Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Ellis Walentine

Yes, folks, late again this month, we need your thoughts on yet another vexing woodworking question. This time it's regarding the future, and maybe the essence, of woodworking. Specifically, CNC vs craftsmanship.

The Museum of Art & Design in Manhattan has an exhibit this Fall of computer-assisted production, not only in wood, but across a range of decorative and functional objects. Also, a major highlight of this year's AWFS in Las Vegas was the introduction of new CNC equipment at more affordable prices for smaller shops. The question is whether this still qualifies as woodworking or is it just computer programming? Are consumers even aware of how things are made? Do they care, or are they just interested in utility and/or aesthetics? And, does the concept of "craftsmanship" apply to CNC-produced furniture and other wood objects?

What do you think?

As usual, we'll publish a digest of your opinions in the next issue of Woodworker West magazine. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#2

Kneale Brownson

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Kneale Brownson

Is ripping with a table saw any less "woodworking" that cutting with a hand ripsaw? The design, assembly and finishing are the craftsmanship parts of woodworking. The rest is just production.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#3

Re: Video Killed The Radio Star?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Not so fast . . .

35 years ago a business opened in New York City known as "Studio For Solid Photography" which purposed to use laser grid scanning and industrial duplicator technology to produce photo-realistic portraits of clients. Various levels of resolution were offered, right down to that mole next to your ear. All the portrait artists started lamenting "We're done. We can't compete with that. They ruined art portraiture forever."

The lamenting artists are still in their lofts, some starving, some not, but the nifty business went bust in short order. Turned out people who wanted a portrait wanted it done by a real artist with all that implied rather than just another photograph.

CNC is merely a production tool that will find its place in production work. Bill Hylton wrote that "every cut in woodworking can be made with a router." He was correct, but I haven't seen tables saws and all the rest of the power and hand tools thrown away and rendered obsolete.

As long as people revere and seek out wood as a material, there will be those who demand to touch and be in touch with it rather than reducing craft to a video game. There will be those who appreciate and demand the tactile feel of a whisper-thin curl coming off a hand plane or bench chisel.

Besides, I've seen some pretty sloppy work come out of shops whose products could be seriously improved by CNC equipment.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#4

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Thomas S Stockton

It's all about the execution, done well I have no problem with people using the tools they have at their disposal. There is also a real art to the programming get it wrong and it looks really wrong.

I've had marquetry done by laser and it turned out really well. The wooden parts of this inlay were done with a laser.

Tom


Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Merle

I agree with the others that the consumer wants a great looking product and probably can't care less how it is produced. If the creator is able to add some fancy "carving" and keep the cost reasonable, so much the better. I think we all know what happened to the Luddites and probably don't want to follow in their footsteps.

However, I choose to use some tools and not others because I mainly make products for my own consumption and speed isn't critical. Sketchup is a wonderful tool, but I haven't taken the time to learn to use it.

So what I am saying is that if woodworking is your livelihood, you need to make your products as cost effectively as possible, but if you are a hobbiest, then you have the freedom to enjoy the process as much as the product.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#6

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Matt Robinette

I watched the cnc do it's thing at the local Woodcraft store and I have to say I was impressed. I was being told how cool it was and what all it can do but it came down to do I really need it the answer was no. It seems that the more high tech the machines get the faster they become obsolete or need an upgrade to stay current. I must admit it has great repeat ability and in a production setting it would be great. IKEA must have a million of them.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Gary Smyth

I'm tempted to remind of how once top rated Zenith disappeared from electronics because as the ads said "made by hand" in the face of other companies electronics assembly. Nor should most of us forget how lowly Honda and Toyota rose through the reliability numbers by using robots rather than humans at critical points in the factories. Place me solidly in the column of backing things generated by CNC. For me, precision is as important as imagining, designing, function, and finish. I seriously doubt that I will reject something solely because it is made by hand or that it was made using CNC. If it does the job better and is aesthetically pleasing to my eye, it won’t matter. That said it will remain a personal goal in my own work to achieve the skill to produce the fit of former and current “furniture masters”. I may be the only one that cares, but in this instance, I’m the one that matters.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#8

Clint Searl

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Clint Searl

Depends on one's woodworking philosophy. I suggest there are two schools: the designers and the fabricators. For the woodworker who values design the most, CNC is merely the path of least resistance to get to the prize. As such, it's a welcome addition that could shorten the project cycle, enabling more designs. For the woodworker who places the highest value on the physical involvement on turning wood into furniture, turnings, or something else, CNC would be banned. For most, there's probably a middle ground, but I suspect the distribution is skewed toward the fab side. Not many of us designers out there.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#9

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Dick Coers

I run a 5'x10' 5 axis CNC as a day job. It can blast through plywood by both cutting and boring with incredible speed. It can carve very complicated objects with ease. It is a robot. It takes a designer designing in 2d or 3d to function. What it can't do is duplicate the surface off a hand plane or a carving chisel. Rotary tools will never be able to get the tight details and surface quality that hand tools can do. There will always be a percentage of the population that will appreciate these handmade details. The style of furniture and cabinets will also influence how furniture gets made. High style carved furniture is not as popular right now as mid century modern, so hand skills requirements are lessened. CNC replace handwork? Never completely for furniture, cabinets?, it already has.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Jesper, Denmark

The "average" consumer does not care and buy, based on utility, aestetics and PRICE. Reference: IKEA. it's production, not craftsmanship.

There will still be craftsmanship and traditional woodworking for the discerning consumer.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#11

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Brian from Monument

Having spent more than 25 years as a software developer, I don't consider CNC programming to be computer programming. Just me.

Do I consider a CNC made cabinet woodworking art NO WAY.

To me the art of woodworking includes the following;

1. selection of quality wood.

2. orienting quality wood to make the most of grain patterns within the piece.

3. working the surface to make the shape of the piece.

4. making the joinery fit perfectly and neatly.

5. finish preparation (planing and sanding.)

6. finishing

7. finishing the finish.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#12

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

John in NM

Ironically, I've just been revisiting CNC possibilities again.

And again I've decided against it. Too expensive, too uncertain - coming up with a multi-curve model of my products is simply beyond me.

So I'm looking into carving duplicators instead. Doesn't really answer the question about programming vs. craftsmanship.... maybe it does though, even if it's not "programming" per se, it's still time spent on software manipulation and not on actual production. To the craftsman, even a 4x carving machine is intuitive, software is not - at least not to me.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#13

JL

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

JL

I have nothing against using CNC tools. That's a personal choice.

Personally - I don't find it fulfilling. Yes, it is woodworking - but it isn't "fun".

I don't think most customers would care - they just want a good, well-made product that looks the way they want it to look.

I think that "Craftsmanship" applies - GIGO is still a rule. If something is poorly designed or engineered - it would not be suitable.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#14

a "Period" woodoworker take on the subject

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was in an Alan Breed demonstration of carving a table edge lip on a recessed table surface. (Astonishing how fast he can carve do to efficiency of his cuts). Someone asked him how he preferred to remove wood to create the recessed surface/field. "I take the top to a nearby shop that has a CNC router", was the reply. A gasp could be heard from the audience, for they were not expecting that answer. Al explained that he liked carving and removing wood to establish the recessed field was busy work that was not rewarding.

A CNC has replaced the shaper at a nearby organ restoration shop. A club member that does "quilt pattern" inlay on jewelry boxes cuts out the inlay pieces with a laser. A couple of years ago a student posted here an amazing geometric woodworking assembly that simply could not have been done other than by CNC.

These examples demonstrate that useful new capabilities will be used to advantage.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#15

Tony Reynolds

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Tony Reynolds

I think it takes a fair amount of a skill to produce computer designs via whatever software package you choose to use. With that said, in order to remain competitive for the stuff I produce I've just added a CNC router to my shop and think the benefits are going to be tremendous. The whole argument to me reminds me of the steam shovel replacing men with shovels argument. You either move forward or get left behind if working in a production business model.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#16

CNC craftsmanship ?

Mark Hennebury

This may not be made of wood, but the principles are the same.

I submit the article below clipped from the craftsmanship museum. The full article is worth looking at and can be seen by following the link. The work that this man has done is quite incredible and question of craftsmanship/CNC, are in my opinion answered unequivocally.

Mark


http://www.craftsmanshipmuseum.com/Tomlinson.htm

Clen Tomlinson is seen with his partially completed Napier Deltic engine at a model engineering show in Oregon. The 18-cylinder, 36-piston, 3-crankshaft engine is an extremely complicated and difficult project no matter how it is made. But is it "craftsmanship" if computer controlled machines are used in the process? See Clen's page in the museum for more photos of the engine and decide for yourself. Clen lays out some of his thoughts on the subject below. (Click on photo above to view a larger image.)

The Debate over CNC Craftsmanship

by Clen Tomlinson

The debate regarding Craft and Craftsmanship has prompted me to examine my understanding of these words. I offer the following ramblings for you to “toss into the ring.”

A Dictionary definition is historically predictable:

CRAFT: “an activity involving skill in making things by hand”

CRAFTSMAN: “a worker skilled in a particular craft”

Taken literally and applied to the process of modelling including model engineering, would suggest we should be restricted to hand basic hand tools such as a hammer, chisel, hacksaw and files or even a whittler’s knife! At the other end of the spectrum few would allow the Craftsman the use of the latest computer driven Rapid Prototyping equipment.

I am sure most observers would allow us to employ the occasional drill press, lathe, mill and grinder as a substitute for our lack of craftsmanship to produce acceptable degrees of accuracy. It also seems OK to use the DRO to overcome the inadequacies of our overused machines and to simplify the process of compensating for wear and tear. I use a computer to control my machine to make the process a practical possibility. Due to the intricacy and minute dimensions limiting the speed of metal removal I do not regard it as acceptable to stand and wind the handles to achieve the results that take the CNC process over two days to complete some operations unaided.

My time is better spent pursuing my skilled and creative craft of creating a design, method and process which will allow me to “get what I want.” I do not regard the swarfe (chip) making process as intellectually stimulating.

It is clearly acceptable to use CAD to produce the drawings from which we manufacture our models. The technology exists to allow the computers to carry on unfettered by us humans to make our models for us. I would suggest that would be a “step to far.”

I found two definitions of A Craft which appeal to me:

“To describe something as a craft is to describe it as lying somewhere between an Art (which relies on Talent) and a Science (which relies on knowledge).”

“It is an intellectual and physical activity where the maker explores the infinite possibilities and processes to produce unique objects.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#17

Really?

John in NM

Perhaps I'm just too literal, but I didn't get much of an answer in what you posted - I didn't follow the link.

The gentleman is certainly highly skilled in the design work. Once that work is done, it seems that anyone could produce the same engine as he has done. If so, any craftsmanship resides solely in the computer design, not in the actual production.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#18

Value of reproducions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would seem from the value placed on reproductions that design is what we value, not execution of the design. Given the science it takes to spot a forgery, apparently many can do the work, but only one can design/conceive the work and it is their work that becomes valuable.

The organ shop uses CNC to make moldings. Does anyone think this approach leads to more value for the product than using a shaper, whether they be making organ parts or molding for a 1720 reproduction?

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#19

But isn't that a different yardstick?

John in NM

Value does not necessarily parallel craftsmanship.

On stuff I sell, I too want to produce to the desired standard with a minimum of work. If I could figure out how to make a machine do the work for me, I would do that - there is value in production efficiency. But I would not call that craftsmanship by any stretch.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#20

One additional thought

Merle

Heck, why stop with CNC? If a 3D printer can "print" a hamburg, can a Roentgen's Berlin secretary be far behind? Ducking and running!! lol :D

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#21

Delusional

Mark Hennebury


Okay so let me get this straight: This is not a fine piece of craftsmanship and the man that made it is not a craftsman, just computer programmer and anyone could make this if given the program?

does that about sum up your views?

As i see it this man is an incredible craftsman, with an uncommon knowledge of the tools, materials and machining process. Mind boggling skill, discipline and dedication, and courage to take on such a huge, complex and precise project.

The engine is in my mind a masterpiece of fine craftsmanship, and an inspiration to many of what a craftsman and his tools can achieve.

One of us is obviously delusional; given the nature of delusion, i feel that there would be no point in me making a guess as to which one. I will leave that judgement to someone else.

I am still amazed at the human capacity to ignore reality, to scoff at, data, facts, measurable, quantifiable evidence... for an imaginary world that they swear exists, yet cannot be seen or measured or in any way proven to exist.

I have heard this craftsmanship argument for the past 45 years of my woodworking, and have yet to have one person define what this special value that is placed within an object that is made by these righteous few of the sacred hand tool society.

I have heard it described in many abstract forms, such as a special "spirit of craftsmanship" that apparently can’t be seen, or measured by mere mortals and certainly wouldn't be understood by such heathens as that torture wood with machines and... god forbid.... computer controlled machines!

I am sorry, but to me its little more than egotistical snobbery.

Small minded people seem to like to make themselves feel superior by joining little clicks and putting down people outside of their group.

I use hand tools, machinery and if I had one i would use a CNC.

Mark Hennebury Craftsman.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#22

Not at all, quite clear in fact...

John in NM

You seem to be telling me that once this gentleman has programmed up his machine to make all the parts for these engines, there is still something that requires that he, the "craftsman", execute said programs. Spirit of craftsmanship if you must.

I disagree. CNC is called "PBD" for a reason - anyone can do it, given the program. The skill is in the program, the ability to visualize the part and translate it into a computer model, not at all in the machining itself. If you wish to argue that this skill is a craft, and its practitioner a craftsman, you may well have a good point.

Now the person who can produce the same engine on worn, conventional machine tools, with no DRO, and fit the parts together afterwards, that person is a craftsman.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#23

craigd

Maybe, maybe not

craigd

anyone can do it, given the program

Maybe it's because I'm a programmer, but this statement does seem quite condescending. It seems to imply, to me, that if I were to acquire Sam M's shop or tools, I could be cranking out pieces equal to his. A blue print is a program; if given one, could anyone make a iphone? A Bombe chest?

That engine is an incredible construction on so many levels and I suspect I would quite challenged just to assemble it if given the parts.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#24

That makes little sense to me...

John in NM

My very point is that you could not stick you or me in Sam M's (I'm assuming you mean Maloof) shop and expect similar results, I don't really see where you got that implication. You could however, stick you or me in a CNC factory and expect consistent results with minimal training -- that is the whole point of computer controled machinery. Why is a recognition that the skill is largely in the programming taken as condescending?

The reason I say what I do in the context of CNC is that the machine follows the program exactly the same, every time, to the same tolerances - assuming the machine is in good working order and the program does not work like some of the one off stuff we get where I work.

Human beings do not work this way. Part of craftsmanship is the discipline to execute repeat operations as consistently as possible - in some cases over years and years of work.

You are right however, that assembly would likely be difficult. I have little doubt that some extensive technical knowledge is required to avoid many mistakes, and that I could not assemble the thing as well as the guy who made it. Does that knowledge equate to craftsmanship? Honestly, I don't know.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#25

craigd

Re: That makes little sense to me...

craigd

My bad - I was upset with the "it's a program, anyone can push a button and recreate something" comment, which I feel can only be made by people who don't actually push buttons (I do agree that this is usually the case in a production environment). I was trying to draw an analogy between "a program is a tool just as a tablesaw is a tool" (in my view) to "it is the tool that makes the object" fallacy. So I agree with you on one level but think your definition of craftsmanship is much too narrow as I think someone who can assemble a Testor model into something that looks really sharp is a craftsman/person.

A CNC controlled machine used in a production environment (which may be where we disagree) is just being used as a cookie cutter. Nice if you need a zillion of something but probably not if that is your job.

Human beings do not work this way. Part of craftsmanship is the discipline to execute repeat operations as consistently as possible - in some cases over years and years of work.

I agree mostly. I just hates making the same thing over and over and over. Thus, I lack the discipline to dedicate the time to make nice hand cut dovetails when I can use my dovetail jig to get dovetails "exactly the same, every time, to the same tolerances". I'd rather get it done so I can implement my design/program to make something new [to me]. On the other hand, I've spent decades to understanding the foundations of computer science because I need that knowledge/skills to make the widgets I'm interested in. I'd like to think I'm a craftsman but maybe I'm delusional.

So, thinking about it, I suspect our differences are the scope of what craftsmanship is and how we express that definition.