Charles, I'm hearing "NO"
Re: garage slab?
#26
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Charles, I'm hearing "NO"
In theory, yes...
John in NM
12 x 20 is not that big. You'll need help screeding it, at least one helper, two would be best - the rest you can do yourself if you are quick about it and don't mind the hard labor. If it were a cold sunny day in NM, I wouldn't hesitate to do that myself, but then I've done it before and am still in reasonably good shape.
On a hot day in June, I wouldn't attempt it - the concrete will start to cure too quickly without a couple experienced helpers. I did a 20x50 slab in June and it was almost a disaster - needed a second bull float and well timed pizza and beer to keep the helpers amused during some of the pauses
Most of the guys were 20+ years older than me, so they tired fast and went home - can't say as I blame them, beer probably would have made it worse! 
Around here, you can rent all the tools you need. Tamp the soil, build the form. Remesh is a debatable issue. It doesn't prevent cracks, but it keeps them from getting huge. Concrete shrinks as it cures, and thus it cracks. No way around it. Put a groove in half way through the long direction and it will crack there. For a garage floor, cracks probably don't matter - unless you're one of those guys who obsessively paints floors and frets every oil drip (obviously, I'm not one
)
So the truck comes and starts pouring concrete. You have to use the trough on the back of the truck to distribute the concrete around your form, or shovel it if the trough does not reach everywhere. Once the concrete is more or less dispersed, you use a 2x6 or similar to screed it down roughly level. This is when you find out how good you were at eyeballing the initial dispersal. Screeding a biggish slab is probably the hardest labor, but it's early in the process so the rest seems worse later on 
Once the screeding is done, your helper(s) usually abandon you, especially if it's a hot day. Next thing you do is to tamp it down a bit with a jitterbug (just a bit of expanded metal screen on something that looks a lot like a Zimmer frame
). The guy tamping just walks through the wet concrete, usually tripping over the remesh. Rubber boots are a must.
If you still have a helper or two, get them to work bull floating right behind the guy tamping. Its easiest to bull float across the shortest dimension obviously. The grooving tool clamps on to the bull float, once you have the whole slab floated, go back and make the groove at 10'.
If it's a nice cool day, you'll probably have a break at this point. Last thing to do is obsessively smooth it with a magnesium float once the concrete is firm enough to hold your weight on some boards. There's a point at which a lot of water comes to the surface for a while and then disappears again. You want to finish it at that point, after is a bit too late. If you don't care about a rough job, you can skip this part. I've had a couple shops where they skipped everything after tamping!
Start finish floating in the middle and work your way out to the edges, smoothing out the marks left by your knee boards.
Much is made of the professional's ability to get concrete flat, but few will guarantee you more than 1/4" in 10', which is well within the amateur's capabilities as well. The pro's main advantage is having willing labor available and knowing when to let them take a break vs. directing them to a waiting task.
The other thing to remember, most of the work I've done is far from the mixing plant - so there was probably a retarder of some kind added, may not be the case where you live.
Another option...
John in NM
Form up in quarters, 6'x10', with rebar tying the quarters, and mix yourself with a rental mixer. Get a pile of plant mix (maybe 3 tons?) delivered and buy sacks of portland for mixing - avoid sackrete like the plague if you need more than 10 sacks of it.
6'x10' is a half dozen loads in a mixer, depending on which one you rent. If you can handle the 100# bags of portland, you can do the work of mixing. You could probably do it with one of those trailer loads too, I forget how big they are. Like the other poster, I don't like those much because the aggregate settles out on the road. It's a pain to deal with, but you can do it.
It won't be cheaper this way, but you'll need much less help and have much more time to do the work. I would still prefer a helper doing it this way, but you won't need two and you won't need the one for long.
Re: Charles, I'm hearing "NO"
Charles Jackson III
That's what everyone is saying.
A method using dry concrete mix-farmer's concrete
robbcarr
I've seen my grandfather use this method on a number of occasions... be sure to tamp down and compact the soil well before putting down the gravel. Then on top of the gravel sprinkle it down with water and tamp it down again-you can't compress gravel, but I think this help the gravel to settle. Then wet the gravel again and take your sacks of dry concrete mix and pour them on top of the gravel-have the bags roughly layed where you need them before you start. Then use a metal rake to move it around, you want to make a layer of dry mixture about 3"-4" deep. Once you get the whole area covered take a hose and with a light mist wet it down until the mixture stops soaking up water. Wait about 20-30 minutes-the time it took my grandfather to have a smoke and drink a beer! Then do whatever finish you want, my grandfather always used a push broom w/ a broken handle duck taped to it give him more reach and stood off the side and broomed finished everything. Then cover the slab with plastic sheets and stick your anchor bolts in for the walls-there are some neat methods for doing this involving having holes drilled in the bottom plate and the anchor bolts mounted to it. The next day wet it down again and put the plastic back over it-do this once a day for a week. The advantage here with this method is you're not working against that clock, one person can do it and you're pushing around dry concrete mixture which is much lighter and easier to work with. He did this when he was in his 70s by himself, he called it farmer's concrete and never used any reinforcing in the slab and I can't remember it ever cracking.
Goals. Guts, and Gumption......
roger lance
Charles,
I hope you have not equated all the "No" responses with the idea that we don't want you to have your shop.....its really the opposite, we want you to have your shop and we want the building of it to go well and to have you happy with the results.
John's idea to break the pour into smaller, more easily managed units is a very good suggestion.....it is what is often suggested to new woodworkers who are facing a large glue-up......break it down into sections and take your time.
But even for that, you need to do a lot of preparation in getting some knowledge about working concrete, gathering the tools necessary, and making sure you are up to it physically. Maybe, you could volunteer some time to a local concrete contractor and learn what you need to know that way.
I've been remembering this song from the John F. Kennedy run for President about an ant and a ram that had "High Hopes" and wanted to do something that few thought they could but they had determination.....keep at it, you'll get that shop built.
do not broom finish
Jerry Gibbs
you will hate yourself trying to sweep the floor.
Farmers concrete......
Barry Irby
I have never heard of anyone doing this before, however, it sounds like the "infusion" method of placing concrete. I don't know how you would get a good flat smooth finish on it, but it should be possible to get a decent sound slab. I have placed many footings for things like deck where I put maybe a cubit foot of dry Sacrete in the hole, tamped it, flooded the hole with water and left it to its own devices. The concrete will soak up exactly enough water to chemically bind the cement and set. I have gone back years later and dug some of them up and always found them to be as good as any where we mixed the water in them and then poured them. I the case of deck footings, water could infuse into the concrete from the surrounding soil providing the water for the chemical reaction, even if it took moths or years. Also, the bearing strength of concrete for a deck footing is insignificant and of no consequence. As long as the surround soil would confine it, gravel would be fine and perhaps better.
The problem for you with the slab is that it would be better in the long run if the slab were not in contact with the soil and were isolated from it by gravel and polyethylene. So if you have gravel and poly under your slab to give you a dry floor later, it will not be able to infuse moisture from below. Might be tricky to be sure you get it thoroughly wet from the top.