Re: the problem of bent sticks - All your answers
TomD
"For better or worse a curve from a bent stick is not a straightforward geometric curve shape. It is not a segment of a circle, parabola, ellipse, catenary, etc."
A bent stick is a parabolic shape, though it may not be perfect if your stick isn't perfect. Drafting suppliers have perfect sticks.
Of course the problem is that most people bending sticks with a few nails want a curve, and that you won't get. you can tiller a stick to bend to a curve, but unless you are used to that process, why bother, it is easier to do it other ways.
"There are ways of drawing a segment of a circle using two sticks and indicating nails but I can't remember it."
You may be referring to the 3 nail method where the base and high points are described by an equilateral triangle, and then a jig is made of two stiff sticks that look like rafters on the nails. These sticks are fixed to each other and as they move across the bottom two nails, the point under the center section describes an arc. The "rafter" overhang has to be twice the width, so this method has efficiency and space issues.
Another good method: say you want a 30 inch span, and a 2 inch rise. You draw a 2 inch radius circle at the center point of the span, and segment the arc, above the line and along the diameter. What this gives you is the distance of the arc above the baseline at various positions along it. You pick these out and place them on the 30 inch span, then use splines to connect them. It can be easier to simply select the % these points are above the baseline, and use these, rather than drawing them out. So the center is 100%, 93.4%, 71.6%. 41.7%, and 0%, if you divide the baseline into quarters from the center to the ends.
Of course these days is it is easier, better, and cheaper to do it in cad, which you can do for free on any computer.