Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

I finished my first guitar

Posts

I finished my first guitar

#1

I finished my first guitar

GolfSteve in Calgary

I finished my first guitar - a classical guitar based on the John Bogdanovich plans & DVD, modified to include a cutaway. I started construction in about March 2012 and finished June 01, 2013. I have no idea how many hours I spent - probably around 200 hours plus another 200 hours looking up stuff on the Internet.

The guitar is loud with very clear trebles and nice deep bass. Lots of sustain and sympathetic vibrations between the strings.

Italian red spruce top (sourced on a business trip to Hearne Hardwood in Pennsylvania).

East Indian rosewood & yellow cedar sides.

EIR back and bridge.

Curly mahogany binding.

Spanish cedar neck.

Ebony fingerboard.

Maple burl in rosette.

Gotoh premium tuners.

Shellac and Mohawk nitrocellulose lacquer finish.

I posted numerous construction photos here if you care to look: https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.10150707942520772.422729.569885771&type=1&l=63e80d3519

The hardest part of the construction was bending the binding strips (with side purfling) for the cutaway. I broke or had kinks in about 8 binding strips before I got it right. I wouldn't recommend a cutaway on a builder's first guitar unless they only plan to build one guitar in their life. I will also avoid using curly mahogany for binding a cutaway - too fragile at the thickness you need to achieve the bend.

The most stressful part of the construction was routing the binding channels. I still have the shakes from that.

The rosette looks great. I thought that would be difficult, but it turned out to be relatively easy except it consumed about a million dollars worth of veneer. Using the Bogdanovich method you make enough herringbone to complete numerous guitars.

I have a pretty well set-up shop, but I still spent a small fortune on wood and specialty items. The biggest unplanned cost was when I bought a heating blanket and controller after I had so much trouble bending the binding on a hot iron. For the most part I avoided buying unnecessary specialty tools, but did get sucked into a few that, in hindsight, were not necessary. I ran out of veneer a couple of times and could not find a local source, so that got expensive.

I thought the Bogdanovich book and DVD were very good. There were a few mistakes and inconsistencies, but overall the instructions were top notch. I had a few questions and John was kind enough to answer them for me.

Finishing a guitar is strangely satisfying compared to completing any other woodworking project.

Now my poor old Taylor DN4 steel string, which I used to love, sits unused and lonely in the corner...











Re: I finished my first guitar

#2

Re: I finished my first guitar

mark valsi

My meagre vocabulary fails me, I must resort to the vulgate: Awesome, dude !!!

WOW !!

Re: I finished my first guitar

#3

All that and cute daughters, too?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Beautiful guitar. Just lovely.

And the two lovely ladies posing next to it in one picture..you're a lucky man, too, in addition to talented.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#4

Bob

Re: I finished my first guitar

Bob

All I can say is WOW Wow.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#5

Re: I finished my first guitar

Mark Hennebury

Beautiful work, great construction photos and incredible lacquer job!

I can well understand your anxiety at using the router for the binding grooves, at that stage in the game you have a lot to lose.

The photos of the jigs and construction give a good idea of the Skill, time, effort, planning, patience and discipline required to execute each operation as it was the only one. It requires this kind of mindset and commitment to achieve such a fine piece of work and its not every day that we get to see something this impressive.

Very nicely done!

Re: I finished my first guitar

#6

Re: I finished my first guitar

Tom

Just by the by, while virtually everyone building these days is heavily into the jigs, masterpiece classical guitars can be built with nothing other than a bending pipe and a 2x4 to set the action. And it isn't harder to do that way, probably easier. The Bogdanovich method uses laminated sides which would be a trade against the pipe. Pipe bending is easy, except when you have thick sides or expensive sides, or no time to get replacements. The technique is easy, however. I had a Fox bender when I was building classicals, frankly because I wanted to see how it worked, but also because one elite builder said that even as good as he was he occasionally lost a side because the wood was bad, which normally does not ever happen with the bender. Tropical woods do not have visible grain due to the lack of any growth seasons, so you can be bending a 1000 dollar piece of wood with no idea of whether it has run-out or not.

Love that finish Steve. Congrats on a beautiful project.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#7

Re: I finished my first guitar

roger lance

Steve.....what a wonderful, magnificent accomplishment!!....congratulations.... beautiful looking instrument.....an exceptional finish.....and, from your description, great sound as well....Happy Father's Day.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: I finished my first guitar

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Every detail, every small element Steve is perfect... wow, this is an amazing work, your skills and pride are shining in those sweet faces too. I have a feeling this will NOT be your last guitar, it's always a pleasure to see your work, this one maybe your very best yet!

Take care,

Jim

Re: I finished my first guitar

#9

Maybe you should ...

Mike Farinella

change your handle to "Guitar Steve"! Absolutely stunning!

Re: I finished my first guitar

#10

Uh oh

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Steve, Steve, Steve! You forgot something! You spend all those hours and that money to make such an gorgeous instrument and you leave out the headstock logo for your "brand"?! I don't even see a label inside the sound hole (although that is easily added). You must left everyone know that this is your incredible craftmanship!

I know exactly that fear you had in routing the binding channels--I built a bowed psaltery for a friend. It had a zillion tuning pins and hitches to drill for and install. I kept waiting for the whole thing to crack, but it held solid. Thanks for sharing your beautiful instrument and construction notes. Well done. And that finish is amazing!

Re: I finished my first guitar

#11

Impressive

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Stringed instruments amaze me. They seem so frail compared to what must be huge forces from the string tension.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#12

Re: Uh oh - Just by the by

Tom

Classical guitars, the headstock style is the logo, they don't generally have a inlaid name. Partly because of lack of space, though it was never traditional. The soundhole label is a classic, but I never personally felt that good about it, or had a better idea. I prefer the woodwork to show up, not a piece of paper. I suspect the reverse was how the ancients felt about it. The didn't finish the inside of the instrument that well, and applying actual finish can be a bad idea, so the paper occupied the area of the main sightlines. These days guitars are often very nicely completed on the inside, and the use of player soundholes makes the whole interior open to view. Most people still have some kind of label in there. It is another place for people to show their creativity.

Steel string guitars, inlaid names, etc... very common.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#13

Re: Impressive

Tom

In general the forces on guitars from classical strings, about 100 pounds are pretty manageable. SS guitars are about double that amount, and those forces do tend to have an affect that requires some serious response, like steel truss rods, and fairly massive internal braces. It is always a struggle though, as making the instrument strong is relatively easy, keeping it responsive somewhat less so, and having a truly musical instrument, very nearly impossible.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#14

Dale Lenz

Very Impressive

Dale Lenz

Something I know nothing about but I'm in Awh!

Re: I finished my first guitar

#15

Re: Uh oh

GolfSteve in Calgary

I tried to design a paper label that I liked but failed. I decided to put a simple signature, which I kind of like:


There is also a private message inside the guitar, and my daughters are the only people who know the "secret". You can see the writing on the underside of the top in this photo


As far as "logos", a lot of classical builders use the rosette as their trademark.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#16

Fantastic-outstanding-wonderful, etc.!!!


Re: I finished my first guitar

#17

I love interior secret messages....

Dick Coers

I built the altar for the church where I grew up. I wanted to donate it in honor of my Dad who had passed away. They didn't like that idea, being a sacred piece in the church. So there is a copy of a newspaper from the day I worked on it, and a lengthy message about my Dad in marker on the inside. Don't know if it will ever need that extensive of repair, but if it gets torn down someday, they will see the surprise. Also brought pleasure to my family when I told them. Fantastic job on the guitar!!!!!

Re: I finished my first guitar

#18

Re: I finished my first guitar

GolfSteve in Calgary

Hi Mark and Tom,

Mark - thanks for the kind words about time, effort, planning, etc. A guitar is not much more difficult that a typical furniture construction project. You just need to take the time to understand:

1. What is important - certain dimensions are critical; others are just a guideline. You need to know.

2. Think ahead. For example, signing the back is almost impossible after it is glued onto the body.

3. Understand how good is "good enough" to satisfy your quality goal.

4. Build your skills. For example, bending wood on a hot pipe was a new skill for me and I could learn it during the construction process. However, your glue-up skills should be well advanced before attempting a guitar as some of the glue-ups are difficult, need good planning, and informed glue selection.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#19

Re: I finished my first guitar

GolfSteve in Calgary

Hi Tom. The solera used to set the neck angle and the forms to do the laminations are pretty useful, and practically essential if you're going to use laminated sides. The other jigs he uses to cut the joinery and shape the heel block are good if you're in production mode, but I didn't make them 'cause it's less time consuming to do that work by hand when building a single guitar.

The EIR sides were bent freehand on a hot pipe, then laminated to the yellow cedar using the side lamination form. Bending was easy. The glue-up was a challenge. Next time I think I would use epoxy instead of white glue to give myself more time.

The solera was useful for setting the neck angle, developing the 25' radius on the top, and keeping the centreline aligned. I really liked the solera method.

Re: I finished my first guitar

#21

Re: I finished my first guitar

waroland

AWESOME!

Re: I finished my first guitar

#22

Ellis Walentine

Wonderful job, Steve

Ellis Walentine

And, thanks for showing the fan bracing photo. It's always interesting to me to get a sense of the amount and type of structure supporting the top. Did you go through a process of scalloping braces to tune the stiffness of the top?

I know what you mean about bending mahogany (curly or not). Pretty frustrating. Was there a reason for your choice?

You say your dreadnought sits unused. Did your style of playing change now that you've got a classical guitar? Are you picking leads up there in the cutaway zone?

Inquiring pickers want to know... :)

Re: I finished my first guitar

#23

Re: Wonderful job, Steve

GolfSteve in Calgary

The dreadnought was my first guitar. Over time I found that it was too large for me to play comfortably. I mostly play fingerstyle and found I was drifting to the nylon side, so it made sense to make myself a nice small classical guitar. It is much more comfortable for me to hold and play.

Over time I also found myself not liking the sound of the B string and high E string on the dreadnought - they were too bright and overpowering. The nylon string guitar provides much mellower treble notes, but they still ring clear like a piano, and not as brassy as the steel string.

Achieving bright treble strings was a goal when building the guitar. A lot of nylon string guitars have very dull sounding treble strings. I had no idea how to achieve a bright tone, other than a pledge that I would not overbuild the structure, so maybe I just got lucky.

I thought the curly mahogany would go nicely with the East Indian Rosewood - simply a visual preference.

The plans I followed did not have a cutaway, and recommended a binding thickness of 90/1000". This was too thick for the cutaway bend to be successful so, by trial and error, I reducef the binding thickness to 55/1000" before the bends were successful.

I scalloped the to braces by eyeballing the dimensions from what I saw on Bogdanovich's DVD. The top had a nice ring to it, so I was happy leaving it at that.

For the back braces, Bogdanovich tunes each brace until the tap tone obtained by tapping directly over each brace provides a different tone from the other braces.