Re: A bench is just a beam on horses, with work ho
TomD
A bench is a really simple device, but as with 7 dollar cups of coffee, we have made it a whole lot more complicated than it needs to be. So for instance, which is better a bench with a tool troth, or one with a solid top. Fair question, but the answer when you don't have a bench is "either".
The big take away is quality and capacity really mater. A lot of the commercial benches fall short, or they are extremely expensive. There are expedient options that are really good. Put your money into capacity and quality, not something that looks like a bench, but may fall short.
A bench is just a beam on horses, with work holding. Some of them never get much beyond that, others look way fancier, but under the glitz that is what they are. If you have a budget that could top out at 3K, I would buy good parts, to get you up and running. So something like this:
Base:
Buy and adjustabench. Should be resellable if you ever move onto a fancy wood base of your dreams. One of the difficulties of getting a perfect bench is getting the right height, particularly if you use power tools most of the time. Maybe you will move gradually to hand tools, as many have. With an adjustabench you have the best of both world.
Or build a simple 2x base, there are ones you can throw together in minutes that are super rigid. Get the perfect one later, once you sort out your needs.
Top/beam:
Best is a really large piece of appropriate solid wood, can even be wetish. You know whether you have any chance of getting such a thing.
There are various laminated tops, I like at least 4 inches, but people do fine with 2 inches. Many thick benches are really framed tops of 1-1.5 inches. You can buy one ready made from LV and many others.
While it probably isn't worth bringing up, (I have all the types in my shop), one I use a lot is made of plywood in a torsion construction. It is and stays dead flat, and working on it is as satisfactory as any of my wooden benches, with the exception of locating structure where you could put a lot of vises and dogs, but if you want to go that route it is better than you might think.
Vises.
There are a lot of great options but for starters, a Record type vise, the largest you can get, with quick release, for both the face and tail is a great way to go. This is another resale item you probably won't drop a lot on if you side-grade later on. Emmert is a good bet also. I love my Tucker, but LV dropped them a long time ago. You can add round dogs and hold downs as you need them
For a lot less than 1K, you could get a real tool that would be pro quality and not just some wannabe thing. I assume the options you mention require minor assembly, and the parts approach would probably be no worse, or take much longer.
http://www.adjustabench.com/ Prices have about doubled, but still within your budget.
If you buy one of the mentioned benches they may or not be classic construction. As a power tool guy, you could buy a large Domino tenon machine (not that one needs one for a base), and bang a classic looking bench together in a really short time. That is where I would put my money.
My advice might be different if you wanted the experience of spending 100 hours to make one. What would remain the same would be the idea of going about it as a kit, or parts approach. One can make a masterpiece out of the gate, as many people have, but you can't really know what is best for you just because some parts company came up with a pompous plan. It takes time to get the details right for you.