Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

My Visit with the Nakashimas

Posts

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#26

Re: Sounds like its time for a picture... *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Click and Scroll, Baby, Scroll!

But here's a taste




Nakashima

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#27

I discovered my problem.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been associated with saw mills in one way or another for many years. The task of the mill is to take a log and saw away the defects to yield attractive lumber to make attractive furniture.

The case in hand retains these defects -edges, knots and the like- of the lumber to yield furniture novel and presumably attractive. Low grade logs are sawed to yield low grade lumber to make novel furniture, as I look at it.

Those neurons you spoke of short circuit from the conflict.......... :) It would send lumber graders into therapy.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#29

getting specific....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I saw this piece when I went on a search to see what pictures I could find and indeed, found it to be the most attractive of any I saw.

There was a lot I liked. The wood is lovely and of course attractively matched. I'll admit on this one that the joinery is not trivial. But the huge rails across the top and bottom kill it for me. They, well, look crude. The base is way cool, but seems out of place from what is sitting on it. Maybe someone skilled in art can tell me how they go together.

I am left with no doubt that Thomas would have rendered this piece of wood into something I would have liked better. Ditto Krenov (to be clear I gag on his philosophical mumbo jumbo but I like many of his lite designs)

I also like "Federal Llite" , a style I apparently coined a name for some time ago. It is Federal with much of the show-off adornments removed and it is sized to fit my house.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#30

Re: I discovered my problem.....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't know whether you still make your annual pilgrimage to the BWCA, Bill, but if you do, I have a recommendation for you.

The MN Landscape Arboretum is just west of Chanhassen on MN Highway 5. Most of the library at the Arboretum was designed and built by Nakashima. The collection includes a couple slab tables and several of his conoid chairs, as well as a variety of other pieces. It's worth the side trip if you still come up this way. Let me know and I'll meet you there for lunch or something.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#31

Call Ahead

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

We'll meetcha :D

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#32

On the one hand...

John in NM

There are several pieces there that I like a lot, tables in particular, even with live edges :D

I'm afraid that cabinet you posted is not one of them. I pretty much agree with Bill's critique of it, though I think I find the base vs. boxy mass a bit more annoying than he did. Just looks kind of top heavy and awkward.

And then there are all the others, I'm afraid I will never end up being one of the converted. I'll spare you all the gritty details, no need to turn this into a troll-fest :D

Still way better than any Frank Gehry buildings though :D

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#33

Make No Mistake

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Every item with George's name on it doesn't necessarily float my boat. I tend to favor his table work over his cabinetry, but the overriding allure is his reverence for any particular piece of tree and how he allowed the wood to speak for itself rather than trying to make it speak for him. Since I tend to favor minimalist design principals and much of "Eastern" aesthetics, perhaps the preference is built-in. :D

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#34

that part I get

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"reverence for any particular piece of tree and how he allowed the wood to speak for itself rather than trying to make it speak for him"

"rather than trying to make it speak for him"....um, I guess that is what we are doing at the saw mill.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#35

Figured You Would 


Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#36

Re: Make No Mistake

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Not to sidetrack the point, but one interesting thing I learned was that George almost never signed his work. If one ever finds a piece that is signed, it is a rare find. About the only time he ever signed a piece is when a client twisted his arm enough....rarely happened.

What is more likely written on the bottom is the name of the client the piece was made for.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#37

Soul of a Tree

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Bill, your philosophy is shared by many. I certainly respect that. Years ago I read GN's book "the Soul of a Tree". It opened my eyes to other perspectives about nature, trees and how we approach nature from a design perspective.

Trees are rarely "perfect". The cracks, bark inclusions, and even bug damage tell the "biography" of each tree. When we (including me at times) mill lumber to remove the "defects" we are removing the history of the tree. In a sense, we are imposing our will upon nature.

Nakashima lived by a different philosophy. He chose to celebrate the history of the tree from where the wood came from. It was as much a design expression as a showing a reverence for the tree itself.

His adoption of the philosophy and how he applied it to furniture was somewhat revolutionary for its time. However, it is much like a philosophy that dates back centuries in Asia.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#38

What's In A Name

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Has to drive gallery owners and insurance adjusters nuts.

Just the reverse from Sr. Picasso!

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#39

It does!!  "Knockoffshimas"

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Mira made a joke about all of the copied or ripped off designs made over the years. She said they call them "knockoffshimas".

They get several requests each week to authenticate his work. Most are fakes. But they have a few ways of telling. Often, visual inspection reveals fakes. But also, they have kept records of his orders back thru the 50's. They still have them on 3X5 cards. (more current work was on computer). They will look for the client's name (written on the piece) and then go back thru the records to find the order and confirm that it corresponds to the piece.

That said, if anyone is considering laying out big bucks, best to get that authentication....buyer beware!!

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#40

Au-then-ti-ca-shun

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Ol' Pablo drove dealers and buyers crazy because his "style" and "hand" were so easy to forge and he was so prodigiously productive yet sloppy with records. A piece would be sent to him for authentication. Apparently, if he liked it, he said it was his. If he didn't, he called it a fake, regardless of whether he'd actually painted it or not!

Gotta love it!

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#41

Polar Opposites

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Come to think of it, George and Pablo were about as polar opposite as you can get! Massive ego compared to massive humility.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#42

This Discussion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Has turned Bi-polar.

[miss you, Colonel . .]

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#43

continuing the discussion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I get that part. Now considering that I have not devoted extensive study to this matter and may not have the ability to do so.......

Hasn't George and Krenov started at the same place, a respect(or what even one should call it) for the wood. But they have developed it into vastly dissimilar ways. Krenov has removed(well had the mill remove) the knots and bark and used and arranged the color and patterns of what is left for his stuff. To my eye the Krenov designs are more refined and accommodating. I would like to stroke and cuddle them. George's often remain hostile to me.

And while we are on this topic I have discovered why I am less smitten and impressed by current style as I see it in galleries, than "classic" styles. It's about the talent required to make the stuff. The current emphasis is on the wood and less on the shaping and assembly of pieces. The furniture becomes an art project of selecting a novel/attractive/spectacular/gaudy/etc. piece of wood. The shaping/ joining/assembly can become the afterthought.

This Steve Latta table in "Federal Lite" style is an example of a modern piece that emphasizes shape over tree souls. I'd like to hug its shapely form.


Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#44

Been there, done that.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Bill,

That is a lovely piece indeed. I cut my woodworking teeth in the genre of Federal form. Attached is a photo of a piece I designed and built in my early days. I still have a great appreciation for period styles, especially Federal.

T.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#45

Re: Call Ahead

Don Orr

What about setting up a WoodCentral event for a tour of the place? I bet it would draw folks in from quite a ways away-including me!

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#46

Now that is funny

John in NM

I wonder if he did that out of a sense of humor... assuming it's true of course :D

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#47

Funny It Is

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Got that from a NYC Gallery owner who tried to get a written provenance out of Pablo. Confirmed what I'd heard from an Art History prof. some years before. The version I received came with the statement that it was Picasso's goof on the whole art-as-investment rigamarole.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#48

Re: Too Narrow A View

Jesse Cloud

There's another polar opposite. Some dislike Nakashima's work because it fails to display the craftsanship of the woodworker and that is a reasonable point of view.

Personally, I am more likely to be disappointed in work that tries too hard to prove the craftsmanship of the woodworker to the detriment of clean design.

Re: My Visit with the Nakashimas

#49

I agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Much Period furniture and some student furniture falls into this category.