Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Sawing white Oak questions?

Posts

Sawing white Oak questions?

#1

Sawing white Oak questions?

Barry Irby

A month or so ago I mentioned a large white oak tree fell on one of my rental houses. I have gotten the tree off the house and now I have three logs ranging from 40" down to 30". Each is just under 8' long. (they were supposed to be 8' but the guy cutting them just cut the major log in three equal pieces.) There is another log about 24" by 10' that came after the first major limb.

I finally found a guy who can saw it and kiln dry it. They will quartersaw it. Pre-dry it and run it through the kiln. they claim the logs will produce about 1700bf and they want a dollar a foot or $1700. They come a get the logs, haul them to the mill, saw a dry them, and bring the wood to me.

I have not found anyone else that has the mill to cut this or a kiln or the equipment to handle and haul the logs.

Would you do this? Is this a reasonable charge? Any better ideas? What thicknesses would you have sawn?

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#2

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

Mike

sounds like a bargain to me. Kiln dried quarter-sawn white oak for a dollar a foot.."I'd buy that for a dollar!"

I would have some cut to 1' rough to clean up to 3/4 and some cut to 11/2" to clean up to a good full inch. Many projects that I build from white oak call for 4/4 and 5/4.

Nice score!

good luck

Mike from CU Woodworking School

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#3

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

Keith Newton

Well, $1 per ft for QS KD sounds great to me. Did he break it down how much each of those parts came to? If you don't have equipment or help to load the logs sections, you will find out quickly that portion is worth something.

QS is a lot more time consuming than plain sawn, although I don't know what the going rate is. i don't think I would bother quarter sawing the smaller log if it were out there by the mill ready to go. i'm pretty sure that a top log is likely to be a lower quality in a yard tree. You might save money having it plain sawn, since it may be #3 grade anyway.

As for worth, it is only worth that if you need it, or can turn it into something of value.

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#4

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

Ray - Middletown, in

Just talked to a local lady last week and she charges .35/bf for sawing and .35/bf for drying of your logs. She is a small one woman operation, so a dollar doesn't seem totally outrageous, just a little. As to how to cut it, tough call, I would do about 2/3 4/4 and the other 8/4, but that's just me.

Ray

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#5

Bob

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

Bob

QSWO for $1.00 and they pick and bring it back. I would do it all in 5/4 or maybe one log in 8/4.

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#6

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

mdclor

I agree with Bob. I make a lot of A&C style furniture and I think it looks better with thicker pieces. FWIW

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

Dale Lenz

I have all of my wood sawn at 1-1/8", they charge me for 1" lumber. All of the lumber probably won't be qtr. sawn. I pay $0.30 for flat sawn more for qtr. sawning. I dry and mill the wood myself. I would have a portable Woodmizer come to the property, myself, but that's me. So...$1 is probably a fair price. As you know yard trees are notorious for buried metal, I'm assuming the sawmiller is aware of that.

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#8

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

Ron

I'd be pretty excited about that opportunity as I'm fond of the qswo. But my take on thickness is a little different from the other fellows. That is a very heavy wood so unless I'm planning on some table legs or other such pieces (I hate glued-up legs) I wouldn't go thicker than necessary for 3/4 finished, which might have me focused on the 17/16-18/16 sawn recommendation. I'd probably sell off the flat sawn pieces after a year.

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#9

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

Larry in nw ohio

Barry I assume that he will have your lumber for a while. Did he say how long he would have it? If the subject didn`t come up, diffinently get a reciept for what he thinks the logs may make, it`ll keep him honest. Larry

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Sounds like a great deal

Ellis Walentine

.... especially since they are including all the shipping and handling. Plus, quartersawing is a much more involved process than plainsawing.

As for thicknesses, if you're planning to make Cradftsman-style furniture, then 3/4" is not the magic number. I'd figure on getting at least 13/16" boards and ideally 7/8", so 1 1/8" would be a good thickness to go for. Also, I would suggest sawing some of the better-figured wood into 8/4 thickness so you can resaw it for bookmatched panels. And some of the lesser quality sections might be nice to have sawn to 12/4 for table legs. Better check with your kiln guy, though, as white oak is notorious for drying defects, particularly honeycombing, in heavier material. The kiln schedule for 12/4 and 16/4 stock is quite long and expensive if you want good material at the end of it.

Nice haul, Barry. Let us know how it works out.

Ellis

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#11

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I mill about 98% of the wod I use and have been doing so since 1994. I think there is a tremendous amoung that the averave woodworker can learn from taking lumber from tree to finished project. the price you quoted is very fair considering the weight of the logs and all the grunt work that goes into milling stickering, drying and moving and delivering.

That all said You need to know that an average tree will produce a small percentage of unusable lumber, a small percentage of clear select lumber and a lot of so-so lumber. Also quartersawing will increase the amount of narrow unusable boards as well as yeilding the best percentage of nicely figured boards.

I don't mean to discourage you and I would still recomend having the wood milled. The price is better than fair. I just didn't want you to be disipointed when the wood is delivered.

Robin

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

#12

Re: Sawing white Oak questions?

segasaw58 sbcglobal.net

I help a guy with a sawmill and we charge .65 cents BF for cutting and .35 cents BF for kiln drying so

a $1.00 BF is more then fair. Also he might have said 1700 BF but the total may be less by quarter

sawing. Also if he is picking the logs up and bringing the dry lumber back that is a bargin. What type

of kiln does he have ? If its a DH or a solar kiln will make a choise in what thickness you want. A DH

kiln you need to have more of one thickness, as with a solar kiln you can mix diff thickness. We have

two red oaks 23" by 8' and we are going to quarter saw both and the total BF is diff, quarter saw to

flat sawn. The red oak should make 184 BF plane sawn but quarter sawn will be less, so his total my

be less.

Lester