Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Metamorphic chair/stool

Posts

Metamorphic chair/stool

#1

Metamorphic chair/stool

Mark Stone

Hi All, It's been a long time. I want to make a metaphoric set of chairs and for the life of me, I can't figure out what type of hinges to use. Any help would be really appreciated. I've attached the url of the chair for reference.

http://reevesd.com/product.aspx?id=76

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

#2

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I don't know John Reeves but I would guess his designs are all copyrighted. He appears to make a living selling furniture and I doubt he would think it appropriate for you to copy his designs and make your own set of chairs. If you don't agree with me then I suggest you contact Mr Reeves and ask him.

What would be appropriate is for you to use the chair in question as the inspiration for you own design. It would need to be significantly different, and chainging the type of wood dosen't count.

Robin

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

#3

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

Mark Stone

My question was misleading and I apologize. I am not looking to copy this design, but to use it for my inspiration for a completely different design incorporating a country theme. The question was really looking for the type of hardware used for this type of dual chair coffee table. I want to be able to hold up the large backs so they do not fall back down. So, to be clear, my design will have 2 side-by-side chairs that can fold separately. It will also have rounded and not square ends and carvings.

Thanks to Robin for pointing out my lack of specifications in my original post.

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

#4

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

William Duffield

If I were doing it, I'd use 1/2" diameter round mild steel rod. The chosen diameter depends on the thickness of the legs and the back/top. Usually, 1/3 the thickness of the stock is recommended. You want to drill the hole in the leg to go most of the way through, and about the same depth or a bit more into the top. The length of the pin should be just short enough that it doesn't bottom out in either mortise. (Imagine a loose dowel, on a horizontal axis, parallel to the back of the chair.) You will want to put together a prototype and load it to failure and see where it splits. Then drive a screw or bolt or rivet across the end of the split to reinforce it when you build the finished chair/tables.

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

#5

Am I wrong?

McKay

If I plan to make and sell the chairs it would certainly be a copyright violation. But if I make them for myself, is that a violation? If that were the case, then there would be an awful lot of people in violation for building a Maloof chair, etc. Since there really is no such thing as an original idea anymore but rather an accumulation of ideas does that mean that we can not build anything because it has been copyrighted? My next desired purchase is a criss-cross from Benchcraft. It is certainly not original to Benchcraft so where is the line?

I am not being the devil's advocate here, (well... maybe), but a sincere desire to fine out where we are.

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

#6

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

Barry Irby

I agree with William. To keep the back from falling you could arrange the parts so that the back leans back about five degrees.

You could make the hinge "blind" by installing the hinge pins o steel dowels in a hole with a spring under them. Press them into the holes, insert the back with matching but shallower holes and let them pop into the holes. Problem is how to dismantle it when the time comes.

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

#7

yes

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

It doesn't matter why you make a copy or who it is for unless you are licensed to do so you are violating copyright law. The fact that Sam Maloof freely gave permission for others to copy his designs does not allow for the free copying of any design. The idea of copyright protection is to encourage the creation of intellectual property. There are many categories of intellectual property and along with inventions, music, novels and software is…. the design of how things look. The recent high profile copyright case between Apple and Samsung included the claim that Samsung copied the way their products looked from Apple. A jury agreed with Apple. When it comes down to it, the way a chair looks is no different.

Robin

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

#8

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

Lee Brubaker

Your not quite right there Robin & the example you used doesn't fit. Your example involved Samsung selling their copy for profit and was definitely an infringement. However, you can copy any design that is copyright or patent protected if your project is strictly for your own use & not sold for someone else's use whether profit is or is not involved

Lee

Re: Metamorphic chair/stool

#9

Re: Not sure

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

If copyright law mimic Patents, I believe you are wrong. Patents are not issued to protect someone from copying your design, only to prevent you from SELLING or PROFITING financially from an item that is protected. You can search the patents and make all you want for your own use as long as you do not profit from them. I was an Engineer for many years and out patent lawyers (several) would never allow patent applications to be made for assembly equipment. These were considered Proprietary - often I had special machines covered to prevent viewing when visitors were present. No cameras were allowed in the plant. To me it is like a Copyrighted song - you can sing it as long as you do not profit (put it on a radio station, make CD's to sell etc.). I feel sure very, very few woodworkers are worried about another woodworker making a copy of their design for his/her own use. They are certainly not losing any market share when this occurs, actually probably will benefit them as someone may see the product and want one like it.