I finally got to coloring the parts for the bookshelves. First step is dye, and I'm using water based. Then I'll seal that color in with shellac, then ill stain, then top coat. I got the dye on and of course got some raised grain. I'm wondering if I should sand now, and risk removing some dye, or if I should seal, then sand. I use plain old Bullseye clear shellac for sealing. I'm thinking sanding after sealing might stiffen up all the fibers and make it easier to sand smooth too.
Stephen I don`t know a thing about what you are doing, but could you just take a scrap board from the project that is lying around and try it on that first? That will take some time to do, but it`ll give you a goood idea what will happen. Good Luck. Larry
I would lightly sand with 400G before applying the shellac. You won't sand enough to remove the dye and if you are using the shellac as a barrier between water and oil, you don't want to risk sanding through the shellac coat. However, testing on a sample or inconspicuous area is always a good idea. HTH
I would definitely de-nib the wood after using the water-based dye, Add more dye if you sand through. I'm wondering about using shellac between the dye and pigment stains though. When I use both types of materials on the same project, I usually apply the dye first, de-nib with fine sandpaper if the dye is water based, then wipe on the pigment stain. This way, the pigment stain has something to adhere to, whereas shellac creates a barrier to the stain, greatly diminishing its effect.
If you use a light coat of shellac and then sand it back to bare wood, that will seal the pores and resist the tendency of the pigment stain to overload those areas and cause garish contrast effects. In this case, you'd wait until after sanding back to bare wood to apply your dye and pigment stains.
The question is, what is the purpose of using the two different coloring materials? I generally use dyes to get a uniform color, even on hard summer wood such as you find in oak and ash. Oil-based pigment stains tend to fill those big open pores with pigment and do little but tone the summer wood. So the dye is important for imparting a uniform color.
Dyes tend to look a little weak though, and a pigment stain of a complementary hue can really make the wood look rich and the color more interesting. Anyhow, that's why I often combine these two types of coloring agents. You may also want to use the pigment stain to create a more dramatic contrast on open-pored wood. That's another reason to use the pigment stain.
As for the shellac, I think you should prepare two wood samples -- one with and one without shellac between dye and pigment --and see for yourself if the barrier coat of shellac works for you. Make your decision based on function first, then aesthetics, then cost and complexity.
I follow along with the path I learned during a class with Peter Gedrys. The shellac is meant to seal off the dye and keep it from lifting. Plus it adds a layer of depth. I made multiple samples with different colors, both with and without shellac. I couldn't see much difference without the shellac, but there was some, enough to make me want to use it. Plus,the shellac helps ensure that the stain goes on evenly.
Like you say, the dye evens out the colors. Then the shellac seals it and keeps the stain from getting into all the pores. I've done this before with good luck. Thing is, I couldn't remember if I sanded after dyeing or after the shellac :-) and I wasn't testing for that in the samples.
Funny, when you dye wood, you have to be committed. All my oak looks looks horribly flat yellow. You gotta know what it will turn into. I'll be staining with General American Oak gel stain (over lemon yellow dye & shellac) to get a deep, rich golden color as requested by my wife/client.
Use plain water to raise the grain and then de nib before you apply the dye. you will still raise it again but this time it will be much much less and you won't have as great of a risk of sanding through the dye.
Did you dye oak in the class? I find that in some cases with red oak, the water based dye doesn't like to get in all he pores. If that is the case for you, you will be partially sealing the uncolored pores, then trying to get color in them with the stain. Definitely use a sample that is big enough and has course grain to tell the entire story.
Lots of good advice above, especially the old warhorse "try it and see." The advice about raising the grain with water and sanding before the dye is good, too.
For what its worthy, I use the process you mention a lot. My favorite treatment for walnut with sap wood is to start with a yellow dye to even out the contrast a bit, seal with shellac, then sand, then apply a stain -which is technically a glaze if used on top of a sealer. I can rub on extra stain where the sap wood is particularly light colored. In the end the sap wood takes on a warm brownish yellow, sort of the color of tobacco and the rest of the piece is slightly darker.
My wife and I got the 3 tops done today. We sanded after everything. It all came out great. I took some pics, but I just can't get a shot with the right color and what I would post would look horrible.
Started with red oak, sanded to 220. Dyed with lemon yellow, let dry. Sanded down raised grain with 220, careful to not go through dye (re-dye a spot if needed). Sealed with Bullseye Clear shellac, right out of the can. Let dry, then sanded with 320, just enough to get smooth, didn't want to go through the shellac. Then stained with General American Oak gel stain, let sit only a minute or so and wiped off.
The grain is really visible, much more so than if I had just done the gel stain alone. Plus, having dyed first it's all rather even. We're quite happy with the look. Dyeing and staining adds a depth to the wood.
Once everything is done, I'll assemble the carcasses and shoot on several coats of General's Enduro Var Urethane.
...would be that he's talking about the successive coat of stain/finish pulling dye into it, as evidenced by the dye showing on the applicator of that following coat.
Bull's Eye shellac is not dewaxed, you may have adhesion problems with your top coat. Seal Coat, by the same Co. that makes Bull's Eye, is dewaxed and will not affect adhesion.
Guess its dewaxed after stain and before finish. While I can't find actual proof that poly over waxed shellac will fail, I kinda figured 16 bucks and an extra hour or three is worth it.