What wax to use for "rub-out"?
Bill Tindall
What is the preferred wax to use after/during rubbing out? I think I am going to rub a duller gloss on the chest of drawers and wondered what wax will be best.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What wax to use for "rub-out"?
Bill Tindall
What is the preferred wax to use after/during rubbing out? I think I am going to rub a duller gloss on the chest of drawers and wondered what wax will be best.
Re: What wax to use for "rub-out"?
Moses Yoder
I like Johnson's Paste Wax and 0000 steel wool. I rub some wax into the steel wool then buff. Results are as smooth as a cirrus cloud.
Not Being
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
A big wax fan, I use paraffin oil to rub out finishes. That goes for the 0000 wool, pumice, rottenstone, and other compounds. It cleans off the surface and is better, IMHO, at keeping particles suspended. Wax tends to dry and become stiff.
YMMV
Re: What wax to use for "rub-out"?
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
I like Tre Wax. It is less yellow than Johnson's and has a bit less solvent smell.
Robin
Re: Not Being
Barry Irby
I also have used Paraffin oil and pumice and rottenstone. Sort of a zen like process. A little mindless but relaxing. Really leaves a surface nice to the touch.
Re: What wax to use for "rub-out"?
Yonak
Moses, do find that applying wax with steel wool causes steel fibres to get in the the wood grain ? I had a terrible experience using steel wool on pecan one time and have used cheese cloth to apply wax and a towel to buff it out ever since.
PS...
Barry Irby
I am not sure about varnish, but I think you want to give the finish PLENTY of time to cure if you use paraffin oil.
Re: What wax to use for "rub-out"?
Moses Yoder
The only projects I have rubbed out that I can think of would be cherry or walnut. I can imagine that steel wool might get caught in wood like hickory or pecan that is coarser grained.
Re: PS...
Steve Schoene
You want to give all finishes plenty of time to cure before rubbing out. But that's not really because of the paraffin oil, which after a couple of days won't have any solvent effect on the varnish. But varnish is easier to rub out evenly if it has plenty of curing time for it to harden. A month is good if you are rubbing to gloss, but you can shade that a week for rubbing to satin. I do like paraffin oil for pumice (if rubbing to satin).
Shellac takes much less time before it can be rubbed out. It's an evaporative finish so their isn't a lot of "curing" going on. I still don't want to rub it out immediately, particularly where it has been used to fill the grain ring on (semi) porous woods like walnut or mahogany. It can shrink a bit as it dries if rubbed out after just an overnight drying period.
Re: What wax to use for "rub-out"?
roger lance
I was using the Briwax brand but it contains toluene and the literature advises against using waxes with toluene for health issues. So look for a brand that is toluene free and I'm not sure if brands like Mylands or Liberon are free of toluene.
I have no fear of toluene in wax
Bill Tindall
I use gallons of it for thinning and cleaning when I use conversion varnish. Industry uses tank cars of it for general industrial solvent uses with no adverse effects to workers. The reason chemicals like these are widely used is because they are benign in moderation. I will be exposed to vastly more toluene and related compounds filling my gas tanks than I ever will waxing something.
What isn't generally appreciated is that common industrial operations expose workers to orders of magnitude more of these sorts of chemicals than any home hobbiest ever will see. These workers are closely monitored and if they are having no ill effects there is no cause for concern from moderate exposure in the shop.
The bottom line is if the person working in the wax factory making this stuff 40 hours a week isn't having any problems someone using it once in a while surely isn't either.
Re: I have no fear of toluene in wax
Cecil Nickerson in Halfmoon Bay
The standard taught to us by a classically-trained English shop teacher was shellac rubbed out with rubbing oil (mineral) and shop-worn fine garnet paper followed by beeswax dissolved in turpentine applied with steel wool. Bronze wool would probably be better for woods with high tannin content. Light mineral oil can be had by buying unscented baby oil. 2¢
Cecil
Re: What wax to use for "rub-out"?
jcousins
like many who posted i have used 2 grades of pumice & rottenstone with paraffin oil - but recently i've been using auto swirl remover - couple of different grades - and find the finish equal - and way less messy.
for rubbing out i used black bison wax.
jerry
Re: What wax to use for "rub-out"?
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Bill I am certainly no expert, but I do like the satin finish and probably 95% of my projects are rubbed out with wax and 4-0 steel wool. I have used Briewax, Minwax, Renaissance wax and Johnson's - can't really say I saw any difference in the final finish although some did dry a little faster and possibly left a "harder" finish. I usually use Minwax if I have it in stock, otherwise I resort to whats on the shelf.
>
George Frank's Water Wax emulsion *LINK*
David Barnett
Yes, you too can have that museum furniture collection dry wax patina...
I have this thing about the dry wax look, (not greasy-looking like so many solvent-based paste waxes), that usually results from laborious rubbing of filtered (not bleached) beeswax with a sprinkle of water. Or simply, I don't mind somewhat shiny but can't stand greasy. George Frank found an easier way to get there based on processes used in the cosmetics industry. It goes on easily, is rubbed to a dry patina in far less time than beeswax, is more durable and you'll be able to lift your arms the following day. Easy to make and cheap, too.
For a great wax shine, apply and wipe down with soft rags, then brush. Then, for the best mellow/matte dry wax glow ever, take a grey (fine) non-woven 3M finishing pad (or bronze wool, etc.) and lightly stroke the surface in parallel overlapping stripes, like you're doing practice touchdowns and take-offs for aircraft carrier landings. Making prop or jet noises helps.
From Olde Mill Cabinet Shoppe (an online supplier):
"George Frank's Water Wax ingredients are also available for you to make your own wax. Carnauba Wax, also known as Brazil Wax from the Brazilian Wax Palm Tree which contributes hardness and polish-ability and Candelillia Wax, from the leaves of a Mexican plant, are combined with Triethanolamine and Stearic Acid to enable emulsification of the water and waxes. It produces a superior wax that reproduces that dry antique shine, functional as well as beautiful. The specifics of manufacturing of this wax is described in George Frank's excellent book on finishing "Adventures in Wood Finishing" (still available at Olde Mill)."
If you can't find this book in your library (it's in my local library but George Frank retired and lived out his life here), the formula's posted to the ClayArt website (not original to ClayArt either, as the poster couldn't give attribution having forgotten where he originally found it):
"George Frank's formula for emulsified wax is an excellent decorative patinating wax especially for limed or whitewashed surfaces.
Melt in a double boiler:
(Suggest a hotplate outdoors to avoid fire danger!)
4 ounces of Candelilla wax flake,
4 ounces of Carnauba wax flake,
and 6 1/2 ounces of Stearic Acid.
In a separate glass, earthenware, or enameled container add:
1 ounce (liquid) of Triethanolamine (for emilsufication)
to 3 1/2 quarts of boiling water*.
(*If your water is high in minerals, use distilled water or rain water)
Now; pour the melted wax mixture into the water; begin stirring with a wooden paddle as soon as you finish pouring. Continue stirring until the mixture cools and has the consistency of heavy cream."
You can buy ingredients in small amounts from those who sell soap and candle making supplies. Stearic acid, a fatty acid, is a staple of soap and candlemakers. Triethanolamine (TEA) is an easily-found alkaline surfactant from Dow. The wax flakes can be had for less than ten dollars a pound from botanicals suppliers to artists, soap and candlemakers, and so on. But if you want it all from one source and don't mind paying more for convenience, here's one.
Ingredients from Olde Mill Cabinet Shoppe
Re: What wax to use for "rub-out"?
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
Wool Lube ™, 0000 Libran ™ steel wool, Minwax ™ wax.
thaks for the suggestions
Bill Tindall
I would seem from the responses that the technique will be more important than the details of the wax.
Re: I have no fear of toluene in wax
Steve SchoeneIt's
There is still very good reason to avoid wax with toluene in rubbing out a new finish that has cured only a month or so. Toluene is a stronger solvents than the standard mineral spirits or naphtha solvents, and can, in some cases damage the new finish. May not happen in all cases, but why risk even a small chance of damage.