Re: Do you make furniture or a paycheck
TomD
It really depends whether you make furniture or are a carpenter. If you look at every serious chop saw out there including the Festool, they are all designed to do one thing, move to the job site. Of course many chop saws are used in the most serious shops, but they just weren't built for that purpose. Makes you wonder why nobody has done it, and actually piled on features that might be valuable, other than making them out of recycled beer cans so they will be easy to move. Comparatively my cast iron RAS has serious linear motion bearings, and milled dovetails, is calibrated for minute adjustments, has a serious work area for jigs, and so forth.
I agree, however, that RASs have a flaw in marketing of their own, the idea you should use them for an overly wide variety of stuff. I only use mine for crosscuts, it cuts perfectly square, it handles much wider stock than a chop, And I can make stop cuts remove feathers of material like a milling machine etc... What I can't do is cut a lot of fancy angles that I do by hand anyway, or that look badly on furniture, for the most part. When I want really clean angle cuts I shoot them with a plane.
But yeah if I wanted something for unskilled workers to cut headers with on the job site, or to use for finish carpentry on a time budget, I would break out a chop right away. A chop may be the only tool I don't own, but I just don't do enough of that kind of work to warrant storing one. If I had the space, I would buy one in a shot, I just find so many other tools more useful than a chop saw.
Radial-Arm-Saw Joinery with Curtis Erpelding will give you lots of ideas on stuff you can do with a RAS in a cabinet shop. He basically built a business on it's joinery cutting ability.