Hi, JL, in making my rocking chair rockers I use the same style for the curves, but instead of using wire or string I use a small chain link chain and mount it to a couple screws I have on each end of the board.
When more than a simple curve was called for I've drawn up what I wanted on the computer with mathematical precision and then printed the curve out on paper, using multiple sheets as needed. The paper gets fastened to 1/4" HDF with contact cement and then is cut out using the bandsaw and refined to the line with a drum sander.
I have never gotten a symmetrical curve from this approach. To compensate I use the stick bend for half the curve and then mirror image the other half.
For better or worse a curve from a bent stick is not a straightforward geometric curve shape. It is not a segment of a circle, parabola, ellipse, catenary, etc.
There are ways of drawing a segment of a circle using two sticks and indicating nails but I can't remember it.
I also use sticks to draw curves, with some caveats. As Bill says, it's hard to get a perfectly symmetrical curve, which may be a problem, or not. I've often made templates of half a curve and flipped it to mirror the other half. I've even made elliptical tables by making a template of one quarter of the ellipse, and then using it to trace and flush trim a full template.
One thing about dry bending any curve is that you should pick an even-textured species and rip it to a thickness that is just capable of making the bend you want. Too thin a stick over too great a distance will result in all kinds of weird, discontinuous shapes.
As for Bill's observation about the fact that any curve thus drawn isn't a pure geometric shape, that's true but not necessarily relevant. You can draw a nice arc with a stick and have it be continuous, attractive and appropriate to your design intent. I do concur that geometric shapes such as ellipses and circles and parabolas, even sine curves, are generally, even intrinsically, pleasing to the eye. And, conversely, curves that are not quite geometrically accurate, or that aren't rendered accurately, are easy to spot. Our eyes are very sensitive to this for some reason. But a bowed curve, drawn with a stick and carefully rendered, can be quite alright.
John, your CAD drawing method gives the most accurate and visually pleasing curves, in my opinion. For larger curves, the piecemeal method works but it's better to have one large drawing so errors are not made when piecing the sections together. If you don't have access to a friend's, a co-worker's or a local company's plotter, local office services businesses usually have plotting services.
I've had good luck attaching the drawings directly to the workpiece and skipping the secondary template .. more opportunity for error. When the same curve is required in multiple places I use the first piece cut as the template.
I draw mine up in IntelliCAD (or whatever), then add registration marks and print. I tape it all together, cut it out, then use it. If you are careful, you can run your pencil along the cut edge pretty well. If it is a template I need, I do the same thing mentioned above and fair the curve with whatever tools I need. Oh, I also print stuff out and use it to trace over using carbon paper to transfer the desgin. Actually, just did that last weekend.
Tony
This is a drawer panel for a desk I'm building...I drew the design in IntelliCAD, printed it, then transferred with carbon paper. I routed the waste away by hand. The pencil lines are there for reference as I added a carved texture so I could see where I had been.
Even using A size paper, I've found CAD programs accurate enough. To accomplish this accuracy, your CAD program needs to print registration marks at each page boundary. These look like the reticle in a telescopic sight, cross hairs and a couple of concentric circles. You also need to instruct the CAD program to print enough overlap on each page that each registration mark appears in the corner of each pair of adjacent pages. With scissors, you cut one pair of reticles in half at the straight line, lay it down and carefully align it to the reticle on the adjacent piece of paper, and stick it down with magic tape. (I'm still looking for a 11x17 printer at a reasonable price. It would save time and improve accuracy., but wouldn't take up nearly as much room in my shop as a plotter.)
If you are making just one, sticking the paper pattern directly to the work is efficient, but I prefer to stick it to a template, for several reasons:
1) I'm usually making multiple copies that need to look similar.
2) Cutting out a template allows me to further refine the curve, with fingers, eyes and a file (or spindle sander).
3) When judging and refining the shape on the template made of MDF or plastic, extraneous distractions, such as scotch tape, registration marks, page overlaps, etc., are removed. For the same reason, I have found it is not a good idea to use plywood for the template. The figure is distracting, as is the grain of the plys.
4) Someone may ask me to build another one some day, or even repair or replace a part on the original.. I can mark joinery and layout info on the template, and even make notes on it advising me of problems or future improvements, as well as the date I created the original and who I built it for.
"4) Someone may ask me to build another one some day, or even repair or replace a part on the original.. I can mark joinery and layout info on the template, and even make notes on it advising me of problems or future improvements, as well as the date I created the original and who I built it for. "
I always keep my templates, not that I have a huge number of them, by drilling a hole in the corner and hanging them up. A quick note on the template gives me some guidance as to the original purpose.
As Bill points out, wooden sticks are not isomorphic throughout their length. This leads to uncontrolled variations in the curves, i.e., the curves are not fair. If you have to use wood, clear straight grained Sitka spruce is a good choice, but you can't find it at your local Borg, and the price you would pay for material for making spars or sound boards is out of the question. There are other materials with more well behaved properties. The trick is to find one with appropriate elasticity for the scale of your work. Fiberglas composites and spring steel come to mind. A sheet of Formica will work, but not glued down to a particleboard substrate. Even the back of a hand saw will work for some curves.
Examples of commercial products that work at typical furniture scales are these drawing bows by Lee Valley:
For smaller scale details, French curves or a set of ships curves are useful.
Note that a hacksaw blade results in what LV calls symmetric curves, while a tapered handsaw blade results in asymmetric curves. If you want to build an asymmetric bow from a material you can work with woodworking tools, you can taper it with a hand plane, either in width or in thickness.
If you don't have a strap and a buckle like Lee Valley uses, some rope will work. At one end you can tie a bowline, or even a couple half hitches. At the other end, a knot called a tent hitch or taught line hitch or tautline hitch works best.
If you are going to draw your curves with your computer, spline curves work, but they are limited to hyperbolas. I prefer using Bezier curves. There are free plug-ins available for SketchUP for drawing Bezier curves.
Lee Valley has bows for marking curves. I have both symetric and asymetric and I use them all the time. They are far more consistent than wood strips and the nylon straps hold them reliably at any setting. Here is a linky:
I got this warning last weekend at a Virginia SAPFM meeting (See Don Williams' blog at http://donsbarn.com/musings/ for a report). There is a difference between carbon paper (used to be used in typewriters) and tracing paper, and the carbon paper has a significant disadvantage. Tracing paper has a graphite back, while the back of carbon paper contains wax and carbon. The wax makes it much more difficult to erase left over marks after you have finished sawing, carving or shaping, and may interfere with your finishing. Tracing paper can be found in large sheets at Woodcraft or even Michaels and A. C. Moore.
As I noted above, I also find these very convenient to use, but I am considering replacing the strap and buckle with a string with a tautline hitch. That may be a bit "retro". but I find it is very easy to tie, to adjust, and to untie. With a bit more practice, I may get more adept at using the buckle, so I'm not changing it yet.
Tapering a bending stick, of whatever material, to vary the stiffness, and therefore curvature from one end to the other, is significantly affected by whether you choose to taper the width or taper the thickness. The stiffness is directly proportional to the width of the stick, while it is proportional to the third power of the thickness of the stick.
Google "adjustable ship's curves". These are a little pricey, but they make very smooth curves and can be taped or clamped to a workpiece. They can also change direction in a curve.
Thanks. I'm not sure what I have to be honest, but it has never caused any issues. Acrylic paint sticks to it for sure as I have used it to trace lettering to paint. I'll have to take a look at the package out of curiosity. it is a dark cobalt blue color.
Bill alluded to the two sticks method. Lets say you want a segment of a circle and it needs to be forty inches long and four inches high. put points on something you are making a template out of forty inches apart. At the center, mark a point four inches above the line from A to B. Using two sticks about 48 inches plus long, Lay them out so that they touch A on one end and B on the other and overlap at the four inch high mark. Fasten them securely together at the apex. Put a pencil in the apex and with the sticks riding on nails in A and B. Draw a line from A to B with the pencil riding in the Apex or Vee. The arch will be a segment of a circle.
Another attractive curve is a catenary (sp?) arch and can be draw by tracing a limp chain hanging from two points. This looks like a McDonalds arch upside down. This an important and ancient arch for mason's. Build it in masonry and it a stable arch. A little beaded chain works well and you can project it onto the paper with a bright light.
I'm obviously misinterpreting this. For a stick that is, say, 6mm x 8mm, directly proportional would be 8 (something-or-others) and the other direction (exponentially) would be 216 (6^3)? That doesn't sound like it could be right. What am I misreading?
The engineering topic here is "beam stiffness", with this stick we are bending to make the curve being the "beam". I don't recall the details. I think it is all explained in Wikipedia or your neighbor's Statics book, but someone worked this all out 100+ years ago. The field is "Satics" a topic in mechanical engineering and the problem is to write an equation that describes the deflection of a bean supported at each end and loaded in the center (just as our stick is bent to make a curve).
The result of this equation says that the beam stiffness is proportional to the thickness of the beam and proportional to the cube of the depth. example- a 2 x 10 on edge(floor joist) is twice as stiff as a 1 x 10. A 2 x 8 floor joist is (2x2x2) times stiffer than a 2 x 4.
I would need to go back and study the equation, but I think if the beam is deflected say 3 " the curve is the same shape no matter the dimensions of the beam cross section. All that changes is how hard it is to bend the stick. I don't recall how the stiffness of the material of construction changes the shape of the curve, wood vs steel for example.
I should probably have been in bed, instead of commenting on math problems. It seems perfectly clear this morning, but last night I was envisioning twisting the 6 x 8 (in my example) by 90° without reassigning which was thickness and which was depth. Duh!
I would, however, point out that in your example of a 2x8 vs. a 2x4, the 2x8 is 2x2x2 times as stiff as the 2x4, not 2x2x2 times stiffer, a distinction that becomes more important as the dimensions of the two become closer to the same.