Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

The lathe saga continues, end in sight

Posts

The lathe saga continues, end in sight

#1

The lathe saga continues, end in sight

Stephen Kirk

So, after talking to Jet, they needed to put a dial indicator on it. Woodcraft, in Allentown, where I got the lathe was very helpful. After trying lots of combinations, we determined that any center we put in was out by 25,000 at the tip (~1/16). In one of the heavily used lathes at the shop, runout was a mere 3,000-5,000. Called Jet back and they said it was the spindle and a new one is coming. Folks at Woodcraft even helped me pull out the spindle so all I have to do is pop the new one in.

Lot of folks helped make a rough situation pretty simple to fix, from here at WC, Woodcraft and Jet. My thanks to all.

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

Moses Yoder

If I am not mistaken, 1/16" would be almost 63 thousandths, ; 25 thousandths would only be a little more than 1/3 of a sixteenth inch. This is probably typical of Chinese quality control.

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

#3

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

wilbur

Moses, this is not typical of Chinese quality control. It's typical of the quality control that you get at this price point.

Chinese manufacturing is perfectly capable of tighter tolerances. You just have to be willing to pay for it. At the prices that you'll have to pay to get that level of quality control, though, you might as well just manufacture your product domestically.

There is a midi (12"x24") lathe that has never had reported issues with spindle runout. It's made by Oneway, it's manufactured in Canada, and it costs $2500, which is a lot more than what Stephen probably got his Jet 1220VS midi lathe for ($560-650 online, based on a quick search).

I am glad that Stephen's lathe problems seem to be coming to an end.

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

#4

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

Howard Norman

Moses, this is not typical of Chinese quality control. It's typical of the quality control that you get at this price point.

Wilbur, I agree completely. It is not one country having sloppy quality and another having great quality. It depends on what the manufacturer is willing to pay for. And then ultimately what the customer is willing to pay.

howard

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

#5

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

Bob Hackett

Not that I am in any way contradicting Wilbur (I agree with him) but I keep hearing that Chinese manufacturers are capable of tight tolerances and excellent quality control. If this is in fact the case then the only logical reason this keeps coming up must be that the US contractors having these problem machines made overseas are instructing them to play it fast and loose and to supply them with substandard equipment in the hopes that many of us will satisfied with this lower quality crap or be willing to tear our brand new machines apart and replace parts ourselves till we finally end up with something acceptable or throw our hands up in frustration and ask for our money back.

This is not what I consider progress and I view the casual acceptance of this as a huge step backward. The answer is to not base your purchase strictly on the price of the machine. Until we get back to supporting the true meaning of quality and durability we have nobody to blame but ourselves when we gamble on the lower price point and lose the bet.

Stop buying the cheap imported crap and it will cease to be imported and then those clever and talented Chinese workers can concentrate on providing us with machines we can be proud to own and hand on to our grandchildren,just like we used to make right here at home and provide to the rest of the world before our fathers retired from the workforce.

Then again those same machines our fathers built can always be bought used,if they haven`t been scrapped and sent overseas to be melted down and turned into cheap, low quality replacements.

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

#6

To kind of prove a point , long

Larry in nw ohio

I suppose most everyone here knows that I`m not a big fan of Chinese products. If I would compare two things of the same item, one made in the US and one made in China, the one made in the US would be far superiour than China. Of course the US made would be more expensive, but that would be the cost of quality and of course union labor. We don`t need to get started about that.

To sort of make the point, I bought one of the new power router raisers from MCLS that they just came out with. I waited for 3 months to get the raiser, but that was known when I ordered it. When I got it and put it together the power unit didn`t even turn on. Well of course they sent a new one and put that on it worked, but know the foot switch didn`t work, got a new one of those,still didn`t work, got another one, still didn`t work. So I did some checking on the switch and it all seemed to be OK, so I called and agreed to get a whole new unit and that they would check it all out first before they send it. Got that one and put it together and fianally everything worked, packed up the first one, but first I checked out to see what was wrong with the first unit, the power unit was again bad, wasn`t anything wrong with the switch. So a happy camper was eye. got to useing it and it started to chatter, so took less and less off the piece untill I was only taking less off eack cut than I ever did with any other lift I had, 3 others, 2 I made and one bought. I worked with it to see if I could work with it to make it work, because I really liked this unit and wanted it to work. I could do things with it I couldn`t do with any of the others. Could not stop it within reason amount of work. I could grab the motor and push it back and forth a goodly amount about1/16-1/8". That is to much. I look at the mounts where the linier bearings would be and they looked like just regular bearings. I may be wrong but that is what they looked like. I do say MCLS customer service was great, but they should be. Like an old friend always told me about new things made up "It`s a dollar short of a great idea". Larry

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

#7

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Thousandths of an inch are written as decimal places to the right of zero.

.5"=5 tenths of an inch

.05"= 5 hundredths of an inch

.005" = 5 thousand's of an inch

When reading a number you read it from left to right and pronounce the decimal denotation of the last digit.

.25 is read as twenty five hundredth's

.025 is read as twenty five thousandth's

This used to be the realm of machinist’s but with the popularity of inexpensive digital calipers it has become part of the wood working lexicon as well.

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

#8

Re: The lathe saga continues, end in sight

wilbur

I don't think that the US contractors are telling the Chinese manufacturers to make crappy equipment and to play fast and loose with tolerances. I think these decisions are really driven by the consumer, i.e. us.

The other, and to my mind, more logical reason is that the US contractors know that woodworkers really aren't going to pay more than $600 for a midi lathe for the most part, and when they contract with a Chinese manufacturer, they say, "Make me a 12x20 lathe for $300" (assuming that manufacturing cost is about 50% of retail). At those prices, the tolerances they get are what you pay for.

If they said instead, "Make me a 12x20 lathe with zero defects in what gets shipped to me so that guys like Stephen won't have an issue with having to replace a spindle," the Chinese manufacturers would likely say, "Fine. But it's going to cost you $1200 for that." And the defect rate would be zero. But the retail price for that lathe would be close to a Oneway.

This is really just a reflection of human nature. Think of it this way: someone hires you to build a 4' tall, 24" wide walnut bookcase with a dovetailed carcasse for $100. How much time are you going to spend on quality control? My bet is that those dovetails are going to be pretty gappy.