Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Which Hammer should I get?

Posts

Which Hammer should I get?

#1

Which Hammer should I get?

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I plan on helping with a Habitat for Humanity house building project in June. I know I will be driving lots of nails of various sizes. I currently own a 16 Oz claw hammer, but know from last year that my hand and arm got tired after a couple of days driving nails. I suffer from carpal tunnel to a small degree. I was looking at the Borgs yesterday and they must have at least 14 or 15 different brands and styles of hammers (Estwing, Husky, DeWalt, Dead On Tools, Plumb, QLT, Hart, Nupla, Pull'R Holding Company, Klien, Kobalt, Stanley, Bostitch, Wise, task Force, and Vaughan)

What is a good hammer for general framing and sheeting work that is comfortable to work with and of good quality. I'm not interested in spending $80+ for a hammer. I'm thinking that maybe a 20 or 22 Oz hammer might be the way to go. Your thoughts are appreciated.

Lee

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#2

As One C-T Patient To Another

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Borrow a framing nailer and small compressor! The repeated shocks from a 22 oz. framing hammer will have your grip suffering in short order. That happens, you start hitting off-center, bending nails, and the whole process is far less enjoyable. Were you closer, Lee, I'd lend you mine. A world of difference

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#3

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

Dustmaker Mike

I have a few hammers most of them Eastwing. How I judge a hammer is hold it and swing it straight down if it feels heavy or off balance put it back and try another. Swing it three or four times you will be surprised how fast you can tell the difference between a good and bad hammer. I have switched over to a framing nailer and love it now I don't have to swing so much. I am not sure if Habit will let you bring in your own but like Mark said if you can it makes the world of difference.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#4

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you aren't allowed to use a framing nailer or can't afford one, be sure to get a wood handle for shock absorption and look into vibration-absorbing gloves.

Or ask if there are other assignments you can do. You're to be honored for doing good works, but don't make your carpal tunnel condition worse in the process.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#5

Get one with good sights

john lucas

The last one I bought didn't have good sights and I couldn't hit a nail with it. I guess the Chinese just don't know how to properly adjust the sights on a hammer. :)

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#6

Framers

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I and several friends have done volunteer work. Crew organizers were, at first, leery about allowing us to "gun" the framing. When we showed them that we don't use "bounce-fire triggers (sequential only!) and then the speed at which we could frame up a wall, they welcomed us with the stipulation that other volunteers, not familiar and trained with nailers, be restricted to hammers, i.e. no sharing.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#7

Re: As One C-T Patient To Another

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

You can't use framing nailers on our local Habitat Project for safety reasons. Also I will need to help with the vinyl siding at some point.

Lee

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#8

Habitat *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I understand the issue. Using (mostly) minimally skilled volunteers, you'd not want them running around nailing themselves to the structure; they'd need the EMTs standing by.

Remember to hold your nails "palm up".

Speaking of "palm", you might consider getting them to let you use a palm nailer as an alternative.


No-Shots

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#9

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

Ralph Lipeles

Lee,

When I do framing type hammering I use an Estwing 20 oz hammer. Look on eBay. There are several sellers with reasonable prices.

Ralph

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#10

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

Barry Irby

When I was a younger man I used to frame a lot of houses. I had a 32 oz. waffle faced framing hammer with a custom handle. A friend of mine made handles for a living and he made me a long handle with finger grips made for my hand. I don't remember how long the handle was but it was so long they teased me about wearing a sword. It nearly dragged the ground. Apparently it was not quite as silly as it seemed because three of them "disappeared" over the years. I could drive framing nails with two blows, one tap to set it and one to drive it home. Nostalgia aside, I learned some things from all that hammering.

Let the hammer do the work. I learned to hold it with my pinky off the end of the handle. On the power stroke I held the handle very loosely and let the hammer do the work. By not gripping the handle tightly, the shock of the blow was not transferred to my hand and arm. I think the message is to hold the hammer as far to the end of the handle as you can and not use a death grip. The gel gloves might be good too, but I have never tried them.

The palm nailers mentioned above are good, but they do vibrate your hand pretty badly. I use them occasionally for driving the nails in joist hangers and they work well for that, but I can see that they might aggravate the nerves with extended use. I think the gel glove would be good with extended use.

My experience with air nailers is that when one man on the crew has one, everyone else stands around waiting for him to nail everything. They forget they cold be nailing with those hammers hanging on their belts.

I have and use both Estwing and Plumb hammers and like both. The Estwing framer I have has a fairly long thin handle, putting much of the weight in the head. I think some body (Stanley??) is making a hammer with a tuning fork or vibration dampener in the handle. Supposed to be good, but I have no experience with it.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#11

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

Brad Chenoweth

Lee,

I know you already said you're not interested in spending big bucks for a hammer, but if you ever spend any time swinging a Stilletto 14 oz. titanium framer (with a wood handle), you'll never want to use a steel hammer again. You have to try one to really understand how nice it is to use.

Brad

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#12

Laser sights especially good


Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#13

Another vote for Estwing

Dave Paine

When I last did some framing, I used my 20oz Estwing claw hammer with smooth face.

I like the thin handle of the Estwing, especially when I miss the head of the nail. :D

The nylon handle does a good job of dampening the vibration from the impact.

I also have a 28 oz waffle head framing hammer, which was only used for driving spikes. Too heavy for frequent use.

If your Habitat project is anything like the one I volunteered for, the materials were, let's just say, not what I would choose.

The lumber is likely to be low density pine, so a 20oz hammer is likely to be sufficient to drive the nails.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#14

Sounds like a great way...

John in NM

to discourage people from volunteering :D

Hope you find a good hammer Lee, I had an elbow injury a couple years ago from using a framing hammer at just the wrong height/angle. Only 30 or so rafters nailed to the ridge but it was enough to cause pain in the joint for 6 months.

I shoulda borrowed the nailer :D :D :D

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#15

Found the Stanley Anti-Vibe

Gary Smyth

I have no experience with this hammer, but here is the description.

The Stanley 22-Ounce AntiVibe Framing Hammer features a one-piece double-forged steel head and handle for superior swing and greater durability. Its patented tuning fork design reduces harmful vibrations three-times more than conventional one-piece forged steel hammers. The unique grip design is great for both framers and nail hammers.

Made with the professional and serious DIYer in mind. View the details under Stanley AntiVibe. You can also learn more about AntiVibe technology.

Its patented ergonomic handle with a rubber grip molded directly onto shaft is designed for multiple grip positions and is specially textured for improved performance even when wet. The grip is flared at the end to help prevent the hammer from slipping. The hammer comes with a manufacturer's limited lifetime warranty.

About Stanley AntiVibe Hammers

Stanley AntiVibe hammers are made with the professional and serious DIYer in mind. Made of one-piece double forged steel head and handle for swing and durability, the hammers feature a patented tuning fork design that helps reduce harmful vibrations. The ergonomically designed handles, with the rubber grip molded directly onto the shaft, allow for multiple grip positions. The handles also have a specially textured grip for improved performance in wet conditions and an enlarged handle design that helps reduce gripping fatigue. A specially designed head shape provides for better balance and a larger "sweet spot."

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#16

Indeed! They Are Hard To Beat


Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#17

One comment about the hammer face

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

People always say, "get a waffle face hammer." This is all very well if you never bend a nail; but if you do, a waffle face hammer and a cat's paw will not be good friends (the Japanese-type cat's paws are hands down the best nail pullers for new construction).

I prefer a smooth face, and my contractor son tells me that he and many of his friends have moved that way too. And he bends way way fewer nails than I do.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#18

Interesting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

They're measuring against a solid steel handle, the most vibration-transmitting of all. The critical measurement is against a wooden handle. If it's equal to/better than a wooden handle, great. If they can't confirm it, I'd still lean toward a wooden handle. Of course, I'm seriously conservative in the tooling area.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#19

I Had A Waffle

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It got pounded smooth.

Then I got a framing nailer . . .

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#20

Ellis Walentine

I have one...

Ellis Walentine

... that the Stanley-Bostitch people gave us at last year's press conference in New York. I must say, it seems to pack the punch of my trusty Estwing 28-oz. The next conference is coming up in a couple weeks. I'll let you know if there are any further developments. Apparently, hammers are a prime area of product development for the DIY and trade suppliers.

Ellis

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#21

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Get one with good sights

Jesper, Denmark

Funny you should say that. My favorite hammer in the shop is a cheapo Chinese 12 oz, purchased in the US somewhere more than 15 years ago. Standard claw head shape, but with an elongated hexagonal shaped handle - if you understand the idea? It seems that the handle shape helps sighting - you don't really look at it - and signals head orientation through your hand.

Not heavy enough for framing, but it works well for just about everything else.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

Jesper, Denmark

You have a very good point, Barry, letting the head do the work. Like with so many things, proper technique makes the job much easier and easier on yourself.

I just wince watching someone holding a hammer in the middle of the handle, using linear strokes instead of letting the mass and velocity of the head do the work.

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#23

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

While there are a lot of things to consider it really comes down to three choices, metal handle, fiberglass handle or wood handle.

I prefer wood and so does my tendonitis prone elbow. Another reason for my preference for wood stems from a trick an old school carpenter showed me for eliminating blisters.

The first thing you do with a shiny new hammer is to take a piece of 36 grit sandpaper to the hande and remove all the varnish. Go ahead and use a bastard file to shape it to fit your hand, then rub it liberally with a lump of bees wax. Keep a lump of bees wax in your tool pouch and periodcaly give it a couple of swipes. Your handle will start to look really grungy but it will not slip in your hand and this is what causes blisters.

Robin

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#24

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

C. John Hebert

.22 once Eastwing has less vibration but to be honest...if you are having some carpel tunnel issues...don't even think of framming

Re: Which Hammer should I get?

#25

Re: I Had A Waffle

Barry Irby

I have a smooth faced framing hammer also. when I bought it I couldn't drive a nail into Jello with it. With a really coarse grinding wheel I VERY SLIGHTLY reshaped the face and left the coarse scratches on it. COMPLETELY changed the performance. Figured I couldn't lose on the attempt because it was headed for the trash if it did not get better.