Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

sealing wood/which would you use?

Posts

sealing wood/which would you use?

#1

sealing wood/which would you use?

Mark M.

I've received great responses to my new project, that is, sealing a 4" wood disc cut from a log. I've been planning on making a tabletop but in the process of drying I'm trying to minimize or even eliminate the cracking. I heard of using propylene glycol, ethylene glycol and pentacryl. The pentacryl was very expensive with glycol being less than half the price. Has anyone had experience using either of the glycols and do they both displace water like the pentacryl is supposed to? P.s. I've used latex paint while cureing in a cool basement for several months but cracks still developed. Thanks in advance.

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#2

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

Robert Fuller

Using PEG will cause problems with finishing later. Not sure about the Pentacryl properties regarding finishes.

I have had some success by first sealing the end grain with latex paint, then using a ratcheting strap clamp around the slab and tightening it down real tight. Then I stood the slab on edge and every day I checked the strap and tightened it again. This worked OK for slabs that were 3" thick and 18.5" diameter. Not sure if it will work equally well on a larger slab.

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#3

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

Keith Newton

The PEG 1000 is also expensive, and would need a pretty large vat to heat and dissolve it for a piece that large, not to mention that the penetration depth would not likely be sufficient for that much thickness.

You can up your odds of success by cutting your cookie at 45º, rather than straight across. This gives the wood a path to relieve some of the differences between radial and tangental contractions as they dry. Then, you might could just get by putting it in a large cardboard box, to slow down the drying.

As you look down on your cross section of a tree, the wood shrinks about two times as much around each annual ring, as it does from the heart straight out.

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#4

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I have a friend that makes drums by cutting concentric cylinders from sections of a log. All of his cutting is done while to wood is green and as you can imagine drying has been his biggest issue. He has had good resuts using pentacryl and if the end grain is submerged the entire piece of wood does not need to be submerged because it will draw the pentacryl up via capilary action.

Robin

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#5

I'll puzzled

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A 4" disk of many woods will dry without splitting if done slowly.

It will help to know the physics behind the situation. Wood shrinks about twice as much tangent to the growth rings as perpendicular to them (tangential vs radial shrinkage). Hence, the circumference of the log section is trying to shrink twice as much as the diameter as it dries. This fact puts tension on the circumference which is relieved by cracking.

However, this difference in a 4" log section is not much. Pick a species that has radial shrinkage close to tangential. These data can be found in various books on wood. Sycamore and ash are good possibilities. Red cedar disks can be successfully dried.

Or, add something nonvolatile that will displace water and keep the wood from shrinking such as polyethylene glycol.

Another possibility is to boil the pieces before drying. This process does something that makes the wood dry more favorably with less tension.

Turners claim that drying by putting the wood in dry ethanol will enable drying while minimizing shrinkage. There is some science to support this claim.

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#6

Re: Puzzled

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Not much of a table from a 4 inch disc. Think, maybe it might be a 4' [foot] disc for that table? Typos can be soo misleading :D

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#7

I Read it as....

Howard Acheson

.... 4" thick not diameter. I don't see anything that specifies the diameter of the item

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#8

Easily Correct 


Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#9

Re: Puzzled

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I thought he was assembling a top from many 4" disks. I have seen a table done this way. but 4', no way to dry that.

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#10

Alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Let your wood dry and crack however it will (there may have been internal fractures in the log that you won't see except as it dries), then deal with the piece in its final "natural" state. When dry, those cracks can be stabilized with butterfly inlays as needed and/or filled with contrasting materials like epoxy (clear or colored) or pewter for dramatic effect.

Your wood's going to be moving with seasonal changes for as long as it exists, and checks and cracks can develop years after you've finished the piece, regardless of what you do to get it initially dry and finished. Most often, they lend character and uniqueness to the piece as they reflect the environment where it sits.

"Work with the wood, not against it."

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#11

A 3rd View

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Actually, maybe, a 5th ;)

Mark M. [no relation] can jump in here anytime and show us all the errors of our ways :D :D

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#12

Example

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

This is an old turning, done when all I knew how to scrounge was local black oak. The crotch had a lot of inclusion that split both sides of the bowl as it dried. I cleaned out the junk, made a dam, and filled the void with pewter, then returned and finished the bowl. That was some 13 years ago and it's still solid.

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#13

now there is some sound advice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Work with the wood, not against it."

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#14

Re: Mark

Larry in nw ohio

You used pewter to fill your crack, where do you get a liqued pewter to pour in a crack. I never heard of it. Thank You Larry in NW ohio

Re: sealing wood/which would you use?

#15

Pewter

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I melt it, Larry.

As I used to cast pewter (couldn't afford the equipment for bronze), I still have some high quality stuff (Britannia Metal) packed away.

Pewter is pretty easy to melt, its about like solder, so for small inlays like I pictured you can use a soldering iron. For bigger "pours" a propane torch and a steel or iron ladle/cup works just fine. In fact, today's lead-free solder for sweating copper pipe is a pretty good substitute alloy for small inlays.