Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

square or round dog holes?

Posts

square or round dog holes?

#1

square or round dog holes?

robert henderson

I'm planning on building a workbench for hand tool work in the coming year.

I'd like to ask you folks your for opinions on which is better: round or square dog holes (with reasons please). I just haven't had enough experience using a good workbench to judge the issue for myself.

thanks

Re: square or round dog holes?

#2

Re: square or round dog holes?

BrianMonumentCO

If you don't already have it you should get a copy of Scot Landis The workbench book.

My take on round vs square is that if you do work that is odd in shape the round dogs will help grip better.

It appears to me from all the pix, books etc that most if not all traditional benches have square (rectangular) dog holes and dogs.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#3

Re: square or round dog holes?

Jim Pugh

I made a bench a good many years ago now using the Workbench Book by Scot Landis. Went to the trouble to make the square holes - which are slanted - and have noticed since that almost all of the neat hold downs and other bench accessories are made for round holes. You might want to check a few catalogs to see what is available that appeals to you.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#4

Re: square or round dog holes?

David Churnega

I am about to cut mine. This will be another bench/location. Hold-downs, in my case, Gramercy, made the decision easier. Also, flat faces can easily be cut into each round peg to get the benefit of the squares.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#5

Re: square or round dog holes?

Richard McComas

I was just thinking what my Festool MFT would be like with square dog holes.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#6

Re: square or round dog holes?

John Lucas

I put round holes in my bench many years ago It was already solid so it was simply easier I like being able to use the round accessories however I frequently use a holdfast a d it has elongated the holes and now I have to fix them. We had a discussion about how to fix them Unfortunately a lot of things happened in my life recently so I still haven't fixed them. On rare occasions I think square hoes might have an advantage but I've been quite happy with my round pegs.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#7

Best of Both Worlds

Hank Knight

My bench has square dog holes along both edges for clamping with the end vise. It has two rows of round holes that run the length of the bench. The round holes are placed so my hold downs reach the edges of the bench. They are about 10" apart and staggered so I can get pretty complete coverage of the bench surface with hold downs. They allow for the use of other modern bench appliances, one of which is a goose neck LED lamp that I can move around to suit my work. The light is a recent addition that I now find indespensable.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#8

Re: square or round dog holes?

roger lance

Hardly anyone here has had enough experience actually USING a workbench, much less has adequate experience with both round and square dogs and, on top of that, for hand tool work to give an honest impartial evaluation and answer to your question.

Truth is both will work.....both do work.....and very few will actually push their bench to the limits of its capacity or have work demands that exceed the ability of either dog to handle the task at hand.

So, its really up to you.....are you more a traditionalist or more avant-garde ??

Re: square or round dog holes?

#9

Re: square or round dog holes?

William Duffield

You have to realize that the traditional workbenches with square dog holes (not the reproductions of these benches documented in and inspired by The Workbench Book) were built and used by joyners. By and large, these were NOT turners, they didn't have a lathe or a turner in the shop, and they couldn't go down to the local Borg and buy some 3/4" dowel stock. For them, it was much easier to make a new dog with a saw than with a lathe, and dogs did wear out, and suffered abuse.

Other than interpreting old ways of working, in the modern shop, there are no advantages to square dogs and dog holes.

They are much less versatile, and you can't go out and buy one to fit the custom dog holes in your bench.

As others have mentioned, holdfasts don't fit them. You have to drill round holes in your benchtop anyway to use them. (Holdfasts are not only useful in the legs and apron of your bench.) You will probably want to drill round holes for other accessories, like a work light, or the myriad clever accessories offered by Lee Valley.

There are pundits on other fora who will tell you round dogs are a disadvantage because they "will turn on you." Don't believe them; That's an advantage, in many ways. To keep stock from turning, all you need is two dogs and intelligent placement of your stock in relation to the dogs. If you want to go even more primitive than a row of dog holes and a tail vise, and want to work against a planing stop only (ref. cover of latest L-V woodworking catalog), they invented the solution to that problem at least five centuries ago. It's something called a Dürer Stick or a reglet, and it's a lot less complicated to make than a tail vise and square dogs. It is easily replaced if broken, and if not abused can also serve as a ruler, a straight edge, or one of a pair of winding sticks.

http://blog.lostartpress.com/2013/11/29/the-dawn-of-the-durer-stick/

Re: square or round dog holes?

#10

Curious how you made this assumption?

Dick Coers

"Hardly anyone here has had enough experience actually USING a workbench, much less has adequate experience with both round and square dogs and, on top of that, for hand tool work to give an honest impartial evaluation and answer to your question."

A lot of guys here, hard to imagine that hardly anyone has enough experience. Built my bench about 35 years ago. I earned a living on that bench for 8 years in the late 80s and 90s when I owned and operated a custom woodworking business. After that it was on the cover of Woodworkers Journal when I worked there. Still gets used everyday now that I am retired. So for one that has enough experience, I have square holes. There weren't many of the fancy bench accessories when I built it. I did install a record hold fast on one end. It's the style that has a steel collar that mounts in the bench top and has a threaded style tightening device on the top of the holdfast. Can't see many advantages to either dog style now.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#11

Re: square or round dog holes?

David Churnega

An interesting response. Saw another you tube video extolling the virtues of having and making a long straight edge. It too had ends that could be called in for other purposes.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#12

Re: Naw, it's just a stick…

William Duffield

;) …until you find it over and over again in medieval illustrations.

Something even deeper to think about:

http://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/world-what-it-today-because-these-six-innovations-180952871/?utm_source=smithsoniantopic&no-ist

I especially like his thought, to "take up a bunch of hobbies."

Re: square or round dog holes?

#13

Mine are round

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Works for me. Accommodates hold fasts. Easy to make things that stick in holes from dowels and blocks. Many Lee Valley fixtures will fit in round holes. It is easy to drill additional ones. I can't imagine a reason to favor square.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#14

Re: Curious how you made this assumption?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I'm standing behind Dick on this issue. I've built some pretty nice furniture on benches with round dog holes, benches with rectangular dog holes and even on benches with no dog holes. The bench with square dog holes was German, built around 1830, and needed a lot of restoration to be useable at all. The others I built myself. I've even built one table running back and forth between the bench with O dog holes and the one with 0 dog holes. You learn to use whatever is available and just figure out strategies to overcome its difficulties. Most of these strategies I have used have involved hand screws.

Re: square or round dog holes?

#15

Re: square or round dog holes?

robert henderson

Thank you all! Given the modern availability of accessories that fit round holes I've decided to go with round holes.

Viva WoodCentral!

Re: square or round dog holes?

#16

Re: Contrary point of view.

TomD

I don't think you will be disappointed, though I have to say I have happily worked wood for 40+ years, and don't see the need for any of that stuff, it is mostly just gimmicks, or for that mater stuff you can add to a far smaller number of holes than having the whole dog system in the round.

A few points in favour of square holes:

1) you can install them with a saw and chisel, without needing, say, a drill press. I have 3 drill presses, etc... but in the day...

2) They are angled and can be pounded down to add downhold that isn't replicated by round dogs. Why would anyone install a round vertical hole in a directional situation. The non-directional situations develop splitting forces, and are marginal.

3), you can make your own good quality wooden dogs. I don't think that round dogs that are made of wood are nice. wood dogs are easier on blades. Square dogs work even with very little retention spring to them, because the load and retention functions can be separated. The springs on the LV dogs are kinda nasty, they aren't even all that good in metal stuff like the Tucker vise. In order to rotate they don't have a flange that holds them at level, and they are generally too short. The holes wear a lot faster, and don't wear round. Possibly not great for softwood benches.

There are other reasons like they don't develop splitting forces, or rotate. Rotation is more useful than non-rotation, but they still only rotate.

You can't have the advantages of square holes without square holes, as also applies to round holes. No law saying you can't have both. I would have a hard time seeing the advantages to the LV round system on the main dog rack, if I was having both. No law against having both.

They look like a carpenter, or a cheese maker made the bench. Cabinetmaking, is not a bout whipping out the drill.