Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Rit compared to Transtint?

Posts

Rit compared to Transtint?

#1

Rit compared to Transtint?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Time to discuss coloring wood. So is there any reason Rit would not work as well as Transtint(water based)?

Thanks a heap.

T.

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#2

Rit

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is a fabric dye and my understanding is that it will not have the resistance to fading that the metalized TransTints have.

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#3

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You might have a better comparison between RIT and TransFast dyes which are water soluable as well. I much prefer the NGR mix so I use TransTint in alcohol

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#4

That makes sense....thanks!


Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#5

And another

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Using TransTint in a 1/2-3/4lb cut mix of dewaxed pale shellac can be very effective as a spray application toner. Dial way back on the material knob and use as wide a fan and as low pressure as you can. You may be pleased on how well you can bring one piece up to match others or blend one part of a piece to match other sections.

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#6

Alan Young

Here are three options....

Alan Young

Purchase according to your skill level




Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#7

Not about skill level.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

....I was not allowed to have more than the 48 box. I envyed the kids with the 64 box (with sharpener). My dad said "48 colors was enough". I begged to differ. As an adult I finally bought a 64 box, in a collector tin. I don't use them....but I have them! Ha!

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#8

JL

Re: Rit compared to Transtint? *LINK*

JL

It really depends on the RIT dye that you are using. Some are more colorfast than others. Test to be sure.

You can either do the sunlamp test or the "roof test". The sunlamp is just that - a sunlamp at 2' - 3' - just enough distance so you don't get a lot of surface heating. The "roof test" is exposing it in a rain shielded enclosure with a southerly exposure. I've had to do it for testing inks on various lawn product bags.

There are other brands of fabric dyes that work well - with or without a mordant. It depends on which colors you want to have.

The link gives you some ideas about the other types of dyes.


Fabric dyes

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#9

Ooooo 96ers!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bet you stayed inside the lines too :D

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#10

All dyes are not created equal

Bill Tindall

There are a multitude of ways to put molecules together to make something colored, say red. Beyond generating the color there is the issue of whether the colored molecule will bind to the substrate, what it is soluble in, whether it will change color when bound to the substrate, whether it will be light fast, affected by ozone,....and the list goes on and on. Presumably, if the dye says it is good for cotton all the red dyes have been evaluated and the one that performs best, or in the case of RIT the one that is the cheapest, will be sold as a cotton dye. Ditto for wood. Unless you just want to experiment to see what happens it would be advised to stick with something labeled "wood dye" for dying wood, wool dye for wool, etc. These various red molecules will be vastly different and perform different on different substrates.

As a general rule anything labeled "premetallized" will be more lightfast. You can tell from the MSDS sheet whether the due is premetallized as this word will most likely be in the MSDS description.

The J. E. Mosers dyes I have looked up are premetallized.available Woodworkers Supply

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#11

Re: Ooooo 96ers!!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Only until I started desgning furniture did I dare to color outside of the lines. Now it's all I do!

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#12

Re: Not about skill level.....

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

That is too funny--my sister used to keep an unused box of 48 or 64 Crayolas around. When she needed to smile, she would just open the box. Sort of irresistible. I'll have to ask her if she still keeps one around.

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#13

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Not about skill level.....

Joe Bradshaw

Back when I was a child, we only had eight colors in a box of crayons. I don't know where all these other colors came from.

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#14

TransTints Are Metalized Dyes


Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#15

What does that mean?

Tony - Memphis

What does metalized mean?

Thanks,

Tony

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#16

an attempt at explanation

Bill Tindall

Dye molecules are assembled from carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and other elements to yield a molecule that is colored. Most dyes do not contain metal atoms- copper, chromium, aluminum and the like.

A "class" of dyes will have the same skeletal molecular structure, by analogy ranch, split level, town house. Addition of a nitrogen here or an oxygen there will change the color but the skeleton largely determine the properties of the dye class, for example its lightfastness or what kind of substrate it will dissolve in or react with.

The premetallized dyes have metal atoms incorporated into the molecule which is unusual for a typical dye. For reasons I don't know this class of dyes typically has superior light fastness. No doubt quantum mechanics explains it.

I don't know this for a fact but I suspect that wool dyes are what is being used for wood dying. In the case of wool the dye chemically reacts with the wool. A very different class of dyes is used for polyester, and different still class of dyes for cotton. In the case of polyester the dye is simply dissolved in the polyester and not reacted. I don't understand cotton dyes.

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#17

PS

Bill Tindall

It is likely that there are significant differences in light fastness among the premetallized dyes, as is the case for other dye classes. The two(yellow and brown) Moser dyes I tested for mahogany were superior to chromate, or lye or an aniline dye.

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#18

no Rit for me

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Ive never used Rit on furniture, but only because I cant fit the furniture in the washing machine.

Robin

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#19

Or as Rooster Cogburn would say.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

"Now, It's a rat writ, writ for a rat, and this is lawful service of same!"

Re: Rit compared to Transtint?

#20

Re: Ooooo 96ers!!

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

After the magic marker incidense when i was 4 years old coloring for me was always a supervised activity. I used my magic markers to color the bottoms of some garden snails and then let them make colored trails on the front porch.

Robin