Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

My Visit with the Nakashimas

Posts

My Visit with the Nakashimas

#1

My Visit with the Nakashimas

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I just got back from a trip out to New Hampshire to visit family. Along the way we stopped in New Hope, PA for a planned tour of Nakashima Woodworking Studio. Only a few times a year the workshops and studios are available for a full guided tour. I was lucky enough to get a tour slot (there were about 20 in the tour) and planned our vacation accordingly.

Just as background, I am a long time fan of the work of George Nakashima. I have read "Soul of a Tree" (wonderful book) and have admired his designs. George passed away in 1990 but his legacy lives on thru his daughter, Mira. Mira is a wonderful designer and woodworker in her own right.

Fortunate for me, the tour was given by Mira and her son (also an artist and legacy of Nakashima woodworking). Nakashima was an architect, and over many years designed and built a compound of several buildings to serve as workshops, living spaces, showroom and design studios. Each building is unique and some were built originally as experimental, but remain today. Each building is facinating in its own way.

As a long time admirer of Nakashima's work, the tour gave me amazing insight into the work. Many might be surprised by how small the actual work spaces are. The main workshop was no larger than mine.....just the basics for power tools. All tools were older machines. The workshop was not a production shop. Rather, it was a shop where individuals would make furniture, one order at a time.

The finishing shop was, again, small and confined. No spraying equipment. Just a small area where pieces were hand oiled...one order at a time. The last actual working space was the chair room. Once again....very small space where spindles were made and chairs assembled.

So were there any large spaces? Oh yes. As anyone familiar with Nakashima's work might guess, the very large buildings were reserved for the storage of wood.....and lots of it! Thousands of square feet of slabs, stacked in sequence in very tall stacks. Walnut was predominent but there were huge stacks of burled slabs, cherry and assorted other amazing woods.

To visit all of the buildings gives you an opportunity to see entire rooms filled with George and Mira's work. Simply awesome. To see the evolution of Nakashima's designs really helped me further understand his work.

Best of all perhaps was being given the tour by Mira and her son. Rather than a scripted form of tour, the tour was very much candid and spontaneous. Not only was there much focus on their work, but also about the life of George, philosphy, and the evolution of their business.

The entire compound was facinating and beautiful. The setting and grounds were likewise beautiful. Mira was very gracious as the tour took over 2 hours and she answered any questions. Mira is now in her 60's but still energetic about the business. From what I could tell of her son, I believe the legacy of Nakashima will live on.

I will never forget that experience. And I highly recommend the tour.

T.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#2

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

it's nice when our heros live up to our expectations of then.

Robin

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#3

So True

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

The entire experience was what I hoped it would be. The Nakashimas are the real deal. No pretentions, just masters who live by their humble philosophy, craftsmanship and aesthetic. In our hyper-drive, CNC, commercial world, the visit for me was affirming and satisfying.

T.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#4

Those trips are good for the soul...

Dick Coers

Congrats on your trip. I've made many trips over the years to places I read about in Fine Woodworking in the "old days". Like you said, each will stay with you the rest of your days. My favorite was to College of the Redwoods for a weekend design class with Krenov in 1998. I was on my way to represent Woodworker's Journal at a woodworking show in Anahiem, and I got the editor to pay for the weekend class as long as I did a story. As they say, win/win! With alll that wood sitting around in Pa., I've always wondered if they have any pest infestation. I've never seen a place with sheds full of wood, that doesn't have some powder post beetles. It took a lot of patience and courage to keep that business going after George's death. I think I saw an interview on tv where she said nearly all the orders were cancelled when he died.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#5

Wood Storage

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Mira was asked about wood pests. All the wood they take in has been dried and checked before entering their storage warehouse. It is off the floor and stacked in sequenced log form. The slabs are enormous. She indicated that they employ moisture and temp. control to deter any such critters.

No surprise, they are preferred customers of Hearn Hardwoods too. But their logs come from all over the world. They are generally sawn by a sawyer they trust in that area.

T.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#6

prove it

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

I have seen photos of the wood hoard and would enjoy seeing more. Did you take any photos??

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#7

Unfortunately....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

....per request of the Nakashimas..."no photos please". But it was tempting!

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#8

A dissenting view

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I may be the only person on the planet that is not smitten by this furniture style. I admit, I just don't "get it". It strikes me as a carefully chosen piece(s) of wood, indeed, but with little added to it. I may be missing something but given the same hunk of wood it seems to me that any experienced woodworker could reproduce an equivalent piece.

I hold in much higher regard the craftsman that can take a plain piece of wood and join it/carve it, shape it into something of beauty and function- Maloof. Krenov, Townsend, Goddard, any Cartouche winner, or the hundreds of others.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#9

Re: A dissenting view

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Bill,

I respect your point of view and I am glad you are honest about it.

A couple of things I note about it. When Nakashima first created his work, it was the 1940's. For that time period, such work was a very bold expression.

Given that his work can sell for $Six Figures, and has been ripped off so often, I have to believe his work has power.

I myself struggle with the demons of creating what I want versus bending to the marketplace. Nakashima's work never wavered from before he was known to the day he died. His work was his own.

But at the end of the day, as with so many creative works, beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

T.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#10

Kneale Brownson

And the eye of a craftsman


Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#11

Re: Wood Storage

Keith Newton

Congrats Thomas, George was a great inspiration for me as well. I bought his book when it cam out, and it had an influence on my perception of trees, and the wood within.

I'd like to take that tour sometimes too. I have to give George credit for inspiring my first Arborescent table, which I've done many versions of, large and small.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#12

Did they issue a drool bucket?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I would think they would need something like that to maintain their moisture control in the sheds; if they let me in, the drool puddle would likely cause the humidity to spike!

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#13

Re: Too Narrow A View

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I think you've formed your opinion based on a mild case of tunnel vision, Bill. G.N. did a large amount of work well beyond the slab-element pieces you seem to focus upon. While he refined the use of "live edge" tables, his cabinetry, joinery, and design vocabulary, a fusion of his architectural training and Japanese heritage, make his work quite unique.

While your taste seems to run to more Western Traditional design elements, you might enjoy picking up a book on his work at your library.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#14

still don't get it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You over estimate the offerings in the Church Hill, TN library. :) I had a 6th grade teacher who I hated. Beyond the course work required from each teacher she taught me something as important as any other teacher. She once told me(probably screamed at me) to "challenge my prejudices". It made an impression and I still remember. While not always successful at taking her advice, I did respond to your challenge and visit the shop's web site of stuff and looked at most of the offerings in all the categories.

My impression was nice pieces of wood assembled into stark, minimalist , to me hostile, designs. While it may take exceptional talent to design these pieces it did not appear that it took exceptional skill to build them. (but then I became vastly more impressed with Krenov after I actually built something similar to one of his "simple" looking pieces.) No denying the style is popular, the shop is successful, but I still don't get it. I would not be comfortable living with anything I saw nor overly impressed by the person that put it together.

I could not be comfortable living with Queen Anne furniture either. But I can understand that the designs could be pleasing to some that like formal stuff and reproducing them takes skill few will ever acquire.

So, while broadening my knowledge in this journey, I remain unsmitten and bewildered by the popularity. I have an artist friend whose opinion and advice I respect. I'll get her to tutor me on a trip back to the web site.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#15

Re: still don't get it

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

Nobody is required to like anything or everything, but I am not sure what criteria you are using to dislike his work. He wanted the natural beauty of the wood itself to be the main focus of his natural edge stuff, and I think he is successful in letting his design get out of the way of the wood. That is all he is doing IMO. It is a simple concept, but as Tom Skaggs points out, a fairly revolutionary one in the 40s. You may not like the result, but you have to give him some points for originality. Think of it: a genuine original thought, successfully expressed!

If you dislike the fact that his designs look simple and uncomplicated or easy to build, well I suppose you are welcome to judge them on those features if you like. But you do not care for Queen Anne designs either, and not based on those same criteria. So you might as well admit to us that your opinions and taste are nothing but the frazzled ends of short circuited nerve endings (kidding).

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#16

ROAD TRIP!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

As you're not all that far away take a trip in this direction and go through the Nakashima facility and on-site gallery. You could also stop by the Esheric home/gallery on your way home.

Best way I know to "get it". :)

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#17

Re: Too Narrow A View

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I am sometimes surprised how difficult it can be to design simple forms that really work. Take away the gorgeous wood and GN's forms offer simple beauty. Similar can be said for Naguchi and later on, many of the great Danish and Bauhaus designers.

Interesting to me that sometimes fancy is easy but simple can be difficult.

T.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#18

Me neither...

John in NM

Live edge tables just don't do it for me... I've seen one or two other pieces that I liked ok, though nothing I've found earth shaking. I've also seen a piece or two that I positively loathe.

More interesting to me is the reaction of any famous designers' fans when confronted with negative or even simply unenthusiastic feedback on a forum such as this one.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#19

Here's a tease

Kevin French

http://www.nakashimawoodworker.com/inventory/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/34822101@N08/8730584462/in/photostream/

Then do a Google image search

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#20

Interesting?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Reaction?

Care to expand on that?

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#21

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Tommy, Tommy, Tommy! I live right down the road from there and Ellis not all that far from me. You should have told us you were coming--we'd have planned a party!

I get my wood from the sawyer who cuts most of Mira's wood. His yard is filled with trees of hers, cut and stacked, waiting to be turned into something interesting. Between the yard and the stash on her property, she has more wood than they can use in a lifetime. Or two!

I meet Mira from time to time at a music event held in Bucks County. I had on a WC shirt once there while I was helping run audio and video for the musicians. Her brother saw the shirt and snagged her to come meet me and discuss woodworking. They were very genuine and down-to-earth and a delight to talk with. I'm so glad you got to visit and have a personal tour with her.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#22

It can go any direction one likes...

John in NM

Lots of things to ponder here, and the variety of responses prompt some of the directions of thought that a person doesn't always follow on their own.

For example, as I do not much care for GN's work, I rarely think about it, or other work that doesn't appeal to me. For that reason I tend not to consider how a revolutionary designer's work may be viewed decades after their revolution. That is one thing that occurred to me reading the posts with such different views of GN's work, regardless of which one I happen to agree with. Honestly, I don't know if there is anything deeper than fashion going on with any designer or even style. I tend to think there is, but there is no way I can prove it.

Aren't the interesting subjects the ones where we don't already know the answer?

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#23

Similar subject to art.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Having studied art in college, I can tell you that I have been in my share of discussions about "what is art" or about why some modern art can be lauded by some and hated by others.

Variety is the spice of life I suppose.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#24

Re: Direction of  "Likes"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Whether one "likes" a design (possibly qualifying as a "fan") is less important than appreciating the designer's/work's merits. I can appreciate good Queen Ann or French Provincial design, but you'll never find a piece of it in my home. I can appreciate well done carved relief but I don't do it because I don't care for it as a matter of personal taste and design preference.

GN brought slab and live-edge into the mainstream of fine furniture, but that's far from all he did. Bill's comment seemed to pigeon-hole GN, so I (and Tommy) suggested he broaden his exposure. I know enough of Bill's work to anticipate that were he to stroll through the GN gallery he would, after all, "get it" as to what George was really about, and might even find stuff he "liked" on some level.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#25

Sounds like its time for a picture...

John in NM

Bill didn't do the pigeon holing, his comments simply reflect the general view of many woodworkers who are aware of Nakashima's but have seen only a handful of pieces.

It could be that there is a good reason that he is known for that one thing, and it could also be that popular culture has been unfair to him in pigeon holing him this way.

This would be a great time to see an example of what you are talking about.