Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Bench Dogs

Posts

Bench Dogs

#1

Bob

Bench Dogs

Bob

I'm about to put my bench together and was wondering if I choose to use square bench dogs should I will cut then using my dado blade before glue up but my question is... Should there be a slight angle say 2 - 3 degrees to compensate for the force of the vice pushing into the dog? Also why would I want to use round dogs if they slip while clamping other then straight and square work surfaces.

Re: Bench Dogs

#2

Re: Bench Dogs

roger lance

with square dogs there is an angle of 2°- 4° on both the dog strip and opposing movable vise block....be sure to lean these two angles toward each other (does not work otherwise).

Re: Bench Dogs

#3

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Bench Dogs

#4

Bench features can be highly personal

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

The details of the "ideal" bench depend on the details of how one works wood.

Those enamored with building shop furniture may build a complicated bench styled from some past time period for the challenge of it with less thought as to how they will actually use its features. I have a theory that benches from times past had all sorts of complexity to enable fastening stuff to the bench because they lacked thickness planers, routers(shapers) and inexpensive fast acting clamps. If you have these aids available a bench with a vise (or better yet a vise on each end) may be sufficient.

My bench has a substantial top overhang. This overhand plus a diverse assortment of "F" style clamps is sufficient to readily fasten down anything I need to for the style of woodworking I do (mixed hand and power tools).

That said, a few years ago I drilled a line of holes behind one vise and turned some round dogs of various heights on the lathe. I wish that I had drilled one hole and then drilled additional holes as the need arouse. then the holes would have been more optimally located. In fact a hole to the side of the vise has been more useful (to me but maybe not to anyone else). I do use dogs occasionally and never encountered any limitation that they were not square. I bought, but rarely use, a pair of hold downs, which only fit in round holes and don't fit behind the vise because the vise mechanism is in the way.

My recommendation would be to build a bench with no holes. If you see that dogs would be handy drill them where they will be handy. Drill a hole in some 2 to 2 1/2" hard wood for a drill guide. Clamp the guide to position the hole on the bench and drill it where it will be most useful to your kind of woodworking.

Re: Bench Dogs

#5

Re: Bench Dogs

William Duffield

Square dogs are an anachronism.

If you have problems with stock rotating, use a batten between two dogs.

Veritas has recently introduced these modern improvements to the batten, but if your dogs are carefully spaced, it's easy enough to make your own.

Planing Stop

It is vastly easier to drill two round dog holes and make two round dogs from 3/4" dowel stock than to make one square dog hole and one square dog.

If the Veritas holddown that David showed is too rich for your blood, the Gramercy holdfasts that Joel Moskowitz makes and sells at Tools for Working Wood, are bulletproof. They also work in 3/4" ø dog holes.

holdfasts

When you get tired of reaching under the bench to push that square dog up, Lee-Valley also makes these well trained Veritas puppies.

Prairie Dogs

Re: Bench Dogs

#6

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Bench Dogs

#7

Re: Not one to mince words, are we?

William Duffield

If your woodworking requires you to wear a poofy shirt and silver buckles on your shoes and to stop working when the sun goes behind the trees, then by all means, use square dogs. Or, if you work with a master like the one who taught Frank Klaus, and who will rap you on the knuckles any time you do something in a different manner than he was taught… :D They do work, in a rather limited way.

You're right about the potential brutality of the Gramercy holdfasts. They are not subtle tools, but the force can be mitigated by gluing leather pads or interposing a block of soft wood.

Re: Bench Dogs

#8

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Bench Dogs

#9

leather gluing question

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

What adhesive will reliably glue leather to the metal pad?

Re: Bench Dogs

#10

Bob

Re: Bench features can be highly personal

Bob

All very good points thank you. I bought a wagon vice so I will at least be putting in one row of holes. I had a plywood vice a year ago and used hold fasts often. I was just wondering if square vs. round dogs have any advantage.

Re: Bench Dogs

#11

Re: The Square Peg Flat Earth Society

William Duffield

What do you use for gluing the leather pads down? I've had them peel off of the Gramercy holdfasts due to the lateral forces involved in releasing them. Maybe I'm using the wrong leather? It was salvaged from a couch that my son and Golden Retrievers wore out after many years of hard use. I also have leather samples from a furniture store, and scraps from Michaels, but they all appear to be of similar quality, and much more fragile than you would expect to use in shoes, or saddles, or catchers mitts. OTOH, I'm not wanting to use Genuine Horse Butt for this purpose. It's way too expensive.

Note that there is less shear force on the pad if your mallet can access the bottom end of the holdfast under the bench. Tapping them sideways at the bottom of the shaft to release is a trick Chuck Bender showed me. It takes a lot less force than whacking them on the back of the top.

Re: Bench Dogs

#12

Bob

Re: leather gluing question

Bob

Hyde glue?

Re: Bench Dogs

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Bench Dogs

#14

Bob

Re: As one who's used both—my choice

Bob

What would you recommend for hole spacing?

Re: Bench Dogs

#15

Re: Bench Dogs

Lars Parrington

i also opted for round dogs when building my bench, and don't regret the choice at all. however, i think do think square dogs look cooler, and perhaps have an advantage when holding wide boards on edge.

i used an 8" spacing between holes, figuring i could easily convert it to a 4" spacing later if i felt the need. so far i haven't added the extra holes, but the shorter spacing would be useful when planing thin pieces that are narrower than the wagon vise gap.

for drilling the holes, i tried making two different simple jigs to help me drill perpendicular to the bench top, but ultimately found that i could actually get better results without the jigs. i used a bit brace to drill the holes, with a couple squares set on the bench for a visual reference. the squares are not even that helpful, the key is really the long length of bit + brace.

Re: Bench Dogs

#16

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Bench Dogs

#17

Re: I've used several, but prefer Barge's

William Duffield

I've been considering using E6000, and wondered if it was in any way similar to Barge's, but looking at their respective MSDSs (recently renamed SDSs), they are totally unrelated chemicals.

For leather to vise jaws, 3M 77 makes a lot of sense, especially when I can remove the jaw from the vise and stick the leather down with a J-roller. For gluing my horse butt to a block of hardwood, I recently used liquid hide glue because it was already warmed up to working temperature.

BTW, I got some of the 0.3µ Cr2O3 you recommended to charge the horse butt. I made a real mess mixing it with mineral oil and loading the syringe (sacrificing another syringe in the process), but I think it's all under control now. Hopefully, the hepa-filters in my vac caught all that I spilled before I got it wetted down. It's now in a Lee-Valley 25K07.05 (used by Steve Latta in his DVDs for controlling hide and yellow glue). Maybe tomorrow, I'll get around to sharpening a bunch of chisels.

Re: Bench Dogs

#18

where to buy Brage Cement

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

What sort of place would have it. I have never seen it.

Re: Bench Dogs

#19

Bob

Re: Spacing considerations—no set distance

Bob

Good food for thought, thank you. Right now I have two vices one is a wooden screw wagon vice the other is a leg vice. I plan to ad one more at the other end but I don't know which at this time.

Re: Bench Dogs

#20

craigd

Shoe store

craigd

Shoe repair stores is where I've always gotten it.

Re: Bench Dogs

#21

Attn Sir William: round dogs

Bruce, a MN Galoot

what do you use for a spring to hold your dogs in place, Sir William? Would you mind posting a pic?

Re: Bench Dogs

#22

Re: Attn Sir William: round dogs

William Duffield

I either use Veritas brass pups, that are factory equipped with a spring, or wooden dogs with a rectangular block on top, wedged in place, so they can't fall through. The blocks are various heights, lower ones for thinner stock. Usually, the dowel is offset, so the distance from its center to each face is different. That way, if I need to hold something kind of irregular between two rows of dogs, I can turn one around to fine adjust the distance between each pair of dogs. If I need to hold something very irregular, I can even take the block to the bandsaw and adjust the shape of one face.

I also have purpleheart dogs (4 of them) in my patternmaker's vise, that I use instead of the original cast iron dogs with steel springs. These wooden dogs use bullet catches set into the side.

Re: Bench Dogs

#23

A challenge to you round dog guys....

roger lance

so its overwhelmingly round dogs as the preferred method....I can understand this preference based on the ease of installation....but in 25 years, I've not found a situation that I could not hold down on my bench with square dogs or clamps....would one of you round dog supporters please post a pic of something round dogs can do and square dogs can not??

Re: Bench Dogs

#24

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Bench Dogs

#25

Re: Challenge accepted

roger lance

Cleaned it up I see....you run easily.