Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

A practical alternative to Bloxgen

Posts

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#26

There are special case exceptions

Bill Tindall

Beer has a very short shelf life in any bottle that is economically feasible to make. One can find special event beer in plastic bottles where it is certain that it will be consumed in a short time, for example base ball game beer. Game beer is always served opened and the mouth of the bottle is huge for a reason. If thrown, the bottle is designed to largely empty before reaching a target.

Ketchup has the same oxygen problem but the oxygen permeability problem is solved with a very expensive 5 layer bottle. Apparently ketchup users are not as frugal as beer drinkers.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#27

Re: no again

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

The cheap ones, but definitely not all. There are plenty of bottles that block oxygen, etc. IV bags and hazardous or reactive chemicals are shipped and stored in plastic containers all the time.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#28

Re: Bloxygen is argone

Jason Waters

Luckliy that wasn't on a vinyl tile floor. More than one has had tiles pop loose form the liquid nitrogen freezing them and contracting them rapidly causing the glue to let loose. Chem lab can be fun, albeit dangerous at times.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#29

Re: A practical alternative to Blogen(sp?)

Jason Waters

Grant,

That is an excellent idea, displace the used area.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#30

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

Jason Waters

Paintball cylinders are CO2. Lowe's used to sell a kit to use paintball cylinders with a nailgun. I have one, and I like it for limited use. So you could displace the air with co2 in this manner. But I have CO2/argon mix for welding too.

I like plastic bottles, when the finish comes in that, then you can squeeze out the air. But you can't use any old plastic bottle always.

Argon in a tank would be best. But Nitrogen is good too, but remember to use "dry nitrogen" which most purchased gas bottles are. If I was getting bulk nitrogen, I'd make sure it was from a tank and not a "nitrogen generator" (membrane system) that makes mostly nitrogen, but still has some oxygen and some water.

I generally don't find it a huge issue, and try to buy about the right amount for a project, and go through it regularly.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#31

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I suppose I'm just old fashioned....

Jesper, Denmark

Do nothing. Let the finish skin over. When you need to use it, carefully remove the skin and use the rest.

Just remember NOT to shake the can before you open it.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#32

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

Sgian Dubh

Bill, isn't most of the fiddling about to save the remains of a can of varnish a bit pointless, and also not really cost effective? If you are using so little of the material that you have this problem then isn't it just about as economical, or perhaps just safer with regard to satisfactory finishing to buy a new can of the stuff and dispose of the old varnish?

In relation to the money, time and effort required to make a piece of furniture, or other wooden artefact, I find the cost of the finishing materials is trivial really, yet essential for a good result.

Apart from occasionally throwing a few marbles or clean stones in a can of certain types of finish for relatively short term storage I generally simply dump old and suspect stuff and buy new. Slainte.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#33

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

Bill,

My thought is carbon dioxide. Probably the first gas that any elementary school aged child created by mixing vinegar and baking soda.

I'd use a plastic coffee can, punch a suitable size hole in the lid for a length of tubing, and stick said tubing through the lid. Then run the tube into the finish container. Dump some baking soda into the coffee can, followed by vinegar, and pop on the lid.

The only problem I see is controlling the foam in the coffe can from getting into the tube (and the finish container). Enough headspace above the soda/vinegar should eliminate that problem and a bit of experimentation (with really cheap ingredients) should point to the correct amount to dump into the coffee can.

Al

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#34

good reasons to cheaply solve the problem

Bill Tindall

The fact that a successful , albeit expensive, product is available to meet this need validates the need for some situations.

To note a few examples, perhaps unique to me.....

1. Marketing is such that quarts of finish, stain and paint cost half what a gallon costs.

2. Some products are only available in gallons or available with such inconvenience (Canadian varnish) that buying a several years supply is necessary or prudent.

3. I use lots of oil based paints for metal objects about the farm and for house trim and floors.

4. I have a large selection of oil based stains, often only available in quarts and larger.

The result is that I have more than a dozen needs to inert a partial container of varnish, paint or stain.

To take a recent example, I bought a gallon of porch enamel for basement stairs(only sold in gallons). I used 2 quarts to prefinish the treads and skirt boards. In the future I will need to paint the moldings and likely some touch up. I solved this problem by putting the remaining paint is recovered quart cans (new ones cost a lot). It would have been lots handier to inert the gallon can. And handier still to have on hand some of this paint for future touch up as needed.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#35

Ellis Walentine

My dad taught me that trick

Ellis Walentine

... and I still use it. In fact, I just used up a jar of original Waterlox Transparent that dad put up in 1985. It was still just as fresh as the day he bought it.

Ellis

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#36

Excellent Discussion!!


Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#38

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

Larry in NW Ohio

I seem to remember awhile back seeing a commercial on TV that was selling some kind of product that they would put a valve in a left over food container and put a hose in someplace in the container also. Then they would connect that hose to a vaccum pump and they would pull the air out of the container. When the air was all out they would then turn the valve closed and turn off the pump. I think that would be just the thing for this. Now if I could remember where I saw it. Anybody. Larry

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#39

Not A Good Idea

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

All finishes use some kind of volatile carrier or solvent, from petroleum distillates to water. If you put the container under vacuum, you lower the boiling point of these liquids, and you'll wind up messing up the chemistry of the finish as they vaporize and get sucked out by your pump. Try this with a vacuum pump (find a turner) and some shellac in a glass jar with a stout lid so you can see the alcohol bubble and foam out of the mix.

It's neat to do this with epoxy casting resin because it has a certain amount of water content. We used to mix it and then put it under vacuum to draw out all the mixed-in air to get clear castings. The stuff would foam up to 5 times its volume letting the water vapor and air out of the mix before we'd pour into the mold.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#40

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

John Pappas

After reading the suggested alternatives, it is my humble opinion that Bloxygen is the simplest and best alternative . Simple, quick, easy.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#41

Re: Aluminum foil?

AZ in Colorado Springs

How would you get a seal around the egdes of the foil? I'm picturing in my mind "tucking" the foil down along the sides of the can. But, of course, what keeps it tucked in?

Alternately, if you had a foil disc sized to the inside of the can, whenever you move the can (to put it on the shelf, f'rinstance), the finish sloshes over the top.

I've not read the entire thread yet (maybe this has been addressed), but what about the idea of setting the container upside down, so the skin forms "underneath" the leftover product?

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#42

a bigger problem

Bill Tindall

A modest amount off sucking would not alter the finish composition but the vapors might alter the pump seals. The larger problem is that the vapor pressure of mineral spirits is not high enough to keep the can from collapsing from the vacuum. This is not a theoretical concern; I've done it.


Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#43

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

AlanWS

Try one of the "compressed gas dusters" sold for getting dust out of keyboards and other electronics. They can be cheaper than Bloxygen, and are not much different. The difluoroethane versions (check the MSDS for composition, or it might even be on the label) should work fine. That would be more dense than argon.

The thing to keep in mind is that you are not trying to add something to the can of varnish, but trying to push out the air. Even a dense gas will mix somewhat if you pour it in, so what you want to do is stick the end of the small tube into the can with the cover mostly installed, and spray until the air has been flushed out, then pull out the tube and push the can closed. That little tube is probably more important than the gas identity.

The best way to make the finish last is to open the can, remove some finish for use, and immediately flush out air and seal the can. Now you can use the finish you removed, but do not return any to the can. The reason is that the reaction with oxygen takes place in two steps. In the first step, oxygen reacts with the finish, helped along by light, to form peroxides. In the second step, these peroxides can react in the dark and absence of oxygen to cure the finish. Putting finish back in the can that has been exposed to air and light for a significant amount of time can trash the finish. Treating it as suggested above can make it last as well as if you had not opened the can.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#44

Dad taught me...

Tom Dunlap

...in the early'60s when I was getting into the shop more to turn the cans upside down and store in smaller containers. He said that it worked most of the time, and I've found that to be true.

Tom

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#45

I'll bet it won't work

Bill Tindall

If the gas added is soluble in the finish solvent a vacuum will be created in the can and it will collapse. I predict that the duster gas is as soluble as propane which failed for this reason.

However, if the can is less empty less vacuum will be created and it will work. But then so will gas from the gas grill.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#46

Look at CRC Duster

Dave Paine

Bill,

I purchased Bloxygen until a friend gave me some cans of CRC Duster. I work for an industrial gas company which makes Nitrogen and Argon, the types of molecules inexpensive enough for Bloxygen.

The principal of Bloxygen is to blanket the vapour space with a mixture of gases which do not contain oxygen.

CRC Duster is a halocarbon equivalent. Cheaper than Bloxygen, a liquid, so far many more molecules in the can. Enough that I do not worry about a few extra seconds to try and get the oxygen out before closing a lid.

I now use CRC Duster in place of Bloxygen to maintain my finishes. I still have my last can of Bloxygen partially used.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#47

details please

Bill Tindall


The picture shows what happens to a half full gallon container can of paint when the air is displaced with propane. The propane dissolves into the paint solvent, creates a vacuum and the can collapses.

I would have guessed that the Duster gas would dissolve as well as propane and suffer the same problem. However, if the finish can is more full, there is less vacuum and the can might not collapse. Also smaller cans will resist collapse better.

Have you ever tried the Duster on a gallon container only partially full? Or, more to the point, under what conditions does it work? As you say, it is hands down the best choice if the can doesn't collapse. I would additionally suggest storing the cans upside down. If there is a tiny leak the finish will seal it.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#48

Re: details please *LINK*

Dave Paine

Bill,

The product is > 99% 1,1,1,2-Tetrafluoroethane (HFC-134a). I am not expecting this complex halocarbon would easily dissolve in paint.

I have used this with oil based finishes, but not with paint. It did prevent the skin on the finish. Some of the finishes start to react with any oxygen and go off after x months. Had this happen with Salad Boxl finish from two different manufacturers, both products gelled. Time to replace.

With this being a liquid in the can, lots of volume when evaporated.

Link to manufacturers web site for the MSDS.


http://www.crcindustries.com/faxdocs/msds/14085.pdf

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#49

Re: good reasons to cheaply solve the problem

Sgian Dubh

Bill, given what you've since described I can understand why you're looking to find a way to preserve partially used wood finishes. If the truth is told I too have found it frustrating to seal a partially used container if finish, usually paint of one sort or another for house decoration, etc, only to find a year or so later that it's gone thick, skinned over, or even turn into a useless lump. I find it irritatin to have to go and find more of the same stuff fresh, but I suppose I've just got used to accepting it. Slainte.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#50

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

dgdubya

You can get Argon gas at a welding supply store, used for Mig welding. I think it cost me $20 last time I refilled my tank. Now of course you need a tank to fill, or one of theirs, but they're nice and heavy so at least you feel like you're getting something rather than the empty can feel from Bloxygen.

For Tung oil which comes in a plastic container, I squeeze the air out. Other finishes get marbles or decanted into smaller containers, usually glass (I know don't drop them).