Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

A question for the professionals

Posts

Re: A question for the professionals

#26

David Barnett

The only route to fame?

David Barnett

"I have come to the conclusion that if you want to be a famous disigner/maker of furniture that the only route to this fame is to get many others to adapt/copy your style."

I have to say, Bill, that I can think of perhaps a hundred early 20th century to mid-century furniture designers who didn't achieve their fame by having their designs copied or knocked off, which isn't to say they weren't in some cases copied, but that the copying was not the sole or even primary mechanism for their fame or success.

Would you say "I sure hope someone copies my designs so I can achieve fame"? I dare say Thomas Moser doesn't believe his fame derives from imitation and intellectual theft as much as from his well-protected designs and his aggressive manufacturing and marketing.

Krenov is a special case inasmuch as he promoted his designs and working methods as part of his teaching and writing, sharing his style and the means to imitate it with real generosity of spirit. Other designers, some builders, others not, work and compete at a very different level, often an elite level where the ongoing dialogue of design and their individual design vocabularies set them apart, bringing fame and notoriety without any need for imitators to elevate their reputations. In fact, some designers achieve fame in a one-off or even a prototype alone.

I think too often woodworkers live in a smaller more parochial world of their tools and techniques of making without exposure to the broader design perspectives of those who consider construction as a means to a design end, as Robin Corell points out in this very thread.

The pieces we see in books and magazines devoted to the studio furniture movement of mostly individual craftspersons is where most of our exposure is likely to occur. There's a wide gulf between this narrow focus, a focus where we make furniture before deciding how to design it, and the larger furniture design world, a world which often dovetails and overlaps with industrial design and architecture, where a designer says "I wonder if I were to design a chair, how would I approach it? What should a chair be?"

We simply don't talk as much about George Nelson or Poul Kjaerholm as Nakashima or Krenov, and that's understandable, as they approached their medium from an entirely different ethos and reverence for wood.

So I have to respectfully disagree with your conclusion of imitation being the only path, but it can and does happen that way from time to time.

Re: A question for the professionals

#27

I think Bill makes an apt point...

John in NM

A large part of Krenov's fame came from his passion for teaching. A large part of that passion necessarily involves encouraging others to build similar works and continue to push that trend of design in new ways using new ideas.

At what point does "inspired" become "copied"?

And, one more time, why is it considered ok to copy old stuff, presumably anonymous, and not acceptable to copy newer works? How many modern designers have come up with something that looks a lot like a Barcelona chair? Or a Parson's table?

Re: A question for the professionals

#28

David Barnett

So if it walks like a duck

David Barnett

"A large part of Krenov's fame came from his passion for teaching. A large part of that passion necessarily involves encouraging others to build similar works and continue to push that trend of design in new ways using new ideas."

And I said:

"Krenov is a special case inasmuch as he promoted his designs and working methods as part of his teaching and writing, sharing his style and the means to imitate it with real generosity of spirit."

I'd also add that Krenov guided and encouraged students to explore his design vocabulary and was happy to promote his students work, which in spite of many innovative features, are still often quite derivative, as one would expect. Nothing wrong with that.

"At what point does "inspired" become "copied"?"

When it's hard to find anything significantly novel in the ensuing version. When it's obvious. Don't forget, there are many artists, craftpersons, designers and performers who copy their own work, their earlier successes, often tiresomely. Sometimes they move on, sometimes not. But at least in these cases, they were originators of their signature style or their individual expression of a broader style.

"And, one more time, why is it considered ok to copy old stuff, presumably anonymous, and not acceptable to copy newer works?"

Again, when its origins and chronology are obvious, at least to those not entirely ignorant of the original work or designer's oeuvre and place in the history and development of design. Copying another's design, something not perhaps as easily or yet widely recognizable as another's design, to represent as one's own is theft, plain and simple, and no rationalizing will make it otherwise. The fact that is too often done is shameful.

[added] Of course, once a design's been around long enough, you can claim it as your own and if no one exposes you or challenges you, you got away with it, which to me doesn't make it right. That there's no longer legality at issue wouldn't change a thing for me. Even if you were to hire lawyers and legally make someone else's recent design your protected property, that's still theft in my book and in spite of a legal appropriation of another's original work, it is immoral. "Just because the cat had her kittens in the oven, that don't make 'em biscuits."

"How many modern designers have come up with something that looks a lot like a Barcelona chair? Or a Parson's table?"

Too many. And I would make a distinction between first designers and those also described as designers as second designers.. We apparently have or use only one word to describe different classes of designers. We could draw distinctions between designers who really created something with little or no predecessors, and those that modernizeor update a design, perhaps making it easier to produce, giving it a new look, making it more accessible through economies of manufacture, and so on.

I'd say that covering a parson's table in galuchat departs from the original parson's table to the extent that it shows, or once showed during the Art Deco, a novel way of presenting that established design. No one of even only moderate sophistication will fail to recognize that parson's table's modernist beginnings, mistake it for anything but a parson's table, but will see the galuchat re-expression of it for what it is, regarding the novel material as making us appreciate the interplay of its original simplicity and minimalist lines from a textural reinterpretation.

In the following decade, that parson's table will be covered in parchment or vellum to fit within another design context. So I'd regard this as design, but design at a lower rung on the hierarchical ladder.

A copy of a Barcelona chair is simply that, a copy of a Barcelona chair. If you wish to regard the new 'designer' as a designer of the first caliber, that's your right, but I wouldn't likely grace the subsequent with any comparison to the former. If one sees the new chair as a Barcelona chair, then I'd say it's a copy of a Barcelona chair. If it sits like a Barcelona chair, is built like a Barcelona chair, and you'd call it a Barcelna chair, then only those elements that depart from a Barcelona chair can be considered for their design value, and if those elements do not offer enough novelty to make you not see it as a Barcelona chair, then it's a Barcelona chair and not an original one.

That's how I see it, anyway. There's lots of room for argument, drawing distinctions both subtle and gross, which has long fueled this part of the design debate. Fun, no?

Re: A question for the professionals

#29

Looks like I missed that...

John in NM

Got distracted looking at pictures from the other guys you mentioned, Oh well :D

Incidentally, looking at the pics is what lead me to the notion about the Barcelona chair :D -- Moser has the most defensible version, being wood framed rather than chromed steel.

I don't think there is much of a consensus on the question when it comes to furniture, much less so than with less functional crafts or even sculpture. Part of the reason is that, as I mentioned before, the customer is usually very conservative when it comes to furnishings. Another part is likely due to the difficulties in enforcing design patents vs. copyright (my understanding is that it gets easier the less functional something is).

Putting the legal questions aside, since few of us are really qualified to debate them intelligently, I still maintain that the most sensible course is to simply make a practice of acknowledging one's influences and get to building. Opening saying that your work is greatly influenced by your favorite designers is the best way to thank them for their contribution to our culture - and that is what Bill was alluding to. It is also honest, both to the world and to ourselves.

Should I ever be so fortunate as to come up with anything original (doubtful :D ),

I'd like to think that I genuinely wouldn't mind being copied, as long as the copier

acknowledges my contribution. Should they pass it off as their own, well the

only thing to do then is utter a few unprintable reflections on their ancestry and

get back to building :D

Re: A question for the professionals

#30

In a different field......

Bill Tindall

Science is as much to do with creativity as art or craft. In Science the worth and validity of ones creativity is only realized when it is copied(repeated) and used by others. There is even a means of keeping score- citations. One can readily find how many times a scientist's work has been cited by others. To become famous others must repeat your creativity and find it useful . Is there a fundamental reason that creativity in craft should have a different value system?

Re: A question for the professionals

#31

David Barnett

Keep looking

David Barnett

Citing is fine in craft and science. In neither case is the scientist or craftsman claiming the original work as his or her own. Sure, there are those who may try to claim fame as the originators, but they're simply liars or thieves, scientists maybe but failed scientists, craftspersons maybe but failed and dishonest craftspersons.

"There is even a means of keeping score- citations."

Also, in science as in other creative fields, there is another way of keeping score - patents. But there is a reason science is not arts and crafts, which is, because it's science, which relies on verification through reduplication. The basis for protection of one's intellectual property is prior art. Scientists protect their novel discovery by becoming first publishers of their research, prior art. Established one's prior art in, well, art is getting it seen and documented.

I still don't believe it's necessary to be copied to become famous. I think it's very likely, however, that after you become famous, you will be copied by those lacking in imagination, talents, or integrity to profit not from yours but from their own. Did Einstein get copied to become famous? No. Granted his thought experiments required verification, but did those who did that work claim it as their own? No. Were they part of Einstein's intitial creative process? No. His imagination? No.

Let me ask you, do you think Mozart really had to be copied before he became famous? Beethoven? Stravinsky? Mondrian? Miro? Picasso? Escher? Balzac? Proust? One can find numerous artists, writers, composers who won't be copied for many years because they can't be copied. It may take years to deconstruct their art to imitate it's individual and idioscyncratic essence.

Try to compose an Elliott Carter piece, any piece. Not even his style is that easily deconstructed, and believe me, there are few musicologists who can even approach understanding him at the level required to imitate him.

Nope. Not gonna buy it. Not so.

Re: A question for the professionals

#32

not so

Bill Tindall

Mozart is famous only because his scores have been copied thousands of times. Elliott Carter(?) isn't because they haven't.

Re: A question for the professionals

#33

David Barnett

"If you can't imitate him, ...

David Barnett

... don't copy him." -- Yogi Berra

"Elliott Carter(?) isn't because they haven't."

Now that's funny! We can only hope he gives back the two Pulitzers.

Re: A question for the professionals

#34

It's a long way from culture.......

Bill Tindall

to East TN. I can barely see it from here. I have heard of Doc Watson, but don't like his music. It sounds just like all the other people's music and the first 10 seconds sounds just like the next 10 seconds, and the next, and the next......tedious.