My definition may indeed be too narrow...
John in NM
Such abstract concepts are almost impossible to put into words and have them be consistent 100% of the time - which is why we resort to examples and analogies to try to illustrate what we think craftsmanship "is".
There may be craftsmanship involved in programming - I don't do enough of it to know. I do work with a couple adequate programmers, and occasionally with one very good one. The good one is good because he wants his stuff to work perfectly and will put a lot of effort into finding bugs and fixing them. The other two just want their stuff to work well enough that the boss will leave them alone. Is this craftsmanship? Could be.
But pushing an analogy to it's extreme, say the guy who programs the CNC is like an author - the art is in the writing. Do we call the guy who prints the book a craftsman? What if they are one in the same guy. Is there something different enough about CNC work vs. printing to make my hyperbolic analogy nonsense?




