Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Charging for plans

Posts

Charging for plans

#1

Charging for plans

Sue McLam

I'm doing production work for a company building counter-top display cases for them to put in stores. They initially gave me their plexi-glass display and I redesigned it to be made of wood and have also added several modifications that they requested. There is also some laser engraving on these displays and I had someone produce those files for me to supply to the laser engraver.

Now all of a sudden I can't keep up with their demand and they're in the process of hiring additional woodworkers to build these (fine with me). Everyone is simply expecting me to hand over the plans and laser files. What do I do? What kind of "ownership" do I have and what, if anything, should I be charging. I first did a prototype and the payment for that accounted for my design time. There was never an agreement that they would then "own" the plans.

I feel like I should be getting some compensation for these plans and wonder what you pros would do?

Thanks,

Sue

Re: Charging for plans

#2

I don't quite understand...

John in NM

You say that the payment for the prototype accounted for your design time, if it were me I would say that they therefore own the plans you created on that time.

But I can see your not wanting to turn over the plans and files if you had counted on a volume of work for this company to pay for your design time.

Re: Charging for plans

#3

Re: Charging for plans

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

They own the design but not your plans. They are free to give another shop one of your displays and have them copy it without paying you any more money for the design, but any working drawings, shop aids, or jigs you used to produce it are then up to the new shop to come up with on their own.

If you don't want to burn any bridges you might tell them you don't work from drawings but offer them the file for the same price it cost you to have some one produce it.

Robin

Re: Charging for plans

#4

JL

Re: Charging for plans

JL

Typically when I "design" a piece - all working drawings, plans and what not are mine. If a customer wants the plans, I'll happily sell them a clean copy - but the operative word is sell.

I would say some negotiation is in order.

Re: Charging for plans

#5

Re: Charging for plans

Dick Coers

I'm with John. You charged them for the design, I assume you charged them for the laser files, and you were compensated for your time. They own the design. Did you compensate the original designer of the item you copied?

Re: Charging for plans

#6

Re: Charging for plans

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Sue,

You are asking the wrong bunch here as your question is a legal one. You may get an applicable answer from one of the "pros" here, but that will be luck and you will not be in a position to complain if you rely upon such an opinion that turns out to be wrong. You should contact an attorney in your own state who practices in the areas of intellectual property, copyrights, etc., for the answer. Rather than just looking up someone in the yellow pages, contact your state's bar association and ask for a referral to someone who sits on the association's Committee on Intellectual Property. The call may cost you a few bucks in a minimal fee, but you'll get both an answer and alternative ways to proceed to protect yourself and your hard work.

Mark

[NJ/NY/PA attorney who doesn't do copyright work]

Re: Charging for plans

#7

Re: Charging for plans

Dick Coers

Kinda funny Mark, "The call may cost you a few bucks in a minimal fee". I've never heard all those same words in a sentence from a lawyer before. They are relative terms though. No ill will, it just made me smile to read them.

Re: Charging for plans

#8

The Fram Principal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

My clients rely upon me for advice that is calculated to keep them out of the Court system. They've learned that they can pay me $x for a few hours time now, or $4X(cubed) later for the trial. Make no mistake, trying cases is the fun part of my job, but, fortunately for my clients, I don't get to do it that often.

One mark of a good commercial/transaction lawyer is how well she/he keeps the client out of courthouse.

Re: Charging for plans

#9

if they hired you they own plan's

del schisler

if you were hired by them , than they own the plan's. If they just gave you something to redesgn than you just did them a faver than you could tell them you own the change. I would stop and get it streight now. Before something big come's out of this.

Re: Charging for plans

#10

Not Necessarily

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Who owns what depends upon the contract between the company and Sue. If it's not specifically spelled out, she has performed a service as an independent contractor (very different from an employee) and may retain full rights to the design and its commercial use. As she has been making the item in her own shop and charging the company on a per-unit basis, she may have the exclusive right to manufacture the design, and the company owns nothing but the right to put their brand on what she makes.

This is part of why she needs to speak to an attorney.

Re: Charging for plans

#11

Re: Charging for plans

Sue McLam

Thanks everybody. I pretty much knew the "correct" response would be to get a lawyer but I was also hoping to elicit what some others have done.

Thanks again,

Sue

Re: Charging for plans

#12

A Note of Caution

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

All too often the worst thing that can happen is that both sides get all "Lawyered Up" so that what starts out as a good faith difference of opinion gets morphed into a battle-royal with confrontational advocates going at it hammer & tong and killing enough trees to build a house.

My advice was and is to do an initial consult with counsel knowledgeable in the subject area. That's very different from "getting a lawyer", Sue. Once you have a basic understanding of your rights and responsibilities that attach to the very particular set of facts that make up your situation, you can make informed decisions about what to do (or not) and how.

m

Re: Charging for plans

#13

Re: A Note of Caution

Sue McLam

Am I getting free advice from a lawyer??? LOL :)

Seriously Mark, thank you for your words and thoughts today.

Sue

Re: Charging for plans

#14

The same had occurred to me...

John in NM

But of course I could not manage to say it so succinctly :D

One thing that none of us who responded are able to gauge is whether there exists a cordial business relationship here. Intellectual property has value, but so do friendly business dealings. The balance of value can really only be gauged by those actually involved.

Re: Charging for plans

#15

Re: Charging for plans

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Sue, I am not a lawyer - worked as an Engineer as my career for 40 years. However, I did purchase many machines, gauges etc. from Tool shops and suppliers (millions of dollars) during those years. A couple of things occurred to me when reading your post. First was the fact that you did and apparently still are building the display cases for the company and that the only reason they are requesting the plans is to purchase more cases than what you are willing to produce (I am sure you could sub-contract some of the work out yourself and produce more if you wished). I don't know what kind of money you expect to get for the "design", but you may want to balance that against the "good will" and future business you apparently are getting from them on a continuous basis. The second issue is that

you said the design work already had been paid for with prototype expense. I do know if I had contracted a job during my tenure and the vendor couldn't keep up with the demand, and I was forced to contract other builders to maintain my schedule, I would be loathe to pay them additional funds for their design. If that had occurred I would have contracted my companies attorneys and found a way (If necessary) around the design. That would probably be the last order I placed with that vendor.

Re: Charging for plans

#16

Re: A Note of Caution

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

There ain't no sucha thing as free lunch. ;)

Re: Charging for plans

#17

Re: Charging for plans

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Sue,

After seeing all the replies to your post I went back and re-read your original post and from the info you gave it is a bit unclear as to if the original was a "design for hire" or a commission. If it was a commission and you were compensated enough to cover all the time you spent on the proto type vs. you received a design fee, then you would retain the design copyright. If they paid a fee specifically for you to do design work then it is likely they own the copyright, but there are very specific rights to each party in a design for hire depending on the contract and this is where the contract and a lawyer are important.

As a sculptor copyright law is a bit easier than as a designer, but there are some similarities. You do have some legal protection even if you do not register the copyright but you need to do three things. The first is to sign you work. The second is the signature must include the year and the copyright symbol. The third is that all three of these things must me in a visible area, not on the back of a painting or on the bottom of a sculpture. If you had included these things on the display it would have alerted your customer that the design of the display case is your intellectual property and just like a music CD or computer software it is not ok for them to just copy it at their whim.

Copy right law is not that difficult to understand the basics of how to protect yourself before the fact but as others have said once you are in the middle of it things get a bit less clear and a few $$ to a lawyer may be worth the education you get as it applies to future work.

That all said I will share the best piece of legal advice I ever received, and it was not given to me by a lawyer: A contract is only worth what you are willing to spend to defend it.

Robin

Re: Charging for plans

#18

"They" own it.


Re: Charging for plans

#19

Re: Charging for plans

Brian from Monument

It is highly likely that they own the design.

I did not see in your OP whether you actually made a set of drawings for the item.

If you made a back of the envelope type drawing then that will have to suffice for free.

If you made a production grade set of drawings and added your name, date and copyright symbol, That may be a different story. But I suspect that you should turn that over also.

Biggest question of the day is what kind of future do you expect to have with this customer?

If you want more, give them the plans no arguments.

If you don't care then you could charge them for a drawing fee.

If you paid for the laser stuff then you should make sure to get compensated for that.

I don't suppose that you had a real contract or even a written agreement.

Are they hiring employees or another company to make the items.

That might make a difference.

Bottom line is that they already paid for the design to be done.

If you made a set of plans they most likely own that as a work product of doing the design.

Most importantly is

If you hire a lawyer all that happens is that he gets money and it comes from you!

Re: Charging for plans

#20

Re: Charging for plans

Larry in nw ohio

Sue I`ve been reading your post just for interest. But one thing I didn`t read was if you do this more in the future then you should get some sort of contract wrote up that spells out how you would want things done, so there is no misunderstanding in the future, it save you time, money and stress. That is of course you intend to do more. Good luck with your future buisnesses. Larry

Re: Charging for plans

#21

Re: Charging for plans-Agree completely

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Larry, I completely agree with your assessment. As an Engineer, I always read the fine print in the contracts. I also prepared my own, and had our attorneys OK all paperwork before I approved the purchase. Unless there was a compelling reason for the supplier to withhold the rights to the design (possibly I was purchasing a modified existing design for my project that they held patents on - and produced for other markets). I would never agree to them withholding the design or rights to any portion of my purchase. However at that time we could agree on a price that compensated them for that work so both parties were happy. In 90+% of the cases the vendor that designed and built the original machine / device had a huge competitive edge in building additional units so it normally was not an issue. BUT in the case above where the vendor could not or did not want to build sufficient quantities of the equipment, I was free to purchase from other suppliers.

Re: Charging for plans

#22

That is the thing about contracts...

John in NM

They are really handy for spelling out all these details of what each party is agreeing to before any work proceeds or funds change hands. A whole bunch of lawsuits seem to stem from one party or the other not reading their contract :D

On the other hand, a lot of the motivation for copyright and similar civil law seems to be to provide a framework for the rights of each party absent a contract - at least to a casual observer like me.

Trouble is, in most situations for woodworkers like us, there is no contract, there is no legal department to run one by, and sadly, there is no collections department to ensure we get paid :D

Re: Charging for plans

#23

Re: Contracts...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

A very wise and experienced attorney, namely my father, posed this question to me after I'd made it through the first year of law school (after a full year of Contracts I & II).

"Okay, Hot Shot, now tell me the purpose for a written contract."

I was primed for this and I'd done well in those classes, so I launched into about 20 minutes of American jurisprudence relating to contract theory and practice. Since I grew up with the guy, I really should have known better.

He listened politely to my recitation, and then said, "Well, I am glad to hear that you were listening to the professors for the last 8 months, but you haven't answered my question."

Oh, boy, knowing that I'd well and truly "stepped in it" I forged ahead and asked, "Okay, so now you're going to either give me the answer or make me stand here and sweat, right?"

He chuckled and said, "The answer is quite simple. The only purpose for a written contract is to keep honest people honest."

It was a lesson that I have carried with me and used for over 30 years.

Re: Charging for plans

#24

Re: I understand but

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

A simple form printed out on your computer could really alleviate any misunderstanding. In many cases the "contract" would not be enforced due to the cost of a lawsuit anyway. I mean if you are dealing with less than a $1000 in disputed charges the only economical recourse would be a small claims court as the lawyer fees would eat up or exceed any recovery. But, I really think that in most cases the real problem is that there is a "honest misunderstanding" when disputes occur. That is where a simple written agreement is very beneficial. The simple agreement should spell out the obligations of the vendor in this case the woodworker and customer - as to 1) Providing the design (and or prototype) at a specified charge (may be time and material - not to exceed charge) 2) Ownership of the design (Vendor or customer) 3) Reasonable timeline to produce Item 1 through project completion. 3) Method of approval by customer (sign off or verbal etc.) 4) Materials to be specified and used 5) Method and delivery / installation and 6) Total project costs and methods of payments accepted - may be on a percentage upon approval of design, a percentage upon item completion and final upon installation etc. and payment -credit card, cash, check etc. Other items added may be specific to the job, such as finish to be applied - warranty of material & workmanship, any disclaimers the woodworker deems appropriate such as no scratch warranty if a specific finish is requested, color changing of wood etc.

This simple agreement signed by both parties eliminates the "I thought you said", "I didn't know shellac would be attacked by alcohol" "I thought you would be done by" " I believed I had design rights and you made one for my neighbor" etc.

Re: Charging for plans

#25

Yes, exactly

John in NM

What you describe will certainly work just fine in many cases and where both parties have a vested interest in their mutual on going business rather than wasting time, money, and grey hair on litigation. As you and Mark have both said, the purpose is to keep everyone dealing honestly and to spell out what each party will provide. By that standard, what you describe is basically a contract. Now if one party or another wishes to start cheating, a basic agreement might not protect you so well, or it might be more expensive to defend your interests.