Re: Best plane for a shooting board
Guillaume Dery
None of the planes you have mentioned is ideal although you could purpose one. As mentioned in some of the other replies, there are a few things you are looking for in a shooting plane:
1. Mass - you want to build momentum so that this thing moves like a freight train when it hits your end grain.
2. Low angle - again, this has everything to do with the end grain. The recommendation of BU planes is a good one if you don't happen to have the coin laying about for the LN miter plane (or more expensive premium miter planes).
3. Square - This has not yet been mentioned in the responses you had so far but it is a must!. You want the sides to be perfectly square to the sole, else your miters will give you fits. This is hit or miss with the older planes but almost a given with the new quality manufacturers such as Veritas and LN
Of secondary consideration is registration and ease of handling. You want decent registration for the side of the plane when in use. Low sides are a negative here. Ease of handling is also a concern but you can develop technique. The old Stanley shooting planes and the new one by LN have the handle mounted at an angle which makes it a heck of a lot easier to get a decent grip on.
I guess what I am saying in a long-winded fashion is that I would have reservations using any of the planes you mentioned in a shooting board configuration. I would opt in favour of the LV LA BU jack or smoother (or if you are totally flush with funds the awesome LN shooting plane which I lust after). If you must use one of your Stanleys, I would probably go for the 5C to at least get some mass in the equation (just check that your wings are 90 degrees to the sole). The iron gets sharpened absolutely square (not cambered) either way.
All of the above is my own opinion, freely given and probably worth what you paid for it 
Cheers,
Guillaume