Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

A practical alternative to Bloxgen

Posts

A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#1

A practical alternative to Bloxgen

Bill Tindall

. It is the stuff in a spray can to make left over finish last in the can.

The problem: Oil based finishes- varnish, polyurethane, oil paint- cure by reaction with oxygen. Put the lid on a half empty can of varnish and 20% of the gas trapped inside is oxygen, eager to set off the curing of what varnish remains regardless of how well the can is sealed. The dreaded crust of hardened varnish will greet you upon opening the can some time later.

The solution: Displace the oxygen from the can before sealing. Bloxgen is just some gas that isn't oxygen or air. I suppose it is nitrogen, or it may be carbon dioxide, as either would work. The problem is that a can of the stuff costs almost as much as the left over varnish is worth.

Alternatives: In principal any gas but oxygen or air will displace oxygen from the can and preserve the varnish. However, my "brilliant" idea of using propane from the gas grill was not successful. Propane dissolves in the varnish solvent, a vacuum is created, and the can collapses. So what other gas might be handy and cheap?

A few small pieces of dry ice would work perfectly, but it requires a trip to the grocery store to get some.

Now days many tire stores have compressed nitrogen for the bogus purpose of inflating tires. Portable air tanks are readily available. One of these tanks pressurized to 150 psi with nitrogen would become a life time supply of gas to displace air from varnish and paint cans. I am going to try to rig a "Freon" tank for this purpose. Perhaps someone can think of an even more convenient solution.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#2

Re: A practical alternative to Blogen(sp?)

John Pappas

Bill, I have read, but not verified, that good wine shops carry a similar product at less cost. As with varnish, a good wine that has been opened can be protected as well. (Not necessary for the wine I drink.) As for the Bloxygen, I have used it and like it, A can seems to last a long time. But, to be honest, I have not tried to evaluate the cost/savings benefits.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#3

Re: A practical alternative to Blogen(sp?)

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Try breathing on it. If you hold your breath long enough, the CO2 content should be high and the O2 content low. I don't know if the moisture in your breath would affect the finish, though. It'd be cheap for sure.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#4

Re: A practical alternative to Blogen(sp?)

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Simple solution- transfer fluid to a container with collapsible plastic liner- think Bag-o'-wine (in a box with vent hole) or an IV bag. As fluid is dispensed via spigot or other spout, the bag collapses via atmospheric pressure- absolutely no air enters the container. Great for storing and dispensing finishes and glues. Re-usable. Bag and spigot material must be impervious to chemicals in contents.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#5

Re: A practical alternative to Blogen(sp?)

Grant Wilkinson

I've used two methods successfully. I use the collapsible bottles from Lee Valley to store the left overs. Or, I put marbles into the can until the liquid level is back to the top. I've been re-using the old marbles for a lot of years.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#6

no

Bill Tindall

one extracts but a tiny amount of oxygen from the air in lungs.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#7

no again

Bill Tindall

Almost all plastics are a "screen door" when it comes to blocking the diffusion of oxygen and other small molecules through the plastic. This is why you don't see beer bottled in plastic and why soda in plastic bottles goes flat after a few months.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#8

Unfortunately

Neal in San Jose

That won't work. You will begin to feel light-headed at oxygel levels below 18.5%, and the oxygen sensors (in my plant, anyway) are set at 19%, and breathing on them doesn't set them off. So, I'm guessing that the oxygen level in your exhaled breath won't be low enough to make much difference. Normal air is at about 20.5 %.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#9

Re: no again

john lucas

It was suggested on another forum if it is an oil based product simply pour water in and the oil will rise to the top. Similar to filling the excess space with marbles. I haven't tried it yet but supposedly this came from David Ellsworth who is a master woodturner.

I purchased a can of wine preservative which is supposed to help but the people from Bloxygen say the wine preservative is not the same stuff.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#10

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have been thinking about using the gas from my MIG welder. It is a mix of Argon and CO2. Haven't done it yet but don't know why it wouldn't work ok. However if you don't have a welder the tank & regulator cost would be in the range of $100. Would probably be a life time supply. I own my tanks (Thoroughbred- I believe is the name so don't have to have them inspected when refilled and no time lease. You might check at one of the Farm stores that carry that brand to see if they have a more cost effective solution.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#11

Surely they were kidding!

Keith Newton

So as you start getting down to the boundary level between the two fluids, how will your brush know to only pick up varnish without getting contaminated with water?

I can only imagine how bad the fish-eye would be with a spoonful of water in the bottom of a spray gun. Maybe there is a way, but I'm sceptical of this idea.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#12

Bloxygen is argone

Alex Grigoriev

according to the manufacturer. Argone is heavier than air.

Pure nitrogen is slightly lighter than air (28 per mol vs 29), so you won't be able to "pour" it into an open container.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#13

JL

Why not just get a "soda" tank??

JL

You can get a cylinder of pressurized CO2 from one of the distributors. CO2 weighs in at 44 as opposed to air which averages 29 so it is heavier than air.

CO2 may be somewhat soluble in varnish, but probably not as much as propane - so I don't think it would be a problem.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#14

Re: Bloxygen is argone

Keith Newton

Alex, That must be at the same temperature, where the nitrogen is lighter.

However, a few years ago, William Powell, head of the Bureau of weights and measures gave a talk at the Clinton Library. At the beginning of his talk, he poured some liquid nitrogen into a bait-bucket. Then periodically during the talk, he would blow up a baloon, and push it down into the bucket.

By the end of the talk, there must have been a dozen inflated balloons in that bucket. Then at the end, with tongs, he started pulling them out, flat as pancakes, he started flinging them out over the audience like frisbies, where the air expanded them back to spherical.

Then he poured it out onto the floor, which caused a low cloud of fog as the moisture condensed around the cold boundary layer of air.

This was from the head of the lab which managed to slow the speed of light, and measure time in nanoseconds. I believe this was the most interesting talk I have ever attended in my whole life. I think you can see it online, if you google it.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#15

Aluminum foil?

Hoa in Alameda

I haven't tried this, but can you cover the surface of the finish in the can with a piece of aluminum foil?

The finish will then NOT be in contact with air, and will not form the dreaded crust.

(I'm in the middle of a project of painting the house. At the end of the day, I simply wrap the roller with aluminum foil and use it the next day).

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#16

Dale Lenz

Collect Jars

Dale Lenz

For 20+ years I collected jars of different sizes. Always kept an open ear for someone with a new-born, got their baby food jar. After using X amount of varnish from the orginal can, I'd pour the remaing liquid in to other labeled jars. I might lose a half the volume in the smallest baby food jar, an oz or two, better than several oz. Never could see why folks spent their $ on some gas stuff. Some folks was conserned over breaking the jars, it's a possible, but don't recall doing that.

I use lacquer now, but like I said it worked for me for over 20 years!

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#17

Re: Do not refill freon tanks

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

It is against Federal law to refill a freon tank. If caught in an accident inspection, the fines exceed $10,000. Freon tanks filled with "wet" compressed air rust from the inside out. They can explode with terrible results.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#18

that will work just fine

Bill Tindall

Which gives me the idea that I can fill my Freon tank with this gas.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#19

I expect that would work

Bill Tindall

I expect CO2 would be fine for the task. It matters not whether it is heavier than air because the best way to inert the can would be to mostly put the lid on, stick a hose in and flush. It might not work with hydrogen but nitrogen is not going to be significantly different density from 80/20 nitrogen/oxygen so it will flush just fine.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#20

Re: Aluminum foil?

Bill Tindall

Interesting thought. I suspect it would indeed work for a short time but eventually, maybe months to years, the oxygen will diffuse in from the edges.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#21

Re: Avoiding the Crust

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Inert gas is nice, but you'll avoid the problem by closing the can tightly and storing it upside down. When you flip and open it, you'll have nice finish right at the rim and the crust will be on the bottom of the can, out of your way.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#22

Re: Surely they were kidding!

Bill Tindall

I have seen this one before. It is worrisome in so many ways. I would expect the water to alter the drying agents, if not outright destroy them. You know how slow varnish dries on a rainy day. Imagine if the vanish is saturated with water!

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#23

Re: Avoiding the Crust

Jesse Cloud

take some plastic wrap or other relatively impermeable material, place it under the can, run a knife against the rim of the can to create a piece of material just a smidgeon bigger than the can. When you pour out some varnish, slip the plastic disk on top of the varnish remaining in the can.

If this works for you, make a bunch of them so you can toss the old one and use a fresh one with each can opening.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#24

Interesting idea,

Keith Newton

The two pound coffee cans that i use, come with a foil lid with a tab for pealing it off, which is just the right size for a gallon paint can.

I have to wonder though, if it will float, or slowly sink to the bottom.

Re: A practical alternative to Bloxgen

#25

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Nope... *LINK*

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

There is "beer" sold in plastic bottles.

I use the quotes, because I consider it to be more along the lines of water, or water that's been through a goat, but the label says it's beer.

Jason


Plastic Beer Bottles