Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

Posts

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#26

My definition may indeed be too narrow...

John in NM

Such abstract concepts are almost impossible to put into words and have them be consistent 100% of the time - which is why we resort to examples and analogies to try to illustrate what we think craftsmanship "is".

There may be craftsmanship involved in programming - I don't do enough of it to know. I do work with a couple adequate programmers, and occasionally with one very good one. The good one is good because he wants his stuff to work perfectly and will put a lot of effort into finding bugs and fixing them. The other two just want their stuff to work well enough that the boss will leave them alone. Is this craftsmanship? Could be.

But pushing an analogy to it's extreme, say the guy who programs the CNC is like an author - the art is in the writing. Do we call the guy who prints the book a craftsman? What if they are one in the same guy. Is there something different enough about CNC work vs. printing to make my hyperbolic analogy nonsense?

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#27

craigd

Re: My definition may indeed be too narrow...

craigd

Opps, I didn't mean to imply I think programming was craftsmanship (although I do think that, I think most "pro" programmers would prefer something more exulted). I think your "good programmer" embodies, at least, the "spirit" of craftsmanship.

I also like you analogy of programmer to author. Having self published several books, making book look "good" is a real skill (I wish I had). The guys who do "old school" printing, where the "feel" (embossed, "depth" of ink, type of paper, etc) of the print is up there with the look, are true craftspeople. And then there are the people who illustrated printed text (like the Gutenberg bible, see below); I view that as a wonderful example of automation providing a base for a great work.

I get mixed up between the "act of" and the "result of" craftsmanship. The definitions I found seem to indicate it's both. And "by hand" vs "with machine" seems ambiguous. So your CNC/printing analogy works for me. I wouldn't think the person who presses the "go" button and pulls the part out is a craftsman unless they were also the person who typeset the work or is the programmer pulling a test part. But it gets fuzzy.

Definitions of craftsman (culled from five or so dictionaries):

Free dictionary:

- A man who practices a craft with great skill.

- a professional whose work is consistently of high quality

- a creator of great skill in the manual arts

- a skilled worker who practices some trade or handicraft

Merriam-Webster:

- a person who makes beautiful objects by hand

- a person who is very skilled at doing something


img

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER***

#28

It's In The Way That You Use It

charlie belden

to quote an Eric Clapton song.

One can make crappy pieces using just hand tools. And one can make nice pieces using a 5 or 6 axes CNC machine, a laser engraver or plasma cutter. The reverse, of course, is true.

It's in the way that you use it.