Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

A question for the professionals

Posts

A question for the professionals

#1

A question for the professionals

Bill Tindall

I blundered into a craft show in Winter Park, FL. It was the most high end show I have ever attended with artists/crafts people from all over the country purveying their wares. I expect it is difficult to be accepted into this show.

There were two furniture makers attending. Their stuff was well designed. The wood selection was excellent, in one case birds eye maple from Michigan. The finishes were similarly excellent. Drawers fit well and were nicely made. Knobs were "home made" and attractive. However, in each case doors were mounted with those hinges that don't require mortises, yielding a gappy door and a cheap looking plated hinge.

What's the story here? Is the installation of butt hinges to costly for a $1500 piece of furniture? Are these young woodworkers lacking the experience to hang a door with butt hinges? They don't know any better........?

Re: A question for the professionals

#2

David Barnett

WPSAF is not exactly a top tier craft show *LINK*

David Barnett

... but it's a fun one to walk through and nearly 50,000 people do exactly that.

I'm going to assume that when you say you 'blundered' into a Winter Park craft show, you mean the Winter Park Sidewalk Arts Festival.

Bill, like most of the better arts and crafts shows, the Winter Park show is juried, but if your work is of sufficient (not always but usually above average) quality, produced mainly by the craftsperson, not knockoffs or obviously mass-produced, and if you follow the guidelines, it's not as difficult to get accepted as you might imagine. The hefty exhibitor fee ($475+) weeds out the worst of the riffraff and the buyers are usually saavy and tasteful enough to make few acquisition mistakes on the higher-priced offerings. But the truth is, as art festivals go, WP is middle tier, though in the top quarter of the middle tier, I'd say.

One thing, though, the WPSAF tries for a balance of arts and crafts that offer a wide range of prices for the represented demographics, so there will be some kitchy offerings and some affordable pieces for every price point. One has to remember this is an open air festival and everyone is welcome. Most major indoor shows, such as the ACC shows and others with more stringent jurying and higher entry fees also charge high enough admissions to further qualify the buyers (Coconut Grove Arts Festival, SOFA, and so on).

By the way, you would never find those hinges or substandard construction issues in the work of ACC exhibitors, and if the judges spotted them mixed in with otherwise well-made objects, they would invariably be asked to remove them.

In the jewelry category, artisans at the better shows are expected to make their own findings for the most part, and a good percentage of the work is fabricated rather than cast. I'm not so familiar with their furniture requirements but am not surprised knobs and pulls are hand made.

While it's not nearly as difficult to get accepted in WPSAF as the juried American Crafts Council retail shows or the Paradise City Arts Festivals (Northampton and Marlborough, MA), it's still an old and respected show, but most definitely not in the same league as the big shows. There is some crossover, though, and some WP exhibitors also do the ACC shows.

Not to sound snobby, but the WPSAF is not what I think of as high end at all. When you ask five figures at a craft show and the smiling customer pulls out his or her checkbook without batting an eye, that's high end.

Take a look at the ACC shows to see the next tier or two up in the crafts show circuits. By the way, you'll always find affordable crafts at ACC craft shows. Many exhibitors manage to offer a range of bread-and-butter objects to at least make their entry fees, travel costs, and so on, but hope for a few sales at the top of their line to make it all worthwhile.


ACC retail and wholesale show schedule

Re: A question for the professionals

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: A question for the professionals

Moses Yoder

Actually morticing a hinge into a stile and door is currently only done by servants working for the extremely wealthy or by a hobbiest with more time than sense.

Actually I find it doesn't take that much effort, but 98% of customers don't have a clue what the difference is. For instance, we rate our customers 1-4 with 4 being the most difficult, and you would be rated a 4 for pointing out the cheap hinges.

Re: A question for the professionals

#4

(snicker-snicker) . . .

steve mackay

Just wondering . . . ever seen a "1-4" for Craftsmen ? Eh Gods, I'd be a "6" ! (very, VERY difficult !)

Re: A question for the professionals

#5

Re: A question for the professionals

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I don't typically do shows myself. But I love art fairs....especially the really high-end ones. I go for the art but I always check out the woodworking. I have seen plenty of craftsmanship "inconsistencies" over the years.

I see woodworkers who will make very fine boxes or small furnishings with plywood drawers. I see gorgeous furniture with cheap "big box" hardware. It doesn't bother me at all. There are no rules. And, as Moses points out, some customers are more discriminating than others.

But as much as some customers don't recognize "corner cutting" other customers really pay attention. My work is not inexpensive. But that means I obligate myself to the level of quality my customers deserve. But that's my own guidepost.

The only thing I see at art fairs that bothers me are woodworkers who blatently steal other designer's unique designs. But that's another issue!

T.

Re: A question for the professionals

#6

David Barnett

Craft shows high and low (long)

David Barnett

"The only thing I see at art fairs that bothers me are woodworkers who blatently steal other designer's unique designs."

Not only in woodworking, of course, but most of the other categories have offenders.

More in jewelry and metalworking than furniture, I have confronted a few egregiously obvious copyists (thieves) with polite but probing questions as to their design 'influences', to put it nicely, and have incurred responses from simply ignoring me and turning away to some of the most creative doubletalk artist-statement-speak that simultaneously amuses and infuriates.

It's unfortunate but expected and understandable for judges to miss some of these imitators simply because they're not always as knowledgeable as we would like them to be, but also because they are overworked and fatigued by a too-often grueling jurying process, seeing too many images at once not to become mind-numbed.

What's more, some judging procedures involve voting by those with no real expertise in a particular field outside their own, the rationale being that they should judge on the general quality and impression the entries make rather than specific knowledge as to where the artists fit into the so-called dialogue of their individual expression within a craft field.

So from the artist's point of view, you submit the best photographs you can to represent your oeuvre , with perhaps a couple shots of your booth layout and look (if allowed), and hope for the best.

From the judges point of view, they'll genuinely try to pick what most impresses them from what may be a sea of sameness, mixed in with rarer but more novel entries (which is where some really interesting mistakes can happen), and try for a good mix with a solid core of proven quality work, styles and attractive prestentations.

When I lived in Northampton, MA, home of the Paradise City shows, the furniture judging and subsequently chosen exhibitors were of high caliber, as were most of the other represented craft fields. You didn't find cheap hardware or poor workmanship in those shows, but Northampton has a long-standing well-deserved reputation for woodworking, with at one time David Powell, Silas Kopf, Michael Coffey, Mason Rappaport, Wm. Sayre and others all in the same building.

As for the ACC shows, I'm not so sure how the recent headquarters move from NYC to Minneapolis is going to play out. I have my doubts. The last one I attended was mostly solid but a few exhibitors gave me pause to wonder if entries were slipping downscale somewhat, and this was before the economy tanked.

Of course, when you have registered knowledgeable buyers at a wholesale show, that's one thing, at open-to-the-public shows, it's another. Either way, those most apt to plunk down the big bucks for the better items usually know what they're looking for in terms of quality and artistic positioning.

What bothers me most are those who walk through the jewelry exhibits taking pictures of items that will be soon be offered in cheaply-made overpriced knockoff versions from wholesaler exporters in one of more Asian countries. True, when the better run shows see this taking place or have it reported to them, they'll often take action, but too often it's not swift enough, and with the plethora of phone cameras, nearly impossible to control.

Woodworking isn't wholly immune, of course, but given the nature, size, and difficulty in mass producing furniture objects, this isn't so much a concern, although the design or gist of a design or signature feature is there for all to see and imitate. But whatever's shown in magazines or on internet sites is apt to get copied these days, so it's a good strategy to make as many unique and more difficult to copy features and difficult to acquire materials in one's exhibited work.

Smaller work suffers the most; boxes, turned items, and so on. The only salvation is to constantly keep changing designs, materials, and features to minimize the knockoff damage to one's business. The notion of copying as the "highest compliment" no longer means anything beyond dishonesty and theft to the individual craftsperson trying to make a decent or even break-even living.

For those plagued by design theft and knockoffs, the overarching strategy may be to prudently choose which shows to attend, which means fewer venues with greater attendance and higher spending ratings from recent shows. It helps to train booth assistants to look for those doing "research" and to promptly dissuade and report them.

At an ACC show I attended years back, I watched an attendee use both a measuring tape and even dial calipers on several wooden boxes in one booth; drawer thicknesses, tops, bottoms, every detail one would need to produce exact copies. He had already taken several photographs (and this was before phones could take pictures). The booth worker, obviously not the boxmaker didn't seem to care at all, continuing to talk to potential customers or between customers staring at the flow of passersby. Nearly a half-hour passed before the 'measuring man' walked away, presumably to another booth. Amazing.

It can get interesting and amusing. I once shared an indoor booth at a small craft show with a close friend and former student, a superb goldsmith who was insecure in promoting his work publicly. We had an attendee become highly miffed and downright irate when we wouldn't share the names of our suppliers, even after politely explaining we had no suppliers, fabricating all our parts from raw materials, alloying our own 22k gold, drawing our own wire and rolling our own sheet. I can't even imagine how she would've made a replica of our Etruscan loop-in-loop granulated chain with off the shelf findings. Another woman waved off our main piece saying "That's not so special. I saw one just like it in the British Museum's Egyptian room."

There are a few sites where art/craft shows trade magazines have anthologized anecdotes of such occurrences. Google something along the lines of craft show horror stories to read some these to marvel at human nature. Really funny.

Anyway, for those who want to know more about the craft show industry, The Crafts Report is a good place to start, and for gallery representation and retailing, Niche is worth a look.

Of course, most of the above wasn't aimed at you, Thomas, but was for others who might wonder about selling their work, and often craft shows are a good place to break in the act. Galleries are where it's at as far as I'm concerned and I don't mean consignment, although I have had my work profitably represented by others at a couple specialized retail shows with adequate security. At any rate, one can learn a lot doing or attending craft shows, and they're all worth at least one look.

Re: A question for the professionals

#7

Re: Craft shows high and low (long)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I will not use names. Just an example of the point. Here is a table designed by a famous mid century designer in the 70's.....


Here is a table I see from this woodworker at many fairs. Different a little....but you be the judge....


Re: A question for the professionals

#8

What's wrong with a little hotmelt among friends? 


Re: A question for the professionals

#9

David Barnett

Good example

David Barnett

The second is definitely not a V.K.

I also see that the 'derivative' inspired (ahem) newer table was removed from one internet source.

While the knockoff's not a 'knockoff' per se, it's certainly far from original. I've seen far more egregious and indefensible examples, too, in woodworking and other crafts, and far too commonly in galleries that should know better. The question can only become "are they ignorant, or are they simply disreputable."

Re: A question for the professionals

#10

Re: Good example

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

IMHO the earlier design was innovative for that time and required a higher level of execution. I have met the later woodworker and I will keep my impression to myself.

I try not to condemn unless I know for sure. I have even caught myself congering up details that I later realize I subliminally took from memory. Once I catch it, to the trash goes that design!

Re: A question for the professionals

#11

It has been going on for centuries

Bill Tindall

Shaker furniture looks similar. Most of what comes out of the College of Redwoods looks similar. Federal Furniture looks similar. Windsor chairs look similar. Queen Ann furniture looks similar. In fact Period furniture is classified by how similar it looks to other furniture of that period. Given this historical precedent one could reasonably expect that any new design that is generally attractive is going to be adapted by other woodworkers. The best that one can hope for is that the new style will be known by the name of its original designer- a Krenov cabinet, a Maloof chair, etc.

Re: A question for the professionals

#12

David Barnett

Almost apocryphal

David Barnett

Only last month somebody told me about a seller at a small local show who said he was 'homaging' another's work, without attribution, of course, when asked about its striking resemblance to the originator. When she informed him who she was (the original artist), he didn't believe her. Turns out he'd copied from another copier, anyway.

As for unconsciously imitating, it can happen to anyone, but artistic integrity means doing as you do, Thomas. Of course, there are degrees of similarity and it's often difficult to not rationalize what differences exist between the new and original, but if the underlying idea's the same and one's re-expression is not significantly novel or distinct, then yes, it should be set aside.

Re: A question for the professionals

#13

David Barnett

I agree with what you say, Bill ...

David Barnett

... but influences and styles are one thing, outright ripoffs and knockoffs quite another.

Re: A question for the professionals

#14

Where is the line?

Bill Tindall

The more I think about this topic the less clear it is where the moral line is located. I am not sufficiently talented to design my own unique style of furniture and might not like to live with it if I was. So everything I have ever made is a more or less copy of something someone else made, which may have been in turn a copy of something else. I have folders full of pictures cut from magazines of stuff I might like to make some day and every issue of FWW design books.

From a picture in a Krenov book I made a bow front wall cabinet which I liked which is as similar to the picture as I could make it. I measured a chest of drawers in Winterthur museum and made a replicate fairly similar. I saw a chest of drawers in a gallery and thought its proportions were nice, measured it and made a similar sized chest of drawers of different wood, moldings, and feet. I took a picture of a tray made by someone and he asked that I not reproduce it exactly. I left the handle off, shrunk it and used a different style of feet, but the attractive fretwork was copied exactly, and in all likelyhood this fretwork pattern dates to 200 years earlier. I don't have a clue if any of these behaviors were offensive or immoral.

Do we have to wait for a designer to die before we can more or less copy the designs, or wait 100 years......or what? Should there only be the Krenov cabinets and Maloof chairs in the world that these designers made themselves....for ever? I am left befuddled, but in reality I will shamelessly more or less copy a design I see if I like the piece of furniture and have the skills to make it, whether it was made in 1720 or 2010.

I don't think I have ever seen this topic discussed from the perspective of someone talented enough to make original design and the rest of the world wanting to make stuff they liked.

Re: A question for the professionals

#15

David Barnett

Re: Where is the line?

David Barnett

Well, Bill... that is the question, and there's not always an easy answer. In furniture, surely one can replicate period furniture, say Queen Ann, Federal, Chippendale, Hepplewhite, even some A&C designs and no-one's going to bat an eye. In fact, how closely you replicate the design and workmanship is key to your success. In woodworking, in glass casting, in jewelry-making, and other crafts which have millenia old traditions and evolution of styles, one would only run into trouble if one replicates with intent to defraud, in essence, to forge with intent deceive and profit from that enterprise.

So one obvious way (but not the only way) to draw the line is legality. If someone owns a design, whether or not they possess a design patent, and another reproduces that design and sells it as his or her own, that can be legally challenged. Copyrights, patents, and other legal instruments, licensing agreements, contracts and so on can protect intellectual property, of course.

When the essence of an owned and novel idea is copied and sold, with altered features, such as proportions, finishes, and so on, it may very well require legal intervention to determine whether the departures are sufficient to establish originality. Whether there was intent to breach another's design by making superficial changes can also figure into the equation, but not always . This can be a very broad and grey area and sometimes it's simply not worth the effort to defend.

On a forum dedicated to jewelry makers, gem setters, silversmiths, and so on, these issues have been covered thoroughly for years. Replicating museum pieces won't likely draw adverse reaction unless they're of substandard execution or materials (there are exceptions, though). But when a novel design and making procedure is owned, to duplicate it without license or claim it as one's own is will likely invoke challenges. With jewelry, the fact that something which may have been originally fabricated from wire or sheet can be knocked off in an inferior cast version and sold at a price undercutting the original designer-maker is an all too-frequent problem and can complicate the protection process.

In the furniture world, Thos. Moser wrote books with plans for his Shaker furniture. To duplicate these designs for one's own use was considered fair use, but selling them to others was not. To measure and copy original Shaker works and make them and sell them as replica Shaker furniture is fair. You will not own the design (though your drawings may be considered copyrighted), nor will you easily challenge another who likewise measures and reproduces his line of furniture from the same originals. You will have to depend on better workmanship, nicer wood, better booth presentation, selling venues and yes, salesmanship to compete with the other fellow.

Now with more recent styles, say pieces with a strong Krenovian influence, one can say "this is a Krenov-inspired cabinet" and that's unlikely to provoke a challenge. Copy and sell a current furniture manufacturer's design, different story.

Yes, it's confusing, it can cause turf wars that may or may not involve lawyers, and it's always a hot topic of discussion in craft forums.

The moral issues aren't so terribly complex, in my opinion. If you make items for your own use, from design books, published and copyrighted drawings and don't make a habit of selling them, you're fine. If someone owns a design and you make and sell it without consent, especially if you make a business of it, that's not fine. If you see someone's original work in a craft show and it's of their design and a distinctly novel design and you think "you know, I could make those and sell them, too," and you give into the temptation and do it, you may not burn for it, but I'd say it's immoral.

So the simple rule for period furniture is the further back you go, the safer. For modern stuff, don't knock it off and try to sell it. If you can't come up with your own design, get legal advice before you make or sell that design, and never ever represent another's design as your own. Except to relatives, maybe.

Re: A question for the professionals

#16

There isn't one...

John in NM

For all practical purposes, it is all fair game unless one can prove their own originality and is willing to defend it in court - as with a patent. Outside of court, the question becomes excessively subjective and usually any discussion degrades to egos and a bunch of chest pounding.

Worrying about people copying one's "original" designs is just another way to race to an already too early grave. A person capable of coming up with truly novel designs always has a huge advantage over the imitators, they can keep designing. Wasting their time worrying about being imitated is just taking time away from the practice of their true skill - designing.

I remember working for a guy who was supposedly the first in town to start making G&G inspired furniture out of local woods. He got very, very offended if anyone came in and wanted to know how we made the little square pegs or some other such nonsense. The whole thing was verging on paranoia, and really a very silly extreme to go to over what were in essence already little more than copies. On the other hand, the boss really did have exceptional taste and a great eye for proportion - I always thought it tragic that he wasted his time tying up his ego in these copies rather than original work he was quite capable of producing.

Re: A question for the professionals

#17

David Barnett

I have to agree, John.

David Barnett

There is truth in everything you say, and I've watched artists driven half mad trying to protect their designs while others laugh off such blatant copying.

At the same time, in other crafts, notably jewelry design, blatant knockoffs and even more subtle encroachments have been successfully challenged by designers and makers, although unlike the individual craft circuit craftsperson, these usually have the backing of large retailers and manufacturers and their legal teams. Neiman-Marcus, Tiffany & Co., et al, don't take lightly to design theft, especially early-on in their retailing of those designs, although as time goes on, one will often see the imitations proliferate until vendors on NYC street corners are selling the knockoffs.

Of course, one doesn't often see this with furniture.

You're dead right. One sure defense against copiers is a boundless imagination and the ability to bring designs quickly to market. Also, one's skill in making, in executing one's original design is another protection. If you can do it better and faster and have a ready market, you're in a far better position.

When I was actively making things, I received email requests for everything from parts and materials suppliers to plans and technical help in product development for those who'd not managed to work out their own methods. I treated those requests with politeness and respect even if the asker's intentions were questionable. More often than not, those who asked were simply ignorant. They thought the elements and working mechanical parts of my designs were off-the-shelf like the 'kits' in turning catalogs or findings in jeweler's supply catalogs. They didn't understand everything I've ever done had been machined from raw materials or fabricated at the jeweler's bench.

In some cases, I've might've agreed to make a one-off so they add the main visible element from their own materials, but when I explained the installation and finishing techniques required, they invariably decided against it. This was not done to purposely discourage them, but that was the effect in every case. Also, I would've had to sell the part for a fair markup over my materials and fabrication costs, and this alone would dissuade most. After realizing what's involved in my product, I'm not surprised they were only too happy to buy one of my already-made pieces.

Also, I've not been averse to teaching how I make certain objects to others, even if it is a making technique that I discovered and developed for myself. Chances are pretty good that I've simply rediscovered something that was done eons ago. I'm not threatened that they will do it better than I can. In fact, I do all I can to make this so. One student learned so well they improved on my technique; everything they did was just a little better than my own, and I quickly partnered up with them so we could learn from each other and mutually improve our art. Our skills in designing, making and marketing complimented one another.

As I said before, when possible, design with the intent to confound copiers, if you can accomplish this without compromising your aesthetics. I have the advantage of skills in several craft fields and the ability to combine them, and even in the same craft field, many of my products have combined complex but subtly rendered designs incorporating enameling, granulation, gem carving and setting, and so on, which makes much of my work too daunting to imitate profitably.

In other words, combine your skills; incorporate carved details into your furniture, boxes, turnings, add tastefully designed features in other materials into your work, such as handwrought hardware, pulls, knobs, glass or stone panels or box elements, and don't forget one-of-a-kind found objects are a great way to confound imitators. You might even discover at some point you're a mixed media artist and wish to enter a show under that crafts category.

Minimalists have the hardest time of it, I suppose, but even so, pristine execution and choice of materials can help. Design proportions, not so much. If you do create an altogether novel design, control your exposure. Get it printed and featured in a magazine, perhaps an ad, gallery or otherwise, so it will be identified as your work, so the crafts cognescenti will recognize its origin as yours.

But I digress...

Getting back to the original question, Bill Tindall's first concern in "Where is the line?" was moral rather than legal, which is what I would expect from Bill, so "it is all fair game unless one can prove their own originality and is willing to defend it in court" is perhaps less germane, as he's asking not whether one can get away with it, rather whether it's right or wrong. I think while there may be individual variation in what one deems to be moral, for the most part these issues address our sense of fair play and right or wrong so will not be too far apart.

Re: A question for the professionals

#18

Re: There isn't one...

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Actualy the line is very clear. A chair per say can not be patented, but if the design is novel and uniqe it can be copyrighted. there are a few minor differences from one media to another but the protection of all intelectual property rights are very clear, they can not be copyied without expressed permission for any purpose. his means you can not make a copy of a protected design for your own, the same as you can not make a computer program for you own use, or make a recording of a movie at the theater for your own use.

Any derivitive work must make significant changes for it to be considered new. Changing the species of wood or the finish or proportions would likely not count as significant. Making a krenov inspired cabinet with Maloof inspied legs would likely be considered significant changes to be considered new as would doing something in someones style that they never did, for instance making a krenov inspired refrigerator.

No body thinks it is right for someone who wants a new car but can't build one on their own to steal one, so why is it okay for anyone to steal the design for a piece of furniture because they can't design one on their own.

Robin

Re: A question for the professionals

#19

David Barnett

Nicely said, Robin

David Barnett

"No body thinks it is right for someone who wants a new car but can't build one on their own to steal one, so why is it okay for anyone to steal the design for a piece of furniture because they can't design one on their own."

That makes it disturbingly clear.

Re: A question for the professionals

#20

Re: Where is the line?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I often read comments similar to yours about not having design skills. It is very common for woodworkers to spend a small fortune on tools and equipment and even on classes and workshops to acquire the skills to use those tools, along with classes in veneer or inlay or haow to make a “X” style chair. What I seldom hear is any reference to woodworkers taking the time to acquire any design skills.

There are a few community colleges that have furniture programs, and many of those have several courses on design. Even if you’re local community college doesn’t offer a furniture program they most likely offer courses in 2 and 3 dimensional design, color theory, drawing, and sculpture courses. All of these will help the burgeoning designer develop some good useful skills.

Robin

Re: A question for the professionals

#21

Re: Craft shows high and low (long)

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Ok so here is one of my more recent horror stories. I was an exhibitor at an ACC show and an ACC board trustee purchased a very nice chair the second day of the 3 day show. I naturally placed a sold sign on the chair and about an hour later a woman wearing designer jeans with silver Conchos on the pockets sat on the chair. The chair had a highly figured walnut pommel seat with a highly polished finish.

That cost me a half day for the repair and a 200 mile delivery.

Re: A question for the professionals

#22

Re: I have to agree, John.

John in NM

The question of right and wrong tends to be rather subjective - hence the need for courts, and of course friendly discussions :D One question to consider, why is it deemed right to copy designs of those who are long dead and presumably anonymous, yet wrong to copy anything else? If it were really a question of morals rather than peer pressure, it would be equally wrong to copy an anonymous and long dead designer.

Accepted standards are often widely different in different trades. On the one hand you are quite right that the jewelry trade is a lot more clear that cribbing another's design is not acceptable. Even there though, there is the question of "inspired" vs. "stolen"...

In furniture, buyers are often far more conservative - a lot of the market wants something that looks familiar, at least a little familiar. Pretty hard to truly be completely original and still be able to make a living. That guy I worked for ran a very popular shop, but he was ripping off G&G, who had simply ripped off Chinese work. I don't mean to criticize selling such copies, just to point out it's harder to sell completely original designs, though maybe ultimately worth it in the long run.

Re: A question for the professionals

#23

Actually...

John in NM

As I understand it, a chair can be patented - using a design patent rather than a utility patent that might be used for a piece of machinery.

Copyright applies to non-functional objects, in some cases furniture (I saw a concrete barcalounger once :D )....

How trademark fits in there is beyond me...

The problem however, is not the protection provided by law, it is in proving infringement. I've had the misfortune to inherit a lawsuit that concerns a fairly simple breach of an unambiguous contract. It has dragged on 5 years now and the outcome is far from certain. While the law is clear and specific, proof of breach and responsibility for damages can be quite difficult to prove.

Re: A question for the professionals

#24

To clarify one thing...

John in NM

My intended observation is that it is futile to worry about being copied rather than to claim it is ok to do the copying.

Re: A question for the professionals

#25

Consider this thought

Bill Tindall

How many people would have heard of Krenov if others didn't copy and adapt his style of furniture? Has anyone ever seen a Krenov original vs something made in this style? Was your appreciation of his style increased by seeing something made in this style by someone else? Was Krenov diminished (or enhanced) in any way by someone else making something in his design style?

From my personal experience....... I like stuff I had seen in this style but from reading his philosophy books I considered him "just" an eccentric artist. Then I set about making a bow front wall cabinet shamelessly copied from one of the books. It soon become apparent that to make stuff in this style one needed new and clever construction techniques not employed in Period furniture. I never would have gotten it made without consultation with one of his students on how to achieve some of the joinery. I came to appreciate that Krenov was a skilled engineer as well as a talented designer. I believe Krenov was enhanced by this exercise, not diminished.

I have come to the conclusion that if you want to be a famous disigner/maker of furniture that the only route to this fame is to get many others to adapt/copy your style.