hot water.

What I would like to have is a version of this system that has something like a push button that activates the system for a few minutes. I could push the button and go about my business for a few minutes while the system brings the hot water to me, without watching water go down the drain. Perhaps a short term timer to keep the water hot for say an hour while I cook.

Does anyone have one of the recirculating systems? Does it send hot water into unexpected places such as the toilet or ice maker? Anything else I need to know? Has anyone retrofitted one?

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#2

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Many years ago when I was just a plumbing apprentice we used to go the upper lavatory and run a 1/4" line back down to the water heater. It constantly circulated the hot water by thermal difference. Then later we used to run three 1/2" lines and install a circulating pump which was timed to come on early in the morning before you arose from bed. ...worked just fine and the pump was only about $70 at the time.

Any good plumbing shop can give you a good answer.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#3

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

mdclor

We had one installed when we built our house in 2007. It worked fine until one morning (maybe 3-6 months after we moved in) I noticed water on the garage floor. We called the contractor to get it fixed and he & his plumber blamed in on our hard water (40+ grains) and the cheap Mexican copper they were forced to use at that time. Now we only use it when we have overnight guests to get hot water to the guest bath in a reasonable time. YMMV

Another option would be to use a tankless water heater under your sink.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#4

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

Yonak

We've had it since our house was built 10 years ago. The pump runs constantly and we've never had a problem. I really appreciate having hot water out of the faucet quickly.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#5

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

John in NM

We had one for a couple years before the pump shut off circuit failed.

The way it worked was to hit the button and it would run until a thermocouple detected hot water. Once it failed it would just run all the time ($$$$).

I looked for spares once, but didn't find any on the internet. I suspect that it is not a very common item. I would repair the thing if it were easy, because it was nice to have. I certainly would not buy it again though, it was around $250 also, not worth the money for 2 years of use.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

Clint Searl

We have it in our place in NM. Only use it while we're there, and the pump is connected through a plug-in timer set for the times usually needed.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#7

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

Larry in NW Ohio

A small tankless water heater would be the way I would go if it were me. But you must watch that you get a heater that has a thermostat that will heat the water from the house water heater to a certain temp that you want or else the tankless heater will be trying to heat the water that is already heated by the house water heater and that may burn the tankless one out. There are heaters that can do it. It`s been quite awhile since I looked into them, and I am looking know, because I want to do that. If I find any I`ll let you know if your interested. Larry

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#8

Re: Recirulating hot water

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It's usually a 2-pipe system and the key to efficient use is well insulated hot water piping. Also cuts down on the constant noise of recirculating water. IIRC, the water supply needs to be properly filtered and neutralized, if not softened. Sediment is abrasive and the pipes will "wear" especially at the fittings. I helped my FIL do one and he used only cast fittings because the "wrought" copper was only equivalent to type M which would not hold up to the continual flow. This may (or may not) still be an issue in the world of plastic pipe.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#9

The retro fit method

John in NM

Is to pump the tepid/cold water from the hot line back into the cold line. This kind of set up shouldn't run full time obviously, since that would make the cold water hot. The three pipe system you describe would be the kind you can run full time.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#10

When Cold's Warm

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Which is exactly what's being described by using the cold supply to return unused hot to the heater. If I want cold water, I expect "instantaneous" cold from the cold side.

Why would I want to have to wait 2 gals worth of water to purge the tepid water out of the cold line to get cold?

Quick Answer: I won't. Especially when I use a well/septic system that means I essentially recycle 98% of the water I use beck into the aquifer?

In my view, the 2-pipe system is the only thing that makes sense. When I replumbed my house, I debated putting in a 2-pipe system on the hot side. Given the length of runs required [meaning the volume of tepid/cool water to run to get hot] I decided it wasn't worth the cost of pipe and work to properly plumb the system.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#11

Re: When Cold's Warm

John in NM

Given how quick the system failed on us, I'm glad I didn't do the three pipe system either :D

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

My sis and BIL put in some aftermarket, under-sink recirculator, named something like Turbolator or some other Popeil-esque name. They live in a ranch house, on a slab, with a long run to the kitchen. I noticed the door bell button (used to activate the system) was still on the sink base cabinet, but I think they gave up on the system pretty quickly due to leaks in the unit. I meant to ask them about it when I was down there for Turkey Day, but forgot. On the upside, they were one of the first ones I knew of to put in a tankless water heater (a Rinnai), which is really nice when my whole family does descend on their place for Turkey Day. There ends up being 12 of us in the house; Mom and Dad retire to a hotel at night, I think in part to preserve what little sanity they have left.

Jason

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#13

Here's how I did it & it's better than a pump

robbcarr

I put one of those small 3 gallon under cabinet water heaters at the kitchen sink. It's plumbed in the hot water line and runs off 120v. This gives you the instant hot water you want, but it won't supply all your needs, but by the time the cold water in the line pushes out and mixes with the hot water in the tank the hot water from the main tank has already reach the sink. As best I can figure it cost about $3 extra a month on the electric bill to run this water heater.... and FYI I cook and use hot water at the kitchen sink a lot, plus it also feeds the dishwasher.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#14

This is why I come to Wood Central....

Barry Irby

As a home inspector I know or should know a thing or two about this.

One of the things I "know" is that you are not supposed to cook with or drink the water out of the hot water heater. It is possible there are bacteria in the tank. As a cook I don't use the hot water. I start with cold water and heat it on the stove.

(I am asked fairly often what to do about the rotten egg smell in the hot water. There is a bacteria that causes it in the water heater)

While considering the recirculating thing it some how did not occur to me that I would be flushing the water out of the water heater and then drinking it or cooking with it out of the cold line used for recirculating.

It would be very difficult for me to run an independent return line.

I had forgotten that 120 volt water heaters were available. I had dismissed the idea of putting a water heater under the sink because it would be as difficult to get a 240 volt circuit there as it would be to run a return line.

I will be investigating installing a small water heater under the sink and hooking into the exiting 120 volt line. I wonder if a timer on it would be worth while or just additional complexity?

Thanks for all the help.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#15

Re: This is why I come to Wood Central....

Lars Parrington

This idea of not drinking hot water from the water heater is new to me, can you elaborate? All I've ever heard of is Legionella, which could only be a problem if you don't set your water heater thermostat high enough, and it only contracted by breathing (the hot vapors i assume), not by drinking the water.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#16

Re: This is why I come to Wood Central....

John in NM

That is my understanding as well. We keep the thermostat's set high, over 140 F, so I've never been terribly concerned about it. From what I've read, the problem really showed up when the conventional wisdom advised turning the temp down to 120 F to avoid scalding. Can't win for losing I guess :D

I don't avoid the hot tap water in cooking because I'm usually using it to boil pasta :D The water here is full of gypsum and salt, so we typically use bottled for drinking or consumable cooking.

I've heard of the H2S odor problem before but never experienced it. I suspect that the higher temps prevent that as well, but another popular cure is to use special anodes instead. Apparently it's less of a problem with zinc alloy instead of magnesium alloy anodes. I've also heard of peroxide treatments that should work, though that's enough of a chore that people won't likely do them often enough to solve the problem.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#17

You might find this on topic

Gary Smyth

January 29, 2008, Health Section, New York Times, by: A. O'conner

Subject: Never use hot water from tap for cooking and drinking

"The claim has the ring of a myth. But environmental scientists say it is real.

The reason is that hot water dissolves contaminants more quickly than cold water, and many pipes in homes contain lead that can leach into water. And lead can damage the brain and nervous system, especially in young children.

Lead is rarely found in source water, but can enter it through corroded plumbing. The Environmental Protection Agency says that older homes are more likely to have lead pipes and fixtures, but that even newer plumbing advertised as “lead-free” can still contain as much as 8 percent lead. A study published in The Journal of Environmental Health in 2002 found that tap water represented 14 to 20 percent of total lead exposure.

Scientists emphasize that the risk is small. But to minimize it, the E.P.A. says cold tap water should always be used for preparing baby formula, cooking and drinking. It also warns that boiling water does not remove lead but can actually increase its concentration. More information is at www.epa.gov/lead or (800) 424-5323 (LEAD)."

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#18

No dog in this fight....but by the way

Gary Smyth

In Europe because there are many more old homes than in the U.S. Pex or similar solderless fittings are used and sometimes required owing to old lead and ceramic plumbing.

From Pex literature:

• PEX plumbing installations require fewer fittings than rigid piping. The flexible tubing can turn 90 degree corners without the need for elbow fittings, and PEX tubing unrolled from spools can be installed in long runs without the need for coupling fittings.

• Attaching PEX tube to fittings does not require soldering, and so eliminates the health hazards involved with lead-based solder and acid fluxes; PEX is also safer to install since a torch is not needed to make connections..

• PEX resists the scale build-up common with copper pipe, and does not pit or corrode when exposed to acidic water.

• PEX is much more resistant to freeze-breakage than copper or rigid plastic pipe.

• PEX tubing does not transfer heat as readily as copper, and so conserves energy.

Water flows more quietly through PEX tube, and the characteristic "water hammer" noise of copper pipe systems is virtually eliminated.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#19

Re: HUH?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Barry, I am 73 years old, did hold a Indiana Contractors Plumbing license and plumbed residential and commercial for many years. Your comment on dangerous Bacteria in a Water heater is the first I have ever heard. Yes, sulfate-reducing anaerobic bacteria are in many water sources (actually in the entire well so in both cold and hot water). It is entirely harmless to humans. Even though it cannot be detected by odor most well water contains a minuscule amount of sulfur.

REF: http://safewater.supportportal.com/link/portal/23002/23015/Article/16004/What-are-the-health-effects-related-to-sulfur-reducing-bacteria-present-in-drinking-water).

The "odor" you are referring too, is actually caused by erosion of the magnesium Anode which protects the water tank from corrosion. This erosion can cause increased activity of the harmless bacteria. Changing the anode to a higher metal on the Noble metal scale like Aluminum will normally eliminate the issue (but may not protect the tank when using "soft" water) or by removing the Anode ~ however both of these actions will void manufacturer's warranty and may shorten tank life. Also as the Aluminum anode adds aluminum to the water, it is recommended that it not be consumed. (although we still boil water and cook in aluminum pots and pans). Another "cure" for the odor issue is to install a "Powered anode" a term for impressed-current anode — these are used by manufactures to protect larger commercial units and are very effective in both tank erosion protection and curing the "rotten egg" odor.

As an aside another bacteria which is prevalent in many water systems is "Iron Bacteria", again it is harmless to humans, but can cause some taste issues as well as iron stains. If your pipes contain this bacterial you normally will see a "slime" and strings of red material in your toilet storage tank! If you are on a private well, it can be mitigated by "shooting" the well with concentrated chlorine bleach. I have done this successfully several times but would recommend you contact a plumber to do the procedure. Municipalities can have this issue with older iron pipes ~ they can increase the chlorine in the water to aid in reducing the problem (and may have other solutions I am not aware of at this time).

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#20

That one is an actual serious problem...

John in NM

No easy fix like the bacteria concerns.

The water temp is not the cause, however, it is the choice of chemicals used in purification of municipal supplies. The EPA was concerned about the health effects of using chlorine to treat municipal water, so they required the switch to chloramine - and that change caused elevated lead levels due to reaction with legacy lead products in municipal supply lines as well as leaking copper pipes in homes.

This is the conclusion of a 2003 study by Marc Edwards, a professor of civil engineering who was looking into the mystery of pinhole leaks in household copper pipe. The elevated lead in municipal water supplies was a surprise in his work, but is, I think, a more important finding than the question he initially intended to pursue.

It is important to note that the lead is thought to come from municipal supply lines that pre-date the 1986 ban on lead products in plumbing. There are plenty of houses old enough to also have legacy lead in their pipes, but the exposure to municipal supply sources is much more likely and important to understand because there can be elevated lead levels even in new construction.

I don't agree with the implication that this has much to do with water temperature, but I've not the chemical expertise to make such a claim. Anyone thinking it better to use cold water for cooking are by all means welcome to continue doing so.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#21

I like pex a lot...

John in NM

But I don't care for the industry habit of using small diameters in order to avoid elbows and other fittings. The logic, as near as I can deduce, is that since everyone has to use low flow fixtures, they can get away with low volume piping and use 3/8 or 1/4 which is flexible enough to use without the typical elbows and stuff.

In practice, I've found that I notice the difference in reduced pressure at the tap.

The one time I used pex I used it as if it were rigid pipe for the most part - 1/2" minimum and elbows where necessary. That worked great, couldn't be happier with the stuff :D

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#22

Wow, never know will provoke a long string.

Barry Irby

and additional good information.

My statement about not using the water from the water heater came from training in the dimly remembered past.

There are reports of the fittings for pex failing due to the Chloramine (I think) in the water. The fittings were made in China. If I recall, they had too much zinc in the brass.

I have been reading on the under sink water heaters and am disappointed at the failure rate. Since my kitchen is up stairs, I am reluctant to use a heater that appears to be poorly made with a short life expectancy.

(I tend to read the bad reviews. The 5 star ones tend be something like "I got this last week and its great". The low rated ones tend to be something like "This POS started leaking after a year.")

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#23

Re: Wow, never know will provoke a long string.

William Duffield

I agree, Barry. Five-star reviews are almost useless. I get a lot more useful information from one- and two-star reviews, but tempered by the ratio of good reviews to bad reviews. I would be very, very stingy with giving five stars, because I can even find minor shortcomings in the high-end tools I've bought and use from the likes of Veritas, Lie-Nielsen, Jess-Em, Festool, SawStop, etc.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#24

Yet another angle

Jesse Cloud

Apart from fears of bacteria or contamination, there are often good culinary reasons for using cold water.

First among them is that when you want to cook something by boiling it, unless it is very thin - like pasta, the food will cook more evenly if you heat the water with the food in it. I always start with cold water for boiling potatoes and eggs, for instance.

Re: Anyone have recirulating (instant) hot water

#25

The Upstairs Kitchen Solutions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Sacrifice a bit of under-counter cabinet space and put in a 30 gal. "standard" heater. Provided you have room in the load center, running a 240 line ain't that big a deal; way easier than pushing pipe. Other option (if the kitchen is on the "top" floor) is to put the heater in the attic above the sink and DW.