Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Curves

Posts

Re: Curves

#26

Correction: Ah!  It was early . . .

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My excuse is that it was too early for heavy duty thinking.

The amount the beam, in our case a rectangular cross section stick with a nail at each end and a finger poking at its middle deflects/bends is proportional to 1/ wxhxhxh, where w is the width of the beam and h is the height and x is a "times" sign.. So for our floor joist case the deflection is proportional to 1/2x4x4x4 in one case and 1/ 2x8x8x8 in the other case.

This result has application to bent laminations. The force to bend them into submission will be inversely proportional to the cube of their thickness. Hence, shrinking the thickness rapidly lowers the force required to bend them onto the bending form.

Re: Curves

#27

Very Interesting.....

Barry Irby

The other assumption is that the material is consistent and homogeneous. Well made steel is, or at least close enough. Wood almost never is. A really nice straight grained piece with the grain parallel to the surfaces may be close, but hard to find. This would be why spline curves are irregular and "lumpy" (a highly scientific term).

Larger timbers are seldom consistent, since almost all of them are knotty. Having been a builder and framing many houses personally, we learned they were seldom straight either. We "crowned" them, turning the convex edge up. We also sorted them so that the warp in them was fairly consistent from joist to joist, with the most crowned ones near the center of the house and the straightest ones near the ends. This way the weight caused them to straighten, rather than sag worse. The worst of them were cut into short pieces and used as headers or the band board. The really bad ones were returned.

Re: Curves

#28

Re: the problem of bent sticks - All your answers

TomD

"For better or worse a curve from a bent stick is not a straightforward geometric curve shape. It is not a segment of a circle, parabola, ellipse, catenary, etc."

A bent stick is a parabolic shape, though it may not be perfect if your stick isn't perfect. Drafting suppliers have perfect sticks.

Of course the problem is that most people bending sticks with a few nails want a curve, and that you won't get. you can tiller a stick to bend to a curve, but unless you are used to that process, why bother, it is easier to do it other ways.

"There are ways of drawing a segment of a circle using two sticks and indicating nails but I can't remember it."

You may be referring to the 3 nail method where the base and high points are described by an equilateral triangle, and then a jig is made of two stiff sticks that look like rafters on the nails. These sticks are fixed to each other and as they move across the bottom two nails, the point under the center section describes an arc. The "rafter" overhang has to be twice the width, so this method has efficiency and space issues.

Another good method: say you want a 30 inch span, and a 2 inch rise. You draw a 2 inch radius circle at the center point of the span, and segment the arc, above the line and along the diameter. What this gives you is the distance of the arc above the baseline at various positions along it. You pick these out and place them on the 30 inch span, then use splines to connect them. It can be easier to simply select the % these points are above the baseline, and use these, rather than drawing them out. So the center is 100%, 93.4%, 71.6%. 41.7%, and 0%, if you divide the baseline into quarters from the center to the ends.

Of course these days is it is easier, better, and cheaper to do it in cad, which you can do for free on any computer.

Re: Curves

#29

Re: Could you give an example?

TomD

If you double the width it is twice as stiff, and twice as strong. If you double the thickness it is 4 times as strong and 8 times as stiff. Which is where tubes and I-beams come in, you space the load bearing stuff as far apart as possible.

You need to consider part toughness, because as you can see it gains in stiffness much faster than it does in strength. So you can end up with parts that are very stiff, but not strong enough, then the stiffness ensures that the loads will be born to a point of fairly sudden failure. This is where wooden beams are nice. Then may not be efficient in the engineering sense, but the material is subtractive, making tubes is tough. So all the material tends to be left in place and you end up with some redundant strength.

Re: Curves

#30

Re: Curves

David Churnega

Do not want to hijack the post but Hodgson's Steel Square book explains how to do this in a wide variety of circumstances. On page 24 of my third edition he explains the means of creating a wooden "fence", this is likely to be the first jig ever published but I am not sure as mine is a third edition published in 1893. The book was first copyrighted in 1880. I do not understand how to use the tables inscribed on the blade as I am not a carpenter. Reprints of the book are available from LV for about $8. Buy the book read it and make the fence. This extraordinary tool has been around at least since the pyramids.


img

Re: Curves

#31

When I needed some large concentric arcs

Keith Newton

for the oak nosing for the choir loft for a church, with radii ranging from 30' to 39', while needing to carry across about 40'.

I used my 100' steel tape clamped to a porch post behind my shop, with the hook on the end attached to the edge guide of my plunge router, making it a simple but giant trammel. A hand-screw held the tape to the post without damage. And under the 1/2" mdf being cut, I had nailed down a piece of scrap OSB to the asphalt, to protect the end of the router bit.

The only other problem to solve, was to keep the edge of the tape from snagging on the rough surface of the parking lot. This was easily taken care of by laying some pvc pipe down under the tape, breaking the overall length into shorter segments.

This was quick and easy to set up, and it worked perfectly. Once I had a 8' length of each radii, I could easily duplicate it, to make longer templates.

A problem with just bending a thin strip of wood, is that the ends will always have a little straight segment 8 times the thickness of the bending direction on both ends.

Re: Curves

#32

Re: Guitars

TomD

Modern methods of guitar manufacture use radii of up to 60' to contour the front and back of the guitars. These are easily defined in computers. Two or three clicks will get you a scaled circle with a radius of 60 feet. a few more clicks will trim out a segment of 24-30 inches for the required jigs. Patterns can be printed with standard printers. In fact, a few of the jigs could be printed out on the small 3d printers that are now popular.

The first few steps of the above, the definition of arcs, are about as easy to do as to add bold or underlining to a Word document. There are big buttons in most cad programs that define circles, all one needs to do after selecting the circle button is something like entering a radius.

Re: Curves

#33

Re: Curves

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I'm not sure what you mean by large radius but I use trammels for anything up to about 18'. Ive used tramels in the past for larger but now i'm in a small shop and thats about the limit I can do without going outside. I have several 1x2's of different lengths up to 8' and for the larger stuff I just clamp a couple together to get what I need. My favorite trammels are the large starretts but the set that General sells will work just fine.

I grind one of the tramels with a slight knife edge whih means I can only use the ecentric fine adjust on the other one which I leave as a sharp point. When stricking the ark I use an extreamely light touch and slow short arcs , gradually advancing. I always strick my line on a pice of door skin Preferably maple or birch, never luan) or mdf. I rough cut on my band saw and sand to the line on my disc sander. I write the radius on it whith a sharpie and this becomes a template I can use to transfer that radius to anything I like.

Robin