Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

Posts

Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#1

Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

Adrian

I have a Shop Vac branded vacuum that I use on my bandsaw. I use it with a cyclone separator connected to my small planer. I sometimes use it with the cyclone separator to vacuum hand plane shavings off the floor. I use it quite a bit when nothing else is running: with an unpowered sanding attachment, and to clean up.

I'm tired of the noise from this device. (And it was the "quiet" model of shop vac!) The only thing in the shop louder than the vac is the planer. So I'm looking for a quiet model. I looked at reviews in some of the magazines and one review I saw dismissed the noise of the vac as irrelevant because the tools are loud. Well, not for me. So from what I have found, I can choose either Festool or Fein if I want to be quiet. Is there anything else out there?

Right now I'm leaning towards the Fein III. Have you used this vac? Any advice? Any reason not to go with Fein? Any reason to spend even more to get a Festool? (The Festools seem so small that the bag will fill up quickly. I do prefer to use the bags.)

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#2

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

Howard Norman

I have not used the Fein III but I have two older models. They are both relatively quite and are still going strong after ten+ years.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#3

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

John McGaw

I have the Fein III and have been using it for around ten years. Yes, it is quiet -- but only when compared on the shop-vac noise scale. Clearly it is quieter than the two previous ones I had (Genie and another cheap brand IIRC) which were both capable of causing bleeding from the ears in close quarters. I suspect that any of the major European maker's vacuums would be relatively quiet because of more stringent safety rules.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#4

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

Merle

I have had my Nilfisk Attix 30 (used to be known as WAP brand) for a few years and it is quieter than the Fein by 1 dB. IIRC the prices were comparable, but the Attix came with more accessories. HTH

http://www.globalindustrial.com/p/janitorial-maintenance/floor-care/vacuums-wet-dry/nilfisk-alto-attix-30-wet-dry-vacuum

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#5

JL

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

JL

Have you considered an external dust collector? In a nice shielded addition?

You can put all sorts of stuff in between you and the noise.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#6

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

john Veerkamp

I have no experience with the Fein. I've had the smaller Festool for about 9 years. With the separator, I don't think you/ll have an issue with the bag size. It is "relatively" quiet, definitely better than Shop Vac, Craftsman, Ridged .etc.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#7

Interesting. Used mine last night...

Joe shelton

...for the first time. It's the turbo iii, and I ran a plate joiner with it. Wearing ear muffs, I couldn't tell the vacuum was on.

The big thing to me was that the small diameter hose got amazingly close to all the ejecta from the cuts, and was not cumbersome to use with the tool.

So far, I think it's terrific.

Joe

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#8

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

Larry in nw ohio

Adrian As JL said, if you could do it , I would look at the dust collectors. They are fairly expensive but they would last pretty much a life time, and they would do the job of 10 or more vacuums. If your planning to keep WW it would be well worth it. I did the vacuum thing years ago, and finally got tired of the dust and just plain messing around with them and just bought one. Good Luck with what ever you do. Larry

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#9

Nilfisk

Adrian

For some reason I had a hard time tracking this down. From my reading of spec sheets, the AS/E model is the one that would be comparable to the Fein since it has a suction control and the tool auto start feature.

http://www.acmetools.com/tools/NILFISK-ALTO+302004235+Attix+50+AS%26%2347%3BE+XC,+12+Gallon,+Wet%26%2347%3BDry+Vacuum

At $663 it's a significant increase from the Fein. Anybody used both who could say whether Nilfisk is worth the extra?

I suspect that it's not meaningful to compare sound specifications across manufacturers, so I don't think we can say much about the 1dB difference in claimed noise level.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#10

dust collector instead?

Adrian

I have thought now and then about them, but I guess I haven't seriously considered dust collectors. I have a small basement shop with a low ceiling, so I wonder about how a dust collector setup would work for me. I don't see a way I can "hide" it . Are there any quiet ones? I just looked up two, one from Penn and one from Grizzly and the claimed noise levels were 75 dB and 85 dB respectively. Also would a dust collector work for sanding?

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#11

Re: Interesting. Used mine last night...

Adrian

"Small diameter hose"? I thought the Turbo III had a 2.25" hose? I have had a hard time understanding the issue with the hose. The Turbo II is listed as having a 1.25" hose, which seems like a problem for hand plane shavings, but I got the impression that all the Fein models have the same hose hookup at the vacuum. Does the Turbo III have a 2.25" hose that connects to a 1.25" sized inlet on the vac?

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#12

Re: dust collector instead?

Larry in nw ohio

Adrian My ceiling in my basement is only 90 inches, and the area is 25x25 feet. If your basement is any lower you may not make what I have, it`s a 3 hp Oneida. There are shorter ones out there. I believe there is a company called JDS, and I think they have shorter ones, and as for noise, like mine runs around 75db. I`ll have to look it up, when I find a little more time. Also most of them may set in a 4x4 foot area. If you could work with that, I would really recommend one. Or I would at least look at them, never know, you may find something. I use mine when I sand all the time, of course you have to watch your hands so it doesn't suck up your sander or hand. Larry

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#13

Re: Nilfisk

Merle

Maybe the mfg has changed the Attix 30, but mine has both adjustable suction and auto start if you plug the tool into the vacuum. I would suggest calling (or live chatting) the vendor of your choice and ask them.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#14

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

Phil

I've been using the Fein II for over 13 years: Fein is the one you want.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#15

Clarification

Joe shelton

Adrian, sorry not to be more explicit. The vac does, as you say, come w/ a 2 1/4" hose. I also bought the 1 1/4" hose to use with small hand tools like routers and the biscuit joiner. I'd previously struggled when "necking down" large hoses on such tools.

The main point I was trying to make, though, was the much better collection of dust and shavings that I got, using a tool that had always before been an utter mess.

Joe

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#16

A.J. Hamler

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

A.J. Hamler

I'll echo what others have said. I have a Turbo I and a Turbo III and have used both for 13 or 14 years. Fantastic, quiet machines. I take the Turbo I into the house because it's so much quieter than the house vacuum.

A.J.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#17

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?) *LINK*

Lars Parrington

I've had a Turbo 1 for 3 years and think it's great. Much quieter than cheap shop vacs, but still loud enough to disrupt the tranquility of the shop. I'd guess it's just as loud as my 1.5hp single stage dust collector.

I make lots of handplane shavings, and they are very good at clogging the 1-1/4" hose on my Turbo 1.

The best way to get what you want might be to build your own vacuum. There is a great series of articles on the woodgears website about how to do that. See the link:


http://woodgears.ca/dust_collector/

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#18

Re: Clarification

Adrian

It's always great to avoid a mess. I'm not sure I understand you, though. Did you previously use a different vac and it worked less well? Or is the main thing that's making it work well the 1.25" hose?

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#19

turbo III hose connection?

Adrian

The turbo III is marked as coming with a 2.25" hose. But it seems that all three have compatible hose hookups. Does the hookup neck down to 1.25" on the turbo III or is it 2.25" all the way to the bag? Can you connect a 2.25" hose to a Turbo II and get a 2.25" wide path to the bag?

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#20

Re: Nilfisk

Adrian

I think the spec chart here is fairly clear about the different models:

http://www.nilfiskaltovacuums.com/images/stories/PDF/Nilfisk_ALTO_Attix_Brochure_WebRes.Nilfisk.pdf

At McFeelys they have two models, one clearly described as lacking auto start with tools and a different one for $200 more that is described as having this feature.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#21

Re: turbo III hose connection?

John McGaw


On my Fein III the opening from the side of the drum to the inside of the bag (see picture) is all pretty much the same size of approximately 2-1/4". Right inside the drum-to-hose fitting there is a deflector that prevents big chunks from flying straight in and shredding the bag but the restriction is pretty minimal.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#22

Re: Clarification

Joe shelton

Yes. I used Shop Vacs for a while, but after the second one died, I tried Ridgid. Mine are very loud, but effective for many uses. They are not effective with routers and plate joiners, due to having big hoses, which must have cumbersome "neck down" attachments. I got tired of having to duct tape things together to run a tool. You may be more dexterous than I.

Joe

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#23

Re: Clarification

Adrian

The hose that came with my shop vac is a 2.25" hose that is very rigid and hard to work with. I suspect I'd have trouble using it with a router, like your experience. I bought an aftermarket hose kit from Lee Valley:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=49304&cat=1,42401,62621,49304

This is probably not as good for use with a router as a smaller hose, but it works OK. I also needed an adapter---I avoided the need for duct tape. This hose is excellent, flexible and smooth on the inside.

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#24

Fein vacs ever go on sale?

Adrian

Anybody ever see these vacs on sale? Or is it the same price all the time?

Re: Seeking QUIET shop vac (Fein?)

#25

Re: Fein vacs ever go on sale?

John McGaw

If by "on sale" you mean "for less than the MSRP" then, yes, they go on sale. If you mean "cheap" then, no, they never go on sale. You can buy a Turbo III at Amazon (and earn a small kickback for WC if you follow the link here) for maybe $120 less than the MSRP and digging around online you may find it for a few bucks less than that but probably not much less. Even the bags are expensive as many have complained although I've found that a single bag will last for a long time with my typical usage. Hint: make sure that you buy the HEPA filter if the one you choose doesn't come with one -- it makes all the difference in the world when it comes to keeping the air clean.