Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

repair advice needed

Posts

repair advice needed

#1

repair advice needed

Bill Tindall


This picture shows the corner of a door for a china cabinet. The door houses a piece of glass 42 x 16". You can see that the mortise is fractured (I have pried it up to show the split) and the joint disassembled. The hide glue failed because the joint was not well made.

There are two problems. Gluing back the cheek of the mortise and reigluing the M&T joint is straightforward. However, this is a frail joint for a big door with heavy glass. There just isn't much gluing surface. Does anyone have a suggestion for strengthening these joints?

Re: repair advice needed

#2

Re: repair advice needed

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I think the best solution would be to remake the door using either real M&T joints or real bridal joints vs the half @#$%& joint that the manufacturer used.

If you don't what to opt for that then I would repair and re-glue as best as possible and then drill and insert a pair of dowels from the "mortice" side and extend them a couple of inches into the "tennon" side.

Re: repair advice needed

#3

Re: repair advice needed

Bill White

Robin's dowell idea wins the prize (from you). :D

Re: repair advice needed

#4

Re: repair advice needed

Dave Paine

I agree that is a large piece of glass. The frame does seem to not be heavy enough for the glass. No surprise the joint gave way.

Ideas which come to mind

a) Replace the glass with polycarbonate sheet. Transparent and much lighter as I found out when I replaced my glasses with polycarbonate lens.

b) Add flat brass "L" brackets. I have used this on some smaller cabinet doors which did not have as much weight. The instructions were correct to advise using steel screws to create the thread and then replace with brass. DAMHIKT.

I would mount these on the back surface if there is room without interference.

c) Knock down screws. Not as strong going into the end grain.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/hardware/page.aspx?p=40050&cat=3,41306,41315&ap=1

d) Knock down fasteners. Very strong if you have enough thickness for the barrel screw and can recess the bolt head.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/hardware/page.aspx?p=67659&cat=3,41306,41319&ap=1

Re: repair advice needed

#5

Re: repair advice needed

Barry Irby

I agree with Robin, but if you don't think dowels will do the job, go big. Turn the joint into a loose tenon joint. Chop a matching mortise into both pieces and insert a loose tenon of the same wood and glue it in with hide glue. Might do all four corners while you are at it. I don't have much faith in dowels, but tenons are another animal.

Re: repair advice needed

#6

PS, are you the same Bill Tindall?

Barry Irby

In the very early days the space program was sort of wobbling along and NASA sent Bill Tindall in to kick butts and take names. Are you that guy?

Re: repair advice needed

#7

Re: repair advice needed

larry in nw ohio

Bill If it were me from what I can make of from the picture, I would glue it back together and let it set up as good as it will. Then drill a 1/4" hole for a dowel from the tenon into the mortise at an angle to catch the mortise and drill it as deep as you can without going thru. But if you do it should not show, at least not much. If you can and your lucky drill another at more of an angle and put in another dowel. If you can do this, you should be a very solid joint, at least better than you had. Good Luck with whatever you end up doing Larry

Re: repair advice needed

#8

Epoxy likes a sloppy fit better than tight.

Keith Newton

Thicken it so it doesn't run out before it cures. Besides a dowel, a screw with a plug could add some strength.

However, you can lay the glass back in with a bead of silicone, which can add a lot of strength, by making it part of the frame. Actually lots of cabinetmakers don't even use a stop on the back anymore in their glass doors.

Re: repair advice needed

#9

Re: repair advice needed

Paul Leuba

In the event that there is not enough tenon available to handle the dowel suggestions above, you may need to consider adding a wooden, decorative corner brace across each of the 4 corners of the door on the inside of the glass. This should be able to be done without harming the aesthetics of the piece. Carefully designed, they could add considerable strength to the door and still appear delicate and in keeping with the design of the cabinet.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: repair advice needed

#10

Re: repair advice needed

Galen Vetterick

Bill

I made a handgun display case with a 24" x 32" glass door insert and was worried about the frame joints. I degreased the glass and used a small bead of silicone adhesive all around to bed the glass. It's lasted some 35 years and the joints see little load. I think it all could hang without three sides of the wood frame. Double thickness glass so it is heavy.

If you can do that the joint repair strength is not as critical.

Re: repair advice needed

#11

Ellis Walentine

Make the glass structural

Ellis Walentine

Integrate the glass into the structure of the door somehow, whether with a fillet of silicone or just by taking up all the slop between the glass and the housing. IMO, it is by far the best, least involved way to fix these doors. I've made display cabinets where the glass frame is more decoration than structure. As long as the hinge stile is properly hinged to the cabinet and the bottom rail is anchored to the hinge stile in a way that won't drop out, as this joint of yours has -- one screw would fix that -- you're good to go.

Ellis

Re: repair advice needed

#12

thanks to all

Bill Tindall

This joint certainly dispels the notion that they "made stuff better back then". I will affix the glass to frame, as recommended, and hope for the best.

Re: repair advice needed

#13

Re: PS, are you the same Bill Tindall?

moon child

Bill Tindall from the old NASA days passed away in November of 1995. Did you know him?

Re: repair advice needed

#15

Re: PS, are you the same Bill Tindall?

Barry Irby

No, I saw a TV show on the moon shot and was amazed to think back on how little we knew about how to do what they did. It was just a coincidence that there was a guy there named Bill Tindall and one on WC. Just wondered if it was the same guy. I think we have gone down hill since then. Makes me wonder what we could do now if we were changed in the same way, perhaps to go to Mars this time. My cousin was an engineer on some of the Mercury stuff. He has some interesting stories.

Re: repair advice needed

#16

Re: PS, are you the same Bill Tindall?

moon child

Bill Tindall (from NASA) was my dad so I was curious if you had worked with him. :) He started when NASA was NACA in Langley and then moved to Houston in the early 60s. From what he told me after he retired in 1979, he thought it would be difficult with all the bureaucracy to accomplish things the same way they did in the early days. If you are interested in the engineering side of the early days of NASA, Charles Murray and Cathrine Cox wrote a really great book called "Apollo Race to the Moon". With my dad gone now, it's such a blessing to have these books to share with my kids.

One thing I would like to mention is, it would not have been a stretch for my dad to be on this site. He ALWAYS had some kind of project going on. When our house flood back in the early 70s, he came up with a scheme to water proof the house. He put sealant on all the bricks, put aluminum siding under all of the wood siding and put "L" brackets in all the doors where he could slide plywood into the slots to stop the water. It worked really great until the water hit the top of the plywood. It was pretty water tight...when we returned the next day after the water had receded, the house was full of water up to the top of the plywood. It was like niagra falls when he pulled those boards out.

Re: repair advice needed

#17

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for posting

Ellis Walentine

Your DIY-nightmare anecdote sounded chillingly like something any good red-blooded homeowner might have done. Your father sounds like he was a great guy. Sorry we won't get to meet him.

Ellis Walentine, Host