garage slab?
Charles Jackson III
I am wondering could I pour the 12x20 garage myself?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
garage slab?
Charles Jackson III
I am wondering could I pour the 12x20 garage myself?
In my youth.....
Barry Irby
I poured literally acres of concrete. Now that I think of it, not much of it by myself.
Do you know what a screed is? Do you own a bull float? Walk boards, wood floats, steel trowels, or a troweling machine? Do you have any experience?
Do you want the floor to be nice, level and smooth?
Can you get the concrete truck close enough to the site to place the concrete directly from the truck? Otherwise you will have to roll it or pump it.
Is your health insurance paid up? Are you in good shape and ready for a very hard day? Perhaps a very long day.
Its all in the timing. Do you know how to recognize when the concrete is ready for the next step?
Re: In my youth.....
Charles Jackson III
I never pour a slab before, I think I can get the truck close to the spot.
Re: In my youth.....
Charles Jackson III
Nope but I will get the tools.
Re: In my youth.....
Curt Stivison
Sorry but the answer is NO. Just my opinion. I have poured alot of concrete and never had enough help.There is help and then there is good help.
Not alone, and not the first time by yourself
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I've done only a little concrete in my life, enough to tell me that there's considerable subtle knowledge required to finish it well. Find someone with experience in concrete finishing and be his/her helper. You'll get a better job done, and you'll learn.
Yes. but you'll regret the results.....
Marvin Horn
Yes. but you'll regret the results for the rest of your life. DAMHIKT,, but furnishing free beer to get your friends to help is not the way to go either. Hire a pro.
Re: garage slab?
Howard Norman
Yes you can pour the slab yourself Charles but I would not recommend it. The only way that I would recommend it is if you have a friend that does it for a living and you can get him to help.
Howard
Not gonna disagree with the others.
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
I've helped pour a couple driveways, so I have a general understanding of the process. I MIGHT attempt something like this, but I'd try like heck to find someone with professional experience to help me first, if nothing else to talk me through it to make sure I don't miss anything
You're looking at about 3 yds of concrete, maybe $300, and maybe another $400-500 for someone to form and finish it for you. By the time you rent all the tools you need, you're probably not out much to have someone do it for you. And if they have to re-do it, it's on their dime, not yours. If it's an attached garage, then you may be looking at permits and insulating foamboard around the perimeter to below the frost line (possibly on a detached garage, too--depending on local codes).
And I'm a die-hard DIYer.
Jason
Re: Not alone, and not the first time by yourself
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I've poured a lot of concrete and I wouldn't think about doing a pad that size by myself. About 12 or so years ago I built a shed, 12 X 16 and dug the footings, etc by myself. Four guys showed up to do the actual concrete work.
Re: Not gonna disagree with the others.
Charles Jackson III
Cant afford to hire some else to do it. I was going to do all the forming and digging myself.
Re: Not gonna disagree with the others.
Barry Irby
Charles, I completely understand the not being able to afford it part. I suggest you investigate two alternatives.
You do all the digging and forming and get it completely set up and then hire somebody to place and finish the concrete. You can take your time forming and digging and you can back up and adjust it if you don't like what you get on the first try. But if you screw up the slab finish, its pretty much written in stone. I know this from experience. My personal garage slab is one of the worst ones I ever had done when I was building. (Cooks get to eat their mistakes and builders get to live in them.) Mine thankfully is level or flat, but it is rough. So it is serviceable but not pretty. Many of the ones I have seen done by first timers are not flat and that's a terrible floor for a shop. So, you do the prep work adn hire a pro to finish it. You won't have to buy or rent the tools and that will be an offset, so it may not cost as much as you think.
The second alternative would be to sue a wooden floor. There is such a thing as a wooden "slab" which is basically a treated wood floor close to the ground. You could look it up on the internet. One way is to spread a gravel pad and them frame a floor resting on it. There could be some serious advantages. You could insulate it, run wires through it, run dust collection in it, leave it so you can unscrew sections for future access etc. Wooden floors are kinder to your feet. Locally, Lowe's carries treated plywood that would work well for this.
Either way, study up on this before you take off. Go watch somebody place and finish concrete. There really is a lot to know about it and a little research would be well worth it. You might even find a crew that would do yours on the side, cheap.
Re: Options
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Charles, I have some experience working concrete, however when I built my 30' X 30' foot shop, we dug the foundation, installed the forms, set up the rebar, had it inspected (yeah, most areas do require inspection prior to installing the foundation!) and poured the foundation. Then an EXPERIENCED friend laid all the block.
I installed enough block on the foundation to allow me to have a 10' ceiling using standard 8' 2x6's. When the foundation was complete, we laid out a level line on the blocks with chalk line, had gravel brought in and compacted it with a rented compactor. Then we laid re-mesh AND rebar, when it was completely ready for the pour, I HIRED a PROFESSIONAL with a crew for $500 to level and finish the concrete. He had the tools and crew available to do the job properly, I did not have the experience to insure the floor would be level and smooth. This was the ONLY time I hired anyone to do any work on my shop.
As has been stated, almost every thing you do when building a shop can be corrected if something goes wrong - except for concrete! Timing is critical, you only get one shot at making it level and smooth. Once it sets - if it is not correct, you either live with it forever or spend Thousands (yup, thousands of dollars) to break it up, remove the debris and then re-pour.
can you afford to do it over?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
...or live with a surface that is too rough to sweep or a surface the peels off over time because too much water was worked to the surface trying to smooth it?
I come from a construction family and have done some myself. Concrete finishing was always a task left to a specialized crew. Concrete finishing is not a task I would remotely consider doing myself for I have seen the results of inexperience. You are not going to learn the optimum timing to do the various required steps by reading a book.
Concrete is not a one man job..... seriously
Tim Greif - West of Chicago
I worked on a commercial concrete crew for two summers putting myself through college. I know what's involved. But I would not even consider doing someting like that myself. A sidewalk - sure. I've done a couple. But not a slab that size. Once the truck shows up, you need manual labor to move, shovel and screed the wet concrete, and manipulate the street mesh up into the contrete. And it needs to be done pretty fast. The ready-mix guys want to dump and run. Time is money.
Then you need to know how to read the concrete to know when to float and trowel the slab. Plus knowing when and how to edge the conrete and put control joints in the slab at the proper location.
This is NOT a first time DIY project. Thust me. Let a pro place and finish the slab. You can save money doing the prep work. Even with that, you'll need to know how to properly prepare and compact the sub-base. Good luck.
There is no practicing w/ concrete
Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL
It's one of the few tasks I can think of where your first job requires all the same knowledge, experience, and tools as your hundredth. Once that stuff starts coming down the chute, you have to execute several steps, in the correct sequence, at the correct time, many of which can be overwhelming for one person, not to mention a first timer.
Oh, and the concrete company "allows" about fifteen minutes to get the stuff out. If you're too slow (because you decided to tackle this job against professional advice) and the driver has to wait on you, the overtime clock $tart$ ticking whether you're done or not. And that fifteen minutes isn't the end of your day—it's just the beginning.
I had the good fortune of a neighbor who was a professional concrete finisher. I was amazed at the amount of training and education he'd had to get to the point of being able to do it for a living. I worked with him to put in my (two car) garage floor, and later my sidewalk (corner lot—lots of sidewalk), plus the front steps. Here's a hint at what you're facing—the first shovelful down the chute is to "take a look at it". Does it need more water? Is it hot/cold/dry outside and thus might need some additives? What additives? If you don't know these answers, or even the questions to ask, get out the wallet.
And yes, there are specialty tools, some of which you may have to buy (steel trowel, cornering tool, margin trowel, and mag float will probably serve you for other tasks, but you'll never need a bull float any other time). You don't get to practice finishing concrete. Your first pour is permanent. There are no "backsies". You can buy labor with pizza and beer, but one of your "help" needs to be a concrete finisher.
I've since done a handful of pours myself, each probably less than 10 square feet, but I wouldn't think of doing a one car slab, such as you're planning. So, the short answer to your question, as confirmed by the other commenters, is emphatically NO!
Rod
Wooden slab
Jack Guzman from Maine
Charles,I poured my own shop floor. It turned out to be a nightmare. I ended up covering it with 2" foam board and plywood. The concrete was way uneven and it cracked and heaved in several places. I like the suggestion of a wooden slab. If you are just planning on tools and human traffic all you need is to frame up a floor making sure the joists are heavy enough for the load. Either that or lay down gravel and lay down beams on the gravel to support the flooring. Either way would be alot easier than concrete.---Jack
Re: garage slab?
Jerry Nicholson
I bought a cartload of concrete one time to pour a 10 x 12 slab for a shed. I thought the carts had mixers connected to the wheels. WRONG! The concrete settled in the cart in the 5 or so miles I had to travel and when I poured it, the "soup" came off first and then the solid stuff. Hot day, working by myself, I barely was able to strike it off and floating was a nightmare. Ugliest concrete I ever saw but when I moved away from there it was still intact. I also poured a patio, 30 square feet at a time, using a half sack mixer run by a garbage disposal motor. That took me part of two summers and I was only in my 40s then. When I moved 14 years ago, I sold the mixer so I wouldn't be tempted to try any more flatwork!
I did make a slab for my generator housing last summer - Quikrete mixed in a wheelbarrow. I did that by myself too, in two pours on two different days. I got a guy a Lowes to put the Quikrete in my truck and then backed my truck up to the slab location so I could move the Quikrete directly from the truck to the wheelbarrow. It worked out OK but wasn't much fun for a decrepit 77 year old.
When I built my 12 x 16 shed at this house in 2001, I got the pros to do the slab. Two concrete professionals and two teenage helpers. I don't think any of them thought it was fun.
Jerry
Re: garage slab?
Jay Lombardo
I have been the grunt labor on dozens of slabs this size (not my trade , but when the concrete truck shows up it's all hands on deck). This is NOT a diy job especially not alone or for the first time. Having assisted so many times I know just enough to be dangerous and still wouldn't even consider doing it without an experienced pro on site. As others have said save money by preparing the site yourself, dig footings, level slab area, frame slab, install, compact and level gravel, install rebar, but when the truck shows up with the concrete, have an experienced pro with the proper tools doing it, and you can be one of the grunts.
just my opinion
So...
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Charles, you thought it just about making a frame and filling it with mud?
Uh, uh, uh.
You should know better by this time.
I, like others here, have done enough mud to know that I don't know anywhere near enough to do more than write the check.
Go to "You Tube"
Gary Smyth
Type in "pouring slab for shop". Also "Garage Pt. 5, 6 ,7 ,8. Those several and more than a couple of others will give you an idea of what you are facing. For a half hour of your time you will learn much. Note the bodies available and the time lapse. I wish you the best.
How Not To Build Your Home
Tony Haukap
Pouring concrete isn't just setting up a couple of 1x6's for a form and dumping concrete -- how are you going to handle; Excavating? Soil Compaction? Frostwall/Footings? Gravel base? Vapor Barrier? Reinforcing/Wire Mesh/Fiber? Anchor Bolts?
I wish I had a better scan of this, it's from the mid-70's and the costs of things are off, but it's message is pretty clear....
Re: How Not To Build Your Home (Better Copy!)
Tony Haukap
A more readable copy... (drag image to your desktop then double-click the 'gif' file)
Still unconvinced ??.....
roger lance
In addition to all the technical/knowledge aspects people have talked about for successfully pouring/finishing concrete.....there is the question of your personal level of physical strength and endurance.
As the oldest son of a building contractor, I grew-up helping my dad pour all kinds of concrete projects.....and I believe that working concrete is one of the top physically demanding types of work going. Not only should you be very strong but also have endurance that can last all day without stopping.
If you've experienced a sense of panic when making a complicated glue-up with multiple clamps etc.....and the glue is starting to tack and take a set.....wait until you have several yards of concrete harding faster than you can work it and there is no one else to help.
So, "NO" would be my answer to your question......that's just my $0.02.....YMMV.
Stamina
Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL
As I wandered into my 60s, I kind of lost touch with my fitness and stamina and instead relied on my memory. Unfortunately, the older I get, the faster I was.
My cousin and I decided to build a two step and landing for his mother's outside door at the condo where we lived. Note, I'm the "expert" in this project, he's the muscle. We got it planned out, excavated (not much for South Florida), and formed up. I suspect we wisely made this a two day project and called it a day at this point.
The next day we got out the wheelbarrow, shovels, hoe, and tools, not to mention the twelve bags of Sakrete we calculated. Then we started. We were smart enough to pace ourselves (he's only a couple of years younger than me), but by about the eighth bag we knew we were in trouble.
And this is the crux of what all of us are trying to convey here—we couldn't stop. Most pours are monolithic, even ones that have expansion joints fitted. Once you start, you're committed.
We agonized our way through, got the last bags mixed, poured, and screeded, and, gratefully, sat down and popped a top. Of course we weren't through. Giving ourselves a few minutes, we floated the three levels, used the margin trowel to smooth out the mud in the forms, and rolled the edges.
Then it was back to the beer and wait. Eventually, it got dry enough to put steel on it, and we trowelled it out, broomed a texture on, and called it a day.
I have never been so whipped in my life (to that point). I don't know if I have any more pours left in me, but if I do, I won't do more than four or five bags—so, baby project.
Rod