Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

Posts

OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#1

OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

I have a knob and tube run that goes to an outlet. Near to this outlet is a newer 14-2 circuit. The old knob and tube doesn't have a ground.

This is in my attic. The old knob and tube is a switched circuit for the light in the attic. As far as I can tell, it is the only thing on the line. But I'm not sure. I've tried to trace it. I've even pulled up some of the tongue and groove flooring in the attic trying to figure out where the switch wiring is coming from and going to. I'm not an electrician, but opening floors and walls and seeing how circuits were run through walls and floors back in the early 1900's is scary...

The switch is at the bottom of the steps up into the attic. I can not figure out where that wire goes once it enters the wall. I believe it runs under the flooring over to another wall then who knows where.

Would it be okay to run some 14-2 from the newer circuit over to the knob & tube outlet and attach the ground only?

Oh, one more thing. The reason I would like to add a ground to this switched circuit is that I would like to add one more light (in the attic) and put an outlet on the switched circuit also.

Thanks in advance for any suggestions.

Joe

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Can't speak to the ground wire, but the best answer is to remove the K&T completely and re-wire.

We just spent a small fortune to re-wire my Mom's old house in Wheeling, WV, so that it could be sold. Mortgage lenders wouldn't touch it until the wiring was upgraded and inspected. We had to completely remove the K&T to qualify for a mortgage on it.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#3

Re: OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

Barry Irby

Without looking it up in the National Electric Code, from memory, the answer is NO. There was a time when it was permitted to run a ground from another circuit or as an independent conductor, but not anymore.

Its also not permitted to bury K&T in insulation. It is designed to operate in free air and dissipates its heat into the air. If you thermally insulate it you could cause it to over heat. (Don't all the time, but still a bad idea. Incidentally, it the AIR between the conductors that is the electrical insulation. Just like overhead power lines, its air insulated. As bad and archaic as it is, it was an inspired system. I don't know when they last installed any, but it must have been before World War II, so those systems have been operating a very long time and generally safely.

So, why not pull your light and outlet out of the more modern wiring rather than the old stuff?

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#4

Insulation

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

That's something I always wonder about; it seems like people around here are always having insulation blown into their houses.

Isn't that a problem? Having insulation blown in around the old K&T wiring?

That's why I am replacing what I can in my attic because I'm getting ready to put insulation up there (something I tried to start doing a year ago...) and didn't want to put it over the K&T.

Thanks.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#5

Re: OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

paul in AZ

A while back I had a house built in ~1908 that had some knob and tube wiring in the basement. The knobs, tubes and wire itself would probably last another 100 years but the wire was covered with a woven fabric insulation -? cotton?- that was extremely fragile. It wasn't far from being a bare copper wire.

For that reason alone I'd suggest replacing it all with modern coated wire.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#6

Re: OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

Larry in nw ohio

I think I know what knob and wire is, it`s just a twist knob with two wires for conductors, but never heard of knob and tube. What is that. Larry

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#7

Re: OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

John in NM

The ones I've seen were ceramic knobs or spools that pinched the wire to hold it out away from the framing. A framing nail held it to the stud. Everywhere the wire went through a fire block or the top or bottom of a wall, there was a ceramic tube to insulate the wood from the wire. Latest house I've seen that installed in was 1940's or so, maybe just after WWII.

Though the method itself is fairly safe, the standard service in those days was about 60 amps, and took the old glass fuses where you could screw a 30 amp fuse in place of a 15. I've seen spots were the lath in the wall had started to burn from the heat of the overloaded wire :D

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#8

Knob & Tube question

paul in AZ

The 'tube' part is a ceramic tube a couple of inches long inserted into a hole drilled in joists or studs that keeps the wire from making direct contact with wood.

The knobs support the wire along it's run.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#10

Re: Yep.

Larry in nw ohio

Thank You, that really brings back memories. I do remember seeing them in my grandmothers house and some other places when I was "young"? Larry

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#11

Gotta go ! . . .

steve mackay

Once you admit it (even here) now you know it. Its like fuel oil tanks burried in the yard etc, etc, etc. Once you know it, its gotta go. The law, insurance, buying & selling. Bite the bullet and replace. If not, it'll haunt you.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#12

Re: OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

There is really nothing wrong with knob and tube wireing. it is the limited capacity of most of the knob and tube systems that is the reason to abandon them and upgrade.

The funny thing about grounded three wire systems is that the white common and the green ground wires are all conected to the same buss at the panel. so if your outlet already has a black and a white it is conected to the ground back at the panel. granted a three wire plug is a bit safer and one of the out dated ways to ground an outlet was to run the ground wire to the nearest water pipe. Now days the ground wire must be run back to the panel.

The biggest reason not to do what you are thinking about is that an outlet should never be run on the sole lighting circut for a room. The theory here is that if you are up in the attic making toast at midnight and trip the breaker you want to be able to see as you leave the room to reset the breaker.

I'm not an electrition and I don't play one on TV, but I have rewired part of my house and all of my shop and it passed inspection on the first try.

Robin

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#13

Re: Insulation

Barry Irby

You got it. You are not supposed to cover K&T in insulation. (Thermal Insulation) Much of electricity is governed by the wire's ability to dissipate the heat that builds up in the wire due to the current. You can look in the NEC (National Elec. code.) and it will tell you how many wires can be put into a conduit. The conduit tends to retain the heat. The same size wire running in free air can safely handle more current. So don't cover it with insulation, its a fire hazard.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#14

Re: OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

Galen Vetterick

John, that burn spot was because of the penny I put under the old glass bodied fuse when it kept blowing. :D

I lived in a few of those old houses!

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#15

That's not the half of it...

John in NM

Previous owner had a VAX mainframe in one room of the house.... I'm guessing he'd had some other electron eating equipment around too :D

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#16

Re: OT - Electrical.  Knob & Tube question

nickb

I had a circa-1952 house that was built with K&T wiring. I think the real problem with it comes in the fixtures - particularly lighting fixtures that most people seem unable to restrain themselves from overamping (ie 100w bulb in a 60w fixture). The excess heat cooks the insulation (I had chunks of crispy insulation just fall out of the box when I was replacing fixtures).

BTW, I also saw scorch marks on the framing when I had walls open, but (at least in my house) I came to realize that it was scorching from where electrician used a torch to solder a splice without using a heat shield to protect the framing.

I would replace the K&T wiring with modern wiring. The K&T is a great system (provided the homeowners can restrains themselves from putting big bulbs in their light fixtures), but really doesn't play well with modern insulation and air sealing techniques/materials.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#17

Those burned spots...

John in NM

The one I'm thinking of was definitely from hot wire rather than soldering. May have a picture around somewhere, but of course it would be on film :O

I've never seen a soldered joint in a house, NEC forbids it these days, though likely not back in the 1950's.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#18

Re: Those burned spots...

Howard Norman

I can't say how common it was to solder connections in house wiring in the 40's and 50's. But it was done, I remember doing it myself.

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#19

Re: Those burned spots...

Larry in nw ohio

When I was young I helped an electrition wire a house and he twisted the wires and solderd the splice. Why would that be not allowed now? I`d think that would be a very good joint. Larry

Re: OT - Electrical. Knob & Tube question

#20

I should have been more clear

John in NM

They allow it with approved splice kits, basically a crimped butt connector that then has solder flowed in. The prohibition I remember (but did not go look up :D ) has more to do with solder not being the sole means of connection. I would suppose it is due to the slim possibility that the wire could heat enough to melt the solder and break the connection.