Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

LN versus Sjoberg work benches

Posts

LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#1

LN versus Sjoberg work benches

cameron

I've re-poured my shop floor, rebuilt the entrance (150 years, poor workmanship at some point converting from detached kitchen to garage and termites left a mess) and have reconfigured my tool layout and dust collection. Now I am eyeing the plywood cabinet/workbench that I cobbled together 13 years ago out of mostly scrap and wondering if it might be time to buy a nice bench. I mostly use power tools to support working on my 150 year old house, building cabinets and furniture but do find that I am often struggling to clamp up workpieces on my frankenbench. Travel requirements for my job leave me with precious little time to do my project, much less make one of these benches from scratch so I am considering buying one, although the price tags and shipping are sobering. I see that Woodcraft has the Sjoberg Elites with a "free" storage cabinet this month but I've seen some mixed feelings on them searching the web reviews. LN seems to have a nice bench but it's 50% more expensive than the Sjoberg (~$3.1k LN with shipping vs ~$2.2K for Elite 2000.) I've only run across one thread that directly compared the 2 benches and it wasn't the exact current model that LN is selling... I'm sure there are a million opinions here but any guidance would be appreciated, espicially with the hefty price tag. Thanks

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#2

some things to think about

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. You will adapt your work habits to the capability of the bench.

2. If time is more important than tradition, a quick action vice is a must.

3. Will you sit at the bench? Personally I could not tolerate one that didn't have a place to put my feet. Others like the handiness of cabinetry under the bench. Good if you don't need a place to put your feet.

4. A large top overhang and a collection of "F" style clamps will enable you to affix anything to the bench. I don't have a tail vice and seldom use my dog holes (see point #1)

5. A trough or not. Do you want flat acreage on the bench or a place to accumulate debris? The trough- I suppose it must have a useful purpose but I have not discovered it.

6. If you can afford the room and cost, bigger and heavier is better. If the bench is large enough you can install a machinist vice on one corner-handy for around the house jobs.

7. It is quick to mortise a table frame together- 4 legs and a stretcher. I did one for son-in-law in a day. Then buy or build a top to sit on it, buy a Record quick action vice to attach and you will have a versatile bench to do anything on. Alternatively you might hire a local shop to make the frame for the cost of shipping a bench. Maybe someone in a local WW club would build one for you.

8. Attend a Woodworking show with your pick up truck and buy one from a vendor at the end of the show.

9. Troll Craig's list for a while and you might get lucky.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#3

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

Jason in OC

I share your time constraints in the "build vs buy" decision, but when the price is north of 2k I'd think hard about freeing up the time. There are several "build in a weekend using construction lumber" bench designs out there. The most recent I've seen was here:

http://blog.lostartpress.com/2014/09/08/download-free-plans-for-the-knockdown-nicholson-workbench/

Searching Popular Woodworking or Fine Woodworking should yield a few others.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#4

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

Hank Knight

I don't have either a Sjoberg or a LN bench, but I've looked at both closely. My impression is that, while the Sjoberg is well constructed, it is something of a lightweight compared to the LN bench. The LN doesn't have all the frills that the Sjoberg has, but it is a very robust, simple bench. The LN hardware is heavier and the bench is made of heavier stock. If it were me, I'd spring the extra bucks for the LN. If you're set on an under-bench cabinet for storage, it would be pretty easy to build one for the LN bench. Having said all that, I think either bench would serve you well and your children after you.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#5

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

Jesse Cloud

Bill pretty much nailed it above.

One additional point would be to think about workbench height. If you are short or tall, you would probably prefer a different height from what they usually sell. Also, if you spend a lot of time pushing hand planes, a lower bench may be more ergonomic. Another reason to explore having someone local make it for you.

I used to have a Sjoberg, it seemed a little lightweight. I made my own - and it was a big job. Including HW and a purchased top, about $1K in materials and about 8 years ago. I put in a tool trough and now I regret it. To answer Bill's question - the purpose of a tool trough is to hide your tools under a bunch of other stuff you are too lazy to clean up. ;) ;)

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#6

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

roger lance

Cameron.....Without a doubt, the LN is the better bench. But you are an exceptional candidate for building your own.....you've built one in the past......you've worked on it for years......you know that bench's shortcomings and know what features you like, need, want etc. A well made bench can be built for very reasonable cost.....may not be the most beautiful.....but could be the more functional and useful to you.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#7

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

Joe Mohnike

Look at your shopbuilt bench again. Determine the features you use the most, what you would like to add and get rid of. Then look at the new ones, other than brite, shiney and new, are they that much different and what do they have and not have that your current one has. You built your bench for your needs and the type of work you do. I saw one person buy an new high dollar bench, pushed his old one out of the shop, yes the new one was pretty and seemed as if it was what he needed. But with in 4 months he drug the old one back into the shop, cut the legs off 3" removed the top from the new one and attached it to his old one. You may only need to modify and clean up your old one.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#8

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

William Duffield

The Sjöbergs are made from European beech. IMHO, sugar maple is a much better choice, because it's much less prone to splintering from blunt trauma. It's also made in the USA and Canada.

The dog holes in the Sjöbergs are a non-standard size. You can't use a Gramercy holdfast or any of the Lee Valley/Veritas accessories with them. Their steel dogs are good for destroying your edge tools.

The vises on the Sjöbergs are slow, very prone to racking, and they don't hold your work securely. I haven't used the vise on the L-N, so I can't compare it, but I strongly support Bill's recommendation of using an old made-in-England Record quick release vise, if you can find one.

The joinery on the Sjöbergs base is of insufficient strength and rigidity (i.e., wimpy).

I've worked without a tail vise for many years. Although I think I would find one convenient, a planing stop with a notched batten and holdfast are sufficient, efficient and inexpensive. If you think you want a tail vise, you should seriously consider the Benchcrafted wagon vise. For more info on the batten: http://www.popularwoodworking.com/workbenches/schwarz-workbenches/notched-batten-great-workbench-trick

The construction of the Sjöberg's tool storage is better than IKEA kitchen cabinets, but not by much.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#9

No help with comparison

Gary Smyth

but I would ask what type of work you intend to do? I confess I'm not a fan of European style workbenches --I would be too rough on them. If I had a fancy workbench, to be honest, I'd be afraid to marr it up/damage it and would have to have some other vice/clamp surface to hammer on, glue on, layout on, exacto knife on, stain on, and work on non woodworking stuff on like the occasional auto/lawn tractor part, motor, plumbing, sawing metal, lubricate, etc. To me a workbench is too valuable to spend over $1K on.

If you do hand work always, my writing is moot, but if not.......

If your mind is set on something esthetically pleasing for your revamped location you could tell any cabinet shop what you want and have one made for the same money or less. You can probably get some storage underneath to boot. It might not have the cache of the show European bench but oh my, it will do the same work and you won't be afraid to abuse it a little.

20 Years ago I built a completely walk around sandwich type top with overhangs on all four sides for clamps and enough thickness to hang Record quick release end and side vices. I couldn't afford a wood butcher block type top so I opted for a 3/4" particle board top. Unknowingly it was the best of all alternatives for me. I can hammer into it, paint on it and never worry about about the occasional gouge (filled in with bondo), Every five years or so I peel off the top and put in a new one, trim it to fit, and I'm good to go. I don't have to remove the vices either. I also have my bench on casters. The top alone (without underneath storage tools) is over 100 lbs -- it does not move unless I want it to. My work tasks may not be the same as yours but perhaps you will consider something other than the European bench.

By the way, if not mentioned earlier, Scott Landis "Workbench Book" may help you decide.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#10

Economically built.....

roger lance

Last spring, I made a reloading bench using 2X4s and 2X6s from the borg.....made a very sturdy base.....at a very small cost. Design a top to fit your needs....hard maple would be my recommendation.....well worth the time and trouble....


Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#11

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

Joe shelton

Cam, I have the Sjoberg 2500, and like it a lot. Still, there are specific reasons I own this bench instead of one from LN. When I bought it, four years ago, it cost $400 less than LN, and was available with free shipping. Now it costs the same as LN's bench, and may incur shipping costs, depending on source. Finally, the only LN I actually got my hands on had an end vise whose action was very balky, and that put me off. (LN now uses a different front vise; I don't expect that there is any real problem with the LN vises.)

For me, there are no problems with its weight (heavy as a Liberals tax burden) or its hardware. WilDuff has commented on holdfasts and dogs, and I agree with him to an extent. The holes are too big for my regular holdfasts, but my Sjoberg holdfast is superb for holding power. My dogs, both steel and aluminum, are excellent and have not yet damaged anything I've used them with. My vises do not deflect any that I can see. I'm certain that they tend less to racking than does my Record 53. As for brutal assaults, do that sort of thing on that new concrete of yours, and then get back to the bench.

And if you're getting back to either the LN or the Sjoberg, you'll be going to a good bench, I think. As for me, I'm very glad to have the big swede around. You never know when a F/A 18 will need to abort right and land short...

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#12

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

don stephan

A tail vise and row of dog holes makes random orbit sanding of pieces much faster and easier (like it does for using hand planes and card scrapers, of course). After eyeing for decades Frank Klaus' bench in the Workbench Book and wondering why anyone would want such an atypical design I finally built one and can't imagine woodworking without it.

I chose ash, as it was much cheaper than hard maple. But the thickest ash available was 8/4 and I spent hours making thicker members. So I recommend maple to people now, as my lumber supplier stocks 12/4 and maybe 16/4.

But for lots of people a framework of 2x4's and 2x6's topped with a double layer of 3/4 mdf meets all their needs, as already mentioned.

Good luck.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#13

As an alternative *LINK*

dIZD

You could look into one of these.


http://americanworkbench.com

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#14

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

Lars Parrington

I second the tail vise recomendation. I use my wagon vise at least twice as much as my face vise. It's great for all kinds of hand tool work, but it's also fantastic for sanding and routing.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#15

Re: A bench is just a beam on horses, with work ho

TomD

A bench is a really simple device, but as with 7 dollar cups of coffee, we have made it a whole lot more complicated than it needs to be. So for instance, which is better a bench with a tool troth, or one with a solid top. Fair question, but the answer when you don't have a bench is "either".

The big take away is quality and capacity really mater. A lot of the commercial benches fall short, or they are extremely expensive. There are expedient options that are really good. Put your money into capacity and quality, not something that looks like a bench, but may fall short.

A bench is just a beam on horses, with work holding. Some of them never get much beyond that, others look way fancier, but under the glitz that is what they are. If you have a budget that could top out at 3K, I would buy good parts, to get you up and running. So something like this:

Base:

Buy and adjustabench. Should be resellable if you ever move onto a fancy wood base of your dreams. One of the difficulties of getting a perfect bench is getting the right height, particularly if you use power tools most of the time. Maybe you will move gradually to hand tools, as many have. With an adjustabench you have the best of both world.

Or build a simple 2x base, there are ones you can throw together in minutes that are super rigid. Get the perfect one later, once you sort out your needs.

Top/beam:

Best is a really large piece of appropriate solid wood, can even be wetish. You know whether you have any chance of getting such a thing.

There are various laminated tops, I like at least 4 inches, but people do fine with 2 inches. Many thick benches are really framed tops of 1-1.5 inches. You can buy one ready made from LV and many others.

While it probably isn't worth bringing up, (I have all the types in my shop), one I use a lot is made of plywood in a torsion construction. It is and stays dead flat, and working on it is as satisfactory as any of my wooden benches, with the exception of locating structure where you could put a lot of vises and dogs, but if you want to go that route it is better than you might think.

Vises.

There are a lot of great options but for starters, a Record type vise, the largest you can get, with quick release, for both the face and tail is a great way to go. This is another resale item you probably won't drop a lot on if you side-grade later on. Emmert is a good bet also. I love my Tucker, but LV dropped them a long time ago. You can add round dogs and hold downs as you need them

For a lot less than 1K, you could get a real tool that would be pro quality and not just some wannabe thing. I assume the options you mention require minor assembly, and the parts approach would probably be no worse, or take much longer.

http://www.adjustabench.com/ Prices have about doubled, but still within your budget.

If you buy one of the mentioned benches they may or not be classic construction. As a power tool guy, you could buy a large Domino tenon machine (not that one needs one for a base), and bang a classic looking bench together in a really short time. That is where I would put my money.

My advice might be different if you wanted the experience of spending 100 hours to make one. What would remain the same would be the idea of going about it as a kit, or parts approach. One can make a masterpiece out of the gate, as many people have, but you can't really know what is best for you just because some parts company came up with a pompous plan. It takes time to get the details right for you.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#16

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

cameron

You guys are making this hard for me... 8-) Thanks for all the advice. I think I'll take a little longer to plan this thing out, it's not like I have an emergency need to get a bench and $3k is a good amount of money, especially when my old 12.5" delta planer is starting to show it's age. I've thought about making something in the past out of the retail butcher block but have talked my self out of that due to the 1.5" thickness. There is a ton of lumber available around me (WV) but finding anything over 4/4 is tough (had to drive 3 hours to get my 8/4 QS white oak for the carriage house doors I'm making and it wasn't cheap.) I don't know all the details of what I would really like to end up with in a bench but I can say that a plywood top on a run of cabinets against the wall is not ideal and almost anything would be an improvement when it comes to actually working on it. One thing that I would like to be able to do with a bench is part it up against my table saw and use it as an outfeed table. Maybe I'll even get lucky and find something used but I'm not going to hold my breath. I certainly don't fear making the base (other than the time spent on it that could be going to my million other projects) but getting the 16/4+ lumber, gluing and flattening is going to be a serious commitment (and I don't have a plane that I'd even try to attempt this with currently). A lot to think about...

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#17

thickness is not essential

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is the weight that is important, not thickness. In the vice area you can build up the thickness as needed. I built a bench for son in law. the top is almost two inches thick. It is heavy enough. I glued up the legs, an easy task.

I flattened planks for the top on the jointer and then glued up the top one board at a time to get perfect alignment. The result was flat enough.


Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#18

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

Hank Knight

Cameron,

I couldn't get my head around laminating a bench top in my small shop, so I ordered a 3" thick, unfinished maple slab from Bally Block. I think 3" laminations are available on their web site, but they come finished and with whatever edge treatment you equestrian. They will send an unfinished one to you with square edges on request. I added 4" thick dog hole strips to both sides to mine and end caps. I couldn't be happier. It's a lot easier than gluing up your own maple top.

Hank

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#19

Re: Some turthiness

TomD

With what they want for some of these pre-glued tops it is often cheaper to order the lamed top.

One thing about thickness is that it plays heavily into the stuff you use. For instance the bench thickness can get too thick for your vises; Hold downs work best with the table top thickness they were designed for, though they are fairly easy to tweak. Other than the metal dogs that are square, most of the gear today seems designed for thinner tops. For instance when I designed a vise jaw for my bench that was something like 8 inches tall, I was using LV hardware, and had to insert bolts into stepped down holes so that I could raise the short little dogs they make. Also you are going to design the top so the area where you pound on it is over the legs so you have essentially 36 inches, or whatever, of wood there. Some vises work as well or better with thick tops. L vises as an example, or wooden screw vises if they bury in the top.

All that said, a heavier top looks better, is in some regards more stable (once it has settled in), and I can't think of any advantage to a thin top all else being equal.

So in order when planing:

1) think about the guy who is working at the bench and the projects he will be working on;

2) decide on the gear that will be used to hold the work for the worker;

3) design the bench top to suit the worker, work, and holding gear

4) design the base to accommodate the above.

As far as I can tell, the projects often get built the other way around. It makes superficial sense to design and build the base first (though I think the top is normally a better choice), and then the top goes on, and then the hardware is bought. All the wrong way around. Today with the popularity of the Bencraft stuff probably some people are starting at 2, but few people really start at 1, particularly because it normally requires some experience working at a variety of similar benches, first.

Re: LN versus Sjoberg work benches

#20

Re: Some truthiness

TomD

OK, that probably was a load of "turthiness"...