Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

seeking planer advice

Posts

seeking planer advice

#1

seeking planer advice

Pete

Hi,

I'm new to this site and fine woodworking and this is my first posting.

I want to buy a planer and don't know anything about them.

Are powermatics a good dependable brand, or are some of the others a better quality?

I am keeping my eye on a 24" powermatic planer, model 224 3 phase

Since I do not have 3 phase, could I remove the motor and replace it with a gasoline engine with the same HP? I know that there are in feed and outfeed motors also and I don't know if they also are 3 phase or 1 phase, but they may be easier (cheaper) to replace than the big motor. Is this a do-able and feasible idea that I have, or is this a stupid and lame brained idea that I should forget about? I think that I can get this one for around 2 grand.

I know of an 18" powermatic planer (green w/white stripe) that is single phase, which would be plug and play for me. It is in like new condition according to the ad and has the grinder with it. Is something like that worth the $3500.00 asking price? How much is something like that worth?

I would like the larger planer as there are some 24" wide pieces that I want to make and the larger planer would do that well, but I'm wondering if it is worth the money and effort. The 18" planer while plug and play would mean my having to join together panels to come up with the final dimension. My worry there is keeping the final product as flat as I can get it.

These 2 planers are fairly close to me and look to be in pretty decent shape. I don't want to spend a year doing restorations.

I'm hoping that some of you that know about planers can provide some sound advice.

My most immediate use of the larger planer would be to fabricate a table top for my industrial size radial arm saw. I also want to build some cabinets and furniture and don't really know what sort of capacity I will need for that since I've not done it before.

I realize that those of you that are professional woodworkrs may think that I'm an idiot, but everyone has to start somewhere. I'm just trying to get into this. Besides, isn't it better to ask a stupid question than to make a stupid mistake? Isn't that what these forums are for, so that the inexpereinced can get practical advice from the experienced? Set me straight.

Thank you, Pete

Re: seeking planer advice

#2

JL

Re: seeking planer advice (long)

JL

To answer your questions in order.

I would not recommend replacing a 7.5 hp 3 phase electric with a gasoline motor. That would limit you to a very well ventilated shop - or outdoors. I would avoid modifying any electric motor with a gasoline, propane or diesel motor for that reason.

I would consider sizing your planer to the lumber rather than the finished piece. As an example, I buy most of my lumber in the 6-10" wide range. Once in a while I buy a piece that is wider - but I have to pay more for it.

I face joint my lumber on my jointer before planing it. That way I know I have a smooth side. I can then plane to that smooth side.

The 18" planer is a bit overpriced. Redmond Machinery will sell you a new 20" for about $2800.

A thought - there is no problem with going large - if you are a commercial operation. But if you aren't - why go that large?

Consider the following.

A 15" planer (with or without a helical insert head) - will plane almost any lumber you are likely to see.

A reasonable sized jointer (8-12") to face joint the lumber - there are ways to use an 8" jointer to joint wide lumber.

A drum sander (22/44") to put a smooth finish on your tops and other panels.

When I want to do a wide top, I glue it up using clamping cauls to make sure the pieces are aligned. That way I can make sure that I don't have to sand any ridge lines away.

Re: seeking planer advice

#3

Re: seeking planer advice

Jim Dillon

Good morning Pete,

Welcome to Woodcentral! JL has given you some very solid advice and I concur. When I started buying woodworking equipment sometime in the mid-90s, the so-called "lunchbox" planers were starting to make their appearance and were designed to offer more portability than the much bigger (and heavier) planers as well as being less expensive. While the smaller planers may not have the capacity of their bigger brothers, they have, over time, proven themselves to be outstanding performers. Powermatic, Delta, and DeWalt all offer competitive planers with a 12 inch or so capacity. For value, Grizzley and Jet can't be beat. And many of these brands now are offering helical cutting heads at affordable prices. I have been happy with my DeWalt and would replace it in an instant with another DeWalt, only with a helical head. Unless you envision building a large production cabinet shop planing boards all day long, I vote for a smaller planer. And a 8-inch jointer. For other opinions, check out the specific model on Amazon and you will find lots of advice, pro and con.

And don't worry about those very wide boards. As you learn more, you will find that there are ways to plane (and joint) those boards by first cutting them down to size, then gluing them up to give you a single board that you will have a hard time finding the seam. And there are even ways to smooth very large planks intended for tabletops by using other portable tools, jigs etc.

Have fun,

Jim

Re: seeking planer advice

#4

Re: seeking planer advice

David Yoho

Pete, most of what I build in my shop is for customers. Unless you are setting up a commercial shop, I think your needs can be downsized a bit.

Before planing rough lumber, it will first need to be jointed flat on one face. This will register against the bottom of the planer and yield a flat board to the desired thickness. That said, you should try to size your jointer to your planer the best you can. There are combo machines out there where the capacity are the same or you could go with dedicated machines.

I use an 8-inch jointer and a 13-inch "lunch-box" planer. If I need something over the jointer's capacity but less than the planer's, I rip to fit my jointer width and glue it back. Normally when I make larger panels I surface individual boards at the jointer and planer and glue up the pieces.

The larger two-speed "lunch-box" planers give a fairly smooth finish with the standard knives because of the speed of the cutterhead.

Re: seeking planer advice

#5

Re: seeking planer advice

John in NM

Good morning Pete, and welcome to WC.

Those old wide Powermatics are fantastic machines, made in the US. New machines are almost universally imported, hence the price premium often put on the old machines. If those planers are in nice condition, they will command a higher price than a new import of similar size. However, a lot of vendors think that an old US machine is still worth extra $$$ when it's been used hard and not maintained. So proceed with caution.

One advantage to vintage Powermatics is that they are very well thought out machines. You will be able to re-adjust most anything that gets out of whack. You will need some machinists tools to do so, but there's always a way to do it.

This may be the case with some imports as well, I've only worked with one - but it had some real logic problems in it's design and construction (it was a Bridgewood).

One word of caution, those old machines are very heavy. You cannot move them by getting a bunch of guys together to pick it up and put it in your truck. Lifting such a machine by slinging it under the moving bed of the planer can damage the machine (I've seen that happen). If you don't have access to a forklift, things are going to get interesting. The 18" weighs about 3/4 ton, so its just barely in the range of most pickups, the 24" is probably a bit heavy to go in a light truck, you'd need a trailer or medium truck.

I agree with JL and Jim that you'll likely not need more than 18". I'm still using an old 12" (PM100) planer, I rarely need anything wider than that. You can always use a belt sander or hand planes on those rare occasions.

Re: seeking planer advice

#6

Re: seeking planer advice

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

You mentioned that one of the powermatics has a grinder attachement and that makes me wonder if it has a spiral head. Some of the older powermatics have spiral heads that use HSS knives rather than the carbide segments that the new breed of spiral heads use. the old style of spiral heads that powermatic used required the knives to be sharpened in place hence the grinder, but not all planers with grinders used spiral knives.

If its a spiral head and it is in good condition the price is not that far out of line but it is still a bit high.

Also since no one has said anything, I would use ply or MDF for a radial arm table.

Robin

Re: seeking planer advice

#7

Re: Drum or Belt Surface Sander

Charlie Lenz

For the wide boards or after glue up, wouldn't this be a more economical choice for a hobbyist ? You could still get a surface planer, but it wouldn't have to be such a large one.

Re: seeking planer advice

#8

Re: seeking planer advice

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I personally would not purchase either of the planers you mentioned. Most 3 phase old equipment has been heavily used and may require some mechanical work - if you are talented in this area they probably are great machines after you "tune" them. I would not attempt to refit a woodworking machine with a gas engine, fumes, fire hazard, speed control, stopping safely etc. would make it a poor choice in my opinion. As far as Powermatic being a good brand, it WAS. Today as far as I know every machine they make is imported. I purchased their new woodworking drill press, and wish I had gone with Grizzly. I do have one of their old made in USA lathes and it is top quality. I do have a 20" planer and really like it and do use much of the capacity when planing panels but the others may be right in stating a drum or belt sander and a smaller planer may be a better deal. However for me I like my setup - I am not a pro by any means. I would recommend Grizzly equipment over Delta or Powermatic today. The Grizzly equipment I have has performed well, the prices are good, and the fit and finish looks better than the new Delta and Powermatic I have seen. Many of the people on this site have Grizzly - you certainly can ask their opinion on any machine you are interested in - I'm sure some have that particular machine You can purchase a 20" Grizzly with the spiral (segmented carbide inserts) head delivered to your door ready for use for around $2800. I have a Byrd head (similar to the grizzly spiral head but more expensive) in my planer (not a Grizzly) and a Grizzly 8" joiner with their spiral head and the finish from both is almost identical. I did work with a DeWalt 13" lunchbox planer for a few years - it did do the job pretty well but the ends of the boards do have snipe, and the finish does not compare to a spiral head.

Re: seeking planer advice

#9

if you want another alternative

DizD

you could look at Woodmaster Tools. I don't own one but I have friend with a millwork shop who has used five of them for over 10yrs and still going strong. The variable speed infeed motor is a great feature.

Re: seeking planer advice

#10

Re: if you want another alternative

Larry in nw ohio

Pete First welcome to WC, and don`t think you asked any kind of dumb question, just dumb people that do not ask the question and really screwed something up or got hurt. I hope you stick around quite awhile. I was going to suggest a sander, but DizD got to it first. I have had 25" woodmaster sander for over 10 years and wouldn`t it for anything but a big belt sander, but a lot more expensive. It`s a very good sander and you don`t need a planner. I get rough lumber and use 40 grit paper and sand it flat pretty quick, that way I don`t have more machines lying around taking up space that I don`t have, and use the money for something I can really use. If you live around Kansas City, that is where they are made, you may get one for a better price. If you have any questions just let me know. Larry

Re: seeking planer advice

#11

Re: if you want another alternative

Pete

I want to thank all of you for the replies.

I think that a woodmaster sander sounds like a good idea.

One of the draws for me to the 18" planer is that it is like new, made in USA (I think the new ones are made in China now) and it has the knife grinder. I thought about all of the work I would have had to convert the 25" planer and didn't go for it. Maybe it wasn't the brightest thing I've ever done, but I got the 18" planer.

I do like the thoughts of a drum sander or wide belt though and in hind sight the sander may have met my needs better. When I rebound from buying the planer I may just end up getting a woodmaster sander also. When I have both machines for comparison, I'll decide if I want to keep both or just sell the planer. I just didn't want to pass up the chance to buy one of the American made Powermatic planers in like new shape. If I find out that I really don't need it then I'll sell it.

I live in PA and there are a lot of trees here and I can buy rough cut lumber from many sources. My thoughts are that I can get some nice woods of different species and finish it myself for a lot less than getting it from a lumber yard.

I'm just getting started and still need to get an 8" jointer, a bandsaw and a shaper amongst other things. I'll be hanging around and I'll update as I continue to get set up.

For now I have an old 4" Duro jointer and a couple of Dewalt radial arm saws. One of them is a GE 5HP single phase and another is a 7790, which is a true 2HP. I have a bunch of shapers with very many profiles that work with the smaller saw. Also have a router, a drill press and a smaller Delta jig or scroll (what its the difference between them?) saw and many hand tools that my father has used for a lot of decades.

I think that I have enough stuff now to start with some small projects and work my way up to larger ones as I get some experience and get more tooling.

I reall like the advice that you folks offered up here and I will definately ask your advice before I make another big investment again.

Thank you all who replied to my post,

Pete

Re: seeking planer advice

#12

Re: if you want another alternative

Larry in nw ohio

I`m very glad that someone here could help you in someway, that`s what WC is here for, is to help any type of woodworker and don`t think that any question you may want to ask "is stupid". No question is stupid here. If you havn`t seen it, it may be in the archives and you just didn`t look for it, or someone else just didn`t run into that situation as of yet, so I hope you stick around, Ellis runs a great site, the best on the web. Larry