Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

Posts

Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#1

Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

Joe Pack

I have room to set up a somewhat permanent 10" radial arm saw or 12" compound miter saw station with 5-6 foot left and right bench tops. I have both saws, and use both, but really have room to set up only one permanent station. Primary use is to cut small pieces to fairly accurate length - anywhere from 1 1/2 - 6" using stops and hold-downs.

So...what would YOU choose to set up, and why? I'm sure there is no "correct" answer, but this should be a good discussion.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#2

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

BrianMonumentCO

If you never plan on doing any ripping then the compound miter saw is your best bet.

I have both a CMS and a RAS my RAS is in the storage area.

But I also have a table saw so ripping is not a problem

I have seen best accuracy from CMS.

Although RAS can be made accurate. The design is not necessarily long term accurate.

My vote is CMS.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#3

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

Rick Christopherson

If you have 5 to 6 feet on either side, then you actually have room for both. It isn't necessary to have a lot of space between them.

If the quality of your radial arm saw is little more than that of the miter saw, then this wouldn't be much help. But if it is a good quality saw, then it is worth having the second station.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#4

JL

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

JL

My preferences would be for a CMS. It is by far the better tool for cutting things to more accurate angles IMO. Both are similar in cutting things to length.

But if you have both - why not just have them side by side? Unless you need the cabinet space?

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#5

I use my RAS to cut Dados

Dustmaker Mike

I have both and use them differently. If I am cutting wide boards to length I made a bunch of 12" wide cutting boards for Christmas this year the RAS was used a lot. I guess I could have cut them on the TS also. When I made a set of shop carts I used all three of them set up different. The RAS was set up with a Dado blade the CMS was set to the lengths I needed and the TAS was adjusted to the width I needed to cut. Made the job easier. If you can put them side by side then that would be the best of both worlds. If not I would look hard at the rest of the tools you have and figure out how to make them do the job of the one you get rid of. RAS can do the job of the CMS and a few more things but the CMS can not do all the jobs of the RAS.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#6

Table saw....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....if I already owned one. I have never seen any need to set up a permanent cross cutting operation for typical furniture building. I see no loss in efficiency or accuracy cutting multiple drawer sides, for example, on a table saw with sled and stop.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#7

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

DaleLenz

First off I believe in tool your shop to your needs. I build flag cases quite a bit and have a 3.25", 22.5° miters on the bottom corners of the flag case. First, I cut them on a 10" TS, had to remove the saw's throat plate, this method sends the cut off flying around the shop, Not Good!

Like you I studied between the RA and the CMS. Most of my researched slanted towards the CMS accuracy over the RA. Purchased a 12" CMS over twenty years ago. Myself, I think I made the best decision between the two.

YMMV

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#8

Think Mobile bases

Kevin French

Works well in my small shop.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#9

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

For 90° cross-cutting to precise lengths, I too prefer a table saw and sled for both safety and accuracy, however, for small pieces (1-1/2") I use a sled on my bandsaw


with a fence to which I can clamp a stop for repeating cuts. I hate when small cutoff pieces get caught by a circular blade and fired off around the shop. The band saw prevents this nicely. True, the cut surface is not as smooth on the BS, but a little touch to the vertical belt sander fixes that.

For angled crosscuts I use the 12" SCMS.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#10

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I had a Delta radial arm saw years ago. I sold it and don't miss it at all. I have a Makita SCMS that has a 15" cross cut. For bigger stuff I use my table saw and a cross cut sled.

Personally, I found the RAS to be a bit dangerous. It had a habit of getting out of 90 degrees too.

T.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#11

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

James Heaston

Sorry to hear you have a RAS.

Nuff said? :b

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#12

Both of course.......

roger lance

Joe.....I'm lucky enough to have both a power miter saw and a radial arm saw. As the photo shows however these tools are of an older vintage. I acquired them for the purpose of framing houses.....the PMS is not a CMS.....and the radial arm is a small 10" DeWalt design which Black & Decker had not yet ruined.....


As time passed and I became involved in woodworking, both tools have found a role in my shop. The PMS is very good at cutting 6" wide stock (or less) to repeatable lengths or angles. The RAS excels at cutting rough raw stock into workable lengths before flattening (the bandsaw cannot do this due to limited throat size and cutting thick unflatten boards on the table saw is unsafe). Furthermore, there are other jobs that the RAS is able to do that other tools would have trouble trying......the ability to adjust the blade high above the table and make cuts occurs now and then......and the ability to cut dados and watch the cut is very convenient.

I've found that the table saw, band saw, RAS, and PMS (CMS) all have certain tasks that they each excel at doing......and instead of trying to play one tool off against another, its nice to have them all.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#13

cms for initial break down

ronster

I'd lose some enthusiasm for my makita scms if I didn't have at 8' to one side and 4' to the other, because I prefer starting with big rough stock that needs some taming prior to flattening and ripping. The cms with trays on both sides are good at this function. They can be good at finish crosscuts too, but my go-to there is a TS sled unless I'm doing 2x lumber or house trim. I was fortunate to be broke back when radials were raging, so I don't have one and now I don't want one. My f-i-l relied on his a bunch but it was finicky about staying adjusted and those things are a bit more scary to me.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#14

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

BrianMonumentCO

Why are you sorry?

A radial arm saw was once hawked as a one tool shop.

My house as a kid had just a RAS.

My current RAS is relegated to the storage area for tools on casters.

So it is far out of the way.

Now how much would I want for that RAS?

Or should I phrase it how much would I pay to have it removed.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#15

Ellis Walentine

A good debate

Ellis Walentine

You've already gotten a lot of sage advice here, but I'll add my two cents. I've had several radial arm saws and many miter-box saws, stationary and compound and sliding compound. I'm happy enough with my 12" CSMS and its 12" crosscut capacity to not care for the radial saw anymore.

If I may digress...

Radial arm saws are still current and valuable in industry and lumberyards, and in home shops, where they are useful for breaking down boards to rough length, where squareness and cut quality aren't important.

In fairness, properly tuned, radial arm saws are capable of a lot of valuable operations, including dados, especially where the opposite side of the piece is the reference surface. But, even there, you need to be aware of safety concerns. A dado head on a radial arm saw is free to climb forward with explosive speed, so you need to be very careful. For ripping and molding and all the other fantasies that Montgomery Ward and Sears fostered in the 60s, they are dangerous and inappropriate, in my humble opinion.

Ellis Walentine, host

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#16

Lumber "breaking down" saw

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

While you stated your need, namely cutting small pieces to length, something a table saw with a stop excels at, the discussion has veered to breaking down lumber.

I'll venture that I work more lumber than most. I am most assuredly not rooted in 1720 technology unless it offers an advantage. I buy 12' lumber when I can and that is too long to rough cut full length at my table saw location. But one cut and it can be moved to the table saw for further rough cutting. So for this chest of drawers I am building we are talking about one cross cut on maybe 4 or 5 boards to get them to table saw length.

Chop saws are screeming loud in a small shop, they make vast amounts of dust and if set up permanent they will occupy at least 14' of wall space to work on 12' long lumber.

Less than half a minute a cut is not an extravagant amount of time to "waste" on a cheap, quick, quiet, space saving means of breaking down lumber. I spend 20 times this amount of time calculating efficient cutting strategy on a board.

Laugh if you will but the picture shows the best way to break down lumber in the home shop. These saws are trivial to learn to sharpen with a triangular file and once sharpened they will make hundreds of cuts.


Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#17

A small parts jig for the PMS......

roger lance

Joe.....I know you mentioned using your CMS to cut small parts and I thought I'd share a jig I use on my power miter saw to safely cut small parts.....


There are cleats on the underside of the jig that position the jig on the saw and the little dowel prevents the saw from being plunged too far into the jig which could accidentally cut it in two (did I mention that this is my second version of this handy jig??).

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#18

A good discussion!

Joe Pack

A good discussion here! Thanks for all the input. I am now firmly convinced that I still don't know what I will end up doing, but I knew there would be lots of different ideas to ponder.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#19

Re: Do you make furniture or a paycheck

TomD

It really depends whether you make furniture or are a carpenter. If you look at every serious chop saw out there including the Festool, they are all designed to do one thing, move to the job site. Of course many chop saws are used in the most serious shops, but they just weren't built for that purpose. Makes you wonder why nobody has done it, and actually piled on features that might be valuable, other than making them out of recycled beer cans so they will be easy to move. Comparatively my cast iron RAS has serious linear motion bearings, and milled dovetails, is calibrated for minute adjustments, has a serious work area for jigs, and so forth.

I agree, however, that RASs have a flaw in marketing of their own, the idea you should use them for an overly wide variety of stuff. I only use mine for crosscuts, it cuts perfectly square, it handles much wider stock than a chop, And I can make stop cuts remove feathers of material like a milling machine etc... What I can't do is cut a lot of fancy angles that I do by hand anyway, or that look badly on furniture, for the most part. When I want really clean angle cuts I shoot them with a plane.

But yeah if I wanted something for unskilled workers to cut headers with on the job site, or to use for finish carpentry on a time budget, I would break out a chop right away. A chop may be the only tool I don't own, but I just don't do enough of that kind of work to warrant storing one. If I had the space, I would buy one in a shot, I just find so many other tools more useful than a chop saw.

Radial-Arm-Saw Joinery with Curtis Erpelding will give you lots of ideas on stuff you can do with a RAS in a cabinet shop. He basically built a business on it's joinery cutting ability.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#20

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

Stuart Johnson

Many segmented turners (Malcolm Tibbets to name one) use CMS when cutting segments. They are much smaller and probably greater angles variations than your 1-1/2 to 6 inch projects. Of course the same pieces can be cut on a tablesaw with a good sled.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#21

Ellis Walentine

A distinction

Ellis Walentine

I think we should clarify that there are basically two kinds of radial saws, one being the vintage, heavy-duty DeWalt and its rehabbed versions, with the rock-solid, registration key on the column, heavy-duty linear bearings, and cast iron parts that stay in adjustment, and the other being the consumer-grade models that have a lot of plastic and stamped steel parts. The cheap saws are capable of being tuned up to cut perfectly, but they tend to not stay in tune, due to all the points of articulation between blade and workpiece inherent in radial saw design. Anyone who plans to use one of these consumer grade saws needs to know that they require a lot of attention to keep them running right.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#22

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I had a cheaper grade of RAS, a Ryobi, for several years. Granted it is not the equilvant of an old Delta with the much better construction, but it did do what I needed, however it didn't do many tasks safely and didn't hold adjustments well.

When I set my shop up before retiring, I purchased a Delta Unisaw, and a CMS. After a few projects, I found I had NEVER used the RAS again. I built an over-sized sled for my Unisaw, and do have a Incra slide table with all the attachments for angle cuts and short (3 or 4 foot - can't remember) accurate stops for repeated cuts.

I haven't found anything I used the RAS for that I can't do as well or better, using either my cabinet saw, CMS, or Router table for and in many cases the operations are far safer. Almost all my equipment is on mobile bases and I have a decent size shop (30' X 30') so have no problem breaking down even 16' or longer stock using my Unisaw with sled. I finally gave my RAS to my son - he was doing some vinyl siding and it worked well for making the angled as well as the straight cuts.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#23

You can have my RAS when you pry it from my....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I've had my old Craftsman RAS since I bought it new in 1977. I probably use it more than any other woodworking tool I own. Early on, I did everything on it. I ripped, crosscut, mitered, beveled and even cut coves for a pool ball wall rack. These days, it's a crosscut tool, and as others have said, a dado tool. Ellis's comment on safety is good. I use a Freud dado with a negative hook. Much less tendency to climb, but the need to be mindful of the effect is still there. Ditto on the crosscut blade. I had no idea how much different the saw behaved after fitting it with a negative hook blade for crosscuts. Most folks get a real surprise the first time they try to cut on a RAS. The climb cut tendency is a shocker for the uninitiated. That being said, my one and only woodworking accident occurred on my RAS.

I also have a Makita CMS, though not a slider. It's used primarily for trim work and picture frame construction, where repetitive miters are common. I found that using the RAS for miters or bevels is what makes the RAS get "loose" or inaccurate. My old Craftsman RAS has cast iron construction and a solid column registration. It's rock solid accurate when left set for 90 degree crosscut duty. Plus, I renew the fence and bondo the table groove regularly to achieve a zero clearance cut situation.

I think personal preference is largely influenced by experience. I am perfectly at ease, though cautiously alert, using my RAS. But I would not recommend it as a tool for a beginning woodworker because of its quirks. I would have to think long and hard if someone forced me to make a decision to give up either the RAS or the table saw. Luckily, I don't have to choose.

As for your situation, I'd keep both. And I would not want to be limited to 5 feet left or right of either saw. My RAS is on a mobil base and I use roller stands left and right to cut any length I need to accommodate.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#24

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound mi

Joe Mohnike

Keep both. The RAS is a far better and more versital piece of equipment. I have both and seldom use the cut off saw. One issue I have is most people pull a RAS, when it should be pushed into the cut. Will not jump, the saw dust actually comes out the shoot, and binding is almost completly eliminated on larger stock. When set up properly a RAS is just as accurate as any CMS, and if not abused will keep its adjustment for a very long period of time.

Re: Let the debate begin-radial arm v. compound miter

#25

Re: A distinction, and a further one

TomD

Good point. My dad actually has one of the Ryobii saws, and they are pretty good, for a saw that is designed to match their lightweight planer. That saw is the only one I have ripped, on, and it was only scary based on my apprehension, though I wouldn't use it for ripping if I had had another option. It has the capacity to be used as a milling machine since it can be rotated to work as a linear pin router. But you are right, there are limits to how stiff these machines are.

The other thought is that the cast iron models are probably cheaper than consumer grade models. And not all are huge on the footprint. RAS as mostly an old school tool, but if you have a cool reason for wanting to buy one, it is probably one of the few tools where you can really find an old iron gem that makes sense in the modern shop.